Evaluating the Governance Impacts of EITI in Azerbaijan and Liberia

The provided content is related to the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) in Azerbaijan and Liberia. The reports highlight the importance of transparency in the extractive industries sector, particularly in countries where natural resources are abundant. The EITI was established to promote transparency and accountability in the management of natural resources, which can help reduce corruption and improve governance. The reports discuss the challenges faced by the initiative in both countries, including a lack of trust between stakeholders and limited institutional capacity. However, they also highlight successes, such as improved data disclosure and increased public awareness about the extractive industries sector. Overall, the content emphasizes the importance of transparency in promoting good governance and reducing corruption in developing countries.

Running Head: Transparency in Oil Industry
Environmental Economics
Transparency in the oil industry

Transparency in Oil Industry 1
Table of Contents
Introduction....................................................................................................................................................1
Extractive Industry Transparency Initiative and the Resource Curse............................................................2
EITI in Azerbaijan.........................................................................................................................................5
EITI in Liberia.............................................................................................................................................11
Conclusion...................................................................................................................................................15
References....................................................................................................................................................17

Transparency in Oil Industry 2
Introduction
There has been a great recognition from the last decade of the significance of transparency. It is
required for the economic growth and the social development, especially for oil-producing
organizations. The continuous enhancement in the prices of the international oil over the last two
years, bring large benefits for different oil manufacturing countries. This also demands a greater
range of accountability and transparency from the broad range of stakeholders (Van Alstine,
2014). In this paper, we will study about the transparency level in the oil industry by studying the
role of extractive industry transparency initiative. This will help us in measuring the impact of
EITI on the transparency of oil industry in different countries. The Extractive industry
transparency initiative is work as a standard for bringing transparency in oil industries of
different countries. More than 50 countries work under the standards formulated by the EITI for
managing their oil industries. It provides international support in both consumer countries and
oil-producing countries (Obeng-Odoom, 2014). Its purpose is to enhance the level of voluntary
cooperation between civil society, private oil organizations, and governments to increase
transparency in the mining and oil sectors. In this paper, we analyze the level of transparency in
Azerbaijan and Liberia oil sector. It represents that while various efforts have already been taken
to strengthen the level of transparency, sustained and continued action is required to identify the
remaining gaps in these areas. Transparency is an essential task for the success of an
organization. Transparency is required to enhance accountability and to improve the use of oil
revenue or also strengthen the fiscal policies to meet the different development priorities of the
countries. Bringing transparency proves helpful in development and poverty reduction in a
country. Thus, it can be said that transparency is considered an important function in a particular
industry. Economic development and growth of a country mainly depend on the transparency

Transparency in Oil Industry 3
level of its existing companies. In the same manner, EITI also plays an important role in bringing
success and growth in the oil industry. The prevalence of corruption and poor transparency in
public management is not limited to oil-producing countries, but oil-rich economies appear to be
in this respect particularly vulnerable (Mahdavi, 2014). Efforts are made to enhance the
transparency level in the oil industry can, therefore, be instrumental in changing the complete
perceptions about governance in the different countries. Therefore, it is the responsibility of the
government of the countries to pay more attention towards the exhaustible nature of oil.
Extractive Industry Transparency Initiative and the Resource Curse
Extractive industry transparency initiative is considered as a global standard to promote the
accountable and open management of extractive resources. It mainly focuses on addressing the
main issues in the mining, oil and gas sectors (Azerbaijan Validation, 2016). On the other hand,
resource curse is considered as a paradoxical situation in which countries with non-renewable
resources experience large growth or even economic contraction. It can be said that resource
curse in a country occurs when they focus their energies on a single industry such as mining and
ignores the other available major sectors. The EITI is considered as a multi-stakeholder initiative
which involves different state-owned and multinational extractive organizations, home
governments, international financial institutions, civil society groups and investors, host
governments, and industry or business associations, which have formulated different means or
ways of revenue transparency (VALIDATION REPORT, 2015). It mainly concentrates on the
prudent utilization of natural resources wealth and concludes that the management of such
wealth should be exercised in the national development interests. It can be said that the EITI
mainly operates on the principle of independent, full, active and free measurement of the ways
that extractive organizations interact with government and influence society and communities.

