Law and Ethics in Nursing: A Case Study Analysis

This article explores the principled and authorized proportions which are practiced by healthcare professional and nurtures. It includes a case study analysis on Law and Ethics in Nursing, discussing the issues, defensive procedures, parts and errands of the healthcare crew, ethical issues of patient’s safekeeping, and lawful responsibilities and penalties of the case.

LAW AND ETHICS 0
[Type the company name]
Law and Ethics in Nursing
[Type the document subtitle]
SystemJP
[Pick the date]

LAW AND ETHICS 1
Contents
Introduction......................................................................................................................................2
The clinical case..............................................................................................................................3
Law and ethics.................................................................................................................................4
Outcomes and discussions...............................................................................................................8
Root cause investigation and risk supervision.............................................................................8
The role of human resources........................................................................................................9
Informing parents (disclosure of medical errors)........................................................................9
Forensic medicine aspect...........................................................................................................11
Conclusion.....................................................................................................................................13
Bibliography..................................................................................................................................15

LAW AND ETHICS 2
Introduction
The UK legal organization has advanced over many epochs, and as per the process it is
progressively composite and refined. The persistence of this report is to comprehend the
commandment and morals in healthcare organization. Healthcare specialists and workers are
circumscribed by these legislatures. Additionally, they are exposed to specialized codes so that
forfeits can be smeared for violations (The Code- NMC, 2015). For example, healthcare
consultants who denies to check on enduring with HIV or the professional who reaches on duty
in a high state. Healthcare specialists are also imperiled to “quasi-law”. Quasi-law rises to health
service circulars originating from the’ Department of Health” which have no permissible
strength, even though anticipated to be monitored unless there are respectable explanations for
not undertaking so (Graham, 2016).
This consignment will explore the principled and authorized proportions which are practiced by
healthcare professional and nurtures. There are three isolated sets of legal rules for fosters, quite
separately from the law which institutes the context of NHS and the all-purpose law of the
terrestrial (Cribb, 2002).
 There are lawful responsibilities to patients, usually arising in the background of
accusations of carelessness.
 There are specialized responsibilities which are forced the count of nurses by the “United
Kingdom Council for Nursing Midwifery and Health Visiting (UKCC)”, which is
accountable for edification, record-keeping, proficient principles, and castigation. The
quintessence of the expert values recognized by the UKCC in its code of exercise is that
each foster must keep an eye on:

LAW AND ETHICS 3
1. Guard and endorse the benefits of separate patients and consumers.
2. Help the welfares of civilization.
3. Defend community faith self-assurance.
4. Support and improve the good stand-up and reputation of the occupations.
Detailed responsibilities in the Code of Practice requires the nurtures to deference the right of the
enduring to be convoluted in the preparation of care, to graft co-operatively with coworkers and
to report whatsoever unpleasantly distresses the customary of care being delivered (W McSherry,
2012).
Enduring security is multidimensional and chastised in moral and permissible necessities.
Therefore, it is the greatest highlighted constituent of the excellence of healthcare facilities all
around the biosphere (Tingle, 2013).
The clinical case
A 14-day old neonatal baby was hospitalized in the “Neonatal Intensive Care Unit” for the
reason of numerous attacks. He was the first juvenile of the household. The mother’s and
household history was destructive for attacks or any other syndrome. Attacks were organized by
medications, and investigative valuations comprising EEG “electroencephalography” were well-
organized. Later, the baby was constant and had endured breast feeding, it was scheduled to
relocate him to the level II NICU. However, it was deferred due to lack of accessible bedsteads.
On the night shift of the fourth day of hospitalization, newborn’s nurse overheard a rapid noise
and perceived that the incubator entrance was open and the baby was on the ground. The nurse-
in charge promptly pronounced the occurrence to the on-call surgeon. The new born was

