Fatigue Lifetime Prediction Of All-Ceramic Dental Bridge

This report focuses on the fatigue lifetime prediction and reliability of all-ceramic dental bridges. It discusses the physical properties, mechanical behavior, and loading capability of dental ceramics, as well as the challenges and improvements in the field. The study aims to provide insights for clinics in choosing the best dental bridge option for their patients.

Fatigue Lifetime Prediction Of
All-Ceramic Dental Bridge
Student Name: Miteshkumar Desai
Student Number: 19159355
A report submitted for
300597 Master Project 1
in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of
Master of Engineering (Major: Mechanical)
Supervisor: Dr. Leo Zhang
School of Computing, Engineering and Mathematics
Western Sydney University
2019
i

ii

ABSTRACT
Today, the use of ceramic is common in all most all the fields, and dental filed is not
different, as the ceramic dental bridge is highly used due to their resistant properties. The
dental ceramics’ success relies on the factors, like materials’ physical properties, its
fabrication and the clinical processes. The research associated with the survival rates of
all the dental ceramic prostheses show that they are prone to fracture due to repetitive
occlusal loading. On the other hand, the advanced ceramics have quite strong
compression, and it even has the ability of withstanding tension, shearing and high
temperatures like 800 °C below huge mechanical loads. Regardless of its required
properties, there is a need to research ceramics’ reliability and lifetime. As its demand is
increasing it becomes even more important to understand the ceramic material and its
modelling limitations to gain longer lifetime and better reliability. The purpose of this
evaluation is to find the strength and lifetime of all-ceramic bridges. The scope of this
project is to connect the gap of knowledge linking the ceramic material’s microstructural
characterisitcs and degradation. The results are determined based on the physical
properties, mechanical behaviour, loading capability, and fabrication to help the clinics to
provide the best dental bridge option for their patients. This study predicts the possible
lifetime of all-ceramic bridges and its loading capacity. It determines the flexure strength
after cyclic loading, fatigue resistance of dental ceramic, fatigue destruction duration and
the challenges of improvement in the ceramics. The reliable material properties are
calculated to get the insights related to occurrence of fracture. With this study, the
researcher gets the knowledge of lifespan of the dental ceramics which has attracted the
iii

observation of patients and dentists. It also helps to determine the degradation strength
and lifetime prediction of ceramic.
KEY WORDS: Dental Ceramics, Fatigue, Lifetime, Reliability, Cyclic Loading,
iv

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I Miteshkumar Desai hereby take an opportunity to express my profound gratitude of all
those who have helped and encouraged me towards the successful completion of the
Mechanical assignment. It has been a great experience completing Masters Project under
the supervision of Dr. Leo Zhang. I am highly thankful for their support and kind attitude
which helped me a lot and made my assignment a success. Above all my family members
have always been my biggest supporters. In spite of my serious efforts to complete this
assignment if I have committed any error it should be looked upon with sympathy.
Miteshkumar Desai
(Signature of the student)
v

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Chapter Page
ABSTRACT.......................................................................................................................iii
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS...................................................................................................v
TABLE OF CONTENTS...................................................................................................vi
LIST OF TABLES............................................................................................................vii
LIST OF FIGURES..........................................................................................................viii
CHAPTER I: INTRODUCTION........................................................................................1
Objective..........................................................................................................................2
Research Questions..........................................................................................................2
Hypothesis.......................................................................................................................4
CHAPTER II: LITERATURE REVIEW............................................................................5
Current Practice of Ceramic............................................................................................5
Adaptation of all-ceramic FPDs..................................................................................5
Strength, Fracture Toughness and Microstructure of Ceramic....................................6
Fatigue Behaviour........................................................................................................7
Cyclic loading’s Influence on Specimens....................................................................7
Step-stress Analysis for Predicting Dental Ceramic Reliability................................10
Ceramic Infrastructure’s Effect on Stress Distribution and Failure Behavior...........11
Correlation between fracture toughness and leucite content in dental porcelains.........11
All-ceramic bridges’ Lifetime prediction by computational methods...........................12
Fractal Analysis.............................................................................................................13
vi

Ceramics fracture Criteria..............................................................................................13
CHAPTER III: METHODOLOGY...................................................................................14
CHAPTER IV: PRELIMINARY RESULT......................................................................17
CHAPTER V: SUMAMRY AND RESEARCH PLAN...................................................21
REFERENCES..................................................................................................................24
Appendix A: HEADING...................................................................................................28
vii

LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
Table 1: Post cyclic loading reduction percentage in flexure strength................................8
Table 2: Research Plan......................................................................................................21
Table 3: Time table of the research...................................................................................22
viii

LIST OF FIGURES
Figure Page
Figure 1: Thickening of grain boundaries after cyclic loading............................................9
Figure 2: In a structure of failure site, Micro-cracking looks like black areas..................10
Figure 3: Block diagram....................................................................................................16
Figure 4: Gantt Chart.........................................................................................................22
ix

CHAPTER I: INTRODUCTION
Ceramics are utilised in various fields. The dental bridge is used to close the dental gap arch that
occurs due to missing of tooth or teeth. There are people who face difficulties of chewing the
food and speaking normally, due to weak tooth. Such patients are helped with dental bridge,
which improves their appearance, including improved mouth function to speak and eat (Yolanda
Smith, 2018). With the advancement in the dental field the ceramics are restoration is introduced
(Rashid et al., 2016). There are various dental bridges and each has its own purpose, which apart
from filling the missing tooth, has specific features that make it preferable for the patients. It is a
known fact that ceramic is brittle; however it is utilized for dental bridge. There are possibilities
of crack (Lodi et al., 2018). Thus, to investigate this concept, it is necessary to investigate the
lifetime of all-ceramic dental bridge and identify its mechanical reliability (Dental clinic
MEA:DENT, 2019). Fracture toughness refers to a material’s mechanical property which
explains its fracture resistance ability. It is impossible to guarantee a completely flaw-free
ceramic material. It is necessary to know the fracture toughness, as it not possible to give
guarantee that the flaws are discarded from the products (International Syalons, 2018). In brittle
materials, as time passes there are chances of failure, yet though there is no crack the material
can reach fatigue (Sanjosedelta.com, 2017).
The important aim of this presentation is to show that there exists a knowledge gap between the
ceramic material’s microstructural properties and degradation which must be bridged. This in
turn is expected to improve the lifetime and design of the ceramic dental bridge. This report
stresses on investigating the fundamental mechanisms and factors which causes ceramic damage
and degradation (REKOW et al., 2006). When it comes to ceramic the microstructure’s
degradation could affect the reliability of any component such as ceramic (Kailer, n.d.).
1

Objective
The main objectives of this research are listed below (Zhang, Sailer and Lawn, 2013):
1) To summarize the recent research on the experimental, clinical, and analytic results.
2) Predicting the possible lifetime of all-ceramic bridges.
3) Predicting the loading capacity of all-ceramic bridges.
4) To understand mechanical properties and fatigue behavior of different ceramics.
5) To determine the flexure strength after cyclic loading.
6) To determine the fatigue resistant dental ceramic at present.
7) To determine when does the material reach fatigue destruction.
8) To determine the main reasons for low strength.
9) To determine the challenges of improvement in the ceramics (Rekow et al., 2011).
10) To close the gap of awareness between the ceramic material’s properties about
microstructural and degradation.
Based on the above mentioned objectives, the researcher aims to understand the dental ceramics’
lifetime service, which grasps the attention of the patients as well as the dentists. Additionally,
fatigue behavior and the mechanical properties of the commonly utilized dental ceramics such as,
lithium disilicate e.max CAD (LD), zirconia Cercon (ZC), and the polymer-in ltrated ceramic
Enamic (PIC) will be measured (Homaei et al., 2016). Further, the degradation strength and
ceramic’s lifetime prediction can be determined.
Research Questions
For helping the investigation meet its objectives, the following research questions must be
determined (Li et al., 2015) (Aboushelib, 2010):
2

1) Has the failure in the dental ceramic prostheses evaluated?
2) Has the strength data gathered, evaluated and determined?
3) Has the lifecycle data tested?
4) Which is the most fatigue resistant dental ceramic at present?
5) What are ceramics susceptible to?
6) Fatigue of dental ceramics
7) What is the evaluated loading rate?
8) What influence does the cyclic loading have on ceramic?
9) What is the evaluated fracture load of ceramic?
10) How is the flexure strength calculated?
11) Is it required to research the impact of the processing method, service condition,
material composition and microstructure to check the ceramic’s strength and
lifetime? If yes, has it been researched?
12) Has the flexure strength after cyclic loading been compared with the theoretical
strength?
13) When does the material reach fatigue destruction (MICHALSKI and STREK, 2018)?
14) Has the mechanical properties and fatigue behavior of different ceramics measured
(Homaei et al., 2016)?
15) How can the challenges in the ceramics be improved?
16) How to close the knowledge gap between the ceramic material’s properties for
microstructural and degradation (Guazzato et al., 2004).
3

Hypothesis
H1: There exists no possibility to predict the possible lifetime loading capacity of all-
ceramic bridges.
H2: The Zirconia Cercon’s mechanical properties are superior to than the other
ceramics types.
4

