Business Issues and the Context of Human Resources
Verified
Added on 2023/03/30
|18
|4737
|345
AI Summary
This report evaluates different factors that impact the organisational business and its HR functions. It also focuses on analysing factors that shaped the HR agenda and compared different tools that assist the HR managers in analysing the business environment.
Contribute Materials
Your contribution can guide someone’s learning journey. Share your
documents today.
0 Business Issues and the Context of Human Resources
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
1 Table of Contents Introduction...............................................................................................................................2 Forces which shape the HR agenda...........................................................................................3 Internal Factors impacting organisational performance and HR function............................3 External factors impacting organisational performance and HR function............................4 Comparison of environmental analytical tools..........................................................................6 Stages of strategy formulation and implementation.................................................................8 Role of HR in business ethics and accountability...................................................................9 Evaluation of Business Performance........................................................................................10 Role of HR in business planning and change management.................................................11 Evaluation of different sources of business and contextual data in planning purpose...........12 HR metrics............................................................................................................................13 Industry information............................................................................................................13 Conclusion................................................................................................................................14 References................................................................................................................................15
2 Introduction In today’s competitive business world, corporations are struggling to generate and sustain a competitive advantage due to fierce competition. Effective human resource management (HRM) strategies assist companies in ensuring that they hire an adequate number of staff members who are skilled and qualified in order to achieve their corporate goals (Albrecht et al., 2015). However, there are many contemporary human resource challenges which are faced by corporations that resulted in making it difficult for them to build a strong and talentedworkforcetoconducttheirbusinessoperations.TheHRmanagerhasthe responsibility to form HRM strategies to make sure that the staffing requirements of the company are fulfilled based on the requirements of the company (Albrecht et al., 2015). This report will evaluate different factors that impact the organisational business and its HR functions. This report will also focus on analysing factors that shaped the HR agenda and compareddifferenttoolsthatassisttheHRmanagersinanalysingthebusiness environment. The key stages which companies have to follow in order to formulate and implement the role of HR will also be analysed in this report along with an evaluation of the HR’s contribution to business ethics and accountability. This report will compare the PESTLE and SWOT framework and identified the ways in which business performance is measured in organisations. This report will also evaluate how different sources of internal and external data should be considered while planning for HR strategies in organisations.
3 Forces which shape the HR agenda Internal Factors impacting organisational performance and HR function There is a wide range of internal factors that affect the HR agenda of organisations by creating challenges and opportunities for them. The impact of these factors is necessary to be assessed by the HR manager to make sure that the company remain prepared for these factors in order to reduce their negative impact and create an overall positive impact on its operations (Marler and Fisher, 2013). Following are the key internal forces that shape the HR agenda of organisations. HR Strategies The HR strategies implemented by organisations in order to manage their human capital requirements affect their business operations as well. Through these strategies, companies focus on identifying their human capital requirements to identify the number and skills of the employees which are necessary in order to achieve its corporate objectives (Stone and Deadrick, 2015). These strategies assist in building the gap between the strategic plan and HRM in the corporations; thus, companies have to consider a wide range of factors while developing these strategies. The agenda prepared by the HR manager focuses on ensuring that an adequate number of skilled and qualified members must be present in the organisation to make sure that they focus on promoting the success of the enterprise (Stone and Deadrick, 2015). These strategies not only focus on analysing and filling the human capital requirements, but they also focus on creating a positive workplace culture in which needs of employees are fulfilled so that they are motivated to work with high productivity. Strategic objections The strategic objectives or goals set by the top level management are necessary to be fulfilled by the company in a particular timeframe. It is the responsibility of the HR department to make sure that it hires an adequate number of staff members which are crucial to achieve the strategies goals in the organisation in an efficient manner without wasting resources (Marler and Fisher, 2013). Stakeholder expectations
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
