Should Australia be a Monarchy?

This article discusses the debate on whether Australia should maintain its monarchy or transition to a different form of government. It explores the arguments for and against the monarchy in Australia, including the role of the head of state, the power of the monarch, and the impact on democracy and human rights. The article also examines the position of different political parties on the issue and provides insights from online surveys and social actions.

HUM10001 2 Template
Name:
Topic:
PART A (300 words)
What is your chosen position on this issue?
Should Australia be a Monarchy?
Position: yes
in Australia, the position of head of state is inherited. A constitutional monarchy is one where
applicable the power of monarch or sovereign. Generally, this issue can be opposed to the position
of government, which are similar the person. The current position is intermediate. At that time,
Australia should have the specific Monarchy because The constitutional with Queen as Sovereign. It
is known as royal style and represent with title of queen title in Australia. Generally, it supports the
monarchy which has grown steadily since 1999. Australia should have the Monarchy but it also
increased inherently violates the constitutional against unusual and cruel punishment (Egan, 2019 ).
Therefore, every decision made by royal price. In order to increase the challenging issue for public

HUM10001 2 Template
When, where, and how was your view on this issue formed? How did you end up holding this view?
What things influenced your decision?
According to My point of view, Australia should have such type oftypeconsists of monarchy. It is
completely moral thing. Each and every citizen has followed the regulation that were formed by
Government. I was increased the different kind, non-judgmental of others and their own situation.
According to chosen the topic related Monarchy. When I was seen that Monarchy that maintain the
dignity, honestly and welfare from other in term of public safety advantage, benefits. As considered
the term of monarchy. It can be defined the government that is ruled by single person such as
president. Monarchy is a type of political system that involved hereditary chain of commands. It can
be organized the murder. Another way, it also influential factor that become irreversible which make
it apologizing to wrongly accused person.
Monarchy’s singularity of power provide people with symbolic and focused on the area for group
identity and loyalty. It will help for individual person to make decision so that they will make quickly
manner. on the other hand, monarch has life tenure which is not subject to national election but also
performed the different activities under specific political system
I believed issue that formed current situation such as identifying the power of Monarchy among the
different way to influence towards Democracy. It is increasing the drug abuse and creating a better
economy of nation.
I have been viewed about the other Australian Minister and officer regularly increase abolition of
Monarchy, which give more priority of human rights issues. These are considered as important
aspects for understanding the concept of Monarchy. According to me, up holding this view regarding
Monarchy, it has been identified that decline the number and frequency of royal scandals which

HUM10001 2 Template
PART B (200 words)
 Take the ABC vote compass Quiz.
 Paste a screen-shot of your results here. (Click inside the box, then go Insert > Picture > and
choose your saved screenshot).
Where are you positioned compared to the main political parties (hint: speak about the X & Y axis on
the graph – Economically left or right; Socially progressive or conservative).
Which political party is closest to your position on your chosen issue?
According to Figure, I have been comparison between the main political parties, which are leading into
this manner. I am positioned in top left quadrant and GRNP is a leading political party represented.
Another top right quadrant, The Australian labour party is basically closed to the position of Green
(Rodrigues, Silva & Spangler, 2019). When I have followed GRNP. My first preference is to vote for
laborlabour and another choice is GRP in the election. Usually, I have been participated and happy to
contribute role within political area. In order to show the own idea, thoughts, belief. But I am not aware
Green political party is the closed to the position of monarchy. There are mainlyit can be
identified two different political parties who have been always shared their position on
the.within specific role. The Australian GRN (green) political partyP want to end the Monarchy,
in order to oppose other political parties. Sometimes, it always support for campaign. Another
laborlabour party support my position since 1973, they were passed the law for eliminating the

HUM10001 2 Template
What did you learn from doing the Vote Compass?
 I have learnt about the current affairs and other political happening so that understand
current situation or condition.
 I have identified the valid view point or opinion regarding importance of issues.
 I have learnt about the Quiz related the Australian politics and examined that who has
voted in election available.
 As I understand the concept of vote compass and altered to focus on Australian people.

