HA2032 Corporate & Financial Accounting: Reporting Standards Report

This report provides a detailed analysis of financial accounting and reporting standards, examining the need for regulatory standards versus voluntary reporting by managers. It discusses the role of the Australian Accounting Standards Board (AASB) in influencing global financial reporting standa...Read More

CORPORATE AND FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING
Page 1 of 18

Executive Summary:
The present report encompasses various aspects of the financial accounting and reporting
standards and its need. The presented report commences with the discussion of the need for
regulatory standards for the financial reporting and the stand of voluntary reporting by the
manager. The report then lists the process by which the AASB influence the global regulation
for financial reporting standards and the reasons of non-mandate of the IFRS for the members
of the IASB. The report then presents the analysis of owner’s equity extracted from the annual
financial reports of four companies. The report concludes with comments on the entire context.
Page 2 of 18

Table of Contents
1.0 Introduction:..............................................................................................................................4
2.0 Corporate regulation: Critical discussion on the voluntary financial disclosures.....................5
3.0 Accounting standards setting:...................................................................................................7
3.1 AASB accountability in the global accounting standard setting process:..............................7
3.2 Compulsion of IFRS for member countries of IASB:..............................................................8
4.0 Owner’s Equity:........................................................................................................................10
4.1 Comparing the equity:.........................................................................................................10
4.1.1 Rio Tinto:.......................................................................................................................10
4.1.2 Woolworths Limited:.....................................................................................................11
4.1.3 BHP Billiton Limited.......................................................................................................12
4.1.4 Commonwealth Bank....................................................................................................13
4.2 Comparative analysis of the debt and equity position:.......................................................14
5.0 Conclusion:...............................................................................................................................16
References:....................................................................................................................................17
Page 3 of 18

1.0 Introduction:
The present report discusses the criticality of the mandatory and voluntary financial reporting
for an organisation. This report also discusses the step through which the Australian Accounting
Standard Board can partake in the global standard-setting process. As part of the research, the
study presents a comparative analysis on owner’s equity from the annual statements of four
different organisations.
Page 4 of 18

2.0 Corporate regulation: Critical discussion on the voluntary financial disclosures
A financial report of a company available to internal and external groups represents the
published document of the company’s position and performance in financial terms. The reports
are classified categorically based on a standard form (Lion, 2012). This information is used by
various stakeholders like investors, analyst groups, government, shareholders, employees and
the general public. The vested interest in the financial performance of a company of the
different stakeholders varies. Each of the stakeholders would require the information in their
own perception, for the ease of understanding and analysis to extract useful insights and future
indulgence with the organisation. Provided, the stakeholders prepare the reports for
accompanying, the information would vary significantly. To interpret the financial reports in a
systematic way, synchronisation and uniformity are necessary for the presentation of the
information. Therefore, the need for regulated financial accounting and reporting arise. Sunder
(2016) also argued that limiting managerial discretion in publishing the reports improves the
quality of the information and overall report.
The owner or board of business delegates the leading functions of the enterprise to the
managers who are responsible for the performance of individual accounts. Although there are
no set standards of the voluntary disclosures by managers, these are often used by companies
in addition to the mandatory reporting to increase potential investors and reduce the cost of
investment. On the hind side, voluntary disclosure can hinder the firm’s competitive advantages
in the market or allow a capital market to conduct an apt evaluation of the company’s shares.
Both the factors can limit the performance of the company in the future. In this regards
Page 5 of 18

Cianciaruso and Sridhar (2018) stated that management may publish reports given the capital
agency cost reduction is lesser than the cost of information publication for the market.
Therefore, voluntary disclosure can be employed by a firm if that could reap some positive
benefit without impacting the performance and long-term goals.
Page 6 of 18

3.0 Accounting standards setting:
3.1 AASB accountability in the global accounting standard setting process:
The Australian Accounting Standard Board (AASB) develops and maintains the set of regulations
applicable to the financial reporting standards of the private and public sector entities in the
Australian economy. This board follows and influence the guidelines of the International
Accounting Standard Board (IASB) to set the accounting standards. As Australia has adopted the
International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), any issue on the program would also reflect
in the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Aasb.gov.au, 2018).
Following steps take place through which AASB affect the IFRS:
Issue identification:
Members of AASB board or individual companies identify some technical issue that needs
consideration related to improve relevance or efficiency and reduce cost.
Include issue in a research agenda:
The AASB prepares a project agenda to assess the potentiality of the amendments related to
the issue.
Research and consideration:
The board then discusses the agenda with the members considering the scope, alternative
approaches and timeline to implement the changes necessary.
Stakeholder consultation:
Page 7 of 18

Post the research on the project scope, AASB presents the related documents for public
feedback and stakeholder discussion.
Pronouncement:
The issue consideration by AASB results in the formation of a standard, framework or further
interpretation of the perspective.
Submission to IASB:
AASB then formally submits the interpretation or framework to the IASB for consideration. This
process contributes towards the setting of improved quality international accounting standards.
3.2 Compulsion of IFRS for member countries of IASB:
IFRS are standard guidelines which are free from specific regulations that are applicable to the
member countries of the IASB. Some of the reasons for the non-compulsion of the IFRS for the
member countries are:
 Accounting standards may have legal obligations in some legislation. This can hinder the
actual convergence with the IFRS rules. Thus, it can require co-operation with domestic
regulators. It may require parliamentary approval too (Prabhakar, 2013).
 The constituents of IASB are numerous and having varied economic statures. The board
may face difficulties in communicating clearly with the relevant member regarding the
implementation of standards. IASB encourages letters from the member constituencies
with comments and consultative feedback (Kwak and Wang, 2015).
Page 8 of 18

 The accounting standard boards of individual countries know what is well suited
according to the needs of the state. The respective standard boards use the
international guideline to align the reporting towards a global structure (Kampanje,
2013).
Page 9 of 18

4.0 Owner’s Equity:
The aim of calculating Owner's Equity is to demonstrate the changes in the capital account due
to the contributions, withdrawals, and the net income or net loss experienced by a firm.
Considering the same, the current section is going to evaluate the equity value of the owners
for the leading organisations named, Rio Tinto, Commonwealth Bank, BHP Billiton and
Woolworths Ltd. over the past four years.
4.1 Comparing the equity:
4.1.1 Rio Tinto:
RIO TINTO
OWNER'S EQUITY (US$M)
FY
2017
FY
2016
FY
2015
FY
2014
Share Capital - Rio Tinto Plc 220 224 224 230
Share Capital -Rio Tinto Limited 4,140 3,915 3,950 4,535
Share premium account 4,306 4,304 4300 4,288
Other reserves
12,28
4 9,216 9,139
11,12
2
Retained Earnings
23,76
1
21,63
1
19,73
6
26,11
0
Total Equity attributable to owners of Rio Tinto
44,71
1
39,29
0
37,34
9
46,28
5
Table 1: Owner’s Equity Value of Rio Tinto between FY 2014-2017
(Source: Created by author)
Analysis:
The above table indicates that the share capital of Rio Tinto Plc. is consistently decreasing.
Although the value was found consistent (US$224M) in two consecutive years (FY2015 and
Page 10 of 18

2016), it was reduced in the FY 2017 (US$220M). Similarly, the share capital of Rio Tinto
Limited, as the value decreased up to US$3,915M in FY 2016, compared to the FY2014, which
was US$4,535M. However, the annual report of FY2017 indicates an improvement and growth
in the share capital of Rio Tinto Limited (US$4,140M). Hence, it can be stated that the company
has issued shares in the market to acquire fund for the business. Thus, the overall business
condition is good.
However, the share premium account shows a consistent improvement since FY2014 (4,306 in
FY2017) and the overall capital utilization towards the business is positive. In addition,
comparing the retained earning value from FY2014 to FY2017, it can be inferred that with
fluctuations, the company is proceeding towards the sustainability (Riotinto.com, 2018). Finally,
contrasting the annual reports of consecutive 4 financial years, it is clear that Rio Tinto’s net
worth of the business is increasing.
4.1.2 Woolworths Limited:
Woolworths Limited
OWNER'S EQUITY (US$M)
FY
2017
FY
2016
FY
2015
FY
2014
Shareholders’ equity 9,526 8,471 10,834 10,253
Total Equity attributable to owners of Woolworths Limited 9,876 8,782
11,13
2
10,52
5
Table 2: Owner’s Equity Value of Woolworths Limited between FY2014-2017
(Source: Created by author)
Analysis:
Page 11 of 18

It may be noted that the break-up of equity for the firm has not been available from the annual
report of the company. The above finding indicates that FY2015 was remarkably good for the
company, as the shareholder’s equity value was increased up to US$10,834M, which was
US$10,253M in the FY 2014. However, in the FY2016 shareholder’s equity dropped into
US$8,471M and it indicates that the net worth value of the business has decreased. Thus, the
selling value is found comparatively lesser than the previous financial year. It also indicates that
the investors might not be willing to invest for the further business expansion. The decrease in
shareholder’s equity also states that the company is not acquiring its true market potential. The
lack of growth potential also indicates that the company has bought back the shares to
reconstruct or restructure the capital of the business, which is a threat for the business in
meeting the stability.
However, from annual report of FY2017, it is evident that the company has increased
shareholder’s equity by more than 10% compared to the previous year. It shows a good sign of
moving towards stability with fluctuations (Woolworthsgroup.com.au, 2018). Hence, it can be
considered that the company has issued shares in the market. Thus, considering the growth
pattern in owner’s equity, the investors might be interested to invest in Woolworths. After
comparing and contrasting the owner’s equity report for four consecutive years, it can be
inferred that overall business is intending towards growth and the approach can provide
stability in the future.
4.1.3 BHP Billiton Limited
BHP BILLITON
OWNER'S EQUITY (US$M) FY FY FY FY
Page 12 of 18

2017 2016 2015 2014
Share capital – BHP Billiton Limited 1,186 1,186 1,186 1,186
Share capital – BHP Billiton Plc 1,057 1,057 1,057 1,069
Treasury shares 3 33 76 587
Reserves 2,400 2,538 2,557 2,927
Retained earnings
52,61
8
49,54
2
60,04
4
74,54
8
Total equity attributable to BHP shareholders
57,25
8
54,29
0
64,76
8
79,14
3
Table 3: Owner’s Equity Value of BHP Billiton Limited between FY2014-2017
(Source: Created by author)
Analysis:
After analysing the equity value from the annual report of BHP Billiton, it has been identified
that the share capital value of the firm was US$1,186M consistently from FY2014 to FY2017.
However, the share capital value for BHP Billiton Plc. was US$1,069M in FY2014 and it remained
consistent to US$1,057M in the last three consecutive years i.e. FY2017, FY2016 and FY2015.
However, the treasury shares value of the selected firm has faced a significant downturn in the
last four years as it was US$587M in FY2014 and US$3M in FY2017. This kind of tax efficient
method helps the firm to keep cash into the shareholders' hands, rather than offering
dividends. Adding to this, the reserves value of BHP Billiton declined in a similar way. It was
US$2,927M in FY2014 and decreased up to US$2,400M in FY 2017 (Bhp.com, 2018). Hence, the
retained earnings of the firm got affected significantly in the last four consecutive years. Hence,
after considering all these it can be deduced that the growth value of the firm is not
Page 13 of 18

outstanding. Moreover, the total equity attributable to BHP shareholders depicts that the
financial health of the firm is not strong.
4.1.4 Commonwealth Bank
COMMON WEALTH BANK
OWNER'S EQUITY (US$M)
FY
2017
FY
2016
FY
2015
FY
2014
Ordinary share capital
35,26
2
34,12
5
27,89
4
27,32
3
Other equity instruments 406 1,895 1,895
Reserves 2,556 3,115 3,195 3,011
Retained profits
22,31
2
20,43
0
18,76
3
16,20
6
Shareholders' equity attributable to equityholders of the Bank
60,13
0
58,07
6
51,74
7
48,43
5
Table 4: Owner’s Equity Value of Commonwealth Bank between FY 2014-2017
(Source: Created by author)
Analysis:
The financial report of Commonwealth Bank indicates that the ordinary share capital value of
the firm has increased in a consistent way as it was US$27,323 M in FY2014, US$27,894M in
FY2015, US$34,125M in FY2016 and US$35,262M in FY2017. The growth of other equity
instruments has collapsed significantly in the last four consecutive years. As per the annual
report of the firm, it was US$1,895M both in FY2014 and FY2015. However, the value changed
into US$406M in FY2016 and it became null in FY2017. In addition, the reserves value of the
firm decreased successively which refers that the firm is potential to hold its consistent position
in the operating market. As evidence, the retained profit of the chosen firm has increased
concurrently to satisfy the shareholders. The statistical data depicts that it was US$16,206M in
Page 14 of 18

