Issues in implementing IFRS in post IFRS harmonization areas
Verified
Added on 2023/03/17
|16
|4305
|45
AI Summary
This article discusses the challenges faced in implementing IFRS in post IFRS harmonization areas and the convergence of IFRS. It analyzes the perspectives of institutional theory and compares the financial statements of companies listed on ASX and NYSE.
Contribute Materials
Your contribution can guide someone’s learning journey. Share your
documents today.
Running head: ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS Issues in implementing IFRS in post IFRS harmonization areas Name of the student Name of the university Student ID Author note
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS Executive summary: For the purpose of analysis, six companies have been operating in the same sector selected from two difference countries. For the analysis, six companies have been chosen from mineralsandmaterialsectorlistedontheNewYorkStockExchange(NYSE)and Australians stock exchange (ASX). The three companies from ASX include BHP Billiton Limited, Rio Tinto and Boral Limited and other three companies that are selected from NYSEincludeHalconResourcesCorporation,CNXresourcesCorporationandEQT Corporation.
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS Table of Contents Introduction:...............................................................................................................................3 Discussion:.................................................................................................................................3 Answer to requirement A:..........................................................................................................3 Answer requirement B:..............................................................................................................3 Answer to requirement C:..........................................................................................................3 Answer to requirement D:..........................................................................................................3 Conclusion:................................................................................................................................3
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS Introduction: The report is prepared to conduct a detailed investigation on the convergence of IFRS (International financial reporting standard) and whether the objective of such convergence has been achieved or not. The study takes into account the perspectives of institutional theory forexplainingthechallengesfacedinimplementingIFRSandinitsconvergence. Convergence of the accounting standard implies that establishment of single set of accounting standard at the international level that helps in reducing the diversity in the reporting format between different countries. Increasing the comparability of the financial statement is one of the primary objectives of the convergence US GAAP (Generally accepted accounting principles) and IFRS (Baskerville and Grossi 2019). The evaluation of the IFRS convergence is done by comparing the basis of the preparation of the financial statements of different companies operating in the same industry and selected from two different countries. These comprised of BHP Billiton, Boral limited, Rio Tinto, Halcon Resources, EQT Corporation and CNX resources limited. Just like any other transitional process, convergence is not an easy task and the prospects and issues are there both in the developing and developed economies. The current paper highlights the looks into the extent to which the IFRS has been successful along with the issues faced due to the adoption of such internationalized standard. Discussion: Answer to requirement A: Convergence of the accounting standard refers to the objective of establishing a single set of high quality accounting standards that would be used at the international level and the efforts of the accounting standard board in achieving such objectives. The essence of convergence lies in the promoting simplicity, consistency, streamlining, transparency and
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS avoiding confusion, conflict and any future meltdown and financial crisis. With all the major economies planning to convergence towards IFRS, it can be observed that convergence is taking place in all the other countries. For instance, all the listed companies in Canada were required to use IFRS and the use of IFRS was permitted by Japan for some multinational companies. Nigeria was also required to adopt the internationalized standard. Some of the articles have been chosen for analyzing the impacts created by the harmonization of global financial reporting with evidences from developed and developing countries (Linet al.2017). The article titled” Relative Effects of IFRS Adoption and IFRS Convergence on Financial Statement Comparability” examined the effectiveness of the convergence on the financial statements using a unique setting in Germany. The intended benefits of the adoption an convergence is to increase the comparability of the financial statements that are prepared by companies located in different countries. It might be expected hat the adoption of IFRS wouldsignificantlyimprovethecomparabilitybetweenthefirmsbyeliminatingthe differences in accounting. However, a limited effect is created on the comparability due to the adoption of IFRS. The discretion of managers can adversely affect the financial reporting prepared under IFRS as they are more principle based. Moreover, in relation to the practice and implementation of IFRS, there exist considerable variations as IASB is not authorized to impose compliance with IFRS in the individual countries (Trimble 2018). It has been found using several comparability metrics in the article that the comparability of the financial statements has increased after the enforcement regulation. Another article titled” A Reinvestigation into Accounting Quality Following Global IFRS Adoption: Evidence via Earnings Distributions” has conducted an investigation in determining the impact of mandatory adoption of IFRS on the accounting quality using distribution on earnings. The study has examined the reporting system of considerable number of firms from different countries. A series of cross sectional analysis is done for
