Law, Policy and Ethical Practice in Health and Social Care

This report explores the relationship between law, policy, and ethical practice in the health and social care sector. It discusses key features of different levels of law and policy, the relationship between ethics and legislation, and the impact of key legislation and national policies on health and social care practice. The report also analyzes the relevance of ethics and law to professional responsibilities in the sector. Find study material, solved assignments, and essays on this topic at Desklib.

Law, Policy and
Ethical Practice in
Health and Social Care

Table of Contents
INTRODUCTION ..........................................................................................................................4
PART 1............................................................................................................................................4
P1 Summarise key features of the different levels of law and policy.........................................4
P2 Relationship between ethics and legislation in relation to the work of health and social care
practitioners.................................................................................................................................5
M1 Analyse the relationship between ethics and law in terms of their relevance to own
professional responsibilities as a health or care practitioner.......................................................6
P3 Relationship between key legislation and national policies, of direct relevance to health
and social care practice...............................................................................................................7
P4 Compare national and organisational policies against the national professional standards in
terms of their impact on health and social care practice.............................................................8
M2 Reflect on ways in which specific tasks in the health, care or support service practice meet
national professional standards within a legal framework..........................................................9
D1 Evaluate the relationship between ethics and law and their impact on organisational policy
and practice towards protecting the rights and maintaining the well being of users of health,
care or support service................................................................................................................9
PART 2..........................................................................................................................................10
TASK 3..........................................................................................................................................10
P5 Explain how specific national and international law influence and inform the equitable and
fair treatment of others in health, care and support service......................................................10
P6 Implement different and relevant legislation and policy in regard to safe and healthy
conduct in own practice ...........................................................................................................11
M3 Analyse recent health and social care legislation or national policies in relation to their
importance in informing the rights and responsibilities of health, care or support service
practitioners to provide safe and equitable care........................................................................12
TASK 4..........................................................................................................................................12
P7 Describe the relationship between law, policy and ethical requirements in relation to real
case scenario in a health or care setting....................................................................................12
P8 Explain the impact of relevant law and policy on the outcome of real case scenario.........13

M4 Explain in detail how chosen law, policy and ethical considerations might result in
difference outcomes to the case scenario..................................................................................14
D2 Critically review ways in which health, care and support service practitioners can ensure
currency and compliance with relevant legislation and national policies through ethical
practice in relation to real case scenario...................................................................................14
CONCLUSION..............................................................................................................................15
REFERENCES..............................................................................................................................16

INTRODUCTION
Laws are regarded as the rules of conduct which on one hand are made to enforce the
justice and on the other hand prescribe the obligation or the duty which an individual is bind to
adhere. These are mainly derived from the formal enactment of the law makers or the customs.
The policies are the basic principles with the help of which a government is guided in order to
preserve the interest of the public at large. The health and care sector when working are bound to
adhere the range of the policies and the law while working in the common setting of primary
care, health trust and other public authority setting. Ethical practices are the code of ethics which
states the standard and codes which must be complied by the authorities in order to ensure that
there is application of ethical standards and codes (Morley, Le and Briskman, 2020). This report
shall deal with the understanding of different levels of laws and policies and the relationship
between legislation and ethics in relation to health and social care practitioners. Further it will
cover r key legislation, national and organizational policies of fundamental importance to health
and social care practice, and the laws in relation to key professional and ethical practice themes.
Lastly it will deal in application of law and policy in line with ethical and regulatory
requirements in the practice setting.
PART 1
TASK 1
P1 Summarise key features of the different levels of law and policy.
Laws are generally made by the law making authority. In UK this power is entrusted to
the Parliament which consists of two houses, House of Lords and House of Commons and the
Royal Monarch. The UK does not have a written Constitution so it is partially written and un-
codified. Its principles are embodied in the special acts of the Parliament and the precedents of
the judiciary.
The top level of law which regulate the working of other law is the Constitution. Then
comes international laws which regulate the working of the country (Kaplan, 2020). It includes
treaty agreements as well. The statutes and the legislations which are made by the Parliament are
the next which are bound to adhere with the constitution. Lastly there then comes the common
law which are case made laws.