LAW AND ETHICS 4
inspected systematically and no corporal wounds were found. Additionally, the occurrence was
described to the chief specialist of the subdivision and the record of this occurrence was
proximately sent to the hospice administrators. Further, all additional incubators were inspected
to make sure that they were safe ample.
When the staff associates well-versed the infant’s father of the tumbling, he blamed the mother
because of the abandoning of juvenile. Although, the mother said that she was compelling rest at
the instant of the happening. In the conference with officers there were numerous queries which
were elevated on the healthcare crew like:
What are the issues which lead to this occurrence?
What are the defensive procedures of this happening?
What are the parts and errands of the healthcare crew in allocating with this occurrence?
On the basis of professional commitments, what are the responsibilities of medicinal and nurture
associates in such occurrences?
What are the ethical issues of patient’s safekeeping in this occasion?
What are the lawful responsibilities and penalties of this case?
Law and ethics
Notwithstanding numerous patient security strategies and values, less consideration is
remunerated to the principled and lawful characteristics of this scenario. As per ethical
standpoint, the main objective of enduring security in the health system can be deliberated from
two features. It can be considered as an applied worth, in the sense that the chief emphasis is its

LAW AND ETHICS 5
optimistic consequences and welfares. It can also be premeditated as an ethical value by
concentrating on the fortification and preferment of humankind and human self-respect
(Lachman, 2012) . It should be highlighted that both characteristics are imperative in the health
system. From a specialized point of view, ethical values in longsuffering protection are not
disconnected from rudimentary medical responsibilities but are so dominant that they may be the
basis of other ethical values highlighted in medication. This imitates that the long-suffering
security is carefully associated with the theory of human pride and all enduring safety procedures
taken must assure the fortification of human’s self-respect. Hence, the accountability of the
healthcare staff and professional obligation are thoroughly associated with human self-respect
(Westrick, 2013).
Specialized morals and patient security are tangled important thoughts in medications. Patient
safety is chastised in ethical philosophies which are measured as care quality pointers. The
understanding of long-suffering safety needs the establishment and application of a certified code
of integrities. On the basis of certified code of demeanor, it is anticipated that all patients be
cured with self-respect and be threatened from any possible damage. Relatively, devotion to
principled moralities necessitates healthcare suppliers to recognize possible safety
disappointments to avoid falling occurrences (JB Butts, 2019).
The founding of durable protection has diverse individual, professional, and administrative
characteristics with a superior focus on morals. Certified and legislative assurance leads to
distinguishing and recording of both one’s and own and other’s mistakes (Webb, 2011)
On the basis of integrities, subsequent activities are suggested in this case:
 Resulting professional and recognized strategies related to falling occurrences.

LAW AND ETHICS 6
 Taking elementary activities to access the patient’s corporeal health and liberation of
patient’s life.
 Notifying the in-charge healthcare operation team.
 Prompt assessment of the condition.
 Comprehensive credentials and broadcasting of the happening (important data like time
of the incident, the position, level of consciousness, vital signs, those present at the scene,
actions taken for the procedure) (J Holt, 2012).
 Enlightening the parents and providing them with expressive sustenance.
Paternal accountability is well-defined by the “Children Act 1989” as all the human rights,
responsibilities, controls, accountabilities and establishments which by law a blood relation of a
child has in relative to the child and his possessions. “The Code of Practice for the Mental Health
Act” recommends that the discrete accountable for the care and management of the enduring
must regulate whether a person with parental obligation has the competence, within the
significance of the “Mental Capacity Act 2005”, to make a decision regarding the child or young
folk’s management and whether the conclusion is within the “zone of parental control” (Victoria
Thomas, 2015). The “zone of parental control” is a perception which was destitute from
“European Court of Human Right” case law and has become essential to parent related
conclusion making. There are strategies in the Code concerning whether a particular resolution
fall within the zone of parental regulator. The Code recognizes that the limitation of the zone
varies from one instance to the other instance, but the following factors should be deliberated:
 The environment and intrusiveness of what is to be done to the enduring (encompassing
the range to which their autonomy will be shortened)
 Whether the persistent is fighting.

LAW AND ETHICS 7
 The overall social principles in force at the time regarding the sort of conclusions it is
satisfactory for maternities to make.
 The stage, adulthood and consideration of the child or young single.
 The magnitude to which a parent’s attention might struggle with those of the child or
young individual (C Johnston, 2007).
Some handlings that could be deliberated predominantly intrusive or provocative, like ECT
“electroconvulsive therapy” are likely to be deliberated to fall outside the region of parent
guideline. Conclusions that would result in a dispossession of authorization will be external
the zone, as confinement involves the article 5 privileges of the juvenile (“Convention for the
Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms right to liberty and security”) and a
parent might not legitimately detain or approve the imprisonment of a child. There is no
exact definition of deficiency of permission, but numerous factors have been recognized that
are probable to be pertinent, like the use of restriction (comprising sedation) to divulge a
person to an association wherein that individual is counterattacking admittance; staff working
out complete and operative control over the care and effort of a person for an important
period; and the person being incompetent to sustain social acquaintances because of
boundaries placed on their admittance to other individuals. Nurture settlements were viewed
contrarily because children would commonly have been placed in this atmosphere by local
establishments. In the wake of the conclusion, a number of progenies and young individuals
who lack proficiency or capability to accord to their admission to hospice and who are being
cured on a casual basis will requisite to evaluate for the assessment whether they are being
dispossessed of their permission (RA Brown, 2015).

LAW AND ETHICS 8
Imprisonment under the Mental Health Act 1983 offers the child with a total of indispensable
fortifications, like as the right to demand against imprisonment. The 2007 modifications to
the Act have ensued in determined continuance for the rights of the children and young
personalities like the duty to guarantee an age-appropriate atmosphere and additional
defenses for ECT. It is important that clinicians functioning with children with mental
sicknesses equip themselves with a good considerate of the law and its submission, in order
that the applicable legal consultant for admittance and treatment is used, taking into
explanation all of the necessities of the patient and the pertinent issues of each case. The
Mental Health Act 1983 can be properly applied to progenies (J Manthorpe, 2015).
Outcomes and discussions
Root cause investigation and risk supervision
The rudimentary investigation of the instance is one of the preliminary and indispensable
procedures taken to reduce the prevalence of patient grievances. The elementary surveillance is
that the declared procedure must be free of any prejudice and should focus on concluding the
foremost reason and determining it instead of recognizing the responsible individual. The
defensive measure of such occurrences is to have superior procedures for broadcasting the event
in an appropriate systematized principled environment without accusing anyone (Morgan, 2012).
Distress of guilt, undeniably, inadequate administrative provision, consequences, lack of
information and, inadequate response regarding the connected dynamics are few of the fences to
recording medical errors in infirmaries.
As per ethics, the importance of trustworthiness is an essential of prosperous risk supervision.
This value is associated to security ethos since it discusses physical movement, functional safety,

LAW AND ETHICS 9
and educational safety. Additionally, it is significant for the supervisors to inspire
multidisciplinary cooperation to facilitate apparent recording and reporting. The incessant
preparation of the personnel in enduring safety, stable command, and controlling the
effectiveness level of the achieved actions are few other steps that can be taken in these
affections (R Griffith, 2017). Like, recurrent checking of the incubator access, usage of multiple
locks, and clarification of security tips concerning the incubator to the staff members are also
indispensable.
The role of human resources
The amount of human possessions is also important in the arena of patient protection. As, quality
assurance hinge on the amount of manpower. Hence, in order to avert similar occurrences,
provided that satisfactory number of staff at the bed sideways is significant (E Kalaitzidis, 2012).
Informing parents (disclosure of medical errors)
It seems in case of any blunder made by the associates, the happening must be pronounced to the
parents fairly without accusing the care benefactors. Additionally, “it happens” and “nothing has
happened though” should not be castoff. Underneath situations which errors were produced by
unsuitable pattern of providing hospital facilities, parents should be comforted that all amenities
will be remunerated by the hospice. It would be improved if the parents were well-versed by the
chief medical consultant or head nurse and should have assumed enough time to express their
apprehension or annoyance (Johnstone, 2011).
However, annoyance under such situations is a usual response; we cannot hide medicinal
mistakes because of terror of parent’s response. Moreover, antagonism would be more disunite if
they found out that the hospital workers have obscured the reality.