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS assessing the validity of distribution measure and differences in reporting environment and the paper contributes to the literature in number of ways. It has been ascertained for both the EU and non EU countries that there has been decrease in the earning distribution after the mandatory adoption of the standard. It is evident from the results obtained that there is a strong positive effect on the quality of accounting in countries outside the European Union after the adoption of IFRS. However, for non EU countries, where the reporting requirements are generally lower with low regulator attention and user demand, the reporting quality is initially lower. Therefore, the adoption of IFRS has larger impact on non EU countries. Alternatively, firms operating in non EU might rely on the adoption of IFRS as signal of quality for becoming competitive in the international market. The countries witnessing positive changes to the accounting enforcement found to have limited capital market benefits after the adoption of IFRS (Yapa 2016). Therefore, from the analysis of the article, it has been found that the quality of accounting has increased in both the EU and non EU countries after the adoption of IFRS along with decrease in the earnings distribution. The article titled” a literature review on the impact of IAS/IFRS and regulations on quality of financial reporting reviews that literature on whether the adoption of IFRS has resulted in improving the quality of financial reporting for listed companies. It is evident from the previous studies that are conducted in line with the issues that the regulation effect and IFRS impact the quality of financial reporting does not have any conclusive evidences. Theresultsobtainedfromthepreviousstudiesonthevoluntaryadoptionproviding contrasting facts about the adoption of IFRS on the financial reporting quality cannot be generalized in the current mandatory settings (Newmanet al.2016). The findings generated from the examination of mandatory adoption of IFRS on the financial reporting is consistent with the conclusion that is drawn from the literature that views that financial reporting quality is improved due to adoption of IFRS. Since, the principle based standards are lower than the
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS local standards, the objective of mandatory adoption of IFRS in benefitting the financial reporting quality cannot be found. From the analysis of the facts presented in the article, it can be inferred that the debate revolving around the financial reporting quality due to the convergence are yet to provide answers on how the regulations and IFRS impacts the financial reporting quality. The researcher in this paper was encouraged to conduct an examination into the poor reporting quality of the listed companies in Zimbabwe. It is also indicated by the literature review that there are variety of factors that forms the basis of financial reporting quality. However, the study failed to find any systematic evidences that the adoption of IFRS would result in improving the quality of financial reporting for the mandatory adopters. In addition to this, it was also founded in the study that there was not any change in the meeting earnings of the firms converging with the local standards (Newmanet al.2017). It was consistently reported by the results deduced from the article there was reduction in the quality of financial reporting over time. Furthermore, the fact that the IFRS cannot be superior to the established local standards has also been acknowledged in the report. Answer requirement B: Some of the journal articles have assessed the process of convergence of IFRS and challengingissuesfacedalongwiththechallengesfacedwhenimplementingthe internationalized standard using the perspective of institutional theory. Such theory helps in explaining the adoption of IFRS in the events when economic pressure is not the only drivers and how the accounting practitioner and accounting standard setting bodies have searched for the legitimacy. The accounting standards are influenced by the several factors along with the institutional influences on the diversity of accounting standards such as political, economic, educational,legalandreligioussystem.Thecontextofinstitutionexplainsthatthe