There are three organs in the United Kingdom, which includes the legislative, judiciary
and the executive. The legislative is the Parliament which makes statutory laws on difference
subjects. It follows its law making process which involves several stages beginning from the first
reading, second reading, report stage, committee stage, third reading, consideration of
amendments and the assent from royal Monarch.
There are many levels of laws like for instance the laws made by the Parliament, then the
delegated legislation which is made by the delegated authority. These have the same relevancy as
of the main legislations made by Parliament.
The legislative are entrusted with the role to enact the legislations and they can further
delegate their power to make laws which is called the secondary legislations. It may be any
policy or guideline for the implementation of the original legislation. These are called the
statutory laws. The common law are the case laws through which the judiciary enacts the law
from any precedent. These both laws have validity and relevancy and are enforced in whole of
the country.
The health and social care sector is managed by different laws and policies so that it can
work in positive environment and eliminate the risk of legal complications. It includes Health
and Social Care Act of 2008, Care Act of 2014, Health and Safety At Work Act of 1974 and
many other. The National Health Service is the statutory body which regulate and govern the
working of the health and social care setting. It takes different initiatives to provide services to
the people in a smooth manner.
The second organ is judiciary which interpret the existing laws and make the new laws
from the case rulings. The Supreme court is the highest court in UK which is entrusted with the
responsibility to make common laws. It has the same validity which the statutory laws have.
The third organ is the executive which makes the policies and the regulations which
helps as guidance for the government to work for the benefit of the general public. The executive
make these policies and regulations and ensure its enforcement. It is responsible for the
governance of the state (Watson and Payne, 2020). The policies helps to ensure that the health
and social sector is secured. For example, National health service code of practice 2003, NHS
England: Confidentiality Policy, 2014, NICE Managing Medicine in Care Home Policy of 2014
and many other.

The executive have the power to make policies in order to implement the legislations
made by the legislature. They are the guidelines which helps in implementation. There are
normally two kinds of policies, national policies are such which are enforced in whole nation and
are formed by the executive and organisational policies are individually made in the companies
to enforce the national policy.
There are mainly national policies which are made by the executive and the concerned
organisations makes the organisational policies in order to implement the national policies. The
organisational policies are made in such a way that the national policies are followed in the
working of the organisation.
P2 Relationship between ethics and legislation in relation to the work of health and social care
practitioners.
The laws are the minimum standards of the behaviour which bound the individual to
comply with it and ethics are the maximum standards which an organization is required to
comply in order to ensure morals are followed and rights things are taken into action. These help
in guiding the organisation as to what is right and the law states the rules which are to be
maintained in order to prevent legal liability (Dawson, 2020). In context to the health and care
sector, the practitioners are required to comply with these ethical code of conduct and
legislations so that it can meet its professional responsibilities. The practitioners must ensure that
their operations and working are according to the ethical code of conduct so that rights things can
take place in the organisation and the users feel safe while availing the service in the health and
social care organisation. There are many issues faced by the health and social care practitioners
which includes patent confidentiality, euthanasia, malpractices in healthcare system, suits by
whistle blower and many other. In order to prevent these, the practitioners must comply with the
legislations and the ethical code of conduct so that work can be carried on smoothly and
effectively.
Legislations bound the organisations to comply with the rules in order to avoid the legal
consequences and the ethics does not bound rather they help in improving the culture of the
organisation so that the rules can be framed internally and have the strict compliance. Laws can
make the practitioners of health and social care bound in case of non compliance whereas the