LAW AND ETHICS 10
It is deliberated that knowing the certainty and precise evidence is one of the elementary rights
patients and their family fellows. As per research, amplifying the error to the patients could be a
traumatic situation united with penetrating emotional responses from patient/family members or
the care squad. Usually, the person that dyed-in-the-wool of error has a sense of guilt or anxiety
of chastisement and patient/family member’s proficiencies feelings like annoyance and
nervousness (R Chadwick, 2016). Moreover, it should be detected that primary discussions
frequently take place when there is no precise and inclusive evidence regarding the happening,
so distinguishing considerations and illuminating all the details in convoluted clinical
circumstances is not conceivable. Hence, it is commended that in such conditions, evidence be
given in numerous stages and by providing emotional support for the enduring. Furthermore,
while they may necessitate sympathetic intrusions, the patient’s family can be painstaking as an
imperative source of data in the technique of RCA (Root Cause Analysis) of comparable
occurrences (S Shrestha, 2014).
Additionally, the father should be guaranteed that hospitalizing the neonatal was essential and
mother should not be liable for the occurrence. In fact, father should be safeguarded that the
happening was utterly due to structure error and not by the mother. Usually, looking after the
truthfulness of the personal is significant and medical crew must consider family sustenance at
all phases, particularly in such circumstances and cases. Indeed, an imperative moral point in this
case is the inevitability of proposing an honest confession (I Norman, 2013). It is not always
artless as saying wretched. The method of notifying the parents is a subtle subject and there is a
crucial obligation for preparing healthcare providers in penetrating relational associations and
associated skills to enable truthful and appropriate announcement with the patient’s personal (A
Carmi, 2012).

LAW AND ETHICS 11
Forensic medicine aspect
Laws and guidelines related with patient security, which may diverge on the base of regulations
system of each nation state, should reassure the revelation of medical errors while subsidiary the
enactment of the ethical requirements of patient safety. Generally, in medicinal regulation, the
patient who is a casualty of carelessness is hypothetical to be fairly remunerated (J Daly, 2017).
Additionally, these instructions provide potentials for preferment of limpidity and open
infrastructures in all stages. Reaching this goal requires apropos of all stakeholders in the
healthcare organization.
As per the explanations, it should be deliberated that maternal postnatal drowsiness in one of the
major risk influences for dropping of new born. Partial of all new born falling occurrences in
hospitals have happened while the mother was holding the newborn in a hospital bed. Therefore,
distinguishing the risks of newborn falling throughout mother baby care circumstances and
schooling the mothers is a major nursing accountability. If the mother is inept of taking care of
the hospitalized newborn, she should be under administration of the care team and should be
polished. Additionally, informing the father is a suitable act if the grievance was elevated by the
father. The chief task of the doctor or nurse after a comprehensive inspection and handling is the
exhaustive record-keeping and report of all events without any expectations (MEL Iglesias,
2014). If the inspections found indication of abandonment, it would be an entirely unlike
conversation and calling the social facilities would be unconditionally essential. Also, there is a
responsibility to notify the personal about the each unsolicited happening in healthcare
organization. The impression that there is no necessity to disclose faults which do not disturb the
patient is grounded on the outdated stance of the law. Furthermore, it is well identified that such
revelations will augment patients’ faith to healthcare specialized while building of all the

LAW AND ETHICS 12
conditions. Additionally, from side to side this tactic, healthcare specialists can admire the
patient’s independence and self-respect (C Leuter, 2013).

LAW AND ETHICS 13
Conclusion
Notwithstanding augmented consideration towards the excellence of health care facilities, there
are immobile numerous menaces in healthcare background. As the persistent security is
multidimensional and pounded in lawful and principled requirements, both allowed and
principled encounters should be taken into excuse. Therefore, healthcare scheme needs strategies
and procedures to nurture the safety backgrounds which are constructed on mutual confidence.
However, this can expedite by the reassurance of multidisciplinary harmonization for the
translucent broadcasting of medical errors. Moreover, the endowment of expressive sustenance
and lawful fortification of the staffs by the supervision is significant for the reassurance of
intended recording of occurrences. This could be the significance of healthcare provider’s
insufficient accepting about the prominence of clinical ascendancy and lack of governmental
safety philosophy.
The most communal reason of wound is medication inaccuracies and falling. Falling comprises
21% of total occurrences, out of which only 4% of them are thoughtful. These belongings are
regularly the outcome of inadequacies in systems and procedures, administrative intricacy and
uncertainty, and poor statement. Additionally, teaching and highlighting on the skilled code of
morals can be operative on excavating the accepting level of and belief in the morals
fundamentals of enduring’s safety.
Nursing performing in the correctional wellbeing field façades many encounters; in spite of the
encounters, correctional fosters have an excessive casual to subsidize in optimistic ways to
advance the health of this susceptible inhabitants and to have a superior influence on the superior
public fitness.

