Comparative Analysis of Handel and Bach's Musical Pieces

The assignment compares the first performances and characteristics of J.S. Bach's Cantata No. 140 Wachet Auf and G.F. Handel's Messiah, two famous pieces of music. Both were performed for the first time in the 18th century, with Messiah being revised by Mozart. The comparison highlights similarities such as the use of SATB choir and solo, violins, viola, oboes, and continuo, while also noting differences like the number of movements (53 in Messiah vs. 7 in Wachet Auf) and the types of instruments used.

Running head: Listening journal
[Document title]
[Document subtitle]
[DATE]
[Company name]
[Company address]

Listening journal 1
G.F Handel messiah was first performed musick Hall in Dublin on 1742. The superstar status of
Handel was made a glimpse in the industry, and after hearing the music the men and women feel
mesmerized. On the other hand, Bach cantata caught attention in the golden Leipzig period by its
melodies and hymn tune composition.
After listening J. S. Bach's Cantata No. 140 Wachet Auf and G. F. Handel's Messiah, I noticed
that there persist a similarity in the context of their first performance. Messiah was first
performed on April 13, 1972, and Canada NO.140 Wachet Auf gave his first performance on 25
November 1731.
The differences are very few in both the pieces. Firstly in the piece of Messiah there aware 53
movements which are divided into three parts and in Bach Canata, there are only seven
movements. (Shrock,,2017).they both used a SATB choir and solo, but in the Bach pieces they
used soprao, bass, and tenor. Secondly, they both use violins, viola, oboes, and continuo.
They differ with the instruments in the way in Messiah, they tried to use timpani and trumpets,
and in Bach piece of music, he uses taile, horn and violin piccolo.In the last, the thing I found
interesting about Messiah that it was a revised and amplified by Mozart and the piece written by
Bach was made for the Sunday 27 that was after Trinity.
References:
Shrock, D. (2017). Choral Monuments: Studies of Eleven Choral Masterworks. Oxford University Press.