Ask a question from expert

Ask now

International Commercial Arbitration Assignment

12 Pages3159 Words130 Views

Added on  2020-05-28

International Commercial Arbitration Assignment

   Added on 2020-05-28

BookmarkShareRelated Documents
International Commercial ArbitrationName:Date:Institution:
International Commercial Arbitration Assignment_1
IntroductionInternational commercial arbitration has become a common method of resolving disputes that involve commercial entities. There are some of the biggest cases which have gone to the arbitration table for resolution. One of these cases includes Mitsubishi Motors Corp vs. Soler Chrysler- Plymouth Inc. One of the major advantages of this method is that it eases the time in which awards are rendered. In a foreign jurisdiction, the debtor can have assets which can be domiciled by the creditors. That ease has been partly due to the New York Convention a treaty of1958 which allowed countries to enforce awards arbitration from other independent jurisdictions.Parties entering into international commercial transactions find it very endearing to international arbitration. Parties to international contracts always have arbitration clauses that tend to protect their rights and eliminate uncertainties when a dispute arises. A court may however render a given dispute as non-arbitral. This is in rise to growing public interest and a highly conflicting policy concern. A court has higher authority and power than the courts of arbitration. It can render a case or a conflict non-arbitral if it’s highly charged. The Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) allows arbitration of international disputes under the UN convention on foreign arbitral awards. The court may reject arbitration on the scope of public Policy Exception. In a recent landmark ruling, the US Supreme court ruled that in the case of Mitsubishi Motors Corp .v. Soler Chrysler- Plymouth Inc. those private antitrust claims are arbitral in transaction arising from international trade.In this case, the court ruled in five-to-three decisions that if a contract has a broad agreement of arbitration, policy that favors arbitration overrides domestic public policy against antitrust
International Commercial Arbitration Assignment_2
claims. They mentioned that arbitration claims need not be specifically mention a given requirement. Statutory provision and treaties in antitrust claim that arbitration can be overruled by a court of law. In Mitsubishi- Soler there was an alternative public policy concern which means that arbitration could have contravened the public interest countervailing the holding company. The agreement was enforceable.In order to comply with this rule, the ICSID arbitration rules require the arbitrators to sign a declaration stating that there is no "reason why they should not serve in the Arbitration Court". While the absence of conflicts of interest is sought, a subjective suspicion about the referee does not disqualify himAs a consequence of the ethical principles of impartiality and independence that we have analyzed, certain ethical duties of the arbitrators arise, which have been specially included in the Codes of Ethics of both the International Bar Association (IBA) and the American Arbitration Association (AAA), known as: disclosure duty; duty of communication, duty of care; and duty ofconfidentiality, which we will analyze.When it comes to the method of arbitration, most corporations fall into three categories. The firstcategory is those that are in favor of arbitration for a particular transaction whenever necessary, those that do not agree on arbitration unless they are given no other alternative or means of settling a dispute and those who have basically no policy and therefore will make ad hoc decisions on issues raised on a particular matter. Corporations that do not want arbitration do so often because they have had bad experiences in the past. Arbitration awards are not appealed andtherefore due to limited grounds of appealing they prefer other methods which can be appealed. An appeal is paradoxical in cases of arbitration.
International Commercial Arbitration Assignment_3
The lack of appeal in arbitration makes it too risky. The time and size of the commercial case will be a determining factor in arbitration cases.Due to the relative privacy and consensual nature of the arbitration process, business participants prefer commercial arbitration as a way of settling disputes. However, the role of national courts has been put on the spotlight because of the way some reverse arbitration decisions. This has highlighted the weaknesses of commercial arbitration as a way of settling disputes. Even though parties choose arbitrators, select substantial laws governing the merits of the case, design procedures etc. It is not uncommon for arbitral tribunal awards to be performed under pressures. It is also possible that in some circumstances, parties would refuse to perform arbitral wards, which has compelled arbitration to turn to existing power to enforce arbitral awards. This has prompted the involvement of national courts, which has shown one weakness of the arbitration process. Commercial arbitration has developed from domestic to international and in this process it has created more chances of national courts intervention and restrictions of lex loci arbitri.According to Professor Goode international commercial arbitration has forced the pace of changein arbitration process. Delocalization movement started as a result of excessive judicial interference with party autonomy. Although the delocalization process is still ongoing, it has led to the freeing of commercial arbitration from the constraints of national laws. The delocalization theory attempts to create a delocalized arbitration that is free from lex loci arbitri. This theory suggests that national laws should not control international commercial arbitration. It however acknowledges that the laws of the place of enforcement should conditionally govern arbitral awards. However, Redfern and Hunter were skeptical of this theory
International Commercial Arbitration Assignment_4

End of preview

Want to access all the pages? Upload your documents or become a member.

Related Documents
International Arbitration Law

International Arbitration: New York Convention and Dispute Resolution

International Rule of Law and constitutional justice PDF