Risk Assessment of BBC's Digital Media Initiative Implementation
Verified
Added on 2023/01/17
|22
|5149
|1
AI Summary
This report evaluates the risk factors associated with the implementation of BBC's Digital Media Initiative and provides recommendations for risk management. It analyzes the causes of failure and the impact on the organization.
Contribute Materials
Your contribution can guide someone’s learning journey. Share your
documents today.
PROJECT RISK MANAGEMENT
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
Abstract BBC was involved in a major digital media initiative fiasco and in this report the IT system of the company was evaluated along with giving appropriate analysis. The aim of the DMI Implementation will be evaluated and the factors that led to the failure of the implementation will be analysed. The risk factors will also be determined and appropriate monitoring and evaluation techniques that could have be used will be ascertained. A project risk management plan will be developed accordingly.
Table of Contents Abstract............................................................................................................................................2 INTRODUCTION...........................................................................................................................4 Aims and Goals............................................................................................................................4 Retrospective Research................................................................................................................5 Risk Management Methodology Adopted...................................................................................6 Internal and External Context......................................................................................................7 Risk Assessment..........................................................................................................................8 Risk Analysis..............................................................................................................................8 Stakeholder Register..................................................................................................................10 Monitoring techniques Applied on Project................................................................................12 Risk Treatment Schedule and Plan............................................................................................14 Risk Action Plan........................................................................................................................16 Discussions and Recommendations...........................................................................................18 CONCLUSION..............................................................................................................................19 REFERENCES................................................................................................................................1
INTRODUCTION BBC i.e. British Broadcasting Corporation is a major public service broadcaster and is one of the oldest broadcasting organization as well (Hearn, Swan and Geels, 2019). In the year 2008, BBC decided to launch a digital media initiative under which the production process was intended to be modernised and a connected production medium through digitalization was intended to be implemented. Ashley Highfield, director of BBC decided to implement the scheme of DMI and approved the funding of£81 million. The project was outsourced to another technology service provider Siemens and it was expected that the cost would be reduced by £18 million (Digital Media Initiative,2019). However, the contract became too expensive because the cost was rising and the number of technical problems were also continuously increasing (BBC's Digital Media Initiative failed because of more than poor oversight,2015). This caused BBC huge losses and when a new DMI plan was formulated, it was again rejected by the BBC finance committee and it was furhter critcised by the National Audit Office. This made BBC again outsource the entire project to 3 IT companies i.e. Computacentre, Meidasmiths and Vidispine but ultimately the project was cancelled in the year 2013. This inefficient applicability of the DMI led to huge losses for the company and the project was declared to be a complete failure (Kelly, 2019). In the current report, the risk assessment will be done on the basis of PMBOK methodology and this will help in controlling and determining the risk factors that are associated with the organization. This will help in identifying causes behind failure in the DMI system implementation and the entire project risk assessment will be detailed in the report wit adequate conclusion. Aims and Goals The DMI implementation by BBC was done so that the entire system could be digitalised and the operation of BBC could be streamlined towards a tapeless and better workflow. Therefore, the decision to implement DMI and its subsequent failure will be the main aspect of analysis in the report. The major aim of this report will be to identify the causes behind the project failure and why the DMI system i.e. the digitalization project implemented at BBC Corporation became redundant and could not achieve the objective behind it (Chowdhury, 2019). The factors behind the increased cost that was caused will be analysed and interpreted in the report. The objectives can be categorized in the following points:
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
ToidentifytheissuesthattheBBCCorporationisfacingduetopoorDMI implementation and remove them. To minimize the increasing costs and the rise in technical problems. To encourage correctcost estimationso that chancesof over-budgetingcould be minimized. To verify what are the exact deliverables and plan accordingly so that the objective can be achieved through DMI. To minimize the impact and consequences of this DMI failure on the organization. Retrospective Research In the year 2008, BBC decided to modernize their system and move towards a more connected and tapeless system and for this purpose, the Digital Media Initiative was developed by the director of BBC Ashley Highfield. With this objective, the DMI programme was given to Siemens by passing the budget of£81.7 million but it was discovered that the cost for implementation of DMI was exceeding and the objectives were not being met exactly. i.e. the requirement of the BBC with this plan was not being exactly delivered by the project that was being implemented by them (BBC's Digital Media Initiative failed because of more than poor oversight,2015). Due to this, the BBC incurred an estimated loss of£38.2 million out of which £27.5 million was received as a settlement from Siemens and the DMI project was cancelled with them. After the cancellation of the project with Siemens in year 2009 and facing criticism from the National Audit Office, BBC brought the DMI project in-house and rebranded it asFabric. However, it was soon discovered that the major purpose for which the programme was being implemented i.e. to support the relocation of the production house to Salford in summer 2011 could not be done because the programme would be delayed beyond autumn 2011. The planning maps lacked any clarity and were largely superficial without any depth that caused confusion and complexity in the work that BBC was doing to implement DMI (Digital Media Initiative,2019). Such rising costs and failure to meet the user expectations led to decline of the confidence of user and this was further strengthened by the enormous problems that the company faced while covering the death and funeral of Margaret Thatcher in the year 2013 where BBC failed to transfer footage in the digital format.
