Business Strategy: Analysing Macro and Internal Environment of Morrisons
Verified
Added on 2023/06/18
|20
|5612
|451
AI Summary
This study analyses the impact of macro environment, internal environment and capabilities of Morrisons, and evaluates competitive forces using Porter's Five Forces model. It also applies various theories and models for strategic planning.
Contribute Materials
Your contribution can guide someone’s learning journey. Share your
documents today.
BUSINESS STRATEGY
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
Executive summary The strategic management plan is the document describing the goals of organisation by setting priorities and using the resources. It takes the actions to achieve goals. Business strategy is a part of strategic management. The company should apply the various business strategies according to the market trend and analysis the competition, the company should gin the market knowledge in respect to customer needs and requirements. The various strategies involve SWOT analysis, PESTEL analysis, VRIO model generic porter’s strategies etc. all this provides the informationregardingthemarketandcompanypositionandhelptocompetewiththe competitors. Morrisonsfocus on expansion of market share by entering in new markets. It provides improved service quality for enhancing consumer choice and enhances customer satisfaction and loyalty by collaborating with more restaurants across the world.The plan is made on Morrisons and evaluating the several growth strategies to enhance growth.
Contents INTRODUCTION...........................................................................................................................1 PART A...........................................................................................................................................1 P1 Analysing the impact of Macro Environment..............................................................1 P2 Analysis of internal environment and capabilities of organisation............................3 P3 Application of Porter'sFive Forces to evaluate the competitive forces.....................6 PART B............................................................................................................................................7 P4 Application of theories, and models for strategic planning........................................7 CONCLUSION..............................................................................................................................11 References:.....................................................................................................................................12
INTRODUCTION The business strategy is related to the aspect of planning which helps in achieving the goals by making effective utilization of resources. The business strategy is the set of decisions or course of actions which helps the person in achieving specific business objectives. It acts likes a master plan of company management to secure a competitive position in the market carried on operations (Benzidia, S and et.al., 2021). The study is being done on the Morrisons founded in 1899 by William Morrison which is the largest chain of super market in UK. It deals in the product of food and drink, clothing, books, magazines and many more. In study impact of macro environment, assessing the internal environment and capabilities of an organisation is being covered. Further, Porter's five force model is evaluated in competitive forces and applying range of theories or models to have an understanding of business strategy. PART A Introduction The business strategy is the set of decisions or course of actions which helps the person in achieving specific business objectives. It acts likes a master plan of company management to secure a competitive position in the market carried on operations. In study impact of macro environment, assessing the internal environment and capabilities of an organisation is being covered of Morrisons. Further, Porter's five force model is evaluated in competitive forces to gain the efficiency. P1 Analysing the impact of Macro Environment. It is defined as circumstances which exits in the economy related to aspects of internal and external environment and the component of strategic planning involving PESTLE Analysis, Stake holder Analysis and SWOT. PESTLE Analysis The tool is used by marketer for evaluating and observing macro-forces putting impact on organisation. Political factor-This is related to policy of government involving tax policy, tariffs, trade restrictions affecting business. The Morrisons was affected with the change in policies and regulations which created lot of uncertainty where the Brexit was the major political event. Due to multiple government legislation, there was huge impact on 1
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