CHAPTER II: LITERATURE REVIEW
Literature review is an essential part of research methodology. This chapter acts as a background
for all the related topics to justify the objectives of the research, then provides rationale for the
hypothesis and supports the research methods, The review is conducted based on the hypothesis
to be addressed.
Current Practice of Ceramic
According to (Kelly and Benetti, 2011), at present, the ceramics are used in daily life like in
application of aerospace, automotive, military and medical fields, which are been engineered to
help both common people and the professionals of different fields. There is a simple
understanding of the Dental Ceramics for their constitution, indications and growth because of
their presentation in simplifying framework. The clinical conduct of all ceramic systems in its
literature is reviewed and is dealt as clinical function of their engineering assessments. Stressed
on the queries like how we know it and what we know it, to maximize the durability and
aesthetics by using dental ceramics and their selection resulting in an appealing and practical
aspect.
Adaptation of all-ceramic FPDs
As per (M et al., 2012), the ceramic systems comprises of various levels of marginal and internal
fit. The main purpose of this research was to measure Fixed Partial Dentures’ (FPDs) marginal
and internal fit, with the help of micro-CT technique. The ANOVA and Tukey tests were used to
statistically analyze the results. It is evaluated that the ceramic systems displayed varied marginal
and internal fit levels, which rejects the hypothesis of the research. However, both the ceramic
systems presented acceptable marginal and internal fit.
5

Strength, Fracture Toughness and Microstructure of Ceramic
According to (Guazzato et al., 2004), conducted two studies to investigate all-ceramic materials’
strength, microstructure and fracture toughness. The purpose of the part 1 and 2 were to compare
the strength, microstructure and fracture toughness of various all-ceramic materials. The part 1
compared three hot-pressed glass-ceramics and alumina glass-infiltrated ceramics. The ANOVA
and Sheffé post hoc test were used for comparing. The study investigated each phase’s volume
fraction, grain shapes, dimensions, porosity and patterns of cracks with the help of SEM. The
results showed the strength and fracture toughness’s average and standard deviation. The
microscopy helped to show the relationship that exists between the crystalline phase and glass
matrix. It is observed that the material’s mechanical properties and microstructure are very
important for knowing the clinical long-term performance for all-ceramic dental restorations.
Even in part 2 (Guazzato et al., 2004), the ANOVA and Sheffé post hoc test were used for
analyzing the data. It was helpful to have investigated the microscope investigation along with
X-ray diffraction to know the relationship between the glassy matrix and crystalline phase, to
strengthen and toughen the ceramic mechanisms. The research shows that the dental ceramics of
zirconia material are quite stronger and tougher when compared to the other glass-ceramics. Its
properties are comparatively better and so they could have a positive influence on their clinical
performance, to restore all-ceramic bridges.
As per (Fischer, 2002), this research aims to compare a couple of fracture toughness techniques
such as, bending method and indentation method. This research completes the analysis of
potentialities and limitations of indentation method. It has evaluated the fracture toughness
values for totally 7 dental ceramic materials on bending method. It is observed that the
6

indentation method fails to accurately determine the fracture toughness of any unknown ceramic
material, and it can just be utilized to estimate the first rough KIc.
Fatigue Behaviour
In this relevant areas, various researchers have contributed their efforts to study the fatigue
behaviour of the dental ceramics (physical properties), followed by mechanical behaviour,
loading capability, fabrication and much more.
Cyclic loading’s Influence on Specimens
In this research (Aboushelib, 2010), the researcher has examined the influence of cyclic loading
on zirconia specimens. Metal free restoration is trending in dental field, to discard the biological
side effects from the metallic alloys. Then, came the glass ceramic restoration, but it didn't last
long because of less mechanical properties and its brittleness. Later, the Polycrystalline ceramics
were used for all-ceramic restorations. Further, the zirconia was introduced which opened the
limitations of design and application of all-ceramic restorations. This is due to its superior
flexure strength and high fracture toughness, long span (multi-unit large restorations) and
complex zirconia frameworks are now possible with high reliability and clinically proven
success rate. For understanding zirconia’s failure mechanisms, its internal structure and
fabrication technique are understood. The zirconia specimens in this research is subjected to
various surface treatments such as particle abrasion either with 50 μm or 110 μm alumina and
grinding using the diamond points. The statistical analysis was carried out which showed high
reduction in flexure strength i.e., 38% to 67% (P < 0.001), post 3 million cycles of dynamic
loading for all the surface treatments. The major structural defects were observed from the
electron imaging such as grain boundary thickening, micro-cracking and grain pull-out. Thus, the
7

final results recommend that, in the oral environment, different surface treatments of zirconia
based dental ceramics might essentially influence its long term fatigue resistance.
Table 1: Post cyclic loading reduction percentage in flexure strength
8