The entire project of DMI was called off in the year 2013 by the director-general of the BBC and the chief technology officer of the BBC was suspended after the external investigation of the entire DMI project was conducted and NAO, after its enquiry, labelled the project as complete failure and the loss of entire project was estimated to be a gross£125.9 million (Digital Media Initiative,2019). Risk Management Methodology Adopted In order to analyse the risk associated with the implementation of the DMI project that majorly occurred in the BBC Corporation, a risk examination process is conducted under which all the aspects related to cost, time taken etc. are analysed and the budget as well as the estimated completion time is analysed and evaluated (Robinson, 2019). The most significant contributor in the risk management process is the risk register and the hazard register that is prepared for the
organization. In the current report, for analysing the risks associated with the BBC Corporation, the PMBOK process and method was adopted. ThePMBOKprocess can be detailed as Project Management Body of Knowledge and there are six major stages that are involved in the entire risk management process: Risk Management Planning Identification of the risks Associated Analysis of the Risk Evaluation of the Risk Executing the risk Management Monitoring of the Risk All these aspects of risks are associated with the implementation of the DMI system and these help in determining what are the additional risks or dangers that are associated with the plan and which steps can be adopted to mitigate these plans or actions (Bolutiwi, 2019). Internal and External Context The risks that were associated with the BBC Corporation can be classified into two major categoriesi.e.internalrisksandexternalrisksthatareprevalentinthecontextofthe implementation of the Digital Media Initiative in the organization: Internal Risks: These are those risks that are associated within the organization and can be controlled or tired to be mitigated by the employees and management working in the company (Chapman, 2019). These can be categorized into following points: The over budgeting or the excess incurring of expenditure than the estimated budget that was prepared in the starting by Seimens. The inefficient leadership in the company where the business objective or goals were not clear and thus could not be integrated with the DMI. Delay in the total implementation time of the DMI system in the BBC Corporation.Lack of any clarity regarding the goals and objectives of the organization and the purpose for which they are developing a DMI system. External Risks: These are those risks associated with th6e external environment over which the management of the organization cannot be controlled and therefore these are not under their control:
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
NonCompliancetolegislativesystemresultinginthefilingofsuitagainstthe organization. Fluctuation in the budget and delivery time making it much more than the estimated one. Risk Assessment Risk Assessmentprocess involves a series of steps starting from the identification of the risk and ends with the acceptance of the risk (Siebert, 2019). Risk Identification: All the risks have some people who are associated and some additional aspects. In this report, the risk can be identified by determining the people that are involved in the company and these can be identified as follows: The DMI project developers hired by the organization New Implementers of the DMI system. BBC Corproation's finance and technology department.Contract with the Seimens. Risk Analysis The risk that is associated with the project can be evaluated in the theoretical terms and in a qualitative manner (Austin and et.al., 2019). Under this, the risk register has been prepared and this involves analysis of all the factors that are associated with the risk and the manner in which they can be mitigated i.e. the strategies that can be adopted in order to mitigate them. Risk register:
Seri al No. Risk Description Impact on project Chang e Mitigation Actions Individual/ Group Responsibl e CostTimelin e of Mitigat ion Action 1Increasing costs due to inefficient implementati on The cost of the project is rising and thus resources of the corporation are being over exerted. YesAvoid by implementin g correct system Project manager TBCTBC 2Over- incurrence of the estimated costs The planning is weak and estimation or forecasting is not proper YesCan be mitigated by developing good budgets Project Manager TBCTBC 3Increasing Timeline The increasing time is impacting the project cost as well YesThe Timeline can be reduced Project Manager TBCTBC 4Faulty Contracts with external parties The growth of the company is being hampered and additional costs are being incurred YesSurveying the actual need and communicati ng it properly after careful selection Project Manager TBCTBC Table1: Risk Register
