Scenario 1: Analysis In the first situation, Tony and Brenda were close friends, and it was a simple agreement based upon a promise. Scenario 1: Analysis In the first situation, Tony and Brenda were close friends, and it was a simple agreement based upon a promise. Rule 4: The rule used in the following situation is consideration an is stated as something that is given in return of another promise, whether in terms of money or terms of services Scenario 1: Analysis Yes, in the first scenario consideration was present