Transparency in Oil Industry 4
During 2015, the 49 countries were reported to be in the process of implementing the EITI
(https://eiti.org/implementing_country/35#extractive-industries-contribution). Among these
countries, 33 are considered EITI compliant. Rest countries were known as the candidates of the
EITI. Due to the resource curse, a particular nation becomes completely dependent on the gross
domestic product or prices of different commodities. Mainly corruption in a particular country
occurs when the framework of income distribution and resource rights are not established in the
society. This will bring unfair practices and regulations in a particular industry.
The main proposal of the EITI is to publish revenue data to hold governments accountable. This
will motivate it to establish good practices to regulate the environment of different oil industries
in a significant manner (AZERBAIJAN EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES TRANSPARENCY
INITIATIVE 2014). EITI adopt efficient standards which state that wealth from a country's
natural resources should provide benefits to every citizen. Due to this reason, all standards are
developed by the EITI with more efficiency because it requires high standards of accountability
and transparency. Generally, the idea of EITI was initiated during 2002, but it was officially
established in 2003. It was established during the high-level meeting of different representatives,
industries, society groups and governments in the United Kingdom. This meeting was mainly
occurring on the formulation of different principles of EITI which will guide an oil and gas
industry in performing their day to day functions. It is mainly considered non-profit
organizations.
There are different drivers for compliance which helpful in bringing transparency in the oil and
gas industry. One of them is the regular publications of all necessary material of gas, oil and
mining payments by different organizations to governments and all types of revenue are received
by the governments from these organizations. It is the responsibility of the EITI to disseminate

Transparency in Oil Industry 5
that publication to a large number of potential audience and public. Second, when the wide
publications and such reporting is insufficient, revenues and payments are made to be a credible
or independent audit of reputable international standards. Another one is the international
recognition which enables EITI to bring such standards which prove its efficiency
(VALIDATION REPORT, 2015). There are different countries which want to be the part of the
EITI. Due to the international recognition, it needs to focus more on the efficiency of its
standards because they play an important role in the success of oil and gas industry of a
particular country. The fourth driver for compliance is investment attraction. Its efficiency
enables it to be the investment attraction of different countries. Most of the countries want to
invest in it so that they can take its membership, but only some countries are able to do so. Due
to high investment attraction capability, it is considered the very popular standard for success of
oil and growth industry. This success enhances the GDP of a particular country. Another
important driver is business environment improvement. Standards of the EITI brings
transparency in different functional activities of a particular country which ultimately leads
improvement in the business environment of different oil and gas organizations. Improvement in
the business environment brings various growth opportunity to get success in future
(https://eiti.org/sites/default/files/documents/2014_azerbaijan_eiti_report.pdf ).
There are approximate 51 implementing countries which try to become the member of the EITI.
It operates in fulfilment of its various objectives. The prime objective of the EITI is to grow the
demand-side of the social accountability by offering the public insight into revenues. All these
revenues are mainly generated from the exploitation of different mineral resources of different
countries. Another objective of the organization is to build a platform for the public debate by
focusing on the spending efficiency of extractive sector revenues. This can also be done by

