(Doc) Assignment - Taxation Law

Page1
Assignment-Taxation Law

Page2
Table of Contents
Facts: Part A................................................................................................................................................2
Question 1...............................................................................................................................................3
A. Advise RIP Pty Ltd when income is derived (i) generally, and (ii) when it derives its income from
funeral services and related activities......................................................................................................3
 Does the Arthur Murray principle apply to the company’s accounting treatment of amounts in
Easy Funeral Plan? Explain.................................................................................................................5
 Does the Commissioner or any taxpayer have a choice in the method of accounting for tax?.....6
B. Advise the company of the tax treatment of $16,200 in ‘Forfeited Payments Account’ in item (iv).
7
Facts: Part B................................................................................................................................................8
Question 2...................................................................................................................................................9
Advise the company about the following:...............................................................................................9
 The nature of trading stock, generally, whether the caskets and accessories would be trading stock
for tax purposes and how the amount of $25,000 is treated for tax purposes...........................................9
 What adjustments (if any) should be made to the company’s reported profit for tax purposes in
regard to items (b), (c) and (d).................................................................................................................9
 What deductions (if any) are available for expenditure set out in item (e). Explain.......................10
References.................................................................................................................................................11
Facts: Part A
RIP Pty Ltd is a resident private company carrying on the business of undertaker/funeral
director. It operates out of premises comprising office facilities, a chapel and assembly area and
professional rooms. Its other assets include a fleet of motor vehicles. For the year ended 30 June
2016 the company reported a net profit of $2.45m. Its income arises from the provision of
funeral services financed as follows:

Page3
 Fees payable under a ‘net, 30 days’ invoice.
 Fees payable under several external insurance contracts to which bills are issued under a
‘net, 30 days’ arrangement. For instance, some funeral costs are paid by the Transport
Accident Commission, others are paid out of private life assurance plans.
 Fees received from RIP Finance Pty Ltd, a company providing credit under an
installment repayment plan.
 Amounts paid under a funeral plan in which clients make periodic contributions to meet
future funeral costs. ‘Easy Funeral Plan’ is a fixed price contract. When the agreed
amount is paid, the client is guaranteed a ‘deluxe funeral arrangement’. If the contract
price in not fully paid at date of death, the deceased’s estate is billed under (i) or (iii),
above. The amount is not refundable or transferable. At 30 June the credit balance Easy
Funeral Plan is $225,000. From time-to-time amounts paid pursuant to the Easy Funeral
Plan are not drawn upon. The clients might die abroad or remains not be recovered and
no funeral service is provided. No refund issues arise.
 At 30 June, the company transfers from Easy Funeral Plan amounts estimated to have
arisen in connection with defaulting members (ie, members who have ceased making
scheduled payments and who are not expected to make up arrears). These are credited to
a ‘Forfeited Payments Account’ that has a balance at 30 June of $16,200.
Question 1
A. Advise RIP Pty Ltd when income is derived (i) generally, and (ii) when it
derives its income from funeral services and related activities.
According to Section 25(1) of the Income Tax Assessment Act, 1936-1965
(Commonwealth), "the assessable income of a taxpayer include the gross income derived
directly or indirectly from all sources, in the case of a taxpayer resident in Australia, or
from all sources in Australia in the case of a non-resident taxpayer".
Here the meaning of the words "income derived" had been considered by the High Court
of Australia in Arthur Murray (N.S.W.) Pty. Limited v. Commissioner of Taxation of the
Commonwealth.