Morrisons. It requires the political stability to carry out its business globally (Björkdahl, J., 2020). Economic factor-It is concerned with the economy aspects including economic growth rate,inflation,interestandexchangerate.TheemergingofBrexitcreatedmajor fluctuations in currency and created inflationary pressure which affected Morrisons in its growth. The inflation affects demand of Morrisons by increasing the prices which lowers the level of brand loyalty. Social factor-This involves the society of cultural and demographic trend considering factorofhealthconsciousness,populationgrowthrate,agedistributionetc.The Morrisons have business opportunities due to rising of age population. To attract the large customers Morrisons can launch new brand positioning with TV Campaign (Cavaleri, S. and Shabana, K., 2018). Technological factor-It is regarding the innovation which affects entire economy comprising of automation, technological advancements factors. The Morrisons takes the use of artificial intelligencesto drive it sales & stack its stores. The technology investment helps in reducing waste & makes business cost effective. The investment in R&D will help in building self-sustaining ecosystem driving innovation. Legal factor-It defines the legal forces of an organisation involving governmental bodies, laws & policies. The Morrisons is required to comply with all the legal laws such as food safety and legal standards, securities law, health and safety laws etc. Environmental factor-This is aspect of ecological impacting on business related to weatherconditions,andclimaticchange.TheMorrisonsaimstoremovecarbon emissions and reduce of poly boxes from supply chain. The Morrisons is required to comply with waste management and recycle policies (Centobelli, P and et.al., 2020). 2
Stakeholder Analysis It is a technique of understanding, determining and prioritizing all stakeholders in accordance to their power an interest over a business. It is an aspect of stakeholder management. The main purpose is to identify those stakeholders who have involvement in business directly or indirectly. High power, highly interested people- In this stakeholder of Morrisons have active participation in business activities by holding high power which puts high influence on people. The stakeholders are CEO or top management. It helps in making effective decision and strategies. High power, less interested people- The stakeholder of Morrison have the power of ruling business but having low interest regarding activities of business and having low influence involving suppliers, investors. They help in providing necessary supplies to meet the objectives (Daryousef, M., 2019). Low power, high interested people- The power of Morrisons stakeholder is low bu5t having high influence and interest in business operations which consider employees, leaders. Their performance helps in accomplishing business objectives by utilising resources efficiently. Low power, less interested people- The stakeholders have low power and interest in the operations of business which are labour (Epure, M. ed., 2018). 3
SWOT Analysis It is an framework used for evaluating the company competitive position by developing strategic planning. It helps in assessing internal and external factors with the current and future potential. Strength- The Morrisons have the efficient supply chain & distribution network. It has the strength of offering large product portfolio to customers such as food, clothing etc. it has 500 stores in UK with the employee strength of 130,000. The facility of online retailing and shopping increased the business sales and brand loyalty. Weakness-TheweaknessforMorrisonsisithaslimitedgeographicalreachin comparison to other brands. It makes delay in adapting changes. The company have weakness in marketing skills and weak brand image in comparison to others (Fayena, I. and et.al., 2020). Opportunities- To meet the demand of customers the Morrisons has the opportunity of tappingintoorganicproductsduetogrowingmarket.Ithastheopportunityof international expansion boosting the sales and overall business. Threats- The increase in competitors market share affects profit margin of Morrisons. It also faces the threat from increase in taxes or change in Government policies. The rise in competition from competitors is a threat for Morrisons (Horne, M.S., Williamson Jr, T.S. and Herman, A., 2018). From above it can be said that assessing the macro environment of PESTEL, Stakeholder analysis and SWOT analysis helped the Morrisons in knowing the factors which can impact on its business operations. The company can manage the policies and have the opportunity of 4
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
technology advancement which will help in attracting large customer base, increasing sales and productivity. P2 Analysis of internal environment and capabilities of organisation. It is related to the elements of business structure which is defines relationship and activities that are carried inside business. The internal analysis helps in knowing the company resources, competencies and competitiveness which helps in making better decision and growth of Morrisons by developingand implementing strategies (Kaliappen, N. and Hilman, H., 2017). The Resources based strategy is a managerial framework of organisation by which strategic resources are determined to have the competitive edge. The organisation assets, capabilities & competencies are identified by focusing on the internal resources. The use of RBV model helped Morrisons in fulfilling new opportunities through existing resources by using innovatively. It includes the framework of VRIO Analysis, and McKinsey framework. VRIO Analysis To evaluate the company resources, it is used as analytical technique through which company can ascertain resources and capabilities to have competitive advantage. The Morrisons uses to examine the internal resources. 5