ethics are not mandatory to be followed but nowadays, it is a requirement in the health care
sector to ensure its compliance so that rights things take place (Matthews, 2019).
In the perfect world, the ethical judgements and legal judgements are different and
separate as people keep their moral bias out of a legal system. But in current world, law and
ethics are intermingled as laws are only based on the religious ethics. Like for instance, a person
has committed an act which is illegal but the judge may give the judgement on its personal
feeling and opinion. A society which lives ethically have positive result on the legal judgements
as people belong to that society where what is ethically right will tend to be legally right.
In context to the health and social care sector, the ethical principle shall lie can be that a
doctor must not say no to the patient for giving the treatment. This shall be ethically wrong.
M1 Analyse the relationship between ethics and law in terms of their relevance to own
professional responsibilities as a health or care practitioner.
The professional responsibility of the health or care sector practitioners are the ethical
behaviour to which they are bound to follow. Like a surgeon is responsible to keep the medical
history of the patient confidential. This is the professional behaviour to which the surgeon and
nurses are bound to follow. In laws, these professional behaviour are also legal requirement as
they are either incorporated in common or statutory law (Berkowitz and Garrett, 2020). But not
all laws are ethical, for instance, euthanasia is a now being made a law but some people believe
that it is morally unethical so they do not comply with it and put themselves at personal risk. So
there is a relationship between law and ethics in the health and social care sector in terms of their
professional responsibilities. For instance, of the doctor shares the confidential detail of the
medical history of the patient with other person, it shall give rise to complications and may result
in minimum standard of behaviour which is unethical.
TASK 2
P3 Relationship between key legislation and national policies, of direct relevance to health and
social care practice.
Legislations are the laws which regulate the working of the society. In context to the
health and social care, the key legislations bound the practitioners of these sectors to comply
with this. The key legislations relating to health and social care sector includes Health and
social Care Act of 2012 which has introduced the legal duties relating to health inequalities.

This law imposes duty on the health bodies like Department of Health, Clinical Commissioning
Groups, Public Health England, National Health Service with regard to reduce the health
inequalities between the people of the country (Scott, Morris and Mars, 2020). This Act
abolished the Primary Care Trust and the strategic Health Authorities and a new authority was
created under this legislation, namely, Public Health England. This act is a result of the policies
which was framed by the Secretary of the state relating to the health.
Another legislation is Social Value Act of 2012 which requires the public sector
commissioners to consider the social, economic and environmental well being in the
procurement of the service or the contracts. It is an attempt to reduce the health inequalities by
improving housing and employment. Other law is Care Act of 2014 places duties on the local
authorities in relation to assessing the needs of the people and also their eligibility for the
publically funded support and care. It imposes duty to promote the well being of the carers and
councils must advice them on their care funding. The care and support provided to the carer must
be covered by Human Rights Act of 1998.
The purpose of the policies relating to health and social care is to provide a
standardization to the care sectors for their daily operations. It helps in giving clarity to the care
sector in dealing with the issues and the activities that are very critical relating to the health and
safety (Lustgarten and Elhai, 2018). It works as guidelines in order to make the effective
decisions and sets a general plan to come with a desired outcome. For instance the UK Policy
Framework for the Health and Social care Research states the principles which promote and
protect the interest of the service users, patients and the public in the health and social care
research. It describe the ethical conduct in order to conduct the research relating to the
confidence of the patients and service users. Another policy of NHS includes the policy of
health and safety in the workplace. NHS Code of Practice 2003 is the policy which works to
ensure that confidentiality is maintained in the health and care sector (Andanda, 2020). The
Public Guardian Safeguarding Policy of 2013 stated that abuse is the violation of human and
civil rights of the individual so it gave protection to the people from any kind of abuse.
Laws normally tell you to to do the activity or the task in such a manner that it is not
illegal. Basically these are rules and regulation which bound the person to follow them whereas
the policies gives the framework as to how to follow them. These are guidelines or work as