Figure 1: Thickening of grain boundaries after cyclic loading.
9

Figure 2: In a structure of failure site, Micro-cracking looks like black areas.
Step-stress Analysis for Predicting Dental Ceramic Reliability
As per (Borba et al., 2013), the researchers have worked on testing the hypothesis on step-stress
analysis for predicting alumina-based dental ceramic’s reliability. The bar-shaped ceramic
specimens are fabricated, polished and separated into three groups such as step-stress
accelerating test, flexural strength-control; and flexural strength-mechanical aging. Every single
specimen was subjected to an individual stress profile, and the number of cycles to failure were
recorded. Then, the second and third groups were tested for three-point flexural strength (σ) in a
universal testing machine with 1.0MPa/s stress rate, in 37°C water. Mann-Whitney Rank Sum
test is used to analyze the data. The step-stress data analysis’ result displayed that the profile
probably weakens the specimens without any fracture during aging. It showed different median σ
10

values for both second and third groups i.e., 493±54 and 423±103, respectively. The determined
aging profile from the step-stress analysis is proved to be effective for decreasing the alumina
ceramic strength.
Ceramic Infrastructure’s Effect on Stress Distribution and Failure Behavior
According to (Borba et al., 2015), the ceramic infrastructure’s effect on stress distribution and
failure behavior of the fixed partial dentures (FPDs) was examined. A couple of experimental
conditions were also examined. The universal testing machine was used in this research for the
control specimens. The study also performed fractography and FEA. With the help of ANOVA
and Tukey's test the data was analyzed. It is observed that YZ16 displayed greatest fracture load
mean value, then YZ16-MC comes in. However, the specimens from YZ9, IZ16, IZ16-MC,
AL16 and AL16-MC groups displayed no changes in fracture load. On the other hand, based on
the type of IS the FPDs’ failure behavior and stress distribution was influenced. Additionally,
same fracture load values were observed for AL and IZ FPDs, however it has different stress
distribution and failure modes. From the overall results, YZ displayed best mechanical behavior.
Correlation between fracture toughness and leucite content in dental porcelains.
As per (Cesar et al., 2005), the objective of the research includes determining the correlation
between the fracture toughness and leucite content in the dental porcelains. The mechanisms by
which leucite influences the fracture toughness of dental porcelains were also investigated.
Totally, 6 types of porcelains were actually tested they are- A (Ceramco I/Dentsply), B (Ceramco
II/Dentsitply), C (Finesse/Dentsply), D (d.Sign/Ivoclar), Cb (Cerabien/Noritake) and V (Vitadur
Alpha/Vita). The single-edge precracked beam (SEPB) method was used to determine their
11

fracture toughness of the Bar-shaped specimens. The fracture force and precrack size was used
for calculating KIc. On the fracture surface the fractographic analysis was performed and even
microstructural analysis was performed. The results showed that the porcelains A and B to have
highest leucite contents (i.e., 22%) when compared to the others and had similar KIc values i.e.,
1.23 and 1.22 MPa m1/2, respectively. The fractographic analysis displayed that the porcelains
which contains higher leucite content had greater incidence of crack deflection. Thus, the
evaluation of the materials showed that, the leucite content has direct association with KIc. The
crack deflection was observed closely around the clusters and leucite particles.
All-ceramic bridges’ Lifetime prediction by computational methods
According to (Fischer, Weber and Marx, 2003), for all-ceramic posterior bridges, the ceramic
material are hardly used, and the primary reason is its strength scatter, low strength and decrease
in strength as per time-dependent because of less crack growth. The main purpose of this
research included predicting all-ceramic bridges’ long-term failure probability and its capacity of
loading. This is performed using the computational techniques. Various bridge model designs’
lifetimes were predicted by using NASA post-processor CARES. From this research, it was
observed that the zirconia bridges displayed significantly high mechanical long-term reliability.
It is also understood that the all-ceramic bridges’ lifetime could be increased drastically with the
improvement in connector area’s design. Thus, it is concluded that the computational techniques
could be helpful in judging the ceramic material.
12

Fractal Analysis
As per (Drummond, Thompson and Super, 2006), the main reason behind this research is to
investigate and ensure measuring the fractal dimensional increase of fracture surface of 6 dental
ceramics. There exists various challenges while measuring the fracture toughness (Jodha,
Marocho and Griggs, 2018). Additionally, measuring the fractal dimensional increment
correlation with the fracture toughness. The investigated dental ceramics are- traditional
porcelain (Finesse[F], Ceramco, Burlington, NJ, USA), 4 leucite reinforced pressable ceramics
(Finesse Pressable [FP], Ceramco; Empress [E], Ivoclar; New Albany, NY, USA and two shades
of OPC [OA2 and OI40], Jeneric-Pentron, MA, USA), and a lithium disilicate containing
pressable ceramic ([LD] Ceramco). The optical microscope was used to see the fracture line,
then the slit island perimeter was measured with the help of 5 types of length rulers. The
Richardson technique was used for determining the fractal dimensional increment (D*). A
confocal microscope was used investigating the correlation that exists between the fracture
toughness and D* values. The results show that the fracture toughness to be correlated
effectively with the values of D*.
Ceramics fracture Criteria
As per (Gogotsi, 2013), the methods to evaluate the resistance of fracture in the ceramic material
and other similar brittle materials are investigated. It is observed that the edge-chipping test
method is a conventional method to help find the required results. The results are evaluated
depending on the linear elastic fracture mechanics. It tests all the small specimens. From the final
results it is determined that the edge-chipping test methods are not effective enough to compare
the ceramics based on the dissimilar fracture surfaces.
13

