Assignment on The Importance of Nursing Research
Added on 2022-09-10
14 Pages3411 Words21 Views
|
|
|
Running head: CRITICAL APPRAISAL OF THE ARTICLE
CRITICAL APPRAISAL OF THE ARTICLE
Name of the student:
Name of the university:
Author note
CRITICAL APPRAISAL OF THE ARTICLE
Name of the student:
Name of the university:
Author note
CRITICAL APPRAISAL OF THE ARTICLE
1
Introduction:
Nursing research has emerged as a contributing factor for the development as well as the
renewal of patient care. Nursing research is also contributed to the development of nursing
education and leadership in clinical practice (Christmals and Gross 2017). Nursing research is
the most suitable source of beneficial evidence for patients and communities for involving
resolving complex diseases that are intrinsic in nursing and health care (Brooke, Hvalič-Touzery
and Skela 2015). In this context, in order to understand the experience of nurses regarding the
involvement in nursing research, the article “An ethnographic study of nurses’ experience with
nursing research and its integration in practice” by Dupin et al. (2014), has been chosen for
critical analysis. After a critical analysis, research findings and the implications for clinical
practice will be elaborated in the research. Caldwell framework would be used to critically
appraise the article. The rationale behind choosing this tool as a critical appraisal tool is that it
enables individuals to develop skills for research evidence and apply them in professional
practice (Caldwell, Henshaw and Taylor 2011). Hence, individuals will develop skills of
critically appraise diverse evidence.
Discussion:
Title of the content:
Yes.
The title of the article reflect the content of the article. The article title, “An ethnographic study
of nurses’ experience with nursing research and its integration in practice” suggested that this
research will explore the experience of nurses in research and its integration in practice.
1
Introduction:
Nursing research has emerged as a contributing factor for the development as well as the
renewal of patient care. Nursing research is also contributed to the development of nursing
education and leadership in clinical practice (Christmals and Gross 2017). Nursing research is
the most suitable source of beneficial evidence for patients and communities for involving
resolving complex diseases that are intrinsic in nursing and health care (Brooke, Hvalič-Touzery
and Skela 2015). In this context, in order to understand the experience of nurses regarding the
involvement in nursing research, the article “An ethnographic study of nurses’ experience with
nursing research and its integration in practice” by Dupin et al. (2014), has been chosen for
critical analysis. After a critical analysis, research findings and the implications for clinical
practice will be elaborated in the research. Caldwell framework would be used to critically
appraise the article. The rationale behind choosing this tool as a critical appraisal tool is that it
enables individuals to develop skills for research evidence and apply them in professional
practice (Caldwell, Henshaw and Taylor 2011). Hence, individuals will develop skills of
critically appraise diverse evidence.
Discussion:
Title of the content:
Yes.
The title of the article reflect the content of the article. The article title, “An ethnographic study
of nurses’ experience with nursing research and its integration in practice” suggested that this
research will explore the experience of nurses in research and its integration in practice.
CRITICAL APPRAISAL OF THE ARTICLE
2
Author credibility:
Yes.
The researchers are credible because majority of the authors Research Fellow & PhD Student or
professor of Human and Social Science Department, Department of Epidemiology, Information
Systems, and Modellin , indicating authors were credible.
Abstract:
Yes.
Abstract summarize key points since the article summarize each segment such as Aim,
background, design, method, results , implication for practice (Downes et al. 2016). The abstract
also provide key words for the study.
Clarity of the rationale:
Yes.
It is valuable in the research practice. The majority of nurses are unable to apply critical
thinking and innovative intervention for treating the patients due to the lack of evidence-based
knowledge and lack of involvement in the research. In this context, this research will provide
nursing professionals to involve in the research work in between the nursing practice and alter
their professional values so that they can serve the professionals better.
Aim:
The clear statement regarding the aim of the study was clearly mentioned in the article
along with the abstract of the article. The aim of the study conducted by Dupin et al. (2014) was
to report the experience of French registered nurses regarding the involved nursing research in
their clinical practice.
2
Author credibility:
Yes.
The researchers are credible because majority of the authors Research Fellow & PhD Student or
professor of Human and Social Science Department, Department of Epidemiology, Information
Systems, and Modellin , indicating authors were credible.
Abstract:
Yes.
Abstract summarize key points since the article summarize each segment such as Aim,
background, design, method, results , implication for practice (Downes et al. 2016). The abstract
also provide key words for the study.
Clarity of the rationale:
Yes.
It is valuable in the research practice. The majority of nurses are unable to apply critical
thinking and innovative intervention for treating the patients due to the lack of evidence-based
knowledge and lack of involvement in the research. In this context, this research will provide
nursing professionals to involve in the research work in between the nursing practice and alter
their professional values so that they can serve the professionals better.
Aim:
The clear statement regarding the aim of the study was clearly mentioned in the article
along with the abstract of the article. The aim of the study conducted by Dupin et al. (2014) was
to report the experience of French registered nurses regarding the involved nursing research in
their clinical practice.
CRITICAL APPRAISAL OF THE ARTICLE
3
Literature review:
Yes.
The literature review is up to date since researchers consider approximately 10 years of
peer reviewed journal to conduct literature review (1995-2013).
Ethical consideration:
The researchers mentioned the ethical consideration in the article for conducting the
research. The study was performed according to the ethical guideline of the Declaration Helsinki.
The research work was approved by the oncology hospital’s head of nursing care (Dupin et al.
2014). The verbal, as well as written informed consent, was obtained from all the participants
who were participating in the research.
Methodology and research design:
The qualitative research design was considered in this case for underpinning the
experience of French nurses regarding the involvement in nursing research in clinical practice.
Gelling (2015), suggested that for exploring personal values, beliefs, and events of the
population, the qualitative research design is appropriate that enable researchers to look deeper
into the attitude and feelings. It also encourages participants to expand on their responses that
can address the area which was not previously considered (Melendez‐Torres, Grant and Bonell
2015). Hence, qualitative methodology is appropriate for conducting this research.
Hypothesis:
No.
3
Literature review:
Yes.
The literature review is up to date since researchers consider approximately 10 years of
peer reviewed journal to conduct literature review (1995-2013).
Ethical consideration:
The researchers mentioned the ethical consideration in the article for conducting the
research. The study was performed according to the ethical guideline of the Declaration Helsinki.
The research work was approved by the oncology hospital’s head of nursing care (Dupin et al.
2014). The verbal, as well as written informed consent, was obtained from all the participants
who were participating in the research.
Methodology and research design:
The qualitative research design was considered in this case for underpinning the
experience of French nurses regarding the involvement in nursing research in clinical practice.
Gelling (2015), suggested that for exploring personal values, beliefs, and events of the
population, the qualitative research design is appropriate that enable researchers to look deeper
into the attitude and feelings. It also encourages participants to expand on their responses that
can address the area which was not previously considered (Melendez‐Torres, Grant and Bonell
2015). Hence, qualitative methodology is appropriate for conducting this research.
Hypothesis:
No.
End of preview
Want to access all the pages? Upload your documents or become a member.
Related Documents