4 The importance of fulfilment of social responsibilities of companies has grown, and it is expected from the top level management that they will maintain a balance between the interests of stakeholders by fulfilling their expectations. This also affects the HR agenda of the organisation since the HR department has to hire an adequate number of employees to make sure that they deliver high-quality products and services to customers as per their expectations (Makela et al., 2013). The expectations of the shareholders of the company are also achieved by the effective management of human capital in the workplace since it promotes the profitability of the organisation. Assessment and compliance with regulatory policies are also crucial to fulfil government expectations, which can be achieved through a skilled and qualified workforce. Financial health The financial health of a company also affects its ability to attract and retain talented employees in the organisation. In the financial health of a company is poor, it cannot offer high incentives or salary packages to its employees, which demotivates them (Makela et al., 2013). Sound financial health assists the company in paying high packages to its employees to retain them for a longer period of time in order to achieve corporate goals. Communications The communication policies implemented by the organisation affects the HR agenda since lack of communication between employees, and the management leads to creating a hostile working environment in which employees face issue such as demotivation, bullying, harassment, mental health issues, poor performance and others (Den Hartog et al., 2013). On the other hand, effective communication enables the management to learn about the factors which affect the performance of employees in order to implement policies which allow them to address these issues to improve their performance; thus, communication policies also affect HR agenda in organisations (Den Hartog et al., 2013). External factors impacting organisational performance and HR function Government policies The government policies of a country affect the performance of organisations and HR functions by bringing challenges or opportunities for them. The rapid change in government
5 policies resulted in imposing new taxes on companies, and it also affects their operations by the introduction of new legal standards which they have to comply with (Kim, 2012). Similarly, the government also provides a wide range of employment legislation and other compliances which are necessary to be followed by the HR department in order to avoid legal consequence such as changing in the minimum wage, maximum working hours, bonus policies, and others. A good example is Brexit that will result in creating challenges for the companies operating in the United Kingdom since it made it difficult for them to conduct their operations in the European Union which affects their performance (Orazulike, 2018). Moreover, the multinational companies that operate in both nations have to make sure that they comply with the employment standards which are brought by the government through Brexit in order to avoid legal consequences. Prevailing economy and market conditions Prevailingeconomyisoneofthebiggestfactorsthataffecttheperformanceof organisations because companies proliferate in strong economies. They receive a plethora of opportunities while conducting their business operations to make sure that they reach a large customer base (Thite, Wilkinson and Shah, 2012). Economic downturn also affects the HR function of organisations since they have to lay off employees and reduce their benefits to cut their costs, which further harm their performance as well. It is estimated that Brexit the economy of the UK could be 3 per cent bigger if the Brexit would have never happened, and it is likely to slow down the economic growth of the country in the future as well which will increase unemployment rates, reduction in salary packages and bonuses and the HR department will find it difficult to retain talented employees in the organisation (Nelson, 2019). Demographic, social and technological trends The changes in demographic resulted in altering the business patters, which affects its performance, and it also affects the HR function. The wants of the older generation are different from the new generation, which are necessary to be taken into consideration by the HR department (Ulrich et al., 2013). For example, millennial employees are less likely to retain in the organisation as compared to baby boomers, which create challenges for the HR department to reduce employee attrition rates (Ulrich et al., 2013). The social and
6 technological challenges also affect the operations of organisations since they make current products, services and processes obsolete. A good example is the shutdown of Blockbuster and Nokia since they failed to innovate like Netflix and Samsung. Similarly, the HR department has to ensure that its hires employees as per the current technological requirements oftheorganisationto makesurethattheflowoftheorganisational performance can be maintained accordingly (Ulrich et al., 2013). An aging employee demographic can be challenging for the company to sustain its performance in today’s highly competitive and innovative marketplace. Globalisation Globalisation has a substantial impact on organisational performance since it opened a plethora of opportunities for companies to expand their operations in overseas markets. However, it also brought new challenges such as management of diversity in the workplace and managing multicultural teams to make sure that the company continues to expand its operations on an international marketplace (Hurn, 2014). The HR department has to make sure that it implements effective policies to ensure that diversity among employees can be maintained by creating a positive and supportive workplace culture and it also assists in ensuring that companies sustain their performance even in adverse market conditions. Comparison of environmental analytical tools Environmental analytical tools assist companies in identifying key internal and external factors that affect their business operations which allow them to develop strategic policies to sustain their growth in the market (Srdjevic, Bajcetic and Srdjevic, 2012). SWOT and PESTLE are two of the most popular environmental analytical tools that are used by companies while developing business strategies. Generally, organisations and their HR department implement both of these frameworks together while forming HR strategies to achieve better results. Both of these tools are cost-efficient, and they assist companies in highlighting their critical problems (Srdjevic, Bajcetic and Srdjevic, 2012). They also assist the HR department in identifying key challenges which all them to implement policies to ensure the effectiveness of the HR functions.