CHAPTER III: METHODOLOGY
Literature review is used as the primary research method for gathering the related information.
The mechanical properties of lithium disilicate e.max CAD (LD), zirconia Cercon (ZC), and the
polymer-in ltrated ceramic Enamic (PIC) is required. The related regulatory document,
standards, guides, field survey questionnaire and protocol etc., will help to collect the required
data about the ceramic. Next, based on the collected data, the experiments will be conducted to
determine the actual results. ANOVA method can be used for analysing the numerical results.
The research approach includes:
1) Determining the required data.
2) Performing experiments.
3) Conducting at the atomic level are the calculations for the reliable material properties.
For the atomic level, the calculations and the simulations helps to gain the insight of the
phenomena and could help to describe what happens on the larger scales, for instance the
fracture, where the atomistic level helps to see the fracture’s occurrence and the planes
and orientations where there is high possibility of fracture on larger scales to occur (Cesar
et al., 2005).
4) Investigating how the stress intensity factor impacts the ceramic materials’ design.
The stress intensity factor indicates the stress state in ceramic material’s crack tip. This
helps in predicting the fracture (Borba et al., 2015). Further, it can determine the
ceramic’s failure. Thus, the gradients stress inside the ceramic material could impact the
factor for stress intensity, which can direct it towards a particular design or loading
recommendations (Borba et al., 2013).
14

5) Determining whether is it possible to explain the material combinations with the
enhanced properties, which are hoped to be developed or not.
For instance, as the ceramic materials are used in different fields, a single combination of
the material cannot expect to provide the necessary benefit. The manufacturing tools and
bearings targeted, where with the bearings, the ceramic rolling components can
experience high mechanical contact stresses. Whereas, with the manufacturing/ ceramic
tools that will undergo at high temperatures and the high mechanical tribological stresses
(Hu et al., 2013).
6) Researching on, what the industrial testing of the material will involve, as most of the
research work depends on developing the theoretical models, techniques and modelling
tools.
Corresponding to the numerical simulations, both the material design and implementation
in the industry can be concentrated and tested. The testing process will use the material
grades that are developed.
7) Enhancing the ceramic material’s reliability and lifetime using multi-scale modelling of
degradation and damage.
8) Evaluating the measures for the various types of ceramics their mechanical properties.
9) The fracture strength need to be evaluated (Gauckler, 2019) (Steyern P, 2007).
How at atomic level are the calculations of reliable material properties carried out? Providing
insight into phenomena by calculations and simulations at the atomic level, which shall
explain what happens on larger scales. Fracture is a clear example: The orientations and
planes at which fracture is most likely to occur on larger scales is shown by the
occurrence of fracture on the atomistic level.
15

The following Block diagram illustrates the research approach of this research
Figure 3: Block diagram
16
Collect required data
Determine the objective
Construct hypothesis
Reporting the Results
Accept hypothesis
Conduct experiments and complete
testing
Reject hypothesis
Draw conclusion
Make observations

CHAPTER IV: PRELIMINARY RESULT
Without getting much attention in the dental community, the competing nodes which have a
clear physical look inside in the many fracture modes; the recommended fracture mechanics
approach provides a distinctive powerful base for analysing fatigue properties in dental ceramics.
The standard single-cycle flexure examinations on disk or bar samples and its strength
information have been mentioned clearly in literatures and reading papers on the subject of
dental materials. Providing the useful and supporting ways for ranking the materials, strength test
alone cannot be taken as the only method suitable as there are various protocols giving clinical
type scenario for testing and all providing good outcomes. Caution has to be taken for these
types as real prostheses long term behaviour has not been the outcome of most of these tests.
Lacking the data for the more damaging mechanical degradation governs the fracture modes at
cycling’s later stage, single-cycle strength tests give data just for the S–n’s left axis diagrams.
Where there are complicated elements like contact, flexural and membrane components in the
tensile stress states of crown configurations, these S–n diagrams are also constrained for their
usefulness. For undergoing the arrest and stable propagation these should have enough newly
initiated cracks by being sufficiently inhomogeneous. Even though there may be difference
between the tests conducted and simulated in a laboratory and in actual clinical scenarios 24,
there has been a marked response to the hard indenters of 'crunch-the-crown' tests, represented
analogues in Figs. 3 and 4, as they have taken a step closer to the geometries of rest restoration.
Like the case of “finite element 12 modeling” which have proven to be not accurate for
accounting the fracture stable phase not including the laborious association of crack increase
subroutines in the code 113, 122, 123 although, it is widely used for the mapping out of complex
stress states. Another case is of “fractographic studies” which is unable to solve the complicated
17