Transparency in Oil Industry 6
measuring weaknesses and gap in resource revenue management. To maintain the efficiency of
the platform EITI provide various recommendations to stop any type of revenue leakage
(Sovacool, 2015). It also focusing on enhancing the efficiency in communication level of
GHEITI and also ensure that all information on mineral expenditure and revenue are provided on
a timely basis and in comprehensible and accessible format. All these objectives enforce it to
come up with latest and efficient standards with which it can accomplish its overall objectives
and ensuring long-term growth of different oil industries. It is continuously progressing day by
day and enforcing oil industry to gain long-term success in their countries. It established
different types of associations in different countries such as international development
association, an organization for economic cooperation and development, and international bank
for reconstruction and development. All these acts work as a positive sign in growth and
development of different countries (García‐Rodríguez, 2013). EITI proves helpful in uncovering
the financial irregularities and also provide a roadmap for different reforms of the mining, gas,
and oil industry sector. It also establishes the different stages for wider sector reforms like
institutional reforms and financial management reforms. The active participation of the civil
society organization also considered as important criteria and a condition for the success of the
standards enforced by the EITI to bring transparency in different functions of the oil and gas
industry sector. Thus, it can be said that resource curse and extractive industry transparency
initiative play an important role in bringing transparency in oil and gas industry of different
countries.
EITI in Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan is considered as the oldest oil producing nation of the world with natural gas reserves
of 1300 billion cubic meters or crude oil reserves of 7 billion barrels (Papyrakis, 2016). The

Transparency in Oil Industry 7
gross domestic product of the Azerbaijan is growing recent years, driven by growth in gas and
oil production through the current global price decline of oil influenced the overall economy of
the nation. The timeline of the Azerbaijan can understand with the help of below mentioned
figure:
(Source: https://eiti.org/implementing_country/35#extractive-industries-contribution)
The key projects of the Azerbaijan are the country's largest oil field Azeri-Chirag-Guneshli,
Baku-Tbilshi-Ceyhan oil pipeline to turkey, and the largest field of the natural gas Shah Deniz
contributes efficiently to the different profits of the government. Extractive industry plays an
efficient role in the growth of GDP of the country. The presence of EITI will lead 34.6% growth
in its GDP and also create 41,500 jobs opportunities to their citizens (B. K., 2016). Azerbaijan
joined the membership of EITI in 2003 and volunteered it wants to become a pilot country in the
implementation of the initiative. It is regularly managing a process of reconciling, disclosing, and

Transparency in Oil Industry 8
publishing payments of extractive sector organizations to the government and government
receipts from those organizations. The first EITI report of the Azerbaijan was published during
2005. In 2014, the EITI reported mainly focusing on implementation of the different initiative so
that report can be published as per the determined standards of EITI. Reconciliation is a process
led by the EITI initiatives. It brings recommendable growth in the economy of the country. After
reconciliation process, the net difference between the payment declared by the government and
the extractive organizations in their initial reports are shown in the below mentioned table:
(Source Azerbaijan annual report, 2014)

Transparency in Oil Industry 9
From the above-mentioned table, the significant difference between the oil and gas industries can
understand in an effective manner. Furthermore, it also contributed largely towards the
development of human. The human development index of the Azerbaijan can be understood by
following figures which are recently 0.751 and have 78th rank in the world (Human Development
Reports 2016):
((
(Source: UNDP, Human Development Index, 2016)
The coalition for improving the level of transparency in extractive industries was established in
2004 and Azerbaijan play an important role in the adoption of UN General Assembly resolution
on EITI in 2008 (Corrigan, 2014). EITI of Azerbaijan establish its objective every year in its
annual work plan. Its main focus has been on the disclosure and preparation of the annual EITI
report. In addition, it also focuses more on bringing awareness regarding EITI and exchange
experiences with other countries. Azerbaijan is producing good outcomes with the combination

Transparency in Oil Industry 10
of the EITI initiatives. It is producing various positive outcomes for its success. Its success can
easily measure with its economic data which are shown in the below mentioned table (Sovacool,
2016):
Estimated reserve of approximate 7 billion barrels
18 PSAs: 5 offshore, 12 onshore
Estimated production of approximated 870,000 bpd
Largest field of oil: Azeri-Chirag-Guneshli (650,000 bpd)
GDP during 2013 43.4%
Revenue from export was approximate 92%
65.8% of the budget during 2013
Recent worth of the SOFAZ $37 billion
Oil resources in the Azerbaijan have been developed after the 1800s. After that time period, the
country represents recommendable changes in its development. During 1985 to 1991, the GDP
of the country also shrank by 17% which will bring huge changes in the oil and gas industry of
the Azerbaijan (Bebbington, 2016). Governance performance score of the Azerbaijan can
understand by the following figure:

Transparency in Oil Industry 11
(Source: https://eiti.org/sites/default/files/documents/Sovacool%20%26%20Andrews
%20%5B2015%5D%20-%20Does%20transparency%20matter%20-%20%20Evaluating%20the
%20governance%20impacts%20of%20the%20Extractive%20Industries%20Transparency
%20Initiative%20(EITI)%20in%20Azerbaijan%20and%20Liberia.pdf)
The presence of EITI influences the development and governance of the country in a significant
manner. Availability of EITI helps the government of the country in collecting the necessary
information required for publication of payments from IOCs (Hawker, 2014). This will bring
positive outcomes for its success. It also enables the country in developing more government
accountability. This will reduce the transparency level of the expenditures which will
significantly influence its performance. It is necessary for a country to monitor its political
accountability which helpful in reducing the significant influence of different unforeseen factors.
On the other hand, social engagement of the country also created with the help of EITI.
Generally, it is said that presence of socio-political mischief works as a hurdle in building the
social engagement by implementing EITI (Hystad, 2014). It portrayed as an attempt to represent
the status quo and win the win the regime of an external respectability. On the home page of the
EITI, its president gives a statement that says "transparency will become one the important
ground for their success. All this brings efficiency in the management of different future
revenues of gas and oil and permits every citizen of the country to feel it in her or his daily life.
All this seems unclear because the country will not be able to reap the combined social, political
and economic beliefs regarding transparency. According to the independent evaluation of the
World Bank, it rates the EITI in Azerbaijan as highly effective in terms of profit transparency
measures. All these brings various growth opportunities for the oil and gas industry of the
country which ultimately enhance the GDP growth rate of the country.

Transparency in Oil Industry 12
The significant influence of the EITI of the Azerbaijan from last twelve years is that it provided
required and credible data, which further helpful in understanding the most important sector of
the Azerbaijan economy and is an important tool for the policy debate and analysis of macro-
environment (García‐Rodríguez, 2013). The main motive of the EITI in Azerbaijan is to bring
transparency to the nature of the extractive revenue processes. President Aliyev of the country
said that transparency is the main focus of their oil and gas industry because it plays an important
role in forming different types of oil strategies. Furthermore, EITI in Azerbaijan brings
considerable success in the form of a genuinely multi-stakeholder dialogue process, and also
brings lots of opportunities for the government of the country as well as its civil society
organizations. During October 2016 the board of the EITI found that Azerbaijan had made
recommendable progress with the implementation of the different EITI standards with
considerable improvements across its different requirements (Otusanya, 2014). Thus, it can be
said that EITI standards play an important role in bringing significant improvements in the oil
and gas industry performance of Azerbaijan country. This development will bring significant
growth opportunities in its near future which ultimately enhance its GDP productivity.
EITI in Liberia
Liberia is considered as a candidate of the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative
candidate since and was the first African country to become EITI compliant in 2009. The
process of the Liberia EITI mainly covers the four important areas which are mining, agriculture,
forestry, and petroleum. The main objective of the Liberia EITI is to assist in ensuring that all
benefits due to the people of Liberia and government on account of the exploitation or extraction
of the mineral and other resources of the country. EITI of the Liberia manages a broad coalition
of stakeholders and also manages a body of multi-stakeholders by keeping in mind all the rules

