This case study examines the ethical issues in Gosport War Memorial Hospital, where medical malpractices resulted in the death of 456 patients. The study discusses the unethical practices conducted by Doctor Jane Barton and the complicity of other healthcare professionals. Recommendations for addressing these issues are provided.
Contribute Materials
Your contribution can guide someone’s learning journey. Share your
documents today.
GOSPORT WAR MEMORIAL HOSPITAL CASE STUDY
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
Executive Summary The concept of medical ethics is success-critical for the medical professionals and hence will have to be considered accordingly while framing the operational policies and procedures for a medical organisation such as hospital etc. The instant paper deals with the ethical issues in the medical profession that has been identified in the Gosport War Memorial Hospital. The entire report is based on the given case study that analyses the unethical practices that had been running in the hospital for years and the root cause of the same. Finally, the researcher provides the recommendations as to the issues so identified and analysed. Page2of13
Table of Contents 1.0 Introduction................................................................................................................................4 2.0 Analysis.....................................................................................................................................5 2.1 Ethical issues in hospital........................................................................................................5 2.2 Implications of this issue.......................................................................................................7 3.0 Conclusion.................................................................................................................................9 4.0 Recommendations....................................................................................................................10 References......................................................................................................................................11 Page3of13
1.0 Introduction Medical ethics is referred to as the system of moral principles, which tends to apply values to the methods of scientific research and clinical medicines. In the statement ofStoltet al.(2018), it has been noted that the core aim of this concept is to help medical students in recognizing the significance of being sensitive to ethical matters on their regular ethical practices. Moreover, another purpose of this concept is also to establish the abilities within the medical students to efficiently address patients’ ethical concerns. According toBenedict (2018), medical ethics is quite significant as the standards tend to promote collaborative work and also the values of cooperation. Ethical standards in the medical segments also other imperative social values like human rights, social responsibilities, patients' welfare, law compliances, and patients' safety. The present report aims to evaluate the importance of following effective ethical practices in the medical segment with a special emphasis on the case of ‘Gosport War Memorial Hospital'. The study would discuss the ethical issues conducted within the chosen medical institute followed by the remedial actions. At the beginning of the study, the paper would provide a brief introduction to the topic followed by the discussion on the overview of the concept of medical ethics. In the subsequent parts, the researcher would aim to identify an ethical issue related to medical operations. The issue will be evaluated again the backdrop of the established theoretical framework. The ethical issues raised in the given case study have been critically argued in order to establish the deficiencies within the operations of the organisation. Based on such analysis, the researcher would provide a recommendation as to the ethical issues and the need for establishing strict governance within the hospital. Finally, the researcher would wrap up the discussion by way of concluding note. Page4of13
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
2.0 Analysis 2.1 Ethical issues in the hospital Information gathered from the provided sources highlight the fact that in the 1990s, 456 patients have lost their lives at Gosport War Memorial Hospital due to the medical malpractices conducted by Doctor Jane Barton. It has been identified that the 456 elderly patients were prescribed with the opioid drugs that cause them to lose their lives due to severe side effects. The consultants working under the instructions of Dr Barton were well aware of the wrong practices conducted within the institute but never intervened. In a similar manner, the nurses and the pharmacist were also aware of the wrong medical practices followed under the instructions of Dr Barton, but they couldn’t raise their voice as they were strictly advised to follow the give instructions. In the year 1991, the senior nurses had managed to bring the matter into the attention of the Royal College of Nursing; yet, they were also instructed of not stretching the matter any further. As per