route issue from the initiation of crack to an ultimate failure even though it is very handy in
recognizing the origins of fractures. Offering a limited look in the parts of the numerous
controlling fatigue parameters, ideally they should be able to analyse the lifespans utmost rest
with examines on specimens anatomically-corrected with situations which replicate true like
oral function, e.q the mouth-motion simulators such as 81, 82, 95, 124, 125.
Provide the assistance for the trending of dental ceramic systems, lifetime fracture maps,
in addition to the delineating of the areas of dominance for various modes of fracture. Having
been dominant over the cycle range, the surface occlusal cracks (especially inner cones) in the
porcelain-veneered structures which have zirconia cores and lithium desilicated. Radial (or
margin) fracture dominates in the zirconia monoliths and lithium desilicated monoliths (Fig. 7c).
Showing more toughness for the former material, commonly zirconia-based monolithic or
veneered structures have better damage resistant than the glass–ceramic-based. Having a lesser
traverse thickness to an interface and also more susceptible to surface cracking, veneered have
inferior structure lifetime characteristics when compared to monoliths. With a maxima estimated
range between 100 N ~ 600 N, the main need in design is to keep the lifespan trend lines higher
the range of bite forces natural. We can observe that this factored in is the porcelain chipping,
indicative of a vulnerable system inherently when, 95, 126, and 127 the veneered structures are
close to violating this requirement. Any feedback on the nature of physical for the response is
required as the emphasis for the mechanical fatigue in the long-term response of dental ceramics.
As seen in the diagram of S–n data, Mechanical degradation can result itself in testing periodic
flexure. Micro cracking at the vulnerable interfaces inside a near-surface damage zone is the next
step after loss of strength as internal friction degradation which is the caused by surfaces subject
to damage by point-contact. As soon as the cracks stable propagation enter the stage for, 103,
18

128, 129 more pronounced mechanical fatigue occurs. Type of 'fracking’, aqueous solution
hydraulic pumping into the fissures shall be the principal underlying mechanism for it.
Comparing the c–n information got by monotonic loading cyclic versus steady or over
comparable test durations is a, simple diagnostic for testing traditional fatigue for the
distinguishing mechanical from chemical (SCG) procedure. While cracks partial cone with inner
and (mostly) median cracks never appear, in loading of single-cycle, radial crack data sets outer
and cone to the SCG growth trendlines remain parallel.
A physical strong basis designing for the next-generation materials in respect to the
dental prostheses is, the bioengineering way to lifetime evaluations. For damage accumulation in
repetitive loading, the key is a good understanding for the parts involving the material and
geometrical parameters for repetitive loading in damage accumulation. Changes of various areas
in the trendlines are the result of the changes in these variables.
Below are the topics mentioned which gives description about the balancing of various factors
required for materials design,
(i) material properties
(ii) microstructure
(iii) residual stresses
(iv) monolithic versus veneered structures
(v) layer thickness
(vi) tooth contact conditions
(vii) shape tooth size
(viii) adhesive modulus, dentine, enamel
(ix) surface state
19

This topic shall be better understood by the given results. Displaying the important
differences between the flexure strength for the examined samples before and after cyclic
loading, which than becomes the result of using new methods for analysis for delivering
statistical outcomes. The analysis of the cyclic fatigue is carried out and (Zhang and Griggs,
2003) to acquire further knowledge about the topic, the information from present researchers is
utilised. The following values for each of the parameters PIC, LD, and ZC are than calculated,
 mean flexural strength
 maximum load for one million cycles fatigue limit of
 mean fracture toughness
Appearing monotonic loading smoother as it is, these fracture surfaces follow the fatigue
loading. With the assistance of multi-scale modelling of damaged and degradation, the important
result includes the enhancement of ceramic material’s lifetime and reliability.
20

CHAPTER V: SUMAMRY AND RESEARCH PLAN
This research work follows a research plan where, initially the existing and related researches are
researched, and then the problems are identified, followed by identification of the objectives.
Moving further, an appropriate evaluation method will be selected and a research plan will be
developed. Next, the research plan will be implemented and the results will be evaluated to
determine the results.
The research plan is represented in the below table:
Table 2: Research Plan
Sl. No Research Plan
1. Research on existing related researches.
2. Identify the problem.
3. Identify the objectives to be met.
4. Establish hypothesis
5. Select an appropriate evaluation method.
6. Create a research plan
7. Implement the research plan.
8. Conduct experiments
9. Evaluate the results.
10. Determine the results.
21