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
7 SWOT AnalysisPESTLE Analysis Itanalysesstrengths,weaknesses, opportunitiesandthreatsfacedbyan organisation (van Wijngaarden, Scholten and van Wijk, 2012). It focuses on identifying political, economic, social,technological,legaland environmentalfactorsthataffectthe operations of a company (Zalengera et al., 2014). The strengths of a company are referred to thecompetitiveadvantageswhichthe companyhasoveritscompetitorswhile operating its business in the industry. The weaknesses are the challenges which the company faces that put it at a position of disadvantagewhencomparedwithits competitors.Theopportunitiesidentify trendsintheexternalenvironmentthat assistcompaniesintakingadvantageof themtoimprovetheiroutcomes(van Wijngaarden, Scholten and van Wijk, 2012). The threats are referred to movements in theexternalenvironmentthatadversely affect the operations of the companies and their HR functions. Thisframeworkevaluatesthepolitical factorswhichincluderegulations,global issues, future and current taxation policies, labour laws, trade restrictions and others factors that affect organisations in a positive or negative manner (Srdjevic, Bajcetic and Srdjevic, 2012). The economic factors include stock market trends, interest rates, inflation, consumer confidence and other factors that affect the operations of companies. Social factorsincludeagedistribution,career attitudes, lifestyle attitudes, cultural barriers, populationgrowthrateandhealth consciousness, which have an impact on the operations of companies (Zalengera et al., 2014).Technologicalfactorsthataffect operationsofcompaniesincludeR&D activities, level of innovation, technological initiativesandtechnologicalawareness (Zalengera et al., 2014). Legal factors include discriminationlaws,employmentlaws, health and safety laws, consumer protection guidelines and others. Environmental factors include climate change, weather, pressure from NGOs and others. SWOT analysis focuses on identifying internal and external micro merits and demerits of a company that creates opportunities for their or hinders their current operations. These factors assist them in developing strategies whichallowthemtogeneratinga competitive advantage in the market (van Wijngaarden, Scholten and van Wijk, 2012). This analysis focuses on evaluating external macro-environmentalfactorsthataffect organisations.Thesefactorsidentify directors of companies and assist them in identifying reasons for growth and decline in the market (Zalengera et al., 2014). SWOTassistsinidentifyingthecurrent market position of companies. PESTLE assists in identifying the impact of external factors on organisations.
8 Stages of strategy formulation and implementation There are various steps involved in the strategy formulation process that assist companies in achieving their goals and objectives. The entire process is divided into six steps which are given below along with an evaluation of the role of HR in each step. 1.Identification of objectives of the organisation While developing strategies, the first step focuses on identifying the targets or goals of the company. The objectives should be designed for the long term, which assists in setting a direction and mission of the organisation (Bamberger, Biron and Meshoulam, 2014). After setting the goals, further strategies are developed for the achievement of these objectives. The HR department evaluates the current goals set by the company to identify the human capital requirement for achievement of these goals. The HR department sets its own goals as well that interlinked with the organisational goals (Bamberger, Biron and Meshoulam, 2014). 2.Organisation Environment Evaluation This step focuses on assessing the current operational environment of the company, which include the economic and industrial environment. This step identifies the competitive position of the company, which is reviewed through both qualitative and quantitative methods (Azhar et al., 2013). This step assists in identifying the strengths and weaknesses of the company in regards to the achievement of its corporate goals. The HR department evaluates the current and future HR trends to evaluate the current HR capabilities of the company. The strengths and weaknesses of the current workforce are analysed by the HR department as well to determine whether it is suitable to achieve corporate goals. 3.Setting up Quantitative Targets Next step is setting target values for the organisation that focuses on meeting organisational objectives of the company. This step assists the company in evaluating the contribution made by different operating departments in the achievement of goals. In this stage, the contribution of the HR department plays a crucial role (Dayan, Heisig and Matos, 2017). The HR manager also works along with the head of other departments to identify their human