roadmap to follow the rules and regulations. They both are inter linked with each other and work
hand in hand for the betterment of the society.
The policies and laws share a mutual relationship. The policies are important to ensure
the compliance of laws and deliver the safe health care to the person needed. The local, state and
the central government carry the regulations so that general public is protected from the severe
health hazards. On one hand the laws are the reference to the overall agencies of the rules and
regulations by which the organisations are obligated to comply with and the policies work as
rules and regulations which are intended for a specific objective. They both work hand in hand
and policies ensure compliance of laws to prevent any legal consequences.
P4 Compare national and organisational policies against the national professional standards in
terms of their impact on health and social care practice.
Professional standards may be described as the level of competent care which the service
providers of health and social care practice are bound to give in each phase of the nursing
process. It reflects the level of performance which is to be achieved in order to maintain the
clinically competent and safe practice of nursing. These act as guidance for the clinical practice.
The practitioners of the health and social care sectors are bound to maintain these standards so
that safe practices are used in the organisation. The organisational policies and national policies
work as guidance for the health and social care sector to build their professional standards so
that they can comply with the national and organisational policies.
Organisational policies must be designed in order comply with the legislations and
regulations which are enacted by the government. These are made to implement the national
policies which are also sometimes monitored by the Care Quality Commission(CQC) which is a
regulatory body for health and social care.
Strict compliance with the national policies allows the health and social care sector to
come up with the organisational policies which helps in making compliance with the national
policies (Barsky, 2017). These work as standards for the service which are provided by these
sector in order to build a prominent health care organisation. The professional standards helps in
complying with the organisational policies so that ethical code of conduct is followed by all the
practitioners and they work ethically and legally. The compliance with national policies helps the
practitioners of these health and social care sector to eliminate the chances of legal
consequences which may arise in case of non compliance.

The government had made the professional standards in order regulate the working of the
health and social care sector. It ensures that the organisations develop the safe practices of
treatment, delegate task tot he licensed personnel so that legally the working of the organisation
is taken place. In case any professional standard is violated, the healthcare organisation may be
subject to the liability or loss of licence. For instance if a practitioner or nurse discloses
confidential details of the patient it may lead to violation of Health Insurance Portability and
Accountability Act which is same as violating the professional standard. It makes the healthcare
organisation accountable for their decisions and actions in order to ensure strict compliance with
laws and policies.
Policies are guidelines to the implementation of law and professional standards sets the
minimum benchmark for the individuals to implement the policies in such a way that they are
according to the professional standards. These are rules which help in achieving the policies.
The dissimilarity lies between policies and professional standard is that the former is
mandatory to be followed and the later is not as these are voluntary. These can be made
mandatory if implemented in the organisational policies.
M2 Reflect on ways in which specific tasks in the health, care or support service practice meet
national professional standards within a legal framework.
In order to comply with the national professional standards, the health and social care
practice makes the organisational policies so that it can also comply with national policies. These
work as guidelines for the practitioners to which they are bound to follow. For instance, in order
to comply with the care Act, the practitioners will frame their organisational policies which will
fulfil the requirement of professional standard so that it can carry on its activities and task in a
legal and effective manner.
For instance, when a doctor takes the blood pressure of a patient, it is mandatory for him
to do its task in an proper manner. While I was working in the hospital, i was checking the blood
pressure of a patient. Here the professional standard is that the doctor must allow the patient to
take rest for at least 15 minutes in order to take Blood pressure so that accurate result is taken
from it. So I allowed the rest to the patient before checking it.