the data of ‘INDEPENDENT’, Dr Barton was chiefly accountable for prescribing the lethal doses of opiate painkiller to the elderly patients with no grounds of medical justifications (Matthews-King, 2018). However, as discussed in the above section that the senior nurses and the consultants were well aware of the harmful effects of the drug, which can cause patients to lose their lives. However, to save the reputation and brand image of the hospital, they stayed quiet. In a similar context,Di Nucci (2018) determined that the hospital focused more on their profit margins and patients' footfall. They have completely overlooked the significance of maintaining an ethical code of conduct to provide the right set of treatments and medical facilities to patients. The discrepancy in the system can also lead to killing lives; it had been Page6of13
entirely neglected by the institute. Further information shows that in the year 2009, the medical practice of Dr Barton had been brought under the notice of the General Medical Council (GMC) that led her to face some disciplinary actions. She had been found guilty of conducting the practices of serious professional misconducts. Conversely, she had not been struck off the hospital register. The findings of the investigation conducted by the panel show that Dr Baton had used opioid drug dose without having any proper clinical indication. The continuous usage of opioid over patients called forrehabilitation, respite care and severe deaths. As perRich, Singleton and Wadhwa (2018), the opioid is a powerful drug that can definitely bring effective health benefits if used with appropriate measures. However, ineffective clinical knowledge over the subject can introduce commensurate health risks. Additional information also shows that panels in the investigation process had accessed to only 40% of the internal records, which showed only 456 patients were affected with the opioid dose. However, the rest of the records are missing. Therefore, it has been estimated that there can be high possibilities of near about 200 patients being similar affected whose clinical records are unfound. Dr Barton was also accused of using inappropriate anticipatory prescribing of diamorphine on the very day of admission when they were not even clinically indicated.Rodger, Blackshaw and Young (2018) mentioned that the administrative department of the hospital is also responsible behind the medical misconducts. The mission records of patients’ clinical treatments are a stern sign of the administrative departments’ casual and informal approach. The maintained records are evidently showing that a sudden change in the patients’ condition was majorly misinterpreted as terminal even, which prompted the doctor to start the lethal drug regime from the very initial stage of treatment. This led the patients to face the symptoms of agitations and several challenging behaviours (Smith, 2019). It has also been observed from the given case that in certain cases the Page7of13
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
depressed consciousness also prompted the inappropriate prescription of opioid drugs and other sedative medicines. Hence, it can be stated that the medical practices followed in the chosen hospital predominantly lagged in ethical conducts and sense of accountabilities (Wardrope and Reuber, 2019). Therefore, despite knowing the negative consequences of the malfunctioning practices, the administrative department, nurses and consultants stayed quiet and allowed the more frequent occurrence of the practice to take place with the passage of time. 2.2 Implications of this issue A report published in the online newspaper ‘INDEPENDENT’ also highlights that the medical misconduct that was practised from a relative period of time in the hospital triggered the families of the patients to raise voice for justice (Matthews-King, 2018). It has been observed that families have struggled from 20 years to get their loved one’s death investigated. Although they wereinitiallymarginalisedbythehospitalinstructorsandpolice,yet,theircontinuous obligations and protests led the panel members to call for an inquiry session, in which Dr Barton’s practices were found guilty. The police and Crown Prosecution Service have been forced to review the evidence brought forward by the inquiry panels to recognise the possible charges. The records highlight that in the year 2014, public inquiry took place that had been backed up by£13 million in public capital, which had been broadly appealed for the patients’ family members with concerns to come forward (Matthews-King, 2018). The family members have been determined to prolong their protest against the management of the hospital to ensure strong actions to be taken on legal grounds. In the year 2010, the General Medical Council have found Dr Barton guilty of ‘serious professional misconduct' post the fitness practice panel intervened the deaths of 12 patients. In her defense, Dr Barton stated that she had been placed with the excessive and increasing burden Page8of13