Transparency in Oil Industry 13
and regulations fixed under the LEITI Act 2009. The republic of the Liberia is considered a west
African country which is surrounded by Ivory Coast, Guinea, and Sierra Leone. It is the only
African country to have been colonizing by the United States. The government of the Liberia
takes various steps to improve the transparency level among the industries as well as the other
business organizations. Improvement in transparency level can bring various growth opportunity
for the country as well as to its citizens. For this purpose, the government of the country
launched the international donors and various other governance programs in 2005. All these
programs are launched with the partnership of some international donors and the government
institutions. But during the 14 years of the war, all big mines are shut down by the government
and the contribution of the mineral sectors was reduced to a negligible level. During 2010,
Liberia shows an attractive progress in reviving the mining sectors. This is the sector which gives
more than 65% contribution towards the export earning of the country and also represented 25%
of the GDP of the country (Stephens, 2013) . The progress of the mining sector is enhanced after
the expansion of the iron ore production. Furthermore, it also contributed largely towards the
development of human. The human development index of the Liberia can be understood by
following figures which are recently 0.43 and have 117th rank in the world (Human Development
Reports, 2016):

Transparency in Oil Industry 14
(Source: UNDP, Human Development Index, 2016)
Liberia has been the member of the EITI since 14 October 2009 after completing its validation in
2009. Now, Liberia has published more than 4 reports for its different fiscal years. EITI of
Liberia is running by a government body known as the Multi-Stakeholders Steering Group
(LIBERIA EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES TRANSPARENCY INITIATIVE, 2009) The EITI act of
the Liberia formulated a structure mandate for the every function of the EITI at the national
level. This group includes different members such as minister of finance, energy, lands, mines,
internal affairs, and the different types of civil societies. Minister of finance is considered as the
head of the group who is responsible for every decision of the group (Strauss, 2015). The EITI of
Liberia also has some different secretariat that is formulated, supported and associated with the
group. the members of the group mainly serve only for three years. The sector which is under the
scope of the group is natural gas, oil, forestry, and agriculture sectors. All these sectors are
determined by the government of the country.

Transparency in Oil Industry 15
Development and governance of the country have a significant influence on the EITI
performance of the Liberia. With the help of EITI, the country can easily access to all necessary
information which helps them in making different types of decisions. It mainly includes
publication of contracts, the inclusion of different sectors like agriculture, and oil sector, or
agreements and concessions on the EITI website of the Liberia. Furthermore, it also influences
the accountability of the government towards its different decisions like EITI in the national
legislature and the mechanisms of enforcement. All these facilitates fruitful benefits in the
economy of the country as well as its future economic growth. The foremost and significant
impact of the EITI on the country is its civil society engagement. It helps the government in the
diffusion of anti-corruption norms. Thus, it can be said that EITI influences the growth and
development of a country in a significant manner. Governance performance score of the
Azerbaijan can understand by the following figure (Sovacool, 2015):
(Source: https://eiti.org/sites/default/files/documents/Sovacool%20%26%20Andrews
%20%5B2015%5D%20-%20Does%20transparency%20matter%20-%20%20Evaluating%20the
%20governance%20impacts%20of%20the%20Extractive%20Industries%20Transparency
%20Initiative%20(EITI)%20in%20Azerbaijan%20and%20Liberia.pdf)