Valuable-In these resources are considered valuable when the firm attains sustainable competitive advantage. The financial resources are considered to be valuable for Morrisons helping in investing external opportunities. The employees for the Morrisons are valuable as they ate highly trained leading productive outcome for organisation. The distribution network is also considered valuable by providing products to every outlet & helps in reaching more customers (Kompalla, A. and et.al., 2017). Rare-There are some resources which are considered as rare as only few firms can acquire. The strong financial resource is founded to rare in Morrisons as it can be possessed by the few companies. The Morrisons employees are rare as they are highly skilled and trained in comparisontootherfirms.ThedistributionnetworkisalsorareforMorrisonsas competitors needs lots of investment to have a better distribution network. Imitable-It provides the company a first mover advantage but the competitors try to imitate their resources. The valuable and rare resources help in strategies that other company cannot pursue. The financial resource is costly to imitate of Morrisons because competitors would also require the similar profits for accumulating number of financial resources. The patents are challenging to imitate of Morrisons because it does not allow legally to imitate an patented product (Oguji, N. and Owusu, R.A., 2021). Organisation-To have the competitive advantage the company itself is required to organise resources to exploit advantage and derive value. The resources of Morrisons are organised in efficient way which helps in capturing the market share and value. The 6
financial resources, distribution network is organised effectively which helps in attracting large customer base and sustains the competitive advantage. McKinsey framework It is a model of organisational effectiveness which postulates the organisation internal factors that necessarily to be aligned and strengthened to facilitates success. It is a mixture of hard and soft skills which are influenced by corporate culture and management. It is a structure of 7S. Structure-The company structure of Morrisons is made with hierarchy, chain of command, which describes interconnection and functioning of business operations.It forms the organisational chart to have the accountability relationship (Saskara, I.A.N. and Marhaeni, A.A.I.N., 2017). Strategy-It is related to plan that organisation develops to being competitive in market andlong-termstrategyisestablishedbycommunicatingorganisationgoalsand objectives. The Morrisons follows the cost leadership strategy to have the market share. Skill-This consists of organisation staff and management capabilities and talents which assess achievements and working that company can accomplish. The Morrisons render training to their employees to develop more skills to cope with challenges. System-It is related to the company daily procedures, workflow, and decisions which helps in making standard operations. It has broad range of system for sustaining operations and works in the systematic way (Schaefer, J.W., 2018). Style-It defines the approaches that management takes to lead the company, influencing performance, productivity and culture of corporate. The Morrisons adopts the effective management and leadership style to motivate the employees for improving performance. Staff-It is associated with personnel of company that are trained and motivated to accomplish the task. Specific strategies are followed by the staff members for improving the level of productivity and efficiency. Shared values-These are related to the standards and norms of company influencing behaviour of entire staff and management. The main aspects of Morrisons are aligned to maintain the organisational design effectiveness (Schaltegger, S. and Wagner, M. eds., 2017). 7
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
From above it can be said, that analysis of VRIO frame work helps the Morrisons in knowing the resources that are valuable or rare and imitable or organised which helps in gaining growth by using the resources in efficient way. The framework of McKinsey comprises of 7S which help the company in knowing their potential of capabilities and competitiveness. P3 Application of Porter'sFive Forces to evaluate the competitive forces This model helps in identifying and evaluating the competitive forces of a firm to know their strength and weakness. It helps in knowing the level of competition and increases the long- term profitability. Threat of new entrant-The emerging of new entrant will increase the competition level and brings additional capacity. The new entrant brings the innovation which forces Morrisons to lower pricing strategy, cost reducing and offers new value propositions to customers. To tackle this threat the Morrisons can innovate new products and services to attract more customers and to differentiate its product. It can create economies of scale by lowering the prices (Stewart, and et.al., 2021). Bargaining power of suppliers-The power of supplier affects the overall profitability as the company purchases raw material from several suppliers. The suppliers having dominant position decreases the margin of Morrisons. The power is low as there is less control on the prices. The products are less differentiated and low switching cost which makes weak power. To tackle this Morrisons can build efficient supply chain with 8