9 capital requirements to make sure that an adequate number of skilled and qualified employees can be hired to achieve corporate goals. 4.Divisional plans In this step, the identification of contribution made by different sub-departments is identified after considering different strategic planning factors that are analysed above. The contribution of sub-department of HR is analysed in this report to make sure that other areas that affect human capital such as work culture, bonuses, remuneration, diversity and others work accordingly to achieve common goals (Dayan, Heisig and Matos, 2017). 5.Performance analysis This step focuses on identifying the gaps between actual and expected performance of the company. During this stage, the past, present and future condition of the company is analysed critically to identify gaps and predictions are made for the future (Dayan, Heisig and Matos, 2017). The HR department also evaluates the gaps in the human capital requirements in the organisation to determine the number and skilled employees who are necessary to be hired to achieve corporate goals. 6.Choice of Strategy The best possible option is selected in this stage after considering a number of alternative options based on organisational goals, potential and opportunities. After this step, the roles andresponsibilitiesofdifferentdepartmentsandindividualsareidentifiedforthe achievement of corporate goals (Azhar et al., 2013). The HR department also selects the most suitable strategy for the organisation that assists the company in achieving its goals. This strategy enables the company in ensuring that it hires an adequate number of skilled and talented workers who work dedicatedly to achieve the targets of the company in an efficient manner. Role of HR in business ethics and accountability Equality: The HR department focuses on maintaining equality in the organisation by ensuring that equal pay is given to employees for equal work. The HR department should take corrective steps for eliminating the gender pay gap between its
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
10 employees and policies should be implemented to avoid unethical behaviour in the workplace such as bullying, harassment, misbehave and others (Janssens and Steyaert, 2012). Fair treatment: The HR plays a major role in ensuring that employees receive equal treatment in the workplace and they should be discriminated based on their age, gender, caste, race, religion, colour or disability (Janssens and Steyaert, 2012). Discrimination should be strictly prohibited during the recruitment, selection and promotion process to make sure that employees are not discriminated. Diversity: The HR department should focus on promoting diversity in the workplace by ensuring that employees who belong to different cultural backgrounds are not discriminated based on their differences. Training sessions should be conducted by the HR department to make sure that diversified is proliferated in the workplace (Parboteeah, Seriki and Hoegl, 2014). The HR department should also try to hire a diverse workforce and implement policies to make sure that they work together to achieve common organisational goals. Evaluation of Business Performance Performance appraisal is referred to the method which is used by organisations in order to assess how their employees are performing and sharing such data with them to find ways through which they improve their performance (Ahmed et al., 2013). Through evaluation, the link between different factors can be established such as purpose, relationship, optimal production, relationship, motivation, rewards and recognition, empowerment and flexibility. Through the evaluation of business performance, the corporation can assist in identifying the organisational viewpoint and maintaining its controls in order to make sure that its work with efficiency (Ahmed et al., 2013). The evaluation promotes harmony between different departments and functions, and it also identifies the factors that affect the performance of the organisation. Following are traditional and modern indicators that assist companies in performance appraisal. Traditional methodsModern Methods Ranking methodCost accounting method
11 Checklist methodManagement by objectives (MBO) Forced choice360-degree appraisal Confidential reportAssessment centres GradingBehavioural anchored rating scales Critical incidents methods Essay method Forced distribution method Paired comparison Graphic scale method Field review method Traditional methods focus on the rating of an individual’s personality traits such as intelligence, initiative, drive creativity, leadership potential, dependability and others. On the other hand, modern methods focus on job achievement rather than personal attributes, which make them more objective and worthwhile (Yalcin, Bayrakdaroglu and Kahraman, 2012). Moreover, review of a business plan, SWOT analysis, benchmarking, financial analysis, employee satisfaction, customer satisfaction and financial ratios are also used in order to critically evaluate the performance of organisations. Role of HR in business planning and change management The HR department focuses on managing human capital in the organisation, and as the company grows the requirement of skilled workforce increases as well. Thus, the HR department plays a major role in business planning and change management. Following are different roles of HR in planning and change management. Selection and staffing: After setting organisational goals, companies have to fulfil these needs due to which finding the right individuals for the right post is necessary. Thus, the HR assist in creating employee section and staffing criteria to make sure that an adequate number of skilled and talented employees can be hired in the organisation (Vora, 2013).