HUM10001 2 Template
Part C (600 words)
Return to your chosen issue, and the position you identified.
What are the best arguments of the OPPOSING position to yours?
Number these opposing arguments in order from strongest to weakest:
It can be identified the most powerful opposing arguments to the position:
Retribution: it is the specific belief on the Monarchy which brings more retribution, in order to guilty
the people towards the punishment in proportion to the severity of their crimes. Generally, it can be
controlled or managed by Monarchist in Australia. Who is responsible for reducing crime level.level?
Deterrence: it is based on the innovative idea that always support for establishing the capital
punishment, equal rights within Australia. In future, it applicable as giving the punishment by
Monarchist.
Prevention through re-offending: it should be considered the capital punishment, who have
committed and convicted the murder. Especially, when person in in danger situation.
Royal prerogative provide the unaccountable power to the executives: The Australian government,
especially prime minister exercise various patronage and considerable power. These power is
enabled the executive appoint and dismiss. In order to choose suitable decision for maintaining
power. Sometimes, it is important reason to abolish the monarchy.
 Royal prerogative provide the unaccountable power to the executives: 1Retribution: 1
 The monarchy has become real power, which need to dismiss the prime minister: 2
 Prevention related re-offending: 2
 The monarchy interface in day to day political life : 3
 Deterrence: 3
 Closure: 4

HUM10001 2 Template
Why do you think the argument at the top of the list is the strongest?
Why do you think the argument at the top of the list is the strongest?
As per discussion, it has found that Retribution is one of the strongest argument for opposing the
position “ royal prerogative give extensive and unaccountable power of executives. in proper
manner. It can be possible when providing the justice while taking an eye for an eye concept.
Nowadays, it has increased the demand of justice which help for controlling the modern society and
provide warranted for every individual person. It help for securing the specific moral contentment
and also established a new order in term of retribution (Tan, 2020). In this way, it is mainly focused
on the power of other executives where they can share their view point about the particular issue or
problem. Sometimes, it is considered the It is not just misled with argument but also taking revenge.
In some situation, many people are confused about the concept of retribution revenge . This is
nothing to signify the inflicting harm for other one. On the other hand, Retribution has been
supported the specific theory that always deserve the punishment, if in case identifying misleading
among political parties. Monarchist always support for improving the current situation in term of
rules and regulation.
Furthermore, government has established coordination with monarchist regarding rewards, declare
ware, emergency state, issue passports, and create foreign nations. It make thousands of

HUM10001 2 Template
Part D (400 words)
Take this online survey: https://scuau.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_bIul6yfUpwZl6BL
Paste a screenshot of the first few items of your answer for the question on “The best type of society
is…” here (you will not be able to capture all the items in one screenshot, that is okay):

HUM10001 2 Template
Read the Assignment instructions for Part D, step 2, and paste a picture of your “Continuum of
social action” for your issue below. (Use the same scale and words below the line as the example).
Identify your current position on the continuum at the moment with a BLACK dot, and label it.
Initially, Black dot indicate the initial process that have wrote a letter to Malcolum turnbull and also
asking about the referendum on the republic day. On the previous years, in order to keep maintain
the information which help for against the political parties.

HUM10001 2 Template
Is your current position where you would like to be?
If not, mark your preferred position with a GREEN dot, and label it.
Explain your current (or preferred) position on the continuum – why is it preferable to the social
actions on the left or the right?
According to social action, According to me, I would like to the current position in the middle
where green dot has been situated. I participation in the march of re-publican demonstration but
currently, it is not running at that time (Vuletic, 2019). The current position is situatedthis
position is mainly represented in the middle and also represented through Green Dot. It may
represent the writing letter to government and ensuring abolishment of Monarchy in Australia
(Vuletic, 2019). Generally, Green political party always opposed to support the different facts,
figure. Sometimes, it applicable to ensure specific reason behind the certain condition or
situation. By consideration of Green dot, it is participated as intermediate which always inspiring
From above social action, it has been identified my current position which mainly occurred on
middle. In order to establish coordination with government and other political agencies
regarding the support. According to me, it is preferable to the social action on the right because
government has provided the legal right for every people. Afterwards, it has taken action illegal
violent action. Usually, I am preferred to maintain the position is right of social action because it
has performed the different execution (Teese, 2020). Setting up the effective legalisation to
receive the Monarchy free. I would like to march in the pro-republican demonstration but they
did not received. This can be possible when government has passed legal regulation where each
member follow them into step by step manner (Teese, 2020). In additional, Civil disobedience
yourself, actively refusal of citizen to obey certain law, demands. Sometimes, it has identified the