ID Task
Mode
Task Name
1 1 Project Management Research Plan
2 1.1 Research on existing related researches.
3 1.2 Identify the problem.
4 1.3 Identify the objectives to be met.
5 1.4 Establish Hypotheses
6 1.5 Select an appropriate evaluation method.
7 1.6 Create a research plan
8 1.7 Implement the research plan.
9 1.8 Conduct experiments
10 1.9 Evaluate the results.
11 1.10 Determine the results.
W F S T T S M W F S T T S M W F S T T S M W F S T T S M W F S T T S M W F S
25 Mar '19 01 Apr '19 08 Apr '19 15 Apr '19 22 Apr '19 29 Apr '19 06 May '19 13 May '19 20 May '19 27 May '19 03 Jun '19
Figure 4: Gantt Chart
A Gantt chart is represented to represent the research plan and timetable.
Time Table
The following table represents the timetable for this research.
Table 3: Time table of the research
22

Model layer structures
loaded with spherical
indenters enable
identification of clinically
relevant fracture modes
in layered dental
prosthetic structures.
Some of these modes are
not
easily inferred from
conventional post-mortem
examinations of failed
parts.
(ii) Ceramics are
susceptible to loss of
23

load-bearing capacity in
cyclic loading, i.e. fatigue,
amounting to declines in
strength or critical bite
force amounting to a factor
of 2 or more over an
equivalent one-year biting
history.
(iii) Part of fatigue is due to
well-documented
chemically-assisted slow
crack growth (SCG), but
more deleterious is
degradation by mechanical
processes such as
24

hydraulic pumping and
internal
friction at microcrack walls.
Some fractures, most
notably inner cone cracks,
do not appear at all
14
in static or monotonic
loading.
(iv) Strength tests in cyclic
flexure provide information
on the stresses needed to
initiate cracks,
but are restrictive in
information relating
25

subsequent stable crack
growth to ultimate failure.
(v) In situ fracture tests on
transparent layer
structures, coupled with
rigorous fracture mechanics
analysis of crack extension
from initiation through
stable growth to failure,
facilitate construction
of lifetime damage maps
for common prosthetic
material combinations.
(vii) Monolith structures
are more resilient than their
26

veneered counterparts.
Zirconia is the most
fatigue-resistant of the
current dental ceramics.
In layered dental prosthetic structures, few clinically relevant fracture not easy modes implied
from the failed parts of conventional post-mortem examinations. In cyclic loading, prone is loss
of load-bearing capacity of ceramics. The slow crack growth (SCG) well-documented
chemically-assisted is noticed in some parts of fatigue. Strength exams of cyclic flexure provide
information for the required stresses for crack initiate, and are information restrictive in relating
stable crack subsequent growth to failure ultimately. Completed are the situ fracture tests on
structures transparent layer that are rigorous coupled with fracture mechanics analysis of
extension of the crack. When compared to the veneered counterparts the monolith structures are
highly resilient. At present, in dental ceramics Zirconia is highly fatigue-resistant.
27

28

REFERENCES
Aboushelib, M. (2010). Long Term Fatigue Behavior of Zirconia Based Dental
Ceramics. Materials, 3(5), pp.2975-2985.
Borba, M., Cesar, P., Griggs, J. and Della Bona, Á. (2013). Step-stress analysis for predicting
dental ceramic reliability. Dental Materials, 29(8), pp.913-918.
Borba, M., Duan, Y., Griggs, J., Cesar, P. and Della Bona, Á. (2015). Effect of ceramic
infrastructure on the failure behavior and stress distribution of fixed partial dentures. Dental
Materials, 31(4), pp.413-422.
Cesar, P., Yoshimura, H., Miranda Júnior, W. and Okada, C. (2005). Correlation between
fracture toughness and leucite content in dental porcelains. Journal of Dentistry, 33(9), pp.721-
729.
Dental clinic MEA:DENT. (2019). All Ceramic Crowns. [online] Available at:
https://meadent.com/en/all-ceramic-crowns/ [Accessed 19 Apr. 2019].
Drummond, J., Thompson, M. and Super, B. (2006). Erratum to: “Fracture surface examination
of dental ceramics using fractal analysis” [Dental Materials 21 (2005) 586–589]. Dental
Materials, 22(2), p.201.
Fischer, H. (2002). Fracture toughness of dental ceramics: comparison of bending and
indentation method. Dental Materials, 18(1), pp.12-19.
29