multiple suppliers. It can also purchase raw material at low cost from suppliers or it can switch suppliers. Bargaining power of buyers-The demanding of buyers is lot as they want to purchase by paying minimum prices. The Morrisons faces pressures on the long run profitability. The powerful customer base leads to high bargaining power and high ability of seeking increasing discounts and offers (Björkdahl, J., 2020). To tackle this Morrisons can build large customer base which will help in lowering power of buyer and provide opportunity to increase sales and production process. The products can be innovated to seeks the discounts for customers. Threat of substitute products and services-The profitability of Morrisons is suffered when new product or service meets the demand of customers in similar way. The threat can be high if offers value proposition which is different in unique way from present offerings. The limited selection of differentiating factor makes challenging for consumers to switch from the super branded products. To tackle this the Morrisons can increase the switching cost for customers. It can offer quality products in contrasting to substitute products. Competitive rivalry in market-The intense rivalry in Morrisons leads to down prices and decreases overall profitability. The rivalry in the industry is high due to upsurge in commoditiesofdemandandsupply(Cavaleri,S.andShabana,K.,2018).The competitors are Tesco, Sainsbury etc. To tackle this Morrisons is required to carry market research for knowing supply-demand situation and it can centre on new consumers for the commodities. With this it can also build sustainable differentiation and collaboration with competitors to enhance the size of market. From above it can be said that, the competitive forces provide the complete picture on the profitability that impacts the Morrisons. It also benefited in analysing the competition. The company faces internal pressure from the bargaining power of supplier and buyers and external pressure from the competitive rivalry, substitute products and thereat of new entrant in market. 9
PART B Introduction The organisation it requires the proper planning and flexibility in designing for the purpose of mobilising resources, meeting challenges and threats, perceiving and utilising opportunities etc.Itisacompetitivemovebybusinessforattractingthecustomerstoachievethe organisational goals by strengthening performance. The several theories and models is been applied on Morrisons to enhance the productivity by using porters generic strategies, Bowman strategy clock and Ansoff model. P4 Application of theories, and models for strategic planning The strategy is defined as the general plan which helps in achieving long term goals in the situation of uncertainty (Centobelli, P and et.al., 2020). The strategy helps in setting goals and priorities, determines actions and mobilize resources to execute the action plan. Porter's Generic Strategies It is an strategy which defines the competitive advantage of the company that in what way it pursues in the market scope. The cost is lowered or product is differentiated to gain the advantage of competitiveness. Cost Leadership-The firms become low-cost producer to gain the competitive edge by lowering the prices in a target market. It considers the factors of economies of scale, technology, and access of raw material (Daryousef, M., 2019). The Morrisons uses to preserve the cost leadership through applying value chain management efficiently. There is an expansion of market by concentrating on consumers to have the importance of pricing factor. The sales growth and brand awareness are increased. 10
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
Cost Differentiation-In this firm differentiates its products from competitors to look unique in Marketa. The one or more attributes are selected and position uniquely to meet those needs. With the premium price the uniqueness is awarded. The new and innovative products are offered by the Morrisons to customers. Through this the customer base is expanded by offering unique features of commodities that helps in achieving growth objectives (Epure, M. ed., 2018). Focus-It is an last strategy of generic model where there is a selection of group of segments which has two variants cost focus strategy and differentiation focus strategy. To gain the competitive advantage it serves to the particular market segment in niche market. The Morrisons adopts to offer the best value by reducing the cost. Bowman’s strategy clock This strategy was developed by the two economists Cliff Bowman and David Faulkner. The main focus of this strategy is to make companies aware regarding their position in the market in comparison to competitors (Fayena, I. and et.al.,2020). It is an marketing model which highlights in what way business can position its product and services. Low price and low value added-The competitive edge can be achieved by keeping price low that business uses to compete with the competitors. The pricing of product and service in Morrisons is low which is not distinguished and little value is perceived by customers. It is not a suitable competitive position for Morrisons (Horne, M.S and et.al., 2018). 11
Low price-In this large quantity of product are produced and are valued in target market. The products are sold at the lower price leading low profit margins but still high amount of profit can be generated by having high volume of profit in Morrisons. It is considered as cheap market leader focusing on cost minimizations. Hybrid-It is an effective strategy for the Morrisons value is added in the product of consistent nature. The Morrisons focus on product differentiation which creates the product of high value in market & customers mind. Differentiation- The Morrisons focus on branding rather than the product quality. The offering of the product is at average price that wishes to offer customers high level of perceived value which makes distinctive identity in market. The customers are ready to pay higher prices for high quality products(Kaliappen, N. and