HUM10001 2 Template
Double-check that the picture of your “Continuum of Social action” includes a RED dot, which
identifies some sort of illegal social action that would result in you being placed in jail. What things
would have to happen in order for you to move to the red dot?
According to the continuum social action, it has identified the Red Dot which mainly representing
storming gates at Buckingham palace. When moved towards red dots, it has occurred the illegal
action against the person, who have not followed the proper regulation. As a result, It being
placed into jail. Everything depend on the own rights where I have followed the regulation under
legalise circumstances.
whereas setting the individual rights regarding the Monarchy. It always support for acquiring the
more information or data from different Australian system. Sometimes, it also included in the
government policies to free Monarchy from countries.
in red dot, Furthermore, it can be identified theit is mainly representing the different legal social
action that would be resulted in being placed into hail. The classification of legal action that
require to perform the different operation in term of safety, orderly. It is prerequisite for rational
allocation of different program opportunities that mainly exits in the institution. It enabling the
proper custody level of an inmate and identifying the inmate vocational and need of individual.
Deviance is considered as illegal action that mainly described behaviours that violate social
norms. Sometimes, it include the formally enacted rules and information violations in term of
social norms. This type of action will be exits under social illegal action. As a result, it has more

HUM10001 2 Template
REFERENCES
Book and Journals
Egan, S. (2019). Murphy, The Tudor Occupation of Boulogne: Conquest, Colonisation and Imperial
Monarchy. 1544–1550.
Mort, F. (2020). Accessible sovereignty: popular attitudes to the British monarchy during the Great
War. Social History. 45(3). 328-359.
Rodrigues, A. M. S., Silva, M. S., & Spangler, J. W. (Eds.). (2019). Dynastic Change: Legitimacy and
Gender in Medieval and Early Modern Monarchy. Routledge.
Tan, K. Y. (2020). The Struggle to Reform Brunei’s Monarchy: The Sultan and the British.
In Viceregalism (pp. 311-330). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.
Teese, C. (2020). What should the champions of democracy care about?. News Weekly., (3063). , 12.
Vuletic, D. (2019). Australia and the Eurovision Song Contest: A Historical Survey. In Eurovision and
Australia (pp. 17-32). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.
Woodacre, E., Dean, L. & Martin, R. (Eds.). (2019). The Routledge History of Monarchy. Routledge.
Egan, S. (2019). Murphy, The Tudor Occupation of Boulogne: Conquest, Colonisation and Imperial
Monarchy, 1544–1550.
Mort, F. (2020). Accessible sovereignty: popular attitudes to the British monarchy during the Great
War. Social History, 45(3), 328-359.
Rodrigues, A. M. S., Silva, M. S., & Spangler, J. W. (Eds.). (2019). Dynastic Change: Legitimacy and
Gender in Medieval and Early Modern Monarchy. Routledge.
Tan, K. Y. (2020). The Struggle to Reform Brunei’s Monarchy: The Sultan and the British.
In Viceregalism (pp. 311-330). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.
Teese, C. (2020). What should the champions of democracy care about?. News Weekly, (3063) , 12.
Vuletic, D. (2019). Australia and the Eurovision Song Contest: A Historical Survey. In Eurovision and
Australia (pp. 17-32). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.
Woodacre, E., Dean, L. & Martin, R. (Eds.). (2019). The Routledge History of Monarchy. Routledge.