Strategic Security Work And Intelligence - Case Study of Turkey
Verified
Added on 2022/08/19
|22
|5906
|13
AI Summary
Contribute Materials
Your contribution can guide someone’s learning journey. Share your
documents today.
Running head: STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE Name of the Student: Name of the University: Author Note:
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
1STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE Table of Contents Introduction:.......................................................................................................................2 Interests of Turkey:............................................................................................................3 Turkey and Russia relation:...............................................................................................5 Need for Security measures and actions in any Country:.................................................6 Security measures that are needed in Turkey:..................................................................7 Undertaken Security Measures in Turkey:........................................................................8 Domestic Measures:......................................................................................................9 International Measures:...............................................................................................10 Strategies for better security environment:......................................................................11 Inside the country:........................................................................................................12 Outside the country:.....................................................................................................13 Conclusion:......................................................................................................................15 References:......................................................................................................................17
2STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE Introduction: Across the middle-east countries, there are heightening tensions regarding the increased risk of terror attacks and tourists have also been warned against visiting in such sensitive times. The UK FCO or the Foreign and Commonwealth Office has also provided similar advice to the travelers and told them to be vigilant amidst the fears that the Western people might be targeted in terrorist attacks. In fact, the tourism industry has been affected the most with the political turmoil. In late 2019, Turkey had launched an offensive of major stature against Kurdish-held positions in the area of north Syria; this prompted FCO to reinstate a number of some severe warnings against all the people travelling to some particular parts of the country. It has also been declared by FCO that Istanbul, the largest city of Turkey and Ankara, the capital of Turkey are mostly safe from any security issues but travelers and people must take precautions in order to avoid chances of being caught in some kind of terrorist attack or civil unrest. These types of attacks generally targeted towards the tourists from western countries but the local and native people are also harmed in the way. Keeping aside the issue of Terrorism, Turkey is also a region which is a target of burglaries and other such similar crimes in accordance to the FCO. Turkey is a country that is predominantly a Sunni Muslim Country and in fact it is the only country with Muslim-majority in NATO. In the current years, some Islamist terror group including that of ISIS has merged on the border of Turkey with Syria and Iraq. As a matter of fact, large number of fighters from foreign lands has crossed the border of Turkey in the hope of joining these terror groups(Bilgin & Ince, 2015).
3STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE Meanwhile there are refugees who have fled from the conflict areas of Syria and Iraq to Turkey and the numbers have reached up to 3 million in the year 2018. The extremist groups within Turkey have subscribed to Islamist ideologies, Kurdish separatist and far- left. According to some critics, it is because of the venerable issues with this country’s Kurds and also the PKK, that Ankara has targeted PKK more than the terror of ISIS itself. Moreover, PKK have also claimed the responsibility for some high-profile terrorist attack including the one that occurred on 13thof March, 2016 in the form of a car bomb attack; this attack killed around 37 people and more than 125 people were wounded. The increasing activeness of the terror groups in Turkey makes it significant for the government to have strategic security intelligence and framework since the safety of innocent lives are at risk. Interests of Turkey: When the Soviet Union collapsed, it has opened opportunities to be a part of the New Game in the region of Great Caspian for major countries like Turkey, Iran, US, EU and Russia. Turkey has certain “strategic geopolitical location” that has created an advantage to establish itself as one of the main energy routes in the area of East-West Energy due to its close ties in the ethno-linguistic area. It is this strategy of Turkey that has allowed the country to re-emerge as a regional geopolitical force. Once Ankara realizes the strategy of energy of this country, it will be able to use this energy factor as its political leverage. Hence, in this context the competition of Turkey with Russia can be viewed in a form of readiness to use its military forces and promoted alternative pipelines as some limiting factors.
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
4STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE However, the geopolitical ambitions of Turkey face several limiting factors like the dependency of Turkey on the political support by US for the promotion of the planned pipelines and also for the potential energy alliance with Russia. Without the support of US in order to gain the lobbying for the significant products, can turn out to be very problematic for Turkey and pose a great challenge for its desire to turn into a major energy hub. Since Russia is also a major competitor that stands in the way of Turkey’s desire, and Turkey might think about forming an alliance with the country in order to strengthen its position in this arena, yet this idea is something that is warned against by many scholars. This is because their “geo-economic alliance” can potentially make threats to the energy security of the members of EU as they would get the option of obstructing the gas supplies to Europe(Khachatryan, 2015). In order to solve the West Energy’s problem, the NATO and US have calculated to achieve a tactical geopolitical benefit over the countries of Russia, China and also Iran; in accordance with this, the US strongly entered the route of Turkey having a primary aim that would diminish the power of Russia and also prevent the possible rise of the influence of Iran and China in theglobalandregionalarena.Thereisaprevailingcompetitionfortheenergy accomplishment, but it cannot be denied that this same pipeline development has augmented certain settlement incentives of peace within regional differences. This competition that prevails as a part of the economics of the market between these countries proves that there is a relationship that directly correlates security, geopolitics and energy politics.
5STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE Turkey and Russia relation: The relationship prevailing between Turkey and Russia has experienced certain rough point in the past few years; these two countries have a long history of interactions that are competitive in nature and things have led to such a circumstance that mutual understanding and trust between these two countries is very hard to attain. However, boththePresidentsofthesetwocountriessharesimilarprocessofconducting themselves and both of them have their trust issues towards the Western Policies. Yet they remain reluctant while making pledges and maintain a friendly relationship through cooperation. Both the leaders are ambitious as well as opportunistic such that they can sway from taking an oath for deliberate partnership to involving into a quarrel and the results can lock both of the countries into a conflict of high risk(Baev & Kirişci, 2017). The start of the decade for both the countries was unhappy; on one handErdoğanwas unhappy with Russia’s annexation of Crimea and thus decided not to join the regime of the Western sanctions but did not violate it; on the other hand, Turkey was disappointed over the way EU managed its process of accession and entertained the idea of SCO. Moreover there was an incident where Russia intervened in Syria and it clashed with the policy of Turkey that aimed to remove the Syrian president from his office. After the interval of two months, a Russian Su-24M bomber was drowned by F-16 fighter of Turkey and it evoked an unprecedented conflict. Moscow was seen to impose economic sanctions on the country of Turkey and although Ankara gained support from NATO, nonetheless,Erdoğan gave his apology in the year 2016; Putin, being an opportunist accepted it and instantly criticized the coup attempt by the military elements of Turkey in spite of the hesitation by EU and US.
6STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE Need for Security measures and actions in any Country: National Security is the defense and security of nation that includes the residing populace,itseconomyandinstitutionsanditisconsideredasadutythatthe government of the respective places must take care of. Originally, the concept of nationalsecurity is conceived as the kind of protectionwhich is providedby the government in case of a military attack against them(Aras, 2015). However, in the present day, national security has gained a wide definition that includes not only protection against the military attacks but also protection against the non- military dimensions like protection from terrorism, acts to minimize crime rates, looking after of thesecurityofeconomy,environment,food,cyber-securityandenergysecurity. National security risks, thus include issues like any actions from violent actors of non- state, actions by the cartels of narcotics and also by multinational corporations and most importantly, the after effects of any kind of natural disaster also falls under this category. Governments of all the states depend on several measures that include economic, political and power of military in order to safeguard the security of a nation. National security is of extreme significance for any country, despite the number of definitions that it has and is continuing to evolve. The presence of national security is meant to protect the citizens of a nation from all kinds of threats(Arikan, 2017). Because of a diverse culture that is persistent throughout the world, there are some people who want to harm the followers of other culture, and their wish is to promote their own culture into a dominant position that will be supported and followed by most of the people and places on the earth.
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
7STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE Security measures that are needed in Turkey: Turkey is said to strengthen its efforts in the realization of a safe zone in the area of Northern Syria as per the statement by the country’s National Security Council. This safe zone will ensure that all the refugees of Syria who fled in Turkey will be able to go backtotheirhomesassoonasthecircumstancespermitthemtodoso (Athanassopoulou,2013).Afterthat,turkeywillgainitsstrengthandwillnotbe hesitating to exert necessary measures that will ensure in the safety and security of the nation. This statement was made by the council President Recep Tayyip Erdogan. The U.S and Turkey have even agreed to work on this matter together in order to create a zone of buffer which will be free of fighters from the People’s Protection Units. The YPG controls some of the enclaves in the area of north east Syria along with the border of Turkey and hence forms a backbone of the U.S -led partnership in fighting the ISIS Islamic state situated in Syria(Clark, 2013). Erdogan also mentioned the shifting of the 3 million refugees who have made Turkey their home after fleeing from the terror of Syria. These refugees would be repatriated to that U.S safe zone. Turkey also needs to continue their operations in the north of Iraq until they are able to eliminate all the terrorists from that area and ensure security and safety of the country from that place. For this, Turkey also launched Operation Claw-3 in the north of Iraq that targets the PKK militants. There also have been disputes over gas and oil between the countries of Turkey andCyprus which havearoused tensions andthoseconflicts need to be resolved since Turkey’s Deployment of vessels in order to search for oil have actually prompted the EU to hit the state of Ankara with sanctions. Finally, Turkey will also have to continue with the military offensive in the area of north east Syria that targets the
8STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE Kurdish forces and that should continue until their goals are attained. Along with that, Turkey also needs to continue its fight with the Islamic state or ISIS and needs to have an open cooperation to end the existence of that terrorist group. Undertaken Security Measures in Turkey: There have been major extremist and terrorist incidents in Turkey that had compelled the country to strengthen their national security framework and intelligence. The Istanbul nightclub shooting that took place on 1stJanuary 2017 under the ISIS operative Abdulkadir Masharipov who is also known as Ebu Muhammed Horasani, killed a total of 39 people and also injured dozens of more people who were enjoying their New Year’s Day at the Istanbul’s Reina Night Club. The following, the ISIS claimed the responsibility of the attack and characterized the gunman of the incident as the “soldier of the caliphate”. On 10thof December, 2016 occurred the Vodafone Stadium Attack that resulted in the death of 44 innocent lives and wounded approximately 155 people. Two bombs were exploded outside the soccer stadium and along with that a car bomb was exploded near the central access of the stadium that also hit a police vehicle and on top of that a suicide bomber detonated himself in a park situated nearby while he was being enclosed by the police. These are just two examples of the terror attack that took place within a few days of time, but there have been numerous more. This is why it is so vital for the government of Turkey to come up with both domestic and international measures that would ensure maximum security of the people residing in the country.
9STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE Domestic Measures: Turkey is standing at the forefront of terror threat which is posed by some extremist organizations like the ISIS, the Kurdish PKK separatists and also some radical left-wing groups. Turkey does not differentiate between these groups officially; in fact, they are of the opinion that PKK and Daesh or the ISIS are the same. The government of Turkey has announced that they would consider stripping the Turkish terrorists off their citizenship and continue to actively work to eliminate them. As a matter of fact, Turkey possesses certain programs to oppose the extremist messages; first, there is a program of outreach that is TNP or the Turkey National Police administrated. It aims to avoid the radicalization through some prior association with the communities that are at risk. This program helps the police to reach the vulnerable residents who are bare to the fanatic half truths and messages. Secondly, there is a program which aims to weaken thebrutalradicalmessaginganditiscontrolledbythegovernmentofTurkey’s Directorate of Religious Affairs which is also known as the Diyanet. The Diyanet’s responsibility is to look over Turkey’s 85000 mosques and promote Islamism in its moderate version which in turn weakens the radical Islamic messaging. There are also Domestic Military Raids against the suspected terrorist targets employed by Turkey; in a series of such raids in July 2017, the security forces allegedly arrestednearabout213suspectedmembersofPKKalongwith46ISISlinked suspects.There were eight people who allegedly had associations with the leftist terroristgroups.AftertheoccurrenceofJuly2016attemptofcoup,Turkey’s government established a long state of emergency in the country that lasted for two years.TheHumanRightsOrganizationsblamedthegovernmentofTurkeyfor
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
10STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE coordinating some unlawful arrests, captivity and abduction. There were tortures of the Gulenists and other suspects of terrorist in Turkey, and in accordance to the interior ministry of Turkey, the authorities held around 35 thousand of suspected Gulenists between the time periods of 2ndJanuary 2017 to 30thof October, 2017. The Human Rights Watch have accused the government of Turkey with torment of the terror suspects and predominantly for those who were accused of having an attachment with the PKK or the FETO. The accusations included that the detentions of the terror suspect often relied on very limited proof and least due process. International Measures: Along with the domestic measures against extremism, it was necessary for the governmentofTurkeytosecurethenationthroughsomeInternationalcounter- extremism. In the year 2017, the government of Turkey announced that it was also undertaking measures to ensure the security of its border with that of Syria, Idlib because of the existence of the groups of terrorists alongside of Syria through a 90-mile border. As per the opinion of the then Prime Minister, Binali Yildrim, Turkey would take the measure of limiting the non- humanitarian supplies across its border. It was also announced that the border would remain open for the trade of the humanitarian goods but it will not allow any weapons to pass. As a matter of fact, Turkey also enhanced its military retort towards their cross- border terrorism. For instance, in the year 2017 in February, the army claimed that they hit 250 targets of ISIS on the side of the border of Turkey- Syria towards Syria and also ended up killing three of those targets. In January, 2018, Turkey initiated their hatred against the Kurdish commune in North West Syria that targeted the YPG Kurdish militia and the Turkish have always accused
11STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE them of posing a real threat to the country of Turkey. It was clearly warned by the government that the YPF would be completely eliminated from that area. In fact, the U.S helpedYPG when they were having a fight against the ISIS inSyria wherethe government of Syria warned that they would take down any jets of Turkey that would fly over Syria. The parliament of Turkey approved their military interference against the ISIS located in Syria and Iraq in the year 2014. It is important to note that Turkey is a originalmemberoftheGCTFortheGlobalCounterterrorismForumwhichisa multilateral and an informal counterterrorism platform; it was launched in the year 2011 in September in order to condense the susceptibility of people located everywhere, to the terrorism through effective, fighting and preventive acts and aimed at countering provocation and enrolment to the terrorism. The legislation of Turkey also mentions the international counter extremism through the Anti- Terror law; this law defines terrorism as any kind of act which aims to damage or change the distinctiveness of the republic that is specifically mentioned in the Constitution of Turkey including the internal as well as the external security of the State. Strategies for better security environment: There have been vast researches about the fact that whether or not Turkey is a rising power; few of the scholars have argued that Turkey is not a rising power and some have highlighted that the economy, foreign policy, position, regional influence and ties of Turkey with the West have actually helped it to sustain its rise. With this power, Turkey canimprovethenationalsecuritystrategy thatit hassinceitisaprime framework for any country, so that they can meet their essential needs and concerns
12STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE regarding security of the residents and also deal with any external and internal threat that is potentially disturbing the peace of the country. Turkey, along with focusing on the effectiveness of the providers of their security, should also look forward to incorporating numerous key issues as a way of making certain on their public authenticity, relevance and sustainability; along with that they should also facilitate their implementation of security and improve their security framework so that it is efficient of the kind of security that is being provided to the citizens of their country. There are key points that should help the country to improve the security framework and it should work efficiently within the country’s premises. Inside the country: Turkey can improve the security of the human that consists of understanding of the basic security requirements according to the requirements of the citizens and not in accordance to the needs of the government or the state. There are opinions that would help in enhancing the human security in the country; by building consensus around Turkey’s conceptualisation of security; it can also be done by incorporating views that is gathered from wide consultations of the public or from submissions from groups who belong to different section of the society. If the security of the people is included in the central importance of the national security framework, human security can be increased. Lastly, by keeping in mind the primary causes of the insecurity of the citizens as a part ofthestrategiestogaintheNationalStrategicSecurity,humansecuritycanbe enhanced. The central point of security and safety at a national level is the human rights; and not only in a national level, have human rights worked on individual as well as the
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
13STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE level of community. A human rights approach is strong that helps in the provision of a framework which helps in building partnerships with the communities and help them develop their resilience that in turn will help the country to address their security issues. Through explicit references in the National Strategic Security, the human rights can be enhanced, so that the obligation to human rights is reinforced in the overarching documents like the Constitution. Moreover, if the country commits to the elimination of any kind of violation of human rights within the justice services and security sector institutions, human rights can be improved. The human rights strategy can also be implemented if the national mechanisms are highlighted since it upholds the civil and international human rights form. The improvement of the justice system in the country is also one of the most important and effective national security strategies that would help the country to remain in peace. The justice System is a vital link that is linked with the criminal justice chain and is directly contributing to the factors that ensures the public order and safety is strengthened. It is important to note that justice system is something that helps in maintain a peaceful internal environment at the country. Outside the country: For strategies that would help in the betterment of security outside the country, Turkey can focus on the oversight and accountability of the sector of security since it is widely recognised as a norm in an international level. This strategy involves vigorous checks and also steadies and upholds the principles of accountability which donates strongly to the authenticity and ownership of National Strategic Security; it supports a more effective and capable usage of the resources and reinforces the honour of the institutions. A strong emphasis on responsibility and oversight can be achieved through
14STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE promotingthecommitmenttowardsaccountabilityandoversightasamediumof achieving the tactical goals; it can also be enhanced by outlining specific roles for the civil society and the mechanism that will allow them to contribute in an effective manner. Lastly accountability and oversight can be enhanced by incorporating and focusing on the roles of the Parliament. Gender may seem to a minute point but it is essential in ensuring peace and security in the country. It must be made sure that the specific desires of all groups of the populace is taken into description and according to the UN Security Council Resolution, equal participation along with the full participation of women in the act of preservation and promotion of peace and security should be allowed. Turkey would have to focus more on the gender equality and enhance their security framework. Another factor that is important in improving the security strategy is the coordination; safety and security can be achieved through the efforts of many factors, agencies and institutions working together, but poor coordination would lead to a failure in the step of the consideration of all the elements that contributes in the international as well as national security. There are options to enhance this coordination; it can be enhanced by detailing mechanisms of precise coordination of national security that would guide the agencies for opting diverse elements of the tactic. It can also be enhanced by stressing the need for all the agencies, especially those agencies that are not traditionally linked with security; it will help to include the execution of the strategic security framework into their sectoral plans. Finally, making the reference to a synchronized budgeting is an effective way to enhance coordination which would successfully help Turkey to achieve internal security aims.
15STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE Conclusion: The paper highlighted the kind of a circumstance that Turkey is in; the terrorism and acts of radical extremists has made the lives of the people of Turkey difficult. Moreover, there are 3 million refugees who fled from Syria to Turkey in search of a safe zone where they would remain alive and lead their lives. Thus, now Turkey along with the concern of their own citizens had to worry about the safety of the refugees as well and it was a big issue to resolve. The national security of Turkey demanded to be improved and strong enough to look after the securit6y of their country, their country people as well as the three million refugees. There have been numerous attacks from several terrorist groups in Turkey and it has led to loss of many innocent lives. The ISIS, the PKK and a leftist terror group have surrounded the area of Turkey in order to achieve their demands. Syria and Iraq are in a worse condition and Turkey has to look after the border that it shares with these countries in order to keep the terrorists at bay. However, there still have been many attacks like the one in the Night Club on 1st January, 2017 where innocent lives were lost. All of these attacks compelled Turkey to take serious steps in strengthening their security measures both inside and outside of their country border. The existing measures are also effective and have resulted into the arrest of thousands of suspects who are allegedly linked with the terrorist groups. They have also decided to strip off the suspects of terrorism from their citizenship in order to maintain security inside the country. At last it can be concluded that Turkey has security framework which are effective enough, but they need to have more strategically security framework to ensure maximum security and safety of the people and in order to that, their focus should be on the needs of the security of people and not focus on just the
Paraphrase This Document
Need a fresh take? Get an instant paraphrase of this document with our AI Paraphraser
16STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE security of the government or state. It must also be mentioned that there is also the option of UN Peacekeeping that keeps two or more countries in conflict to resolve their issues peacefully and meet in the midway to have the consent of both the parties. However,sincemostoftheconflictthatTurkeyhasiswiththeterroristgroups, peacekeeping are rarely an option. Due to the attacks that were done by terrorist and named as the act of their god, Turkey became determined to eliminate the terrorist group’s existence from their border and from their land.
17STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE References: Aras, N. E. G., &Mencütek, Z. Ş. (2015). The international migration and foreign policy nexus: the case of Syrian refugee crisis and Turkey.Migration letters,12(3), 193- 208. Arikan, H. (2017).Turkey and the EU: an awkward candidate for EU membership?. Routledge. Athanassopoulou, E. (2013).Turkey-Anglo-American security interests, 1945-1952: The first enlargement of NATO. Routledge. Aydın-Düzgit, S. (2013). European security and the accession of Turkey: Identity and foreignpolicy intheEuropeanCommission.CooperationandConflict,48(4), 522-541. Baev, P., & Kirişci, K. (2017).An ambiguous partnership: The serpentine trajectory of Turkish-Russian relations in the era of Erdoğan and Putin. Center on the United States and Europe at Brookings. Bilgin, P. (2013). Security in the Arab world and Turkey: dierently dierent. InffffThinking international relations differently(pp. 36-56). Routledge. Bilgin, P., & Ince, B. (2015). Security and citizenship in the global South: In/securing citizens in early republican Turkey (1923–1946).International Relations,29(4), 500-520.
18STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE Biresselioglu, M. E., Yildirim, C., Demir, M. H., &Tokcaer, S. (2017). Establishing an energy security framework for a fast-growing economy: Industry perspectives from Turkey.Energy research & social science,27, 151-162. Cihan, A. (2016). The private security industry in Turkey: Officer characteristics and their perception of training sufficiency.Security journal,29(2), 169-184. Clark, J. H. (2013). ‘My Life Is Like a Novel’: Embodied Geographies of Security in Southeast Turkey.Geopolitics,18(4), 835-855. Donelli, F. (2018). Syrian refugees in Turkey: a security perspective.New England Journal of Public Policy,30(2). Elik, S. (2013).Iran-Turkey Relations, 1979-2011: Conceptualising the Dynamics of Politics, Religion and Security in Middle-Power States. Routledge. Ensaroglu,Y.(2013).Turkey'sKurdishquestionandthepeaceprocess.Insight Turkey,15(2), 6. Esen, B., &Gumuscu, S. (2016). Rising competitive authoritarianism in Turkey.Third World Quarterly,37(9), 1581-1606. Esen, Ö. (2016). Security of the energy supply in Turkey: Prospects, challenges and opportunities.International Journal of Energy Economics and Policy,6(2), 281- 289. Fackrell, B. (2013). Turkey and Regional Energy Security on the Road to 2023.Turkish Policy Quarterly,12(2), 82.
Secure Best Marks with AI Grader
Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
19STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE GençoğluOnbaşi,F.(2015).SocialmediaandtheKurdishissueinTurkey:Hate speech, free speech and human security.Turkish Studies,16(1), 115-130. Hughes,J.(2013).Islamicextremismandthewarofideas:Lessonsfrom Indonesia(No. 592). Hoover Press. Jenkins,G.(2013).Contextandcircumstance:theTurkishmilitaryandpolitics. Routledge. Karabacak, B., Yildirim, S. O., & Baykal, N. (2016). Regulatory approaches for cyber security of critical infrastructures: The case of Turkey.Computer law & security review,32(3), 526-539. Kardaş, T., &Balci, A. (2016). Inter-societal security trilemma in Turkey: understanding the failure of the 2009 Kurdish Opening.Turkish Studies,17(1), 155-180. Kaygusuz, K., Toklu, E., &Avci, A. C. (2015). Energy security in a developing world: a case of Turkey.Journal of Engineering Research and Applied Science,4(1), 265- 277. Khachatryan, H. (2015). The Southern Gas Corridor and Turkey's Pipeline Politics at the Post-Cold War Period. Kibaroglu, M., &Sazak, S. C. (2015). Business as usual: The US‐Turkey security partnership.Middle east policy,22(4), 98-112. Köknar, A. M. (2018). Turkey and the Caucasus: Security and military challenges. InDangerous Neighborhood(pp. 91-122). Routledge.
20STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE Lemon,E.,&Thibault,H.(2018).Counter-extremism,powerandauthoritarian governance in Tajikistan.Central Asian Survey,37(1), 137-159. Luiijf,E.,Besseling,K.,&DeGraaf,P.(2013).Nineteennationalcybersecurity strategies.International Journal of Critical Infrastructures 6,9(1-2), 3-31. Martin, N. (2015).Security and the Turkey-EU accession process: Norms, reforms and the Cyprus issue. Springer. Özerdem, A., &Özerdem, F. (Eds.). (2013).Human Security in Turkey: Challenges for the 21st century. Routledge. Park, B. (2013).Modern Turkey: People, State and Foreign Policy in a Globalised World. Routledge. Rumelili, B. (Ed.). (2014).Conflict resolution and ontological security: Peace anxieties. Routledge. Ruth, A. (2017). Between East and West-Strategic Potential Analysis of Turkey. Sirkeci, I. (2017). Turkey’s refugees, Syrians and refugees from Turkey: a country of insecurity.Migration Letters,14(1), 127-144. Sirkeci, I., & Martin, P. L. (2014). Sources of irregularity and managing migration: the case of Turkey.Border Crossing,4(1-2), 1-16. Vellani, K. (2019).Strategic security management: a risk assessment guide for decision makers. CRC Press.
21STRATEGIC SECURITY WORK AND INTELLIGENCE Webber, M. (2013). Inclusion, exclusion and the governance of European security. Webber,M.(2013).Inclusion,exclusionandthegovernanceofEuropean security.