D1 Evaluate the relationship between ethics and law and their impact on organisational policy
and practice towards protecting the rights and maintaining the well being of users of
health, care or support service.
The ethics are the morals which the organisation are bound to follow in order to run their
activities according to the norms of the people. On the other hand, laws are the legal requirement
which are made keeping in mind the ethics so that people follow them. The health or care sector
makes organisational policies within their practice in order to comply with the legal and ethical
requirement so that they do not face any legal consequences (Wolff and et. al., 2020). These laws
and ethics are framed keeping in mind the rights of the well being users so that their human and
civil rights are protected. The legislation like equality Act or Care Act ensures that there is
protection of the human rights of the care users so that they can avail the health services in an
effective manner. So these laws and ethics are kept in mind while framing the organisational
policies so that rights of the users are protected.
PART 2
TASK 3
P5 Explain how specific national and international law influence and inform the equitable and
fair treatment of others in health, care and support service.
Equal and fair treatment to all the people is their fundamental and human right. The
Equality Act of 2010 clearly states that there must not be any kind of discrimination in the
workplace and fair and equal treatment must be given to all. Apart from this legislation, the
Human Rights Act of 1998 also makes the discrimination illegal on many grounds which
includes colour, sex, race, language and etc. In context to international law, the European
Convention on Human Rights, 1950 provides various human rights to which every individual is
subjected to and the national law implementers like judiciary and legislators are bound to make
its compliance in the country (McGuinness and Montgomery, 2020). Under Article 14 of the said
convention, it states the prohibition of discrimination and provides that every person are given
human rights to which they can enjoy without any discrimination. These laws influence the
working of the health or care sector so that no patient or staff face any kind of discrimination
while availing service or working for the organisation. As UK is signatory to Council of Europe,
it has to ensure strict adherence of the ECHR into its state. So Human Rights Act of 1998 was

enacted to show its compliance and made every person, company or association bound to follow
it.
For instance, while working in the London Hospital in the administration department, I
was able to closely monitor the working of the authorities. While admitting any patient to their
organisation, the management did not consider any of their details initially but start the treatment
immediately. They have the organisational policy that every person irrespective of their race,
colour, gender, etc. shall be given treatment in the hospital first and then ask for the details. This
standard assured the compliance of the legislations and policies (Collingridge and et. al., 2020).
This made me realise that equality in the workplace is very essential to comply with. The doctors
and practitioners makes its sure that ethical code of conduct is substantially reviewed after every
few months in order to make sure that they comply with all national and international
requirement in terms of laws and policies. The staff of the hospital faces problems and
challenges in complying with all the regulations but they all make sure that it is being followed
strictly in the hospital. The authorities of the London hospital ensure that they follow every
legislation, standard and policy in order eliminate the risk of any legal consequences which may
harm the goodwill of the organisation. Apart from the national rules and regulations, the hospital
must make sure that it has taken care of the human rights of the patient as these are their basic
rights and as UK is signatory to ECHR, they must comply with this at domestic level.
P6 Implement different and relevant legislation and policy in regard to safe and healthy conduct
in own practice
Safeguarding is very important for the groups which includes children,young person and
the vulnerable adults in order to protect them from abuse, harm or neglect. This is because they
have less ability to keep themselves safe. In relation to health and care sector, safeguarding is the
legal obligation for all the organisations, be it private or public (Dhai and Mahomed, 2020).
There are four major laws relating to this which includes The Children Act of 1989 which is
aimed to make sure the welfare of the children by making it a priority. Another is The Children
and Social Work Act of 2017 is designed ton the principles of Children Act which gives more
responsibility to clinical commissioning groups and protect the whistle blowers. It ensures that
child safeguarding is being followed or not in the organisation. The Care Act of 2014 safeguard
to adults who are vulnerable from abuse, harm or neglect. Another piece of legislation is

Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups Act, 2006 which is designed with same aim and provides a
provision of safe recruitment.
In order to ensure the safe and healthy environment and conduct, it is essential to have a
relevant policy and legislation. There are various policies enacted by the government of UK to
ensure that healthy and safe conduct is present. The following is the safeguarding policies which
includes Safeguarding of Vulnerable Adults which was designed to stop the neglect or abuse in
the health and care sector and also provides the ways in which it can be stopped and how concern
can be raised about the well being and safety of the adult. Another policy is Safeguarding
children and young people, 2014 which gives framework to this sector to ensure that measures
are taken in order to eliminate the risk of harming the children (Rissman and Paquette, 2020). It
sets the roles and responsibilities of the person working for the organisation to ensure that
children and young person are safe while availing service.
The examples for safeguarding are care home for adults and children's ward in the
hospitals. It is aimed to provide good healthcare to young patient and makes staff responsible for
their care. For instance, while I was working in London Hospital, a case came where a child was
severely injured and parents claim that it was a mere accident due to which these injuries were
inflicted. But after detailed study, the doctors came to know that it was intentionally inflicted.
This was a major safeguarding issue (Buka, Davis and Pereira, 2016). The practitioners in the
hospital took strict action against it and inform the concerned authority regarding the same. Strict
action were taken against the parents in order to ensure further safeguarding of the children. Here
the compliance with the Care act, 2014 is necessary and the policy of safeguarding the children
and young people, safeguarding the vulnerable adults policy and other legislations shall also be
taken care of so that healthy environment is given to them.
M3 Analyse recent health and social care legislation or national policies in relation to their
importance in informing the rights and responsibilities of health, care or support service
practitioners to provide safe and equitable care.
The practitioners of health and care sector have various rights and responsibilities to
which they are bound to follow. These are incorporated in various laws and policies enacted by
the government of UK and the NHS which includes Equality Act of 2010 which states right to
equality to all, Human Rights Act of 1998 which states various human rights to all, UN
Convention on rights of a child, 1989 provides rights to the children and protect them from abuse

or harm. It imposes responsibilities on the practitioners to safeguard their rights. The Care Act of
2014 imposes duty on practitioners to take care of the well being of the vulnerable adults.
TASK 4
P7 Describe the relationship between law, policy and ethical requirements in relation to real case
scenario in a health or care setting.
Laws are the legal requirements which sets the rules and regulations for regulating the
working and functioning of people and companies. Every workplace is required to comply with
the legal requirements in order to eliminate the risk of legal consequences (Campbell and Arkles,
2017). The polices work as guidelines to carry on the activities in a legal manner. The ethics are
the morals which are set by the people which tells what is right and wrong. The laws and policies
are farmed keeping in mind the ethics.
In the case scenario, the Wharlton Hall is an independent hospital for the people with
autism or learning disabilities who are 18 years old or above. Apart from this, the hospital also
engages people who have additional mental and physical challenges in health or behaviour. Till
2017 it got good ratings by the inspected body of CQC. In 2019 BBC panorama run a
documentary which showed how hospital authorities abused and harmed the patients and
provided poor treatment to them. The hospital also failed to care the vulnerable adults.
Under this case scenario, the hospital management failed to comply with legislation. For
instance they failed to comply with the Mental Health Act of 1983 which imposes duty on
health and care sector to provide adequate care to the patient and protect their rights who are
suffering from the mental health disorder. Instead of giving them proper treatment, the care
workers abused them and threatened them for violence. It also violated the safeguarding
vulnerable groups Act which imposes duty on care workers to safeguard the vulnerable adults
(Ye-long, 2019).
The hospital also failed to comply with the ethical requirements which involves to treat
the patients fairly and provide adequate service and treatment to all. The laws are extended
version of the ethics which are to be complied. The policies act as guidelines for carrying the
activities of the health and care sector. The policies which were violated by the hospital includes
Safeguarding vulnerable adults policy, which provides to give safe environment and treatment