Hilman, H., 2017). Focused differentiation-This strategy is applicable on the brands of luxurious products or exclusive products that have high quality and sell on higher price. The Morrisons attain higher profits by targeting promotions, marketing, and segmentation strategies. Risky high margins-In this high price for the product is charged that perceive moderate value by the customers. It is a risky strategy for the Morrisons for positioning in long run. The customers seek for better quality product in similar price range for the objective of value for money (Kompalla, A. and et.al., 2017). Monopoly pricing-In this company position themselves as monopoly market leader in the market as they are one in offering specific type of product. The Morrisons do not have the fear of facing competition as there is one determinant for product pricing. The customer has no choice regarding the product purchase even they have to buy on the higher prices which puts less effective for Morrisons. Loss of market shares- This strategy is not desirable for the organisation as it denotes to worse position or the company is in declining stage (Oguji, N. and Owusu, R.A., 2021). The Morrisons in this stage is not able to offer the products that is valued by the customer. The customers are not interest in product purchasing as prices are high. 12
Ansoff matrix It is a marketing model used for determining the company product and marketing growth strategy. It is a stage of marketing planning process. It displays four strategies that is used by organisation for their growth. Market penetration-In such strategy the firm in existing market uses its product for increasing the market share by declining in prices for attraction of customers. The Morrisonscanincreaseitspromotionanddistributioneffortsforincreasingsales (Saskara, I.A.N. and Marhaeni, A.A.I.N., 2017). Market development-It is a strategy of creating new market for the same products which seeks the expansion in geographic region, customer segments. The Morrisons can have market development by entering into international market or catering different customer segments or it can have regional expansion by entering into domestic market. Product development-This is the strategy where new product is developed by the company in same market by having research and development and expanding company product range. It can be employed by the firms after having strong knowledge of market to provide innovative solutions to meet needs of existing market (Schaefer, J.W., 2018). The Morrisons can have product development by adding new features in the same product. The Morrisons can acquire product or resources can be merged to meet the demand of existing market. 13
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
Diversification-This is strategy where the firms enter into new market with new product. It is a risky strategy for both the development of market and product. With the help of diversification, the risk can be minimised and offers the great potential for increasing revenue (Tsai, S.C., 2017). From the above it can be said the Morrisons can opt differentiation strategy of porter’s generic from bowman strategy it can choose hybrid and product differentiation which will help the company in differentiating product from the competitors by involving new and unique features which facilitates in higher profit and sales by offering innovative products. From the Ansoff matric Morrisons can choose strategy of product development for the growth. Strategic management plan Business description-The Morrisons is supermarket in UK which is established in 1899 which employees 1,10,000 employees and serve around 11000 million customers. It has 497 stores. The vision statement to become great leaders in the UK for sustainable future. Themission statement is to use experience and designing innovation for providing flexible and responsive solution of product. To be competitive in market by improving product feature and specification (Yasir, M and et.al., 2020). To enhance sales by 25% by 1 year. Market analysis-This involves the analysis of STP for attracting more customers and increasing sales. The segmentation of Morrisons targets the market segment on the basis 14
of age group and on basis of demographics. The targeting of Morrisons targets to every class of people providing quality products and services. The positioning of the Morrisons will be through by making product unique, providing better customer services. Marketing Strategies-The Morrisons can have the strategy of product development for customer attraction and increase in sales by offering innovative products in same market. Marketing tactics-Product: It offers varieties of products and focuses on fresh food. Price: It uses premium pricing for encouraging favourable brand products. Place: The company makes products available to all geographic region and in all the stores. Promotion: for the product promotion it makes the use of various promotional techniques such as digital marketing for more customer interactions (Zhou, P. and Wen, W., 2020). Monitoring and controlling-The bench marking tool can be used by Morrisons for making comparison with the actual performance with plan. CONCLUSION From the above analysis it can be said that implementation of appropriate strategies helps the company in growth and leading to success. The businesses are expanded by making the strategy which clearly defines the company objectives, mission etc. The clear strategy helps in providing clear understanding to employees, accountants, borrowers and investors regarding the business. The good strategy helps business in earning long term profit. The company takes in account several growth strategies in accordance to marketing trend and analysis of competition. The business is required to have proper market knowledge to meet the demand of customers and their requirements. 15