Page4
In the aforesaid case, the RIP Pty Limited to is engaged in providing funeral services. It
has various plans for its services. The company has provided the provisions that it can
receive its payment of fees in full or in installments. Here, the company has received its
fees in terms of installments. The company has not yet received any full consideration
amount till now. Thus, on the basis of the definition provided by the Income Tax
Assessment Act, the assessable income of a taxpayer include the gross income of the
organization.
This case can be better understandable with the case law of the Arthur Murray (NSW)
Pty Ltd v FCT (1965) 114 CLR 314. According to the Arthur Murray (NSW) Pty Ltd v
FCT (1965) 114 CLR 314 case, Arthur Murray (N.S.W) Pty limited holds a license from
a company based in United States. The company was engaged in providing dancing
lessons in Sydney and Melbourne. Some of the students entered into a contract to take
dancing lessons from the aforesaid company. The classes offered by the company were
generally of five, ten and fifteen hour in a period of one year. Accordingly, payments
were made by the students and contract was signed. The contract mentioned that it can
occasionally provide about 1200 dancing classes. Most of the payments were made in fill
or by deposit of substantial amount followed by the installments paid during the course of
the lessons provided.
The provisions of the contract states that it is not divisible and the student have the
responsibility to pay the full tuition fees set forth. No refunds and No cancellation of the
contract.
The main issue of this case was if the taxpayer received the pre paid fees in the year in
which the dancing classes were provided or the year in which the fees were meant to be
received.
The court in the aforesaid case held that no income had been derived until the services
rendered.
This case law can be applied in the aforesaid case i.e. the case RIP Pty Limited is as well.
Here, the company has been receiving money from its clients in terms of full payment or
in installments under various plans. The company has not yet provided any services to its
clients. According to the nature of the business, the client or one of its family members

Page5
must die to avail the services of the company. The funeral ceremony can took place only
if a person dies.
Here, the death of the person is the deciding the factor for aviation of the services of the
company. The client is paying for the services which he will get in future. Here, the fees
made by the client will be considered as prepaid fees which are being deposited in the
company's account. Here, income of the company is not derived yet according to the
judgment provide by the court for the case of Arthur Murray (NSW) Pty Ltd v FCT
(1965) 114 CLR 314. The judgment of the case suggests that the income will be
considered as generated income only if the services provided to the client for which
income was generated.
In this case also the income is not generated income. The income will be generate if the
client or any of its family members died.
 Does the Arthur Murray principle apply to the company’s accounting treatment of amounts
in Easy Funeral Plan? Explain.
According to the Arthur Murray (NSW) Pty Ltd v FCT (1965) 114 CLR 314 case, Arthur
Murray (N.S.W) Pty limited holds a license from a company based in United States. The
company was engaged in providing dancing lessons in Sydney and Melbourne. Some of
the students entered into a contract to take dancing lessons from the aforesaid company.
The classes offered by the company were generally of five, ten and fifteen hour in a
period of one year. Accordingly, payments were made by the students and contract was
signed. The contract mentioned that it can occasionally provide about 1200 dancing
classes. Most of the payments were made in fill or by deposit of substantial amount
followed by the installments paid during the course of the lessons provided.
The provisions of the contract states that it is not divisible and the student have the
responsibility to pay the full tuition fees set forth. No refunds and No cancellation of the
contract.
The main issue of this case was if the taxpayer received the pre paid fees in the year in
which the dancing classes were provided or the year in which the fees were meant to be
received.

Page6
The court in the aforesaid case held that no income had been derived until the services
rendered. The court also discovered that the gains and profits of the company have not
only derived from the taxpayer which can be called as come home receivables. The
court was also of the opinion that if the sum received will be considered as gain or there
is legal obligation to the same.
The court then focused on the qualification regarding the concept of income derived.
Here, even if the fees were paid in advance there is no legal implication in the way of the
recipient of the dealing.
According to the rules and guidelines of the accountancy and commercial practices, the
amount received in advance of the goods or services which are not yet provided by the
seller or service provider, it will not be considered as the as revenue and will not be
entered in the revenue account until the services are not provided to customer.
The prepaid fees received by the clients will be credited to a account named suspense
account and the income account of the business took place only after the services are
provided to the clients. After the aforesaid process only the income generated will get the
recognition of the character of income.
In the aforesaid judgment also applicable in the case of RIP Pty Limited is as well. Here,
the company has been receiving money from its clients in terms of full payment or in
installments under various plans. The company has not yet provided any services to its
clients. According to the nature of the business, the client or one of its family members
must die to avail the services of the company. The funeral ceremony can took place only
if a person dies.
Analysis of the easy funeral plan suggests also it is a suspense account created for the
reservation of the pre paid amount received by the client. According to the rules and
guidelines of the accountancy and commercial practices, the amount received in advance
of the goods or services which are not yet provided by the seller or service provider.
Here, the amount received will not be considered as a derived income and revenue and it
cannot be entered in to the books of accounts of the company.
 Does the Commissioner or any taxpayer have a choice in the method of accounting
for tax?

Page7
In case of Arthur Murray (NSW) Pty Ltd v FCT (1965) 114 CLR 314t, the taxpayer adopted the
method of accounting which is popularly known as the Accrual or Earrings Method. According
to the aforesaid method all the payments received will be considered as advance payment and the
same will be credited to an account named general Reserve instead of credited to the account
named unearned deposits and untaught lessons account.
Each of the lessons given by the instructor must be recorded in record sheets which will act as a
registration of the student of the company. The record must contain the details of the sum
received at the end of the particular month and same will also be seen in instructor's sheet also
transferred to an account named the earned tuition account. Thus, according to the aforesaid
reason the money transferred will not be treated as assessable income until it is actually earned.
The members of the court Barwick, C.J., Kittto and Taylor, JJ. provided the said lessons under
this case. They added that at the end of the year, the income which are unearned and will be
carry forward to the following year.
The same principle can also be applied by RIP Pty Limited. The company is transferring the
advance payment of fees to forfeited account instead of transferring to general reserve or
suspense account. This provision for the settlement oif account should be made for the smooth
and authentic record keeping of the data.
B. Advise the company of the tax treatment of $16,200 in ‘Forfeited Payments
Account’ in item (iv).
From the above explanation and discussion it cane be concluded that the payments
received by the company cannot be considered as a revenue or income for the company.
According to the rules and guidelines of the accountancy and commercial practices, the
amount received in advance of the goods or services which are not yet provided by the
seller or service provider, it will not be considered as the as revenue and will not be
entered in the revenue account until the services are not provided to customer. The
prepaid fees received by the clients will be credited to a account named suspense account
and the income account of the business took place only after the services are provided to

Page8
the clients. After the aforesaid process only the income generated will get the recognition
of the character of income.
Here, the forfeited account will be considered as suspense account for the implication of
tax.
Facts: Part B
a) RIP Pty Ltd holds a stock of three types of caskets as well as a range of accessories (such as
religious and secular icons). In June 2016 the company prepaid $25,000 for material to be
delivered in August 2016. The company obtained considerable discounts for the advance
purchase.
b) A fully franked cash dividend of $21,000 was received from RIP Finance Pty Ltd.
c) An amount of $57,000 was paid on 1 March 2016 for two year's rental of storage space. The
lease expires on 28 February 2018. In the company’s financial accounts an amount of $9,500
was expensed and $47,500 capitalised.
d) On 1 June 2016 the managing director of RIP commenced three months long service leave and
was paid $22,000 in advance. In the company’s accounts the amount was debited against a
Provision for Long Service Leave Account.
e) In 2013 the company’s Board of Directors decided existing accommodation was inadequate
and it resolved to construct a purpose built facility. In that year $250,000 was paid for
preliminary architectural designs. In 2014 land costing $1.25m was acquired and $50,000 paid to
demolish an existing structure. Construction of the new premises commenced on 1 September
2014 at a cost of $2.5m. Fitting and equipment was installed on 1 June 2015; operations began
on 1 August 2015. On-site car parking costing $125,000 was completed on 30 September and
landscaping of the site was completed on 31 January 2016 at a cost of $40,000.