to the vulnerable section of the society, mainly adults. The hospital did not have the right code of
ethics which resulted in such devastated treatment to the vulnerable adult. The organisational
policies were such weak that the hospital did not bothered to have strict code of ethics in its
compliance. This shows that there is no compliance of law, policy and ethics in the hospital.
The relationship between these legislations, ethics and policies is that they all are inter
related to each other as they have the common purpose of protecting the people and giving them
fair and safe treatment in the health and care sector. The legislations and policies are made with
an intention to give enforcement to ethics (Wallerstein and et. al., 2017). These laws, policies
and ethics are to be followed in the hospital so that there is safe, fair and equal treatment to all.
So it can be said that the relation between ethics, policies and laws is such that they all
are formed to protect the people and make the wrongdoer accountable for the illegal act. For
instance, the compliance with the Mental health act is necessary in order to make sure that
vulnerable people are given safe environment and if they are not given, the wrongdoer must be
punished.
P8 Explain the impact of relevant law and policy on the outcome of real case scenario.
In the case of Wharlton hall, the care workers abused, violated and threatened the
vulnerable adults when they were undertaking the treatment. This was published by BBC
panorama where a documentary gave evidence of this abuse. The Equality and Human Rights
Commissions launched a legal challenge against the UK Department of Health and Social Care
and accused them of violating the provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights. As
a result to this, the UK department immediately took action against the care workers who were
liable for abusing the vulnerable adults. They were detained under the Mental Health Act and the
Safeguarding the Vulnerable Adults Act.
The culture of the hospital was toxic as it allowed the staff to abuse the vulnerable people
and still no action were taken by the management. They continuously avoided such incidents.
After reviewing the whole case, the impact of the Mental Health Act and safeguarding the
Vulnerable Adults forced to close down the hospital as it has not complied with any of the
legislation, policy or ethics (Morley and et., al., 2020). The official body (Care Quality
Commission CQC) which is entrusted with a role to monitor the quality failed to highlight the
matter. During its inspection, the CQC founded that the hospital has breached the regulations but
still remained quite. This shows that the Care Act was also violated.

The outcome was that all the patients were shifted to other services and the hospital was
shut down. The mistreatment to patients forced the official authorities to take this step as they
not only violated the laws and policies but also infringed the human rights of the people which is
above every law and policy. Other outcome includes that there was lack of compliance with the
laws which led to abuse and harm to the patient. This was violation of mental Health Act were
the duty is imposed on the workers to take care of the patient and provide them proper treatment.
The hospital authorities were negligent in taking adequate care to treat the patients fairly and
properly. Further the hospital was also shut down as there was no compliance with laws and
policies like Care act, health and safety Act and many other. and the patients were not
safeguarded. This was under the Act of Safeguarding the Vulnerable Groups Act.
M4 Explain in detail how chosen law, policy and ethical considerations might result in difference
outcomes to the case scenario.
Under this case, if the hospital worked to complied with the laws and policies, the
hospital could have been saved from shutting down. Under the legislation of mental Health Act,
the hospital could have worked to protect the rights of the mental health survivors and took
immediate action against the wrongdoer. Under the policy of Safeguarding the vulnerable adults,
the hospital could have ensured safe environment and treat to the patient, failure to do so has
resulted in such outcome which could have been different if the management of the hospital and
the CQC and other local authorities have reported this incidents earlier. The hospital failed to
work according to the ethics and were negligent in protecting the patients. This ethical wrong
resulted in shutting down the hospital.
D2 Critically review ways in which health, care and support service practitioners can ensure
currency and compliance with relevant legislation and national policies through ethical
practice in relation to real case scenario.
In order to comply with the relevant national policies and legislations, the practitioners of
the health or care sector must ensure that they have proper code of ethics in their organisation so
that they can comply with the laws and policies (Conn, 2018). The ethics must be such that it
must en root the professional standards in it according to the legislation and policies so that it
can comply with the legislations and the policies. In context to the case scenario of Wharlton
Hospital, the management of the hospital must have strict organisational policies and code of

ethics so that it can comply with the laws. The staff and care workers must be made bound to
follow such ethical standards which gave strict compliance to the policies and law.