References: Books and Journals Benzidia,Sandet.al.,2021.Disruptiveinnovation,businessmodels,andencroachment strategies: Buyer's perspective on electric and hybrid vehicle technology.Technological Forecasting and Social Change.165.p.120520. Björkdahl, J., 2020. Strategies for digitalization in manufacturing firms.California Management Review.62(4). pp.17-36. Cavaleri, S. and Shabana, K., 2018. Rethinking sustainability strategies.Journal of Strategy and Management. Centobelli, P and et.al., 2020. Managing supply chain resilience to pursue business and environmental strategies.Business Strategy and the Environment.29(3),. pp.1215-1246. Daryousef,M.,2019.ExploringtheStrategiesProjectManagersNeedforBusiness Transformation and Sustainability for New Product Development(Doctoral dissertation, Colorado Technical University). Epure, M. ed., 2018.The role of language and symbols in promotional strategies and marketing schemes. IGI Global. Fayena, I. and et.al.,2020. Learning strategies of high-tech entrepreneurs about business opportunities.International Journal of Entrepreneurial Venturing.12(2). pp.228-250. Horne, M.S., Williamson Jr, T.S. and Herman, A., 2018.The contingent workforce: Business and legal strategies. Law Journal Press. Kaliappen, N. and Hilman, H., 2017. Competitive strategies, market orientation types and innovation strategies: finding the strategic fit.World Journal of Entrepreneurship, Management and Sustainable Development. Kompalla, A. and et.al., 2017. Tailored automotive business strategiesin the context of digitalization and service-oriented models.Calitatea.18(156). p.77. Oguji, N. and Owusu, R.A., 2021. Market entry into Africa: Acquisitions and international joint ventures. Studies of foreign firms' market entry strategies, challenges, and performance in Africa. Saskara, I.A.N. and Marhaeni, A.A.I.N., 2017. The role of social capital and business strategies indevelopingthebusinessofBantentoincreaseBalinesewomen’s employment.Journal of Comparative Asian Development.16(1). pp.68-86. Schaefer, J.W., 2018.Content Marketing: Essential Guide to Learn Step-by-Step the Best Content Marketing Strategies to Attract your Audience and Boost Your Business. EC Publishing via PublishDrive. Schaltegger, S. and Wagner, M. eds., 2017.Managing the business case for sustainability: The integration of social, environmental and economic performance. Routledge. Stewart, R. and Niero, M., 2018. Benzidia, S., Luca, R.M. and Boiko, S., 2021. Disruptive innovation, business models, and encroachment strategies: Buyer's perspective on electricandhybridvehicletechnology.TechnologicalForecastingandSocial Change.165.p.120520. Björkdahl, J., 2020. Strategies for digitalization in manufacturing firms.California Management Review.62(4). pp.17-36. Cavaleri, S. and Shabana, K., 2018. Rethinking sustainability strategies.Journal of Strategy and Management. 16
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
Centobelli, P and et.al., 2020. Managing supply chain resilience to pursue business and environmental strategies.Business Strategy and the Environment.29(3),. pp.1215-1246. Daryousef,M.,2019.ExploringtheStrategiesProjectManagersNeedforBusiness Transformation and Sustainability for New Product Development(Doctoral dissertation, Colorado Technical University). Epure, M. ed., 2018.The role of language and symbols in promotional strategies and marketing schemes. IGI Global. Fayena, I. and et.al.,2020. Learning strategies of high-tech entrepreneurs about business opportunities.International Journal of Entrepreneurial Venturing.12(2). pp.228-250. Horne, M.S and et.al., 2018.The contingent workforce: Business and legal strategies. Law Journal Press. Kaliappen, N. and Hilman, H., 2017. Competitive strategies, market orientation types and innovation strategies: finding the strategic fit.World Journal of Entrepreneurship, Management and Sustainable Development. Kompalla, A. and et.al., 2017. Tailored automotive business strategiesin the context of digitalization and service-oriented models.Calitatea.18(156). p.77. Oguji, N. and Owusu, R.A., 2021. Market entry into Africa: Acquisitions and international joint ventures. Studies of foreign firms' market entry strategies, challenges, and performance in Africa. Saskara, I.A.N. and Marhaeni, A.A.I.N., 2017. The role of social capital and business strategies indevelopingthebusinessofBantentoincreaseBalinesewomen’s employment.Journal of Comparative Asian Development.16(1). pp.68-86. Schaefer, J.W., 2018.Content MarCircular economy in corporate sustainability strategies: A reviewofcorporatesustainabilityreportsinthefast‐movingconsumergoods sector.Business Strategy and the Environment.27(7). pp.1005-1022. Tsai, S.C., 2017. Effectiveness of ESL students' performance by computational assessment and roleofreadingstrategiesincourseware-implementedbusinesstranslation tasks.Computer Assisted Language Learning.30(6). pp.474-487. Yasir, M and et.al., 2020. Promoting environmental performance in manufacturing industry of developingcountriesthroughenvironmentalorientationandgreenbusiness strategies.Journal of Cleaner Production.275.p.123003. Zhou, P. and Wen, W., 2020. Carbon-constrained firm decisions: From business strategies to operations modeling.European Journal of Operational Research .281(1). pp.1-15. 17