Feminist Standpoint Theory: Strengths and Weaknesses

This essay discusses the precepts of the Feminist Standpoint Theory, its strengths and weaknesses. It argues that the theory seeks to empower women and democratize literature and social work practices. However, it has been criticized for its focus on feministic theories and essentialism.

Running head: FEMINIST STANDPOINT THEORY
Feminist Standpoint Theory
Name of the Student:
Name of the University:
Author’s Note:

1FEMINIST STANDPOINT THEORY
“Women have served all these centuries as looking glasses possessing the magic and
delicious power of reflecting the figure of man at twice its natural size.”
The above quoted lines of the author Virginia Woolf from her famous work “A Room
of One's Own” points to the role which women have been made to serve in the human
society since the traditional times. The female gender had to bear a considerable amount of
suppression as well as stigmatization since the ancient times on the score of their gender and
the traditional gender stereotypes attached with them (Garry and Pearsall 2015). The French
critic and author Simone de Beauvoir commenting about the suppression as well as
stigmatization which women had to receive since the ancient says in her famous work “The
Second Sex” (1949) that the women are not even considered as the sex which is opposite to
men rather they are viewed as the second sex that inhabits the human society. However, in
the present times it is seen that the condition has improved a bit with the changing nature of
the human world and the publication of the works of some of the prominent female writers
like Mary Wollstonecraft, Virginia Woolf, Dorothy Richardson, Judith Butler, Kate
Millet, Margaret Atwood and others (Shakeshaft 2015). The views as well as the
standpoints taken by these women writers and others have contributed in a significant manner
towards the freedom and the status which women are enjoying in the society currently
(Shakeshaft 2015). This essay will discuss about the various precepts of the feminist
standpoint theory and more particularly focus on the strengths as well as weaknesses of this
theory.
The “Feminist Standpoint Theory” propounded by Dorothy Smith and Nancy
Hartsock in the early part of the 1980s is a major feminist theory which has sought to
empower the women of the present times in a significant manner (Luke and Gore 2014). The
various precepts of this particular theory are based on the concept of Marxism and seek to
use the theories of Karl Marx and other theorists belonging to the genre of Marxism in the

2FEMINIST STANDPOINT THEORY
wider canvas of feminism (Luke and Gore 2014). The primary precept of this particular
theory is grounded on fact that the various social sciences as well as the literary works of the
present times should be based on the framework of the concept of feminism. The theory
argues the fact that the lives of the women of the society are significantly different from the
lives of the women and therefore the literary works which are based on their lives should not
be interpreted on the basis of the framework of the masculine theories which had dominated
the interpretation of the literary since time immemorial (Meyers 2014). Thus, in a way it can
be said that this particular theory seeks to overthrown the hegemonic dominance of the
masculine theories which had held sway in the world of Literature and social sciences for a
very long time. Moreover, this theory argues the fact that the lives of the women who are
often seen as subordinates to the male members of the society by means of being the
suppressed class offers new insights into the working mechanisms of the world which is
seldom exhibited by the other theories (Meyers 2014). Thus, it can be said that this particular
theory by its insistence on the interpretation of the world and the various literary texts
through the lens of the lives of the women is likely to not only empower the women of the
society in a significant manner but at the same time is likely to provide a much broader
interpretation of the literary texts and the social works in a much more credible manner.
The recent popularity gained by this particular theory is an indicative of the relevancy
which this particular theory holds within the framework of the modern day society. For
example, one of the most important precepts of this particular feminist theory is the fact that
this particular theory seeks to show that the present framework of the society has been
constructed in such a manner that it upholds the suppression as well as the discrimination
which the women receive at the hands of the male members of the society (Lal 2018). This
particular aspect of the theory is totally in synchronization with the views of Judith Butler
which she articulated in her famous work “Gender trouble and the subversion of identity”

