Solving Ethical Dilemma in IT Production Management
Verified
Added on 2023/06/14
|5
|775
|169
AI Summary
This article discusses the steps to solve ethical dilemma in IT production management using Mc Donald’s framework. It also mentions the relevant stakeholders, values involved, and codes from ACS code of conduct. The decision is evaluated based on benefits and burdens, workplace health and safety act, and comfort level.
Contribute Materials
Your contribution can guide someone’s learning journey. Share your
documents today.
Running head: SOLVING ETHICAL DILEMMA Assignment Cover Sheet Subject Name:Professional Environments Assignment Name/Number: Date of Submission: Participant Name: ACS Member Number Email Address:
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
1SOLVING ETHICAL DILEMMA For Solving the Ethical dilemma the steps enumerated below in accordance with Mc Donald’s framework need to be followed. Step One: Assessing the moral conflict In the given case study, Kushalni faces an ethical obligation. Kushlani is the IT Production manager who has been assigned the task of carrying out trials of the task of soldering the chips with the pins of the processor by humans. This task was previously carried out by robots, however the error rate was very high and the cost of manufacturing the robots was also very high. The task when carried out by humans produced better results and improved accuracy. However the technicians faced headaches and eye strain due to looking at a brightly lit object through microscope. The management when informed, chose to neglect the complaints of the technicians. Thus in this case Kushlani clearly has a moral dilemma of whether to carry on the production of chips by human or not Step two: Recognizing the stakeholders The relevant stakeholders in this scenario include the technicians who are assigned the duty to carry on production of the microchips, the management and the Kushlani, the It manager. Step Three: Assessing the values involved The values of primacy of public interest, enhancement of quality of life and competence are involved in the aforementioned scenario (Acs.org.au 2018). The relevant codes from ACS code of conduct that are involved in the given scenario are (Acs.org.au 2018): Code 1.2.1.a
2SOLVING ETHICAL DILEMMA Code 1.2.1b Code 1.2.1c Code 1.2.2b Code 1.2.2d It can be said that Kushlani, being the It manager has the moral responsibility to act in the best interest of the public. He also has the responsibility to enhance the quality of life of the stakeholders involved. In this case thus in order to uphold his responsibility of enhancing the quality of life of the technicians he must stop the production of micro chips by such technicians. He also has the responsibility to work diligently for the company who is also a stakeholder. Thus the ethical dilemma arises. Step Four: Evaluating the benefits and Burdens of the decision. It can be said that if Kushlani continues the production of the microchips by the technicians, the health of such technicians would be adversely affected. However, in such a case the management would be pleased. On the other hand if Kushlani decides to pay attention to the complaints of the technicians and stop the production of microchips by humans, such technicians would not be subjected to adverse health conditions and their quality of life would be enhanced.However, in such a case the management would be displeased as producing microchips by robots would be more costly to the management. Step Five: Assessing situations which are similar
3SOLVING ETHICAL DILEMMA In accordance with the workplace health and Safety act 2011, It can be said that Business owners have the responsibility to maintain health and safety in the workplace. Step Six: Discussing the decision with people In the given scenario Kushlani can discuss the ethical dilemma with the colleagues, managers and family members for making the ethical decision Step Seven: Analyzing the decision with organizational and legal rules The decision of stopping the production of micro chips by technicians would be ethically correct and the same can be stated in accordance with the Workplace Health and Safety Act 2011. Step Eight: Assessment of the comfort level It can be said that the decision of stopping the production of microchips by humans would make Kushlani feel that she acted fairly and in accordance with the ACS code of ethics and Leal regulations.
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser