Impact of Accounting Standards on Firm Performance

This assignment delves into the effects of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) on firm performance. It examines various aspects, including asset measurement in imperfect credit markets, the impact of operating lease capitalization on financial ratios, and the use of unverifiable estimates in goodwill impairment testing. The analysis draws upon research articles and case studies, such as CODAN's annual reports and the influence of Total Quality Management on risk identification. Students are expected to critically evaluate the relationship between accounting standards and firm performance outcomes.

Running head: FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
Financial Impairment
Name of the Student:
Name of the University:
Author Note:

1
FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
Table of Contents
Assessment Task: Part A:................................................................................................................2
1. Impairment Test of the Asset value.............................................................................................3
2. Procedure of Impairment Test.....................................................................................................4
3. Expenditure of the Impairment....................................................................................................4
4. Necessary estimation and assumptions associated with the impairment test..............................6
5. Associated subjectivity in Impairment Testing Process..............................................................7
6. Surprises, difficulties, confusion, and interest associated with the impairment test...................8
7. Insights derived from the impairment test...................................................................................8
8. Measurement of the Fair Value...................................................................................................8
Assessment Task Part B:.................................................................................................................9
1. Absence of former accounting standards in the economic reality...............................................9
2. Reasons why under the previous accounting standards the lease liabilities of the reporting
entities in the balance sheet were 66 times more than the reported debts under the balance sheet.9
3. Views of IASB Chairperson regarding the accounting standards.............................................10
4. The view of Chairperson about the ineffectiveness of the new standards.................................10
5. Possibilities in providing better improvement in investment decisions....................................10
References......................................................................................................................................12

2
FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
Assessment Task: Part A:
The financial impairment depends on the costs that include exceeded amount of the book
value. This report would provide the insights of the financial impairment and the underlying
assumptions. Codan Limited, the financial corporation, would prepare the financial statements
and the annual report by conducting the impairment tests based on the measurements of existing
assets. Furthermore, the report would also focus on the associated practices and procedures
related to the impairment tests process developed by the organization. The study would also
provide the clear elaboration of the subjectivity associated with the developed tests of financial
impairment. Codan Limited has captured the leading position in manufacturing and supplying
the mining technology, communication, and metal detection technicalities. Headquarter of the
company is in South Australia from where the company generates the revenues of almost $132.3
million. The information obtained from the annual report of 2016 suggests that the company
utilizes the highly advanced technologies to overcome the issues emerge due to the security,
communication, safety parameter, and productivity. Currently, the company has secured the
position in the competitive business market by selling the products in 150 nations from which
almost 85% revenue is gathered.
According to Amiraslani, Iatridis and Pope (2013), asset impairment is conceptualized as
the measurement of the lower value of the existing asset than the actual value. It is necessary to
facilitate the impairment in the tangible fixed assets, such as plant, property, and equipment.
Apart from these tangible assets, it is necessary to impair the intangible assets as well, such as
establishing the good will and developing the remarkable account receivable. The income
statement of the company highlights the subsequent loss, which is needed to be adjusted for

3
FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
improving the values of the assets by undertaking impairment practices. The practices for writing
off impairment display the reduced level of the carrying cost. The asset value is decreased as
some of adjustments are made and the result further discloses the significant loss.
1. Impairment Test of the Asset value
Codan Ltd published the annual report on 30th June, 2016, in which the entire financial
impairment test result is systematically informed. It has been observed that the impairment tests
are conducted annually or more than once in a year. The report of these tests specifies that the
reputation of the company, which is considered as the major intangible asset, is not amortized n
the field of financial account. Andrews (2012) implied that the asset impairment is generally
required if the company makes any changes to the event or to any specific circumstance. The
further report indicates that the accumulated loss during the impairment affected the financial
aspects by decreasing the costs. The other assets in Codan Ltd. include property, equipment,
inventories and plants. These assets are also needed to be tested for the impairments, especially
when the irrecoverable amount becomes the major concern.

4
FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
2. Procedure of Impairment Test
The carrying amount of the asset is sometimes unrecovered due to which the impairment
tests become essential to be conducted. The intangible assets and the company reputation are
also needed to be tested for impairment (Jennings and Marques 2013). This test is needed to be
conducted for more than once in a year. The particular set of assets is needed to be combined
together for the impairment assessment since the separated cash inflow indicates the reduced
level. The cash generating units depends on the independent cash inflows received from the
group of assets. On the other hand, the non-financial assets also require the impairment analysis
(Filip, Jeanjean and Paugam 2015). In fact, it is noticed that each of the reporting date of the
impairment in the organization can be reversed at times.
3. Expenditure of the Impairment
The report presented in the annual report published on 30th June, 2016 highlights the
expenditure amount, which is as follows:
 Expenditure of the Tangible Asset Impairment

5
FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
It is reported that Codan Ltd. has recorded the total amount of the impairment on building,
which reached up to almost $1,379 during the period. The total amount of the impairment
including the costs of property, plants, and Minetec equipment reached up to $524 in the year if
2016.
 Expenditure of the Intangible Asset Impairment
The expenditure amount of the intellectual property and the inventory process has reached up
to $592 and $1,287 respectively as presented in the annual report.