Fischer, H., Weber, M. and Marx, R. (2003). Lifetime Prediction of All-ceramic Bridges by
Computational Methods. Journal of Dental Research, 82(3), pp.238-242.
Gauckler, P. (2019). ETH - NONMET - Cyclic Fatigue and Lifetime Prediction of Ceramics.
[online] Nonmet.mat.ethz.ch. Available at:
http://www.nonmet.mat.ethz.ch/research/Structural_Ceramics/Cyclic_Fatigue_of_Ceramics/
index [Accessed 19 Apr. 2019].
Gogotsi, G. (2013). Criteria of ceramics fracture (edge chipping and fracture toughness
tests). Ceramics International, 39(3), pp.3293-3300.
Guazzato, M., Albakry, M., Ringer, S. and Swain, M. (2004). Strength, fracture toughness and
microstructure of a selection of all-ceramic materials. Part I. Pressable and alumina glass-
infiltrated ceramics. Dental Materials, 20(5), pp.441-448.
Guazzato, M., Albakry, M., Ringer, S. and Swain, M. (2004). Strength, fracture toughness and
microstructure of a selection of all-ceramic materials. Part II. Zirconia-based dental
ceramics. Dental Materials, 20(5), pp.449-456.
Homaei, E., Farhangdoost, K., Tsoi, J., Matinlinna, J. and Pow, E. (2016). Static and fatigue
mechanical behavior of three dental CAD/CAM ceramics. Journal of the Mechanical Behavior
of Biomedical Materials, 59, pp.304-313.
International Syalons. (2018). The Fracture Toughness of Ceramic Materials. [online] Available
at: https://www.syalons.com/2018/10/31/fracture-toughness-ceramic-materials/ [Accessed 12
Jun. 2019].
30

Jodha, K., Marocho, S. and Griggs, J. (2018). Challenges in measuring fracture toughness of
dental ceramics: SEPB method. Dental Materials, 34, p.e63.
Kailer, D. (n.d.). Advancing ceramics. Rolicer. [online] Available at:
https://www.rolicer.eu/content/dam/iwm/rolicer/english/andreas-kailer-advancing-ceramics-
rolicer-fraunhofer-iwm.pdf [Accessed 19 Apr. 2019].
Kelly, J. and Benetti, P. (2011). Ceramic materials in dentistry: historical evolution and current
practice. Australian Dental Journal, 56, pp.84-96.
Li, W., Xu, Y., He, H., Zhao, H., Sun, J. and Hou, Y. (2015). Strength degradation and lifetime
prediction of dental zirconia ceramics under cyclic normal loading. Bio-Medical Materials and
Engineering, 26(s1), pp.S129-S137.
Lodi, E., Borba, M., Rhoden, K., Bona, A., Benetti, P. and Corazza, P. (2016). Oral environment
simulation affects ceramic failure behavior. Dental Materials, 32, p.e68.
Lodi, E., Weber, K., Benetti, P., Corazza, P., Della Bona, Á. and Borba, M. (2018). How oral
environment simulation affects ceramic failure behavior. The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry,
119(5), pp.812-818.
M, B., PF, C., JA, G. and Bona Á, D. (2012). Adaptation of all-ceramic fixed partial
dentures. The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 107(6), p.365.
MICHALSKI, J. and STREK, T. (2018). Fatigue Life of Polymer Dental Crown. Vibrations in
Physical Systems.
31

Rashid, H., Sheikh, Z., Misbahuddin, S., Kazmi, M., Qureshi, S. and Uddin, M. (2016).
Advancements in all-ceramics for dental restorations and their effect on the wear of opposing
dentition. European Journal of Dentistry, 10(4), p.583.
REKOW, E., HARSONO, M., JANAL, M., THOMPSON, V. and ZHANG, G. (2006). Factorial
analysis of variables influencing stress in all-ceramic crowns. Dental Materials, 22(2), pp.125-
132.
Rekow, E., Silva, N., Coelho, P., Zhang, Y., Guess, P. and Thompson, V. (2011). Performance of
Dental Ceramics: Challenges for Improvements. Journal of Dental Research, 90(8), pp.937-952.
Sanjosedelta.com. (2017). Ceramics for Fatigue Resistance. [online] Available at:
https://www.sanjosedelta.com/ceramics_fatigue_resistance.html [Accessed 12 Jun. 2019].
Steyern P, V. (2007). All-ceramic systems for fixed partial dentures. Dental Abstracts, 52(3),
pp.172-173.
Yolanda Smith, B. (2018). Uses for a Dental Bridge. [online] News-Medical.net. Available at:
https://www.news-medical.net/health/Uses-for-a-Dental-Bridge.aspx [Accessed 19 Apr. 2019].
Zhang, Y. and Griggs, J. (2003). Evaluation of failure probability estimators for cyclic fatigue
using boundary technique. Journal of Materials Science Letters, 22(24), pp.1775-1777.
Zhang, Y., Sailer, I. and Lawn, B. (2013). Fatigue of dental ceramics. Journal of dentistry,
41(12).
32

Appendix A: HEADING
33