Risk Evaluation: The DMI implementation fiasco that occurred in the BBC Corproation can be analysed with the risk evaluation strategies as these help in determining what was the extent up to which the damage was caused in the company (Jathol and Rüling, 2019). LevelRiskScale of Severity HighOver-incurring of costs than the estimated Budget for implementation of new system Unacceptable HighThe timeline is extremely delayed delaying the operations unacceptable MediumContracts are not being developed precisely Tolerable Table2: Risk Evaluation Matrix Stakeholder Register The stakeholders are the most important party in any project and can directly or indirectly influence the manner in which the project is being completed and conducted (Eskerod and Jepsen, 2016). There are external as well as internal stakeholders in the project management and in the current project of DMI implementation of the BBC Corporation, there are various stakeholders for the company. In the current project some of the major stakeholder of the project were: NamePositionRoleContact Information CategoryMajor requirements Expectation Ashley Highfiel d Director ofBBC Technolog y Initiatorof theDMI project ashleyhgf@g mail.com InternalPhone, E-mails, Reports The DMI project tobe implemented successfully. Seimen s Compa ny Technolog yservice provider for BBC The technologica lpartner who was to implement theDMI seimens@g mail.com InternalVideo Conferences, Documents, Phone, E-mails Integratingthe objective for the BBCCompany for the DMI plan andgiving appropriate
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
systemin BBC deliverables. John Linwoo d Chief Technolog yOfficer of BBC Chief Implementer afterBBC broughtthe DMI project in hand due toSiemens failure. linwoodjohn @gmail.com InternalE-mails, phone, reports Addressingthe requirementof theBBC Companyfrom DMI Project and makingastrong IT system Lord Hall Director General of BBC Decision taker of the projectwho ultimately decidedto calloffthe BBCDMI project. lrdhall12@g mial.com InternalVideo Conferences, Messages Documents, Reports, Phone, E-mails Ensuring that the DMIprojectis goinginright directionand checkingthe results regularly. Employ eesof BBC Team members ofthe DMI project The implementer softhe project working underthe project manager working extensively. -InternalReports, Phone, E-mails Theywereto workeffectively on the project and implement a DMI systemthat would deliver the requirementsof theBBC Company. Govern ment, Sponsors and The intervening -ExternalVideo Conferences, Monitoringthe projectand
NAO and local people invested parties partieswho ascertain whatwas theexact losses in the entire projectand finally orderedto abandon the DMI project. Reports,E- mailsand phone checking whether thereis unnecessary expenditureor increaseinthe cost and ensuring thattheDMI Projectis completewithin designated budgetand timeline. Table3: Stakeholder Register The stakeholder register helps in identification of the major stakeholders in the company and the categorization of the different stakeholders help in quick identification of the responsible stakeholder in case any potential risk or threat arises and therefore the stakeholder register is a very useful tool in identification and mitigation of the risk factors at an early stage. Monitoring techniques Applied on Project In every project, it is necessary that in order to ensure the success of the project, appropriate monitoring and controlling tools are applied by the responsible individuals or team members of the project (Pandi-Perumal and et.al., 2015). There are a variety of risks that can arise in the project and in order to monitor this, there are different techniques that can be used. Reconsidering the Risk: The risks that have been identified beforehand should be regularly monitored and the meetings with the project manager and team members help in keeping a track of the potential work that is being performed or completed. Under this, different qualitative and quantitative analysis is conducted where the different tasks are evaluated and which is the task or risk with the highest priority is analysed and evaluated. Auditing the Risk: This helps in discovering the internal risks that are associated with the project like the non integration of the DMI objective with it s planning was identified by this method. Here, an overall evaluation takes place regarding the performance and the productivity of the
project so that the project can be improved significantly (Sanghera, 2019). This identification of risks helps in controlling it or trying to minimize the impact and in certain cases even stop the project like cancelling the contract with Siemens in the current case. Change and movement Investigation:Under this method, the tasks are regularly evaluated and modified with the changing environment, the work that is being done in the project etc. so that the necessary modifications can be included in order to complete the project accordingly (Cagliano, Grimaldi and Rafele, 015). In the DMI project, this technique could have helped in identifying that the project is not going well i.e. the costs are increasing and the results are not at par with the expenditure that is being made. Methodological Presentation Management: Under this risk evaluation system the loopholes in the entire project are identified and ascertained with the help of evaluation of the entire project management. With the help of this monitoring tool, the BBC Corporation could identify the faults in the implementation of the DMI right form the beginning when the contract belonged to the Siemens (Kliem and Ludin, 2019). This could have helped in avoiding the unnecessary losses that took place in the company. Replacement Examination:This kind of monitoring technique is usually applicable when the project is for long term. It helps in identifying those activities or tasks that have become redundant with time and then removing the said task by replacing it with other task. This helps in removing the destructive activities for the project. If this had been applicable in the BBC Corporation, then those activities that were found to be redundant in the BBC Corporation could have been removed and replaced with better activities. Consultation: This kind of technique involves seeking consultation or opinion form some external party so that a realistic and correct opinion can be developed on the activities that are being undertaken in the project (Wu and et.al., 2018). The current project of undertaking DMI Implementation in BBC Corporation appointed an external consulting agency i.e. Deloitte and it was found that the project was not going well according to them and they had already forewarned. Risk Treatment Schedule and Plan Risk treatment plan is the combination of the technique which are used to overcome the different risk which used to occur in the project. This treatment schedule used to help in finding out the strategy which can be used in the project to mitigate the different issue in the project. In
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
this schedule all the risk used to monitor very closely and on the basis of the same risk are rank from high to low. Also this risk treatment used to include all the personnel who can treat the risk and minimize the effect of the same in the organization (Hulett, 2016). Possible Risk Possiblerisk treatment Option Preferred Option RiskRatting after treatment Result of analysis Waysof Monitoring Increasing costdueto inadequate planning and implementati on Analysingthe market as well as theinternal positionofthe business to have a accurate estimation. Usingbetter resourcesatthe timeofplanning and implementation Analysingthe marketaswell astheinternal positionofthe business to have aaccurate estimation (Cattonand et.al., 2016). LowAcceptBy comparing theresultof onereportto the another to findoutthe deviation whichhas beenbrought by the change Over- budgeting thanthe estimated amount Analysingtask needtobe completedbefore allocatingthe resources. Usage of technical resourcesatthe timeof allocating of budget. Analysingtask needtobe completed before allocatingthe resources. LowAcceptBy comparing the amount of thewastages before implementing themeasure withafter implementatio n of same. Continuously increasing project timeline Properscheduling of the work before starting the same. Properdelegation Proper schedulingof the work before startingthe LowAcceptBy setting the benchmark and comparing the
oftherolesand responsibility. same.actualresult with the same (Roveaand et.al., 2015). Lackof leadership in the implementati onofthe plan Conducting trainingand development programinthe organizationfor the leader. Allocatingthe implementation work to more than oneleaderinthe organization. Allocatingthe implementation worktomore than one leader inthe organization. MediumAcceptBy organization themeeting withallthe leaderonthe fixedtime interval in the organization. Inadequate research before enteringinto contracts Properanalysis about the different clientandthe offering of them. Lookingatthe contactsofthe competitorinthe marketbefore deciding the list of contact. Properanalysis aboutthe differentclient and the offering of them. MediumAcceptComparing theefficiency of the support oftheclient bycomparing theactual performance withthepast performance. Complete project failure Properevaluation oftheprojecton thetimelybasis during the process of completingthe Proper evaluationof theprojecton the timely basis duringthe HighAcceptThiscanbe measurewith thehelpof setting up the benchmark
project. Settingthe benchmarkfor everystepinthe project and try to full fill the same processof completingthe project. before starting theproject and comparing the same with the actual result to findoutthe deviationout of the same. Risk Action Plan Risk action planhelps in investigating and measuring all the risks that are associated with the project and then eliminating all the possible risks that could have arisen in the project as closely as possible (Wang and et.al, 2016). This helps in avoiding the losses and the chances of project failure. The BBC Corporation can develop a risk avoidance and reduction plan so that the potential risks for the DMI Project can be identified and minimized accordingly. The risk action plan for the implementation of the DMI system in the BBC Corporation can be developed by segregating risks on the basis of different level and deciding the actions based on the severity of the risk. RiskRecommended Response and Impact Responsibiliti es TimingReporting and Monitoring Required Proposed Actions Increasing costdue to inadequat e planning and implement ation Developproper panningand implementation technique so that the estimatedcostscan beascertained beforehand. Finance Manager, Project Manager Immediat e YesAdetailed projectcharter shouldbe preparedanda particular project management methodology such as Prince 2
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
Methodology can be adopted. Over- budgeting thanthe estimated amount Controlthe expenditurethatis taking place ensuring thatnounnecessary costsarebeing incurred. Project Manager Immediat e YesDeveloping proper forecastingand budgeting tools. Continuou sly increasing project timeline Timelycompletion oftheactivities where the actual and standard time match closely to each other. Project Manager, Team members Immediat e YesThe WBS should be prepared in a detailedmanner whereeach activityis properly classifiedand segregated. Lackof leadership inthe implement ationof the plan Ensurethatthe project manager and leader have adequate knowledgeofthe productanddonot falter in making the objectives meet with the deliverables. Project Manager TimeYesEvaluatethe leadership qualityina detailedmanner and then appoint the leader of the project. Inadequat e research before entering into contracts Thecompanywith whomthirdparty contractsarebeing entered into must be carefullyevaluated and their ability must Project Manager TimeYesDevelop a proper formatfor ascertainingthe abilityofthe thirdpartywith whichthe
be tested.contract is being entered. Complete project failure Theprojectshould be carried out after researchingthe currenttrendsand knowing what is the want of the potential consumer segment. Market ForcesTimeYesThe project must bedeveloped afterconducting propermarket research. Discussions and Recommendations The entire project management report evaluated the applicability of Digital Media Initiative in the BBC Corporation and the reasons why the entire project ultimately led to failure of the DMI Implementation. In this report, the different factors which led to the failure of the DMI project were evaluated and it was found that ineffective integration between the desired and the delivered objectives was one of the major reasons for failure (Sangaiah And et.al., 2018). The reason was that there was no clarity regarding what was the requirement of the BBC from this project. Different risks which led to the failure of the project was identified such as the risk of increased expenditure etc. and its impact was ascertained where the risk action plan and risk treatment planning tools were used to evaluate that how these risk could have been mitigated or avoided. The recommendations that can be made on the basis of research that was conducted in the report include: Identifyingthecorrectpersonwhoknewwhatwasexactlyrequiredformthe implementation of DMI so that these could be clearly conveyed to the Siemens and deliverables could match the requirements. Developing proper budgeting and forecasting tools so that there is no over budgeting and the expenses are made within the allowed limits. Using proper monitoring and evaluation tools so that at each stage the activities and the project could have been monitored and early signs of failure could have been identified by the manager regarding expected failure of DMI (Muriana and Vizzini, 2017).
Implementing the project only after through analysis had been done regarding the availability of resources in the company. CONCLUSION Theresearchconductedinthereportabovehelpsinconcludingthatinevery organization,successfulimplementationofanysystemrequiresadequateplanningand documentation. In the above report, it was concluded that the major reason behind the failure of theimplementationofDigitalMediaInitiativeprogrammeintheBritishBroadcasting Corporationwasinefficientimplementationandintegrationoftheobjectivewiththe deliverables. The report also concluded that the risk ascertaining and monitoring is extremely useful in elimination of the risk and if these could have been implemented in the BBC Corporation then the loss to the company could have been avoided and the project of DMI Implementation could have been successfully completed.