3FEMINIST STANDPOINT THEORY
in 1990 that “gender is a performance, a social construct which has been constructed to
maintain the power balance within the society” (Butler 1990). Thus, the “Feminist Standpoint
Theory” seeks to upset precisely this particular power balance between the two sexes in the
human society by way of the interpretation of the various literary texts as well as the social
works through the specific lens of the feminist theories. Moreover, another major strength of
this particular theory can be said to be the fact that it seeks to democratize the world of
Literature as well as the various social work practice by the interpretation of them on the
basis of the various kinds of feminist theories (Lal 2018). It is significant to note that earlier
the literary text as well as the social work practices was interpreted strictly on the basis of the
various theories which were created by the male members of the society and catered to the
interests of this particular sex of the society. However, the advent of this particular theory and
its wide use by the various literary scholars have much democratized the way these literary
texts as well as the social work practices are now being interpreted. Furthermore, the theorist
Uma Narayan is of the opinion that the fundamental epistemology of this particular theory to
challenge the male dominated biases as well as the perspectives of the society can also be
considered to be one of the key strengths of this particular theory of feminism (Carole and
McCann 2003). The theorist Elizabeth Gross, on the other hand, is of the viewpoint that the
major strength of this particular theory can be seen as its objective to challenge the various
patriarchal discourses as well as the male dominated images which has formed the central
fulcrum of the human society since the traditional times (Crowley and Himmelweit 1992).
The viewpoint of Sandra Harding when she says that the various precepts of the Feminist
Standpoint Theory has contributed much to resolve the much debated as well as the anxiety
producing areas of the human society need to be taken into consideration at this particular
juncture (Harding 2004). These in short are of the key strengths of the “Feminist Standpoint

4FEMINIST STANDPOINT THEORY
Theory” which has contributed much towards the wide popularity gained by this particular
concept in the recent times.
The “Feminist Standpoint Theory” has come under much criticism in the recent times
on the score of the various weaknesses which it has. For instance, critics are of the viewpoint
that the emphasis of this particular theory only on the use of the feministic theories for the
interpretation of the literary texts and other kinds of social work practices removes the focus
of feminism from its important purpose of the empowerment of the female gender to other
not so important areas (Allen 2018). Furthermore, it is generally seen that this particular
theory is often criticized on the basis of the concept of essentialism. Thus, the feminist critics
argue that this particular theory seeks to create a genre of feministic Literature on the basis of
the previous feministic Literature and female experiences (Allen 2018). However, these
critics are of the viewpoint that as such there are no past feministic literary cannons and
female experiences which have been brought to light owing to the stringent hold which the
masculine society had placed on the female sexes of the society (Mosedale 2014).
Furthermore, another significant weakness of this particular theory can be said to be the fact
that this particular theory fails to take into account the various important factors which have
affected the feministic discourse in a significant manner like the concepts of racism,
colonialism and others (Tyagi 2014). Thus, the failure to take into consideration these factors
which have shaped the female experiences in a significant is considered to be one of the
major weaknesses of this particular theory.
To conclude, the “Feminist Standpoint Theory” has emerged as one of the major
theories of feminism in the recent times and has sought much to improve the condition of the
women of the present times. The interpretation of the various literary texts as well as social
work practices on the basis of the feministic theories as well as experiences of the women of
the society has contributed in a significant manner to not only empower the women of the

5FEMINIST STANDPOINT THEORY
society but at the same time has equipped them with equal kind of opportunities in
comparison to the male members of the society. However, there are certain negative aspects
of this particular theory as well since it fails to take into consideration the important factors of
racism, colonialism and others which has shaped the experiences of the women of the society
in a significant manner.

6FEMINIST STANDPOINT THEORY
References
Allen, A., 2018. The power of feminist theory. Routledge.
Butler, J., 1990. Gender trouble and the subversion of identity. New York and London:
Routledge.
Carole, C. and McCann, R., 2003. Feminist theory reader: Local and global perspective.
Routledge.
Crowley, H. and Himmelweit, S., 1992. Knowing Women Feminism and Knowledge.
Routledge.
De Beauvoir, S., 2014. The second sex. Random House.
Garry, A. and Pearsall, M. eds., 2015. Women, knowledge, and reality: Explorations in
feminist philosophy. Routledge.
Harding, S.G. ed., 2004. The feminist standpoint theory reader: Intellectual and political
controversies. Psychology Press.
Lal, J., 2018. Situating locations: The politics of self, identity, and" other" in living and
writing the text. In Feminist dilemmas in fieldwork (pp. 185-214). Routledge.
Luke, C. and Gore, J., 2014. Feminisms and critical pedagogy. Routledge.
Meyers, D.T. ed., 2014. Feminist social thought: A reader. Routledge.
Mosedale, S., 2014. Women's empowerment as a development goal: taking a feminist
standpoint. Journal of International Development, 26(8), pp.1115-1125.

7FEMINIST STANDPOINT THEORY
Shakeshaft, C., 2015. Am not going to take this sitting down’: The uses and misuse of
feminist standpoints-Theory in women's educational leadership research. E. Reilly & Q.
Bauer (2015)(eds.). Women Leading Education across the Continents: Overcoming the
Barriers.
Tyagi, R., 2014. Understanding postcolonial feminism in relation with postcolonial and
feminist theories. International Journal of Language and Linguistics, 1(2), pp.45-50.