FY2014 and increased up to US$22,312M in FY2017 (Commbank.com.au, 2018). Hence, after
calculating all these it can be depicted that the value of shareholder’s equity has been increased
from US$48,435M (FY2014) to US$60,130M (FY2017). Hence, it can be deduced that the
Commonwealth Bank is able to maintain its financial commitment to its shareholders.
4.2 Comparative analysis of the debt and equity position:
As far as debt position is concerned, it may be noted that the same has been much lesser for
Rio Tinto (long-term debt is $15,148 million as compared to equity of $44,711 million for 2017)
than $29,233 million debt as compared to equity of $57,258 million for 2017, in the case of BHP
Billiton. Moreover, the debt position of commonwealth bank has also been much controlled in
the sense that the loan capital occupies $17,959 million as against the equity base of $60,130
million for the current year. Therefore, it may be construed that none of the companies have
been debt dependent and management of all the firms have been managing the capital
structure by way of relying more on equity in order to avoid the fixed interest payment burden.
Page 15 of 18

5.0 Conclusion:
Based on the discussion and analysis performed in the preceding sections of the report, it may
be concluded that the regulated financial reporting plays a long way to maintain the efficiency
of the financial reporting framework globally., different standard setting bodies and regulators
have, time to time, issued standards for the purpose of streamlining the corporate reporting
process for the purpose of better comparability, The report shows how the different company’s
financial statements may be compared and evaluated based on the given parameters.
Page 16 of 18

References:
Aasb.gov.au. (2018). The standard-setting process. [online] Available at:
https://www.aasb.gov.au/About-the-AASB/The-standard-setting-process.aspx [Accessed 25
Sep. 2018].
Bhp.com. (2018). [online] Available
at: https://www.bhp.com/-/media/documents/investors/annual-reports/2017/
bhpannualreport2017.pdf [Accessed 25 Sep. 2018].
Cianciaruso, D. and Sridhar, S. (2018). Mandatory and Voluntary Disclosures: Dynamic
Interactions. Journal of Accounting Research, 56(4), pp.1253-1283.
Commbank.com.au. (2018). [online] Available
at: https://www.commbank.com.au/content/dam/commbank/about-us/shareholders/pdfs/
annual-reports/annual_report_2017_14_aug_2017.pdf [Accessed 25 Sep. 2018].
Kampanje, B. (2013). Bridging Gap between IAS 1 and IASB Conceptual Framework on Users of
Financial Statements. SSRN Electronic Journal, 8(20), pp.33-45.
Lion, J. (2012). How the IASB Interacts with Domestic Standard Setters - A Network of Standard
Setters. Australian Accounting Review, 22(3), pp.244-245.
Prabhakar, R. (2013). Varieties of Regulation: How States Pursue and Set International Financial
Standards. SSRN Electronic Journal, 16(23), pp.113-214.
Page 17 of 18

Riotinto.com. (2018). [online] Available
at: https://www.riotinto.com/documents/RT_2017_Annual_Report.pdf [Accessed 25 Sep.
2018].
Sunder, S. (2016). Rethinking Financial Reporting: Standards, Norms and
Institutions. Foundations and Trends® in Accounting, 11(1-2), pp.1-118.
Taiwan Kwak and Hyun-Sun Wang (2015). Value Relevance of Global and Non-Global Firms by
Adopting IFRS. Korea International Accounting Review, 20(61), pp.1-24.
Woolworthsgroup.com.au. (2018). [online] Available
at: https://www.woolworthsgroup.com.au/icms_docs/188795_annual-report-
2017.pdf[Accessed 25 Sep. 2018].
Page 18 of 18