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS institutionalization can be viewed as the social process with the help of which the national accounting standards are accepted by the individual in the interest of harmonization of the international accounting (Felski 2017). This provides an explanation of the fact that why the countries tend to use the same accounting standard. This tendency to adopt the internal standard continues irrespective of the fact that the adoption might not results in economic benefits as promoted by IASB (Tsunogaya 2016). Therefore, to conduct a study on the adoption of IFRS, it is considered appropriate to use institutional theory of isomorphism. The study evaluating the global fitness of the accounting standards in the institutional theoretical perspective have concentrated on the response of organization to adapt to the standards in light of the pressure from institutional environment. It has been found from one of the articles that the probability of developing countries to adopt the IFRS is better predicted by the institutional isomorphism. Moreover, the institutional pressure is more influential in adopting the IFRS compared to the other economic pressures such as growth of GDP and inflow of FDI (Leuz and Wysocki 2016). It has been stated that the standardization has benefitted the super national regulations, but in order to address the needs of the firms in country, it is required to have jurisdictional regulations for avoiding the problems caused due to the approach of one size fits all. There are significant differences in the reporting standard of the firms in different countries because the reporting incentives of managers are affected by the institutional factors. Such institutional factors include strength of enforcement regime, legal system of country, compensation of firms, governance structure, ownership and capital market forces. For instance, it would be futile for companies such as USA and Japan to adopt IFRS without adjusting for resources and related facilities as they have well organized related infrastructures(NnadiandSoobaroyen2015).Apluralityofmodelsisassumedby institutionalperspectivewhichemphasizesoncreationoflinkbetweentheseveral institutions. Therefore, many of countries take into consideration institutional factors before
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS adopting the IFRS and this count on one of the challenges that is encountered while adopting the IFRS. Answer to requirement C: This section demonstrates the comparison between the financial statement of the companies listed on ASX and NYSE. For this, six companies operating in the same industry have been taken into account. BHP Billiton Limited is one of the largest mining companies of Australia that is engaged in the production of steel, iron, silver, copper, oil and gas and aluminum. The strategy of the company rests in operating and owning low cost, life long, upstream and diversified assets by geography, commodity and market (Li and Qin 2018). The financial statements of BHP Billiton limited have been prepared according to the requirements of the UK companies Act, 2006 and Australian corporation Act, 2001. In addition to this, the consolidated general purpose report has also been prepared according to the interpretation and theaccountingstandardscollectivelyreferredto asIFRSandAASB (Australian accounting standard board) that is being equivalent to the IFRS along with the IFRS and interpretations that are adopted by the European Union. The company also fulfills the requirement of consistency in the presentation of the financial statements in the current year by presenting reclassified comparative information (Bhp.com 2019). In addition to this, all the amended and the new standards along with the interpretations that are issued by relevant bodies under IFRS have been adopted by the company. Rio Tinto is one of the largest mining and metal companies of the world that is based in Australia. The focus of the company as a leading global mining group lies in mining, finding and processing the mineral resources of Earth. Rio Tinto has prepared the financial report for the year ending 2018 according to IFRS which differs in certain aspects from the
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS IFRS version in Australia that is referred to as AASB. The financial statement of the group was prepared according to UK GAAP prior to January, 2004. In addition to this, some of the accounting treatment has been done under the rules governing the transition set out in IFRS 1 compared to IFRS such as elimination of goodwill directly against the equity. In addition to this, the netting of goodwill against the equity is not provided by AASB 1 and consequently, the shareholders fund includes the residue of goodwill. The financial statements are also drawn upon in accordance with the section 340 of the Australian Corporations Act 2001 that is issued by ASIC (Riotinto.com 2019). This requires the financial statements to be prepared according to the requirement and principles of IFRS adopted by the EU. BorallimitedisanAustraliancompanythatisengagedinsupplyingand manufacturing of construction and building materials and carries out its operation in Asia and United States. The organization is reaping the benefits of strong construction market with a particular emphasis on the activities of infrastructure. The consolidated financial statements for year ending 2018 are prepared according to the requirement of Corporation Act, 2001 and Australian accounting standard which is issued by AASB.Financial statements incorporate the financial statements of the entities which the group controls and the company as a whole. Company while preparing financial report encompasses all the transactions, unrealized profits and intercompany balances (Boral.com 2019). Halcon Resources Corporation is an independent energy company focusing on the exploration, acquisition, production and on shore liquid rich oil and natural gas development. The consolidated financial statements of the group are prepared in conformity with the generally accepted accounting principles (US GAAP). This requires the management of company to make assumptions and estimates that impact the disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities and the amount reported for the assets and liabilities. The judgment and