6
FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
4. Necessary estimation and assumptions associated with the impairment test
It has been observed that Codan Ltd. is much concerned about the future opportunities due to
which the company has made few of the estimations and assumptions much significantly. It is
important to make the equal estimation outcome in accordance with the related actual outcomes.
In fact, if there will be any specific mistakes occurred in making proper estimation, it may affect
in leading the adjustments of the materials of any specific asset. This asset would carry the value
for the next financial year that will be disclosed through presenting the notes (Rennekamp, Rupar
and Seybert 2014). The judgments are generally based as per the necessary accounting necessity.
It has been observed that the business atmosphere of Codan Ltd. has been experiencing adverse
and negative conditions that developed and the continuous downturn in the market is also much
foreseen. The ash generating unit was conducted to ascertain the recoverable amount of both the
tangible and intangible assets. CGU (Cash Generating Unit) of the recoverable amount depends
on the value-in-use calculations, which can be utilized in projecting the cash flow based on the
financial forecast. The management has been working since last five years to develop this
forecast report. The impairment report is developed by comparing the values of the present and
the estimated cash flows for the future (Cotter 2014). The discount is estimated by depending on
the previous interest rate. The following assumptions are utilized for assessing the value-in-use:
 Margin of Sales
 Rate of the estimated discount
 Use of the growth rate with the help of extrapolate cash flows beyond the forecast time

7
FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
5. Associated subjectivity in Impairment Testing Process
The accounting regulations IAS 36 of asset impairments imply that the asset impairment
demands subjective interpretation and the appropriate IFRS standards. However, the estimation
can be adjusted as per the requirements presented by the managers in the company. It is notable
that the asset impairment does not depend on the limited portion of the creative accounting
(Ramanna and Watts, 2012). The report obtained from the 2016 annual report highlights that the
involvement of the subjective assumptions is huge. The organization has the considerable
opportunity of exploiting the discretion and conducting the impairment tests for the developing
the goodwill of the company. The cash generating units can also be utilized for allocating the
goodwill. The amount is quite recoverable and there is no possibility of the active prices since
the goodwill can become a subject of discretion (Bertomeu and Cheynel 2015).

8
FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
6. Surprises, difficulties, confusion, and interest associated with the impairment test
Presenting the indication of the impairments is highlighted as the most difficult and confusing
part as per the report derived from the above assessment. Both the internal and the external
signal of the asset impairment help in creating this indication as a whole. The management
discretion is responsible for delivering more frequency in the impairment test (Bertomeu and
Cheynel 2015). In fact, it has been observed that the management can even practice the test
opportunistically if there will be any value downturn is visible.
7. Insights derived from the impairment test
There are the considerable differences observed between the recoverable amount and the
carrying value of the assets. The higher fair value of the recoverable amount can be decreased
due to the deposal of the value-in-use cost (Costantini and Zanin 2015). The sales agreement and
the asset value determine the fair value of the organization in which the asset trade exists. The
fair value of the company discloses the exact amount of the existing asset, which can be sold by
the company (Bepari, Rahman and Mollik 2014). As mentioned in IAS 36, the business value-in-
use is characterized by the future cash flow that is to be gained from the cash generating units.
8. Measurement of the Fair Value
As highlighted in the IFRS 13 standard, the fair value of the company is determined by the
following aspects:
 Sales agreement
 Existing assets in the trade market
 Availability of the adequate information in which the asset can be sold.

9
FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
Assessment Task Part B:
1. Absence of former accounting standards in the economic reality
In 1 out of 3 companies that are utilizing the US GAAP or IFRS standards are
recognizably affected by various forms of the accounting techniques. The current status is
reflecting that the organizations under these standards amount and commits for more than 3.3
trillion (Ifrs.org. 2018). It is noticed that almost 85% of the total asset are not shown in the
financial statement or balance sheet of the company as these are considered as the operational
leases. The real liability is created if these leases are not shown. Therefore, the company can face
bankruptcy if it does not maintain the standards with the latest economic reality during the
financial crisis (Fitó, Moya and Orgaz 2013). The company is committed towards the long-term
operating leases which were shown as lean in the balance sheet.
2. Reasons why under the previous accounting standards the lease liabilities of the
reporting entities in the balance sheet were 66 times more than the reported debts under
the balance sheet
The earlier accounting standards present the report, which determines 85% of the
operating lease and it even reflects on the balance sheet. It creates the real liability even though it
is not mentioned in the balance sheet (Fitó, Moya and Orgaz 2013). Therefore, during the time of
the financial crisis, the major companies need to make the amendments in the economic reality.
The company even requires developing the commitments for the long-term operating leases due

10
FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
to which it is noticed that the lease liabilities are proved to be 66 times more than compared to
the existing debts under balance sheet.
3. Views of IASB Chairperson regarding the accounting standards
The former lease accounting technique lacks the compatibility. Airline industries usually
deal with the operating leases, which are not shown in the balance sheet or in the financial
statement. Therefore, the airline firm is proved to be quite dissimilar from the competitors that
are purchasing the overall fleets (Lee and Hooy 2012). There is no sign of the negligible level
playing field foreseen among the airline industry. Hence, these leases are considered as the
liabilities of the firm.
4. The view of Chairperson about the ineffectiveness of the new standards
The new standards is not considered to be popular among the companies but is expected
to have the long impacts in many of the listed companies. The changes are made in a very
controversial way (Banker, Basu and Byzalov 2016). It can even create negative impact on the
economic situations and the fair costs. It is necessary for the organization to accept the changes
readily and make amendments in the balance sheet and the income statements. For instance,
several contractual arrangements and banking covenants are associated with the financial
statement
5. Possibilities in providing better improvement in investment decisions
The operating lease for all the new documents are treated as off balance sheet items in the
former accounting standards. The complete picture about the financial business position is not
there with the financial statement users or the investors. Thus, it is not possible to compare the

11
FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
organization are buying assets and that are leasing assets. IFRS 16 consist of advanced updates
which can be used for outweighing costs and providing better decisions.

12
FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
References
Amiraslani, H., Iatridis, G.E. and Pope, P.F., 2013. Accounting for asset impairment: a test for
IFRS compliance across Europe. Centre for Financial Analysis and Reporting Research
(CeFARR).
Andrews, R., 2012. Fair Value, earnings management and asset impairment: The impact of a
change in the regulatory environment. Procedia Economics and Finance, 2, pp.16-25.
Banker, R.D., Basu, S. and Byzalov, D., 2016. Implications of Impairment Decisions and Assets'
Cash-Flow Horizons for Conservatism Research. The Accounting Review, 92(2), pp.41-67.
Bertomeu, J. and Cheynel, E., 2015. Asset measurement in imperfect credit markets. Journal of
Accounting Research, 53(5), pp.965-984.
Codan.com.au (2018). Annual Reports. [online] CODAN. Available at:
http://codan.com.au/news-media/annual-reports/ [Accessed 24 Jan. 2018].
Costantini, A. and Zanin, F., 2015. The influence of total quality management on risk
identification and non-financial performance measures: an Italian-based empirical
analysis. International Journal of Management Cases, 17(4).
Cotter, D. (2014). Advanced financial reporting: A complete guide to IFRS. Financial
Times/Prentice Hall.
Filip, A., Jeanjean, T. and Paugam, L., 2015. Using real activities to avoid goodwill impairment
losses: Evidence and effect on future performance. Journal of Business Finance &
Accounting, 42(3-4), pp.515-554.

13
FINANCIAL IMPAIRMENT
Fitó, M.À., Moya, S. and Orgaz, N., 2013. Considering the effects of operating lease
capitalization on key financial ratios. Spanish Journal of Finance and Accounting/Revista
Española de Financiación y Contabilidad, 42(159), pp.341-369.
Gordon, E.A. and Hsu, H.T., 2017. Tangible Long-Lived Asset Impairments and Future
Operating Cash Flows under US GAAP and IFRS. The Accounting Review.
Ifrs.org., 2018. IFRS. [online] Available at: http://www.ifrs.org/ [Accessed 24 Jan. 2018].
Jennings, R. and Marques, A. (2013). Amortized cost for operating lease assets. Accounting
Horizons, 27(1), pp.51-74.
Lee, C.H. and Hooy, C.W., 2012. Determinants of systematic financial risk exposures of airlines
in North America, Europe and Asia. Journal of Air Transport Management, 24, pp.31-35.
Md Khokan Bepari, Sheikh F. Rahman and Abu Taher Mollik. (2014) Firms' compliance with
the disclosure requirements of IFRS for goodwill impairment testing: Effect of the global
financial crisis and other firm characteristics, Journal of Accounting & Organizational Change,
Vol. 10 Issue: 1, pp.116149, https://doi.org/10.1108/JAOC-02-2011-0008
Nawaiseh, M.E., 2016. Can Impairment Recognition under IAS 36 Be Improved by Financial
Performance?. International Journal of Economics and Finance, 8(12), p.163.
Ramanna, K. and Watts, R.L., 2012. Evidence on the use of unverifiable estimates in required
goodwill impairment. Review of Accounting Studies, 17(4), pp.749-780.
Rennekamp, K., Rupar, K.K. and Seybert, N., 2014. Impaired judgment: The effects of asset
impairment reversibility and cognitive dissonance on future investment. The Accounting
Review, 90(2), pp.739-759.