12 Organisational Development:During change management, the importance of the development of the capability of employees increases. Thus, the HR department focuses on developing the professional and personal capabilities of employees to makesurethatthecompanyisabletoeffectivelymanagechangesinthe organisation (Arrowsmith and Parker, 2013). Training and development: Through training and development policies, the HR department ensures that the company has an adequate number of skilled and talented employees to achieve its corporate goals. Training employees did not resist to changes in the organisation since they are prepared for them, which promotes the growth of the company (Arrowsmith and Parker, 2013). Being proactive: Effective planning is necessary for organisations to effectively manage change strategies in the workplace. The HR department plays a major role in this by being proactive to make sure that it encourages employees to be prepared for key changes and implement policies for the achievement of future objectives of the company. Evaluation of different sources of business and contextual data in planning purpose The data which is used by companies in order to develop strategies is collected through two mediums, which include internal and external sources. There are different sources through which business information can be collected by organisations such as internal records, financial statements, books, conducting survey and others which assist the management during the business planning process and introducing improvements in the process as well (Schlafke, Silvi and Moller, 2012). The internal information sources of a company include shareholders and employees of the organisation. The external sources of information include books, journals, newspaper, articles, magazine and others. With the popularity of the internet, the data collection process has become easier for companies. They can easily collect reliable data through online media, which allow them to stay up-to-date with information regarding the global environment (Schlafke, Silvi and Moller, 2012). While collecting data from these sources, it is important that parties must have adequate search skills to collect relevant data in an efficient manner.
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
13 HR metrics While collecting internal data, the HR department can focus on HR metrics, which include a number of sources for data collection. For example, HR costs assist the managers in learning about the current and future costs which incurred in the organisation and this information assists them in forming budgets to be prepared (Dulebohn and Johnson, 2013). The responsiveness of the company also provides crucial information regarding the current capability of the company to change as per market conditions. The issue management provides data regarding the management of conflicts in the organisation. Recruitment policies assist in identifying the current capabilities of the company to fulfil their talent requirements (Dulebohn and Johnson, 2013). The productivity analysis provides information regarding the current productivity of employees and their ability to perform better in the future. Industry information External data can be collected from a number of sources by the HR department such as HR trends which provide relevant information regarding the current HR abilities of the company and the potential future challenges which are likely to affect the business. Competitive information is also crucial, which assists companies in identifying the steps taken by their competitors and evaluate how they affect their operations (Bharwani and Butt, 2012). Another source is government information which assists companies in becoming aware regarding changes in future policies brought by government policies that affect the operations of the HR department (Bharwani and Butt, 2012). All these data can be evaluated by the HR department during the planning process to become aware regarding factors that affect the business and implement policies to make sure that those operations are addressed accordingly in order to sustain the growth of the company by ensuring that talented workforce is retained in the organisation.
14 Conclusion Based on the above observations, it can be concluded that there are various internal and external forces that affect the HR agenda of organisations. The internal forces include stakeholders, communications, financial health and other factors whereas the external factorsincludegovernmentpolicies,marketconditions,prevailingeconomy,and demographic, social and technological trends. In order to manage these forces, the HR department can implement strategies after collecting insights to develop a solution, which promotes the performance of the company while ensuring stakeholder expectations. Environmental analytical tools can be used by organisations in order to evaluate the internal and external environmental factors that affect their business operations. This report compared SWOT and PESTLE analysis in order to determine how they assist organisations in being prepared for current and future challenges. This report also analysed the key steps involved in strategy formulation process that assist companies in addressing the key issues faced by them while linking the role of HR in each stage. This report also evaluated the role of HR in promoting business ethics and accountability. Different ways through which business performance can be evaluated and example of traditional and modern indicators are identified. The role of HR in change management is also analysed in this report, along with an evaluation of factors that affect these policies. Based on evaluation of these factors, companies can ensure that they effectively manage HR challenges and be prepared for future growth opportunities which must be disrupted in order to sustain the growth of the company.