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS estimates is done by the company based on historical values that are believed to be relevant under the circumstances (halconresources.com 2019). CNX Corporation is an oil and gas company operating independently and is engaged in the development and exploration of the natural gas. The consolidated financial statements of the group is prepared in conformity with the US GAAP that requires the management of company to make assumptions and estimates that impact the disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities and the amount reported for the assets and liabilities. In addition to this, the controlled entities of the group is required to consolidate that is pursuant to the topic of consolidation of the FASB (Financial accounting standard board). The annual report discloses that the supplement gas data is prepared in accordance with the accounting standards of FASB (Investors.cnx.com 2019). EQT Corporation is the largest producer of natural gas in United States and is a technology driven leader and its associated benefits would give the lowest cost structure in the industry of natural gas. The US GAAP forms the basis of preparation of consolidates financial statement of EQT Corporation that requires the management to make assumption and estimates affecting the reported amount of liabilities and assets. For the measurement and recognition of the items in the financial statement, the attribute concerning the same is utilized by the company. In addition to this, EQT Corporation has also complied with the accounting standards updates that are issued by the FASB (Ir.eqt.com 2019). From the analysis of the annual report of all the listed companies on the ASX and NYSE, it can be inferred that the organizations listed on the ASX has complied with the IFRS and AASB and that of NYSE listed organization has prepared the financial statement in confirmation with the US GAAP and accounting standards issued by FASB wherever applicable. Therefore, it can be said that there is a difference in the reporting system of the
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS companies listed on the ASX and NYSE and the differences is attributable to the compliance of the accounting standard. Answer to requirement D: The evaluation of the financial statements of the companies listed on ASX ascertains that the companies have adopted and have prepared such statements in conformity with the IFRS. However, the convergence with the internationally accepted standards and principles by the companies has been largely shaped by the international forces such as foreign investors, supranational organizations and the accounting firms. Other factor that has been identified to influence the adoption of IFRS by ASX companies is the interaction amongst organizational players who may mobilize the power to protect their interest and preserve the status quo (Babatunde 2017). The adoption of the IFRS by the US companies is restricted due to the differences between the US GAAP and IFRS legal requirements and the model according to which the reporting should be done. It has been found that the comparability between the financial statements prepared by US GAAP and IFRS can be enhanced. However, the GAAP practice resulting from the US economic setting is supported and the adoption of the IFRS is restricted due to the cost of information processing and home bias frictions (Bhimaniet al.2019). Conclusion: ThereportpreparedabovededucesthefactthatadoptionofIFRSandits convergence has resulted in significant benefits when it comes to report the financial statement. This has been witnessed by the improvement in the comparability of the financial statements. However, it has also been found that there might improvement in the financial reporting quality in other aspects such as earnings distribution and other factors. In addition to this, it can also be observed from the analysis that incorporating the institutional theory
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS sufficiently contributes to address the challenges faced in the standard implementation. Furthermore, from the analysis f the financial statements of ASX and NYSE companies, it is ascertained hat there exist difference in their reporting system as the former adheres to IFRS and later adheres to US GAAP. The findings have been supported by the factors that restricts the companies or countries from adopting the IFRS.
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS References list: Babatunde, S.A., 2017. Implementing international public sector accounting standards in Nigeria: Issues and challenges.International Journal of Business, Economics and Law,12(1), pp.52-61. Bhimani, A., Bond, D. and Sivabalan, P., 2019. Does greater user representation lead to more userfocusedstandards?AnempiricalinvestigationofIASB’sapproachtostandard setting.Journal of Accounting and Public Policy. Bhp.com.,2019.[online]Availableat: https://www.bhp.com/-/media/documents/investors/annual-reports/2018/ bhpannualreport2018.pdf [Accessed 12 May 2019]. Boral.com.,2019.[online]Availableat: https://www.boral.com/sites/corporate/files/media/field_document/Boral-Annual-Report- 2018.pdf [Accessed 12 May 2019]. Dumitru, M. and Guşe, R.G., 2017. The Legitimacy of the International Integrated Reporting Council.Accounting and Management Information Systems,16(1), pp.30-58. Felski, E., 2017. How Does Local Adoption of IFRS for Those Countries That Modified IFRSbyDesign,ImpairComparabilitywithCountriesThatHaveNotAdapted IFRS?.Journal of International Accounting Research,16(3), pp.59-90. Hopper, T., Lassou, P. and Soobaroyen, T., 2017. Globalisation, accounting and developing countries.Critical Perspectives on Accounting,43, pp.125-148.
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS Investors.cnx.com.,2019.2017.[online]Availableat: http://investors.cnx.com/financials/annual-reports/2017 [Accessed 12 May 2019]. Ir.eqt.com.,2019.[online]Availableat: https://ir.eqt.com/sites/eqt.investorhq.businesswire.com/files/doc_library/file/EQT_Form_10- K_2018.pdf [Accessed 12 May 2019]. Klibi,M.F.,2016.Usinginternationalstandardsasacomplementtoovercomethe unachieved nature of local GAAPs: The case of a developing country.Journal of Applied Accounting Research,17(3), pp.356-376. Leuz, C. and Wysocki, P.D., 2016. The economics of disclosure and financial reporting regulation:Evidenceandsuggestionsforfutureresearch.JournalofAccounting Research,54(2), pp.525-622. Li, Z. and Qin, Y., 2018. Context cultures, translation strategies and learning efficiency of accounting standards: experimental evidence based on ASBE and IFRS texts.China Journal of Accounting Studies,6(2), pp.206-229. Lin, S., Riccardi, W., Wang, C., Hopkins, P.E. and Kabureck, G., 2017. Relative Effects of IFRS Adoption and IFRS Convergence on Financial Statement Comparability.Contemporary Accounting Research. Newman, W., Edmore, T., Milondzo, K. and Ongayi, W.V., 2016. A literature review on the impact of IAS/IFRS and regulations on quality of financial reporting.Risk Governance and Control: Financial Markets & Institutions,6(4), pp.102-108. Nnadi, M. and Soobaroyen, T., 2015. International financial reporting standards and foreign direct investment: The case of Africa.Advances in accounting,31(2), pp.228-238. Riotinto.com.,2019.[online]Availableat: http://www.riotinto.com/documents/RT_2018_annual_report.pdf [Accessed 12 May 2019].
ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTING IFRS IN POST IFRS HARMINIZATION AREAS Team,M.,Directors,B.,Information,S.,Presentations,E.,Releases,N.,Filings,S., Materials, A., Governance, C., Coverage, E., Documents, R., Alerts, E., Owners, I. and Alerts, E., 2019.Annual Report & Proxy Materials - Halcón Resources. [online] Halcón Resources.Availableat:http://www.halconresources.com/investors/annual-report-proxy- materials/ [Accessed 12 May 2019]. Trimble, M., 2018. A reinvestigation into accounting quality following global IFRS adoption: Evidenceviaearningsdistributions.JournalofInternationalAccounting,Auditingand Taxation,33, pp.18-39. Tsunogaya, N., 2016. Issues affecting decisions on mandatory adoption of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) in Japan.Accounting, Auditing& Accountability Journal,29(5), pp.828-860. Yapa, P.W., 2016. The institutional environment of accounting profession in Asia.Asia Pacific Journal of Accounting and Finance. Leuz, C. and Wysocki, P.D., 2016. The economics of disclosure and financial reporting regulation:Evidenceandsuggestionsforfutureresearch.JournalofAccounting Research,54(2), pp.525-622. Mulyany, R. and Ariffin, N.M., 2018. Islamic Finance and the Convergence towards InternationalFinancialReportingStandards(IFRS):TheStateofResearch Development.Journal of Accounting Research, Organization and Economics,1(1), pp.85-97. Baskerville, R. and Grossi, G., 2019. Glocalization of accounting standards: Observations on neo-institutionalism of IPSAS.Public Money & Management,39(2), pp.95-103.