LAW AND ETHICS 14
Bibliography
A Carmi, S. S., 2012. Nursing law and ethics. 1 ed. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
C Johnston, J. L., 2007. The Mental Capacity Act 2005: a new framework for healthcare
decision making. Journal of medical ethics, 33(2), pp. 94-97.
C Leuter, C. P. A. M. G. T., 2013. Ethical difficulties in nursing, educational needs and
attitudes about using ethics resources. Nursing Ethics, 20(3), pp. 348-358.
Cribb, J. T. a. A., 2002. Nursing Law and Ethics. 2 ed. Oxford: Blackwell Science.
E Kalaitzidis, K. S., 2012. A study of an ethics education topic for undergraduate nursing
students. Nurse Education Today, 32(1), pp. 111-115.
Graham, A., 2016. Law and ethics in nursing and healthcare: an introduction. 2 ed. Los
Angeles: Sage.
I Norman, I. R., 2013. The art and science of mental health nursing: Principles and
practice: A textbook of principles and practice. 3 ed. London: Mc Grwa-hill.
J Daly, S. S. D. J., 2017. Contexts of nursing: An introduction. 5 ed. Chatswood:
Elsevier.
J Holt, H. C., 2012. Ethical practice in nursing care. Nursing Standard, 27(13), pp. 1-3.
J Manthorpe, K. S., 2015. Care professionals' understanding of the new criminal offences
created by the Mental Capacity Act 2005. nternational journal of geriatric psychiatry,
30(4), pp. 384-392.

LAW AND ETHICS 15
JB Butts, K. R., 2019. Nursing ethics: Across the Curriculum and into practice. 5 ed.
Hatteisburg: Jones and Bartlett Learning.
Johnstone, M., 2011. Nursing and justice as a basic human need. Nursing Philosophy,
12(1), pp. 34-44.
Lachman, V., 2012. Applying the ethics of care to your nursing practice. Medsurg
Nursing, 21(2), p. 112.
MEL Iglesias, R. d. B. V., 2014. Nurse attitudes in relation to health care ethics and legal
regulations for nursing. Acta Bioethica, 20(2), pp. 1-3.
Morgan, D., 2012. Issues in Medical Law and Ethics. 1 ed. London: Routledge-
Cavendish.
R Chadwick, A. G., 2016. Ethics and nursing practice. 2 ed. London: Palgrave
Macmillan.
R Griffith, C. T., 2017. Law and professional issues in nursing. 4 ed. London: Learning
Matters.
RA Brown, P. B. D. M., 2015. The Mental Capacity Act 2005: a guide for practice. 3 ed.
Los Angeles: Learning Matters.
S Shrestha, P. J., 2014. Knowledge & Practice of Nursing Ethics and Laws. Journal of
Universal College of Medical Sciences, 2(3), pp. 30-33.
The Code- NMC, 2015. The Code - NMC. [Online]
Available at: https://www.nmc.org.uk/globalassets/sitedocuments/nmc-publications/nmc-

LAW AND ETHICS 16
code.pdf
[Accessed 25 07 2019].
Tingle, J. a. C. A. e., 2013. LAW & ETHICS IN NURSING & HEALTHCARE. 4 ed.
London: Wiley Blackwell.
Victoria Thomas, B. C. L. R. a. P. M., 2015. The application of mental health legislation
in younger children. BJ Psych Bulletin, 39(6), pp. 302-304.
W McSherry, R. M. R. W., 2012. Care in Nursing: Principles, values and skills. 1 ed.
Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Webb, L., 2011. Nursing: Communication skills in practice. 1 ed. Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
Westrick, S. J., 2013. Essentials of nursing law and ethics. 2 ed. Connecticut: Jones &
Bartlett Publishers.