Page9
Question 2
Advise the company about the following:
 The nature of trading stock, generally, whether the caskets and accessories
would be trading stock for tax purposes and how the amount of $25,000 is
treated for tax purposes.
According to the provisions of the Australian Taxation Office, an income to be considered as an
business income must be generated through the business operation which are directly related to
the day to day operation of the business. Then only it will be considered as business income and
will be assessed to tax. Here, the income generated is a prepaid income for which services are
not provided yet.
According to the rules and guidelines of the accountancy and commercial practices, the amount
received in advance of the goods or services which are not yet provided by the seller or service
provider, it will not be considered as the revenue and will not be entered in the revenue account
until the services are not provided to customer. As it is a prepaid amount it will not be considered
for tax purposes.
 What adjustments (if any) should be made to the company’s reported profit
for tax purposes in regard to items (b), (c) and (d).
The options b, c and d provides the details of the capitalization of the profits of the company. The
company has received a cash dividend of $21,000 was received from RIP Finance Pty Ltd and
received an amount $57,000 for rental storage space. However, expenses are also incurred for
$9,500 and $22,000.
According to the provisions of the Australian Taxation Office, the adjustments of the incomes of
the company will be made only if it is generated from business and not from any other source. It
should be of direct source of business. Here, the first two incomes are considered as business
income as it is related to the business i.e. dividend received and rent received which was given
for business purposes. Providing the long leave service account to the employee is not
considered as a business income.

Page10
 What deductions (if any) are available for expenditure set out in item (e).
Explain.
According to the provisions provided by the Australian Taxation office, a tax deduction can
reduce the burden of payment of tax. The tax deduction can reduce or decrease the amount of
taxable income. One can claim for the tax deduction if most of the expenses incurred are directly
or indirectly related to the business. Rebates, concession, offset can also reduce the tax reduction.
As per the provisions provided by the Australian Taxation office one can claim for the deduction
for expenses of business if it is incurred in relation to the day to day running of the business. This
will be considered as the assessable income. The following are the conditions which must be
followed to identify the deductible expenditure:
The money spent must be related to the business
If the money spent is a mix of business and personal use, the company can claim only the portion
related to the business use
The expenditure spent for business purposes must have a record
In the aforesaid case, the business incurred the following expenses;
Preliminary architectural designs $250,000
Land costing $1.25m
Demolish an existing structure $50,000
Construction of the new premises cost $2.5m.
On-site car parking cost $125,000
Landscaping of the site cost $40,000.

Page11
The aforesaid expenses are related to the smooth running and improvement of the business. The
aforesaid expenses are not incurred for private use. Thus, the company can claim deductions for
the aforesaid amounts.
References
(n.d.).
Arthur murray nsw pty ltd v fct 1965 114 clr 314 the. (n.d.). Retrieved from
ttps://www.coursehero.com/: ttps://www.coursehero.com/file/p6ddtac/Arthur-Murray-NSW-Pty-
Ltd-v-FCT-1965-114-CLR-314-The-taxpayer-was-a-dance/
Arthur Murray(Ns) Pty Ltd V Fct (1965) 114 Clr 314. (2012, October 26). Retrieved from
https://www.bartleby.com: https://www.bartleby.com/essay/Arthur-MurrayNs-Pty-Ltd-V-Fct-
1965-P33LLNLK6YYS
deductions, o. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.ato.gov.au/:
https://www.ato.gov.au/individuals/income-and-deductions/deductions-you-can-claim/other-
deductions/
Office, A. T. (n.d.). Amounts not to be included as income. Retrieved from
https://www.ato.gov.au/: https://www.ato.gov.au/Individuals/Income-and-deductions/Income-
you-must-declare/Amounts-not-included-as-income/
Office, A. T. (n.d.). Deductions you can claim. Retrieved from https://www.ato.gov.au/:
https://www.ato.gov.au/Individuals/Income-and-deductions/Deductions-you-can-claim/
Prepaid Income – Arthur Murray Case. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.stptax.com/:
http://www.stptax.com/tax-tips/prepaid-income-arthur-murray-case/
Review, S. L. (n.d.). WHEN IS INCOME DERIVED? ARTHUR MURRAY (N.S.W.) PTY.
LIMITED v. COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH .

Page12
Studymode. (2012, October 24). Arthur Murray(Ns) Pty Ltd V Fct (1965) 114 Clr 314. Retrieved
from http://www.studymode.com/: http://www.studymode.com/essays/Arthur-Murray-Ns-Pty-
Ltd-v-Fct-1141814.html