Transparency in Oil Industry 16
It can be said that transparency in a country brings various opportunities for the growth of the
country. But, it also has some limitations which work as a hurdle in the way of the success of a
country such as transparency mainly focuses on the extractive revenues which are not sufficient
to measure the success of the country. Furthermore, it is considered as a voluntary mechanism
which brings various problems in the success of a country. In addition, the data produced by the
transparency level of an organization is poor in quality which sometimes misleads the
government of the country about the financial outputs of different sectors. This will create
misunderstanding in the mind of ministers as well as the citizens.
In spite of such limitations, it also brings various achievement opportunities for the country such
as it enhance the level of interaction and dialogue between different stakeholder group which
leads better decision and better outcomes in the near future (LIBERIA EXTRACTIVE
INDUSTRIES TRANSPARENCY INITIATIVE, 2009) In addition, it is also strengthening the civil
society which gives ultimate benefits to the country and it can grow continuously in its near
future.
Conclusion
After studying all this, we can conclude that EITI brings significant growth opportunities for the
success of both countries as well as the other countries. It can be said that the EITI affirms the
import and power of information. EITI also ensure that there should be complete participation
from the civil society of the country so that it can implement with the desired motive (Mahdavi,
2014). One of the foremost weakness is that the different available stakeholders are expected to
work in such type of countries where civil society is not firmly established. It is required to
change the inertia of the status quo for both countries. Thus, it can be said that having

Transparency in Oil Industry 17
transparency in the different functions of the organization proves very beneficial for the success
of every country. It not only brings growth opportunities but also improves the performance level
of the GDP of countries.

Transparency in Oil Industry 18
References
Azerbaijan 2016 Validation | Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative. (2016). Eiti.org.
Retrieved from https://eiti.org/validation/azerbaijan/2016
VALIDATION REPORT: Azerbaijan. (2015). Retrieved from
https://eiti.org/sites/default/files/documents/AZERBAIJAN%20VALIDATION%20FINAL
%20REPORT_RCS_15_04_10v2_0.pdf
Azerbaijan | Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative. Eiti.org. Retrieved from
https://eiti.org/implementing_country/35#extractive-industries-contribution
AZERBAIJAN EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES TRANSPARENCY INITIATIVE. (2014).
Retrieved from https://eiti.org/sites/default/files/documents/2014_azerbaijan_eiti_report.pdf
Sovacool, B. & Andrews, N. Resources Policy. Retrieved from
https://eiti.org/sites/default/files/documents/Sovacool%20%26%20Andrews%20%5B2015%5D
%20-%20Does%20transparency%20matter%20-%20%20Evaluating%20the%20governance
%20impacts%20of%20the%20Extractive%20Industries%20Transparency%20Initiative
%20(EITI)%20in%20Azerbaijan%20and%20Liberia.pdf
|Human Development Reports. (2016). Hdr.undp.org. Retrieved 12 December 2016, from
http://hdr.undp.org/en/countries/profiles/AZE
Van Alstine, J. (2014). Transparency in resource governance: The pitfalls and potential of “new
oil” in Sub-Saharan Africa. Global Environmental Politics, 14(1), 20-39.
Obeng-Odoom, F. (2014). Measuring what?“success” and “failure” in Ghana's oil
industry. Society & Natural Resources, 27(6), 656-670.

Transparency in Oil Industry 19
Mahdavi, P. (2014). Why do leaders nationalize the oil industry? The politics of resource
expropriation. Energy Policy, 75, 228-243.
Otusanya, O. J., Lauwo, S., & Bakre, O. M. (2014). Extractive Industry Transparency Initiative:
a utopia in oil and mining industry in developing countries. In Critical Perspectives on
Accounting Conference, York University, Toronto. July (pp. 7-9).
García‐Rodríguez, F. J., García‐Rodríguez, J. L., Castilla‐Gutiérrez, C., & Major, S. A. (2013).
Corporate social responsibility of oil companies in developing countries: from altruism to
business strategy. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 20(6), 371-
384.
Hystad, S. W., Bartone, P. T., & Eid, J. (2014). Positive organizational behavior and safety in the
offshore oil industry: Exploring the determinants of positive safety climate. The journal of
positive psychology, 9(1), 42-53.
Hawker, G. (2014). The Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative: African lessons for
Australia.
Bebbington, A., Arond, E., & Dammert, J. L. (2016). Scalar politics and transnational
governance innovations: A political settlements lens on the Extractive Industries Transparency
Initiative in the Andes.
B. K., Walter, G., Van de Graaf, T., & Andrews, N. (2016). Energy