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
REFERENCES Books and journals Jathol, B.A. and Rüling, C.C., 2019. Temporary Incorporation as a Mechanism of Strategic Responsiveness: The BBC’s Digital Transformation, 1992–2015. InStrategic Responsiveness andAdaptiveOrganizations:NewResearchFrontiersinInternationalStrategic Management(pp. 111-124). Emerald Publishing Limited. Austin, J., and et.al., 2019. The BBC micro: bit–from the UK to the World.Communications of the ACM. Siebert, S., 2019. ‘A deeply troubled organization’: Organizational satire in the BBC’s W1A comedy series.Scandinavian Journal of Management,35(1). pp.56-63. Chapman, R.J., 2019. Exploring the value of risk management for projects: improving capability through the deployment of a maturity model.IEEE Engineering Management Review,47(1). pp.126-143. Robinson, O., 2019. Malicious Use of Social Media: Case Studies from BBC Monitoring. Bolutiwi, M., 2019.An Empirical Investigation into the Challenges and Failures of Large-Scale Complex Information Technology Projects(Doctoral dissertation, UCL (University College London)). Hearn, G., Swan, D. and Geels, K., 2019. Action research. InThe Palgrave Handbook of Methods for Media Policy Research(pp. 121-139). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. Kelly, R., 2019. Future-Proofing Organisations for Leadership 4.0. InConstructing Leadership 4.0(pp. 153-174). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. Chowdhury, R., 2019. From Barriers to Boundaries: Learnings from a Healthcare IT Project Failure. InSystems Thinking for Management Consultants(pp. 111-138). Springer, Singapore. Hulett, D., 2016. Practical schedule risk analysis. Routledge. Catton, C. N. and et.al., 2016. A randomized trial of a shorter radiation fractionation schedule for the treatment of localized prostate cancer. Rovea, P and et.al., 2015. Once-weekly hypofractionated whole-breast radiotherapy after breast- conserving surgery in older patients: a potential alternative treatment schedule to daily 3-week hypofractionation. Clinical breast cancer. 15(4). pp.270-276. Eskerod, P. and Jepsen, A.L., 2016.Project stakeholder management. Routledge. 1
Pandi-Perumal, S.R. And et.al., 2015. Project stakeholder management in the clinical research environment: how to do it right.Frontiers in psychiatry,6. p.71. Sanghera, P., 2019. Monitoring Stakeholder Engagement and Communication. InPMP® in Depth(pp. 519-533). Apress, Berkeley, CA. Kliem, R.L. and Ludin, I.S., 2019.Reducing project risk. Routledge. Wu, S. and et.al., 2018. Research on construction engineering project risk assessment with some 2-tuple linguistic neutrosophic Hamy mean operators.Sustainability,10(5). p.1536. Wang, T. and et.al, 2016. A major infrastructure risk-assessment framework: Application to a cross-sea route project in China.International Journal of Project Management,34(7). pp.1403-1415. Sangaiah, A.K. And et.al., 2018. Towards an efficient risk assessment in software projects–Fuzzy reinforcement paradigm.Computers & Electrical Engineering,71. pp.833-846. Muriana, C. and Vizzini, G., 2017. Project risk management: A deterministic quantitative techniqueforassessmentandmitigation.InternationalJournalofProject Management,35(3). pp.320-340. Cagliano,A.C.,Grimaldi,S.andRafele,C.,2015.Choosingprojectriskmanagement techniques. A theoretical framework.Journal of Risk Research,18(2). pp.232-248. Online DigitalMediaInitiative.2019.[ONLINE]Availablethrough:<https://www.nao.org.uk/wp- content/uploads/2015/01/BBC-Digital-Media-Initiative.pdf> BBC's Digital Media Initiative failed because of more than poor oversight.2015. [ONLINE] Availablethrough:<https://www.theguardian.com/media/media-blog/2014/feb/03/bbc-digital- media-initiative-failed-mark-thompson> 2