of patients. Although she had given her best effort to help patients out with quicker recovery, however, inadequate support had caused the margin of stress that led to the misconduct. Hence, as per the statement of Dr Baton, the practices conducted for the year were entirely unintentional. Moreover, the information gathered from “the guardian” reflects that in 2014, the health secretary had apologised before the family members of 456 patients for the ethical misconduct took place within the hospital (Boseley, 2018). The report states that 450 elderly patients were purposely given the life-shortening opioid drug, which they did not require. This had influenced the family members to pledge a campaign fighting for criminal prosecution not only against the doctor who prescribed wrong medicine but also against other resources who knew and failed to stop the practice. In her defense, Dr Barton also stated that the drug was given specifically to the cancer patients to relieve their pain. The patients whose fatality rate was high were prescribed their drug to at least get relief for a certain amount of time. On the other hand, evidence found where one of the nurses raised her voice stating the opioid drug cannot be a treatment for any cancer patient. For instance, the patients were found conscious when they were prescribed other medicines. But once they were given the opioid drug, they were found unconscious till death (Boseley, 2018). Page9of13
3.0 Conclusion It has been inferred from the above evaluation that Dr Barton along with the other resources in theGosport hospital lagged ethical sense of responsibilities. They were extremely unprofessional and casual with their approach, which influenced them to continuously conduct unethical practices. It is evident for a doctor to know both the pros and cons of every prescribed medical treatment. Hence, it is illogical for Dr Barton to regularly prescribe the harmful drug dose to 456 patients just on the ground of extensive pressure. Thus, the practice conduct within the hospital is completely intentional and purposeful. Page10of13
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
4.0 Recommendations Based on the discussion and analysis performed in the preceding sections of the report, it may be construed that the hospital has been experiencing ethical issues with respect to the operations. The drug discussed herein has been prescribed to the patients who do not require such drugs. The implication may be extremely fatal and may cause the death of the patients. The researcher may point out certain recommendatory measures which could have been performed herein. Firstly, the administrative department of the hospital needs to be strict with their internal process of marinating and supervising the records of patients and the kinds of treatment offered to them (Neal, 2019). Herein, the administrative department was extremely unprofessional to have lost the records of other patients who had also been the victim of medical misconducts. The administrative panel needs to maintain a strict look over every day’s operation to immediately identify and stop any clinical malfunctioning action. Secondly, the regulatory authorities of the state may also be held responsible to a certain extent as the event has been occurring within the state jurisdiction for certain years and no one raised any voices or concerns. The regulatory bodies should have been more vigilant in this regard. Thirdly, it may also be noted that a well-designed ethical policy within the hospital supported by the strong governance and honest administration will significantly contribute towards the attainment of the organisational goal of sustainability in its ethical framework in the long-run ion most time and cost efficient manner. Page11of13
References Benedict, J., (2018). Plain Anabaptists and Healthcare Ethics.The Journal of clinical ethics,29(3), pp.201-205. Boseley, S. (2018).Gosport hospital: more than 450 patients died due to opioid drugs policy. [online] the Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/jun/20/gosport- war-memorial-hospital-opioid-drugs-policy-inquiry [Accessed 3 Apr. 2019]. Di Nucci, E., (2018). Ethics in Healthcare: A Philosophical Introduction. Matthews-King, A. (2018).Hampshire police to 'step back' from an investigation into Gosport deaths. [online] The Independent. Available at: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/gosport-hospital-scandal-latest-hampshire-police- jane-barton-investigation-deaths-a8410856.html [Accessed 3 Apr. 2019]. Neal, M., (2019). The idea of vulnerability in healthcare law and ethics: from the margins to the mainstream?. Rich, C.R., Singleton, J.K. and Wadhwa, S.S., (2018).Sustainability for healthcare management: a leadership imperative. Routledge. Rodger, D., Blackshaw, B. and Young, A., (2018). Moral distress in healthcare assistants: a discussion with recommendations.Nursing ethics, p.0969733018791339. Smith, M.A., (2019). The promotion of social justice in healthcare.Nursing made Incredibly Easy,17(2), pp.26-32. Page12of13
Stolt, M., Leino-Kilpi, H., Ruokonen, M., Repo, H. and Suhonen, R., (2018). Ethics interventions for healthcare professionals and students: A systematic review.Nursing ethics,25(2), pp.133-152. Wardrope, A. and Reuber, M., (2019). Medicine and the media: the ethics of virtual medical encounters.Clinical Medicine,19(1), pp.11-15. Page13of13