15 References Ahmed, I., Sultana, I., Paul, S.K. and Azeem, A. (2013) Employee performance evaluation: a fuzzy approach.International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management,62(7), pp.718-734. Albrecht, S.L., Bakker, A.B., Gruman, J.A., Macey, W.H. and Saks, A.M. (2015) Employee engagement,human resourcemanagementpractices andcompetitiveadvantage:An integrated approach.Journal of Organizational Effectiveness: People and Performance,2(1), pp.7-35. Arrowsmith, J. and Parker, J. (2013) The meaning of ‘employee engagement’for the values androlesoftheHRMfunction.TheinternationaljournalofHumanResource management,24(14), pp.2692-2712. Bamberger,P.A.,Biron,M.andMeshoulam,I.(2014)Humanresourcestrategy: Formulation, implementation, and impact. Abingdon: Routledge. Bharwani, S. and Butt, N. (2012) Challenges for the global hospitality industry: an HR perspective.Worldwide Hospitality and Tourism Themes,4(2), pp.150-162. Dayan, R., Heisig, P. and Matos, F. (2017) Knowledge management as a factor for the formulationandimplementationoforganizationstrategy.JournalofKnowledge Management,21(2), pp.308-329. Dulebohn, J.H. and Johnson, R.D. (2013) Human resource metrics and decision support: A classification framework.Human Resource Management Review,23(1), pp.71-83. Hurn, B. (2014) The challenges facing international HRM in an increasingly globalised environment.Industrial and commercial training,46(7), pp.371-378. Janssens, M. and Steyaert, C. (2012) Towards an ethical research agenda for international HRM:Thepossibilitiesofapluralcosmopolitanframework.JournalofBusiness Ethics,111(1), pp.61-72.
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
16 Kim, S. (2012) The impact of human resource management on state government IT employee turnover intentions.Public Personnel Management,41(2), pp.257-279. Makela, K., Björkman, I., Ehrnrooth, M., Smale, A. and Sumelius, J. (2013) Explaining stakeholder evaluations of HRM capabilities in MNC subsidiaries.Journal of International Business Studies,44(8), pp.813-832. Marler, J.H. and Fisher, S.L. (2013) An evidence-based review of e-HRM and strategic human resource management.Human Resource Management Review,23(1), pp.18-36. Nelson, E. (2019)In an alternate universe without Brexit, the UK economy is 3% larger. [Online] Available at:https://qz.com/1587374/the-uk-economy-would-be-3-bigger-if-brexit- never-happened-sp-says/ [Accessed 31/05/2019]. Orazulike, U. (2018) Post-Brexit Threats to Work Safety and Health Standards and Good WorkingConditionsintheUK.PsychosociologicalIssuesinHumanResource Management,6(1), pp.63-95. Parboteeah, K.P., Seriki, H.T. and Hoegl, M. (2014) Ethnic diversity, corruption and ethical climatesinsub-SaharanAfrica:Recognizingthesignificanceofhumanresource management.The International Journal of Human Resource Management,25(7), pp.979- 1001. Schlafke,M.,Silvi,R.andMoller,K.(2012)Aframeworkforbusinessanalyticsin performancemanagement.InternationalJournalofProductivityandPerformance Management,62(1), pp.110-122. Srdjevic, Z., Bajcetic, R. and Srdjevic, B. (2012) Identifying the criteria set for multicriteria decision making based on SWOT/PESTLE analysis: a case study of reconstructing a water intake structure.Water resources management,26(12), pp.3379-3393. Stone, D.L. and Deadrick, D.L. (2015) Challenges and opportunities affecting the future of human resource management.Human Resource Management Review,25(2), pp.139-145. Thite, M., Wilkinson, A. and Shah, D. (2012) Internationalization and HRM strategies across subsidiariesinmultinationalcorporationsfromemergingeconomies—Aconceptual framework.Journal of World Business,47(2), pp.251-258.
17 Ulrich, D., Younger, J., Brockbank, W. and Ulrich, M.D. (2013) The state of the HR profession.Human Resource Management,52(3), pp.457-471. Vora, M. (2013) Business excellence through sustainable change management.The TQM Journal,25(6), pp.625-640. Yalcin, N., Bayrakdaroglu, A. and Kahraman, C. (2012) Application of fuzzy multi-criteria decision making methods for financial performance evaluation of Turkish manufacturing industries.Expert Systems with Applications,39(1), pp.350-364.