CONCLUSION
It is concluded from the above report that laws and policies set the guidelines for the
people and organisations in order to carry on their activities. In context to health and social care
sector, the organisational policies must be such that it must comply with the legislations and
policies. In order to give effective to the national policies and laws, the health or care sector must
en root in their ethical code of conduct and organisational policies, the provisions of them.
Further it is concluded that the case of Wharlton hospital have impacted the compliance of
legislations and policies. The management of the hospital could have taken the action earlier by
bringing strict laws, policies and ethics into their system. If the hospital have followed the
relevant laws and policies the outcome could have been different and it may not have resulted in
the shutting down of the hospital.

REFERENCES
Books and Journals
Andanda, P., 2020. Ethical and legal governance of health-related research that use digital data
from user-generated online health content. Information, Communication &
Society. 23(8). pp.1154-1169.
Barsky, A.E., 2017. Social work practice and technology: Ethical issues and policy
responses. Journal of Technology in Human Services. 35(1). pp.8-19.
Berkowitz, I. and Garrett, J.R., 2020. Legal and ethical considerations for requiring consent for
apnea testing in brain death determination. The American Journal of Bioethics. 20(6).
pp.4-16.
Buka, P., Davis, M. and Pereira, M., 2016. Care of Vulnerable Older People: Legal and Ethical
Aspects of Nursing. Macmillan International Higher Education.
Campbell, L.F. and Arkles, G., 2017. Ethical and legal concerns for mental health professionals.
Collingridge and et. al., 2020. Ethical Practice in Social Work: An applied approach. Routledge.
Conn, N., 2018. The Ethics of Care and Control Dilemmas in Mental Health. Ethics and social
welfare. 12(2). pp.188-196.
Dawson, A., 2020. Ethical practice in public health: developing the workforce for the
future. Journal of Public Health.
Dhai, A. and Mahomed, S., 2020. Ethical, Legal, and Social Issues. In HIV Infection in Children
and Adolescents (pp. 309-322). Springer, Cham.
Kaplan, B., 2020. Revisting Health Information Technology Ethical, Legal, and Social Issues
and Evaluation: Telehealth/Telemedicine and COVID-19. International journal of
medical informatics, p.104239.
Lukas and et. al., 2020. An Ethics-based Approach to Global Health Research Part 2: Strategies
for Overcoming Logistic and Implementation Challenges. Research in Social and
Administrative Pharmacy. 16(11). pp.1580-1587.
Lustgarten, S.D. and Elhai, J.D., 2018. Technology use in mental health practice and research:
Legal and ethical risks. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice. 25(2). p.e12234.
Matthews, R., 2019. Health ethics and Indigenous ethnocide. Bioethics. 303(7). pp.827-834.
McGuinness, S. and Montgomery, J., 2020. Legal determinants of health: Regulating abortion
care. Public Health Ethics. 13(1). pp.34-40.
Morley and et., al., 2020. The ethics of AI in health care: A mapping review. Social Science &
Medicine, p.113172.
Morley, C., Le, C. and Briskman, L., 2020. The role of critical social work education in
improving ethical practice with refugees and asylum seekers. Social Work
Education. 39(4). pp.403-416.
Rissman, L. and Paquette, E.T., 2020. Ethical and legal considerations related to disorders of
consciousness. Current opinion in pediatrics. 32(6). pp.765-771.
Scott, R.E., Morris, C. and Mars, M., 2020. Development of a “Cellphone Stewardship
Framework”: Legal, Regulatory, and Ethical Issues. Telemedicine and e-Health.
Wallerstein and et. al., 2017. Community-based participatory research for health: Advancing
social and health equity. John Wiley & Sons.
Watson, K. and Payne, D.M., 2020. Ethical practice in sharing and mining medical data. Journal
of Information, Communication and Ethics in Society.

Wolff and et. al., 2020. Protecting sexual and gender minorities in academic institutions with
disallowing policies: Psychological, ethical, and accreditation concerns. Training and
Education in Professional Psychology. 14(3). p.249.
Ye-long, S.U.N., 2019. Causes, Ethical Problems and Coping Strategies of Medical
Futility. Studies in Philosophy of Science and Technology. (5). p.20.