Woolworths Audit Report Analysis

This assignment requires an in-depth analysis of Woolworths Limited's audit report for a specific year. The focus is on identifying and explaining significant transactions and events, particularly those related to the Home Improvement business exit. Key areas of analysis include the impact of new auditing standards (ASA 701), transparency provided to investors, and the company's accounting practices in relation to complex transactions. Students are expected to evaluate the adequacy of Woolworths' systems and processes, considering the company's size and complexity.

1
IMPACT OF ASA 701 – COMMUNICATING KEY AUDIT
MATTERS IN THE INDEPENDENT AUDITORS REPORT
Student Name: Student ID:
1/21/2018

SYNOPSIS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Impact of ASA 701 – Communicating key audit matters in the independent auditors report is title
of the report. The first major aim of the report is to identify whether the auditor of the selected
company has reported the key audit matters in its independent auditors report. The second major
aim of the report is to identify whether the key matters so reported in the independent auditors
report has the risk of material misstatement. The third major aim of the report is to identify any
significant event or transaction that has been taken place during the period of audit and whether
the same have any effect on the audit conducted by the independent auditor. The last major aim
of the report is to state whether these risks and transaction has affected the going concern
assumption of the company. With these aims, the report has been prepared into proper headings
and sub headings.
2

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY................................................................................................................................ 2
INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................................................. 4
DETAILS OF COMPANY........................................................................................................................................ 4
SELECTED COMPANY.....................................................................................................................................................4
NATURE OF BUSINESS................................................................................................................................................... 5
NEW AUDITING STANDARD – 701....................................................................................................................... 5
REASON FOR DEVELOPMENT.......................................................................................................................................... 5
MEANING................................................................................................................................................................... 5
KEY AUDIT MATTERS LISTED................................................................................................................................ 6
EXIT OF HOME IMPROVEMENT........................................................................................................................................6
VALUE OF PROPERTY PLANT AND EQUIPMENT – BIG W......................................................................................................6
PROVISION OF INVENTORY.............................................................................................................................................6
REBATES.....................................................................................................................................................................7
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY SYSTEMS..............................................................................................................................8
AREAS OF RISK.................................................................................................................................................... 9
SIGNIFICANT EVENT OR TRANSACTIONS AND ITS EFFECT ON AUDIT...................................................................10
RECOMMENDATION AND CONCLUSION............................................................................................................ 12
REFERENCES...................................................................................................................................................... 12
3

INTRODUCTION
The audit plays a very crucial role in depicting the financial health and position of any company
across the World. If there has been no provision for audit in statutes then the financial condition
of any company can never be depicted and the regulating authorities will not be able to track the
record of the company. In this report, the annual report of the company shall be analysed and
interpreted. The company selected for the purpose of the report is Woolworths Limited, being a
company listed in the Australian Stock Exchange. The annual report of the company for the year
ending 25th of June 2017 has been considered and has been analysed.
At first the detail of the company has been discussed then the importance of the new auditing
standard 701 has been discussed. After that, an independent auditors report has been analysed
with respect to the key audit matters reported therein as envisaged by the new auditing standard
number 701. Along with the key audit matters, the significant event and transaction if any
occurred during the period of audit has been discussed and detailed with regard to their likely
effect and impact on the audit of the company. Simultaneously matters have been discussed,
which are of risk and involves significant auditor and management judgment. At the last, the
summary has been given along with the recommendations on the basis of the results obtained.
, .
DETAILS OF COMPANY
Selected Company
The company that has been selected for the purpose of the report is M/s Woolworths Limited.
The company is listed in Australian Stock Exchange and is top 100 listed Corporation. Looking
back into the history of the company, the company has started its operations in the year of
nineteen hundred and twenty four.
4

Nature of Business
The company is into the retail sector since its inception and has been regarded as the second
largest company in retail sector having the higher revenues. The company is into the retail chains
of departmental stores in Australia and New Zealand and deals in all type of products whether it
is fruit or vegetables or home décor or hotels. As per the annual report of the company for the
year ending 25th of June 2017, the company has its focus on major five important things –
customers, performance in food, generating revenue from drinks area, the hotel business shall
have more revenue and lastly becoming a best retailer by improving the processes and systems
installed in the company (Woolworths Limited official website, 2017)
NEW AUDITING STANDARD – 701
Reason for Development
The anew auditing standard 701 deals with the communication of the key audit matters in the
independent auditors report. The development of the standard has been invoked by the global
financial crisis which has been happened because of the major accounting flaws and
discrepancies that has been made by the management of the some companies. Like Lehman
Brothers, HIH Insurance, ABC Learning and One Tel. These companies are the example and the
reason of bringing the global financial crisis and have alarmed the regulating authorities by the
different class action suits so as to avoid the manipulative practices that have been adopted by
the aforementioned companies (Bajada and Trayler, 2010; Cordos and Fülöpa, 2015).
Meaning
As auditor plays fiduciary role in communicating the financial health and position of the
company to their stakeholders and the shareholders, it is the duty of the auditor to fairly disclose
and describe the true and fair view. Thus, in order to give more value to the auditor report, the
new standard has provided more transparency (AASB, 2015 and Thomson, 2008). The key audit
matters deals with the additional information which will have the valuable impact on the decision
of the investor. It will include those matters which in the view of the auditor’s professional
judgment are of significant importance in the audit of financial statements and thus required
5

significant management judgment. These have resulted the revision of auditing standard on
going concern (Masytoh O, 2010).
KEY AUDIT MATTERS LISTED
In the annual report of the company – Woolworths Limited for the period ending 25th of June
2017, the auditor has communicated five key audit matters in the independent auditors report.
These are as follows:
Exit of Home Improvement
The company has decided to discontinue the operations of the Home Improvement Business. In
this process, there have been major interrelated components which needs to be scrutinized and is
very much complex in nature due to which the auditor of the company has mentioned the same
as one of the key audit matter.
Value of Property Plant and Equipment – Big W
The carrying value of the Big W segment of the company has been arrived after deducting the
huge amount of the impairment. This is so because the results of the Big W have been
deteriorating on a yearly basis and the stage have come where the carrying value of the assets is
more than the recoverable amount. Thus, the company has charged an impairment of $35.3
million. It has been regarded as one of the key audit matters as the management of the company
has uses its own judgment for arriving at the recoverable amount using the future cash flows and
discounting the same at the capitalization rate.
Provision of Inventory
The company has provided for obsolescence and shrinkage in relation to the inventory on the
basis of the forecasts and the historical estimates. The more emphasis has been given to the slow
moving products and seasonal products. Forecasts includes management judgment and is of high
importance and hence regarded as key audit matter.
6

Rebates
The company has been receiving the rebates and discounts from the suppliers but the accounting
for the same requires deep knowledge of the recognition principle with respect to the contracts
entered into with the suppliers.
7

Information Technology Systems
The information technology system installed is complex across the organization and hence forms
the key audit matter.
8

AREAS OF RISK
There are two major areas of risks:
1. The working of the segment of BIG W is at significant risk. It is because the revenue as
being generated by this segment is very less and instead of discontinuing the business the
company has written down the value of the property plant and equipment belonging to
the business of BIG W. The risk is that the property plant and equipment belonging to
this segment will get eroded in future year and thus will deteriorate the net worth of the
company.
2. The second major risk is the working and implementation of the Information Technology
Systems. It is because only through the information technology systems the company has
9

been working and if that is complex then it will be difficult for the next auditor and the
investors to rely on the controls placed by the company in this regard.
SIGNIFICANT EVENT OR TRANSACTIONS AND ITS EFFECT ON AUDIT
In accordance with the paragraph number nine of the auditing standard 701, following are the
major significant transaction that have occurred during the course of the audit and have the
relevant effect on the audit as described below (AASB, 2015):
1. The considerable decrease in the value of the property plant and equipment of the BIG W
business is one of the major significant transactions. It is because the auditor has in
accordance with the procedures as specified in paragraph number nine, has taken
appropriate steps like discussion with the management, evaluating the methodologies as
adopted by the management and testing and evaluation thereof including sensitivity
analysis. In order to find out the recoverable amount, the management has used its
judgment for arriving at future trading results including the future growth rates. The
management judgments although reviewed by the auditor but it needs to be referred as
the significant event and transaction as the assets of BIG W has been bought at
recoverable amount (Kachelmeier, Schmidt and Valentine, 2016).
10

2. The second major significant event is the exit of the home improvement business. It is
because along with the sale of the home improvement business, other major events and
transactions has got happened beginning from the period of August 2016 and extending
to next year. These events include Sale of the Hydrox holdings Pty Ltd to the Home
Consortium, appointment of GA Australia Pty Ltd for the clearance of the Masters
Inventory under a guaranteed price of $492 million, granting of exclusive call option to
Home Investment Consortium company in Hydrox holdings Pty Ltd, entering of Share
Sales agreement, settlement of Lowe’s put option and recognition of the impairment of
the property plant and equipment and other assets of the Home Improvement business,
etc. All these have made the exit of the Home improvement more complex and due to this
complexity in nature as well as in accounting and therefore reporting, the transaction is
the significant (McKee, 2015).
11

RECOMMENDATION AND CONCLUSION
It is recommended for the company to employ the clear and best accounting practices so that
even the complex transactions and the event and the complex accounting can be understood by
the auditor in best manner so that true and fair view can be given.
The new auditing standard 701 has provided more and more transparency to the investors and
will provide the framework for the investors where they can evaluate different companies
performing in particular industry at one place. In the report, the auditor of the company has
mentioned the five key audit matters and relevant significant transaction and the event have
occurred. Although the company is the second largest company in the retail chain sector but the
systems that the company has employed in relation to accounting and management does not
commensurate with the business and thus to conclude the report the accounting treatment and
assumptions shall be carefully done and with transparency.
REFERENCES
AASB, (2015), “ASA 701, Communicating Key Audit Matters in the Independents Auditors
report”, available on http://www.auasb.gov.au/admin/file/content102/c3/ASA_701_2015.pdf
accessed at 21/01/2018.
Bajada, C. and Trayler, R., 2010. How Australia Survived the Global Financial Crisis. The
Financial and Economic Crises: An International Perspective, Edward Elgar: Cheltenham, UK
and Northampton, USA, pp.139-154.
Cordos, G.S. and Fülöpa, M.T., 2015. Understanding audit reporting changes: introduction of
Key Audit Matters. Accounting and Management Information Systems, 14(1), p.128.
Kachelmeier, S.J., Schmidt, J.J. and Valentine, K., 2016. The disclaimer effect of disclosing
critical audit matters in the auditor’s report.
12

Masytoh O, (2010), “The analysis of determinants of Going Concern Audit Report”, Journal of
Modern Accounting and Auditing, Vol 6(4), pp 27-36.
McKee, D., (2015). New external audit report standards are game changing. Governance
Directions, 67(4), p.222.
Thomson, J., (2008), “Five lessons from the Spectacular fall of Eddy Grooves”, available at
http://www.smartcompany.com.au/finance/five-lessons-from-the-spectacular-fall-of-eddy-
grroves.html accessed on 21/01/2018.
Woolworths Limited official website, 2017, “Annual Report 2017” available on
http://www.woolworthslimited.com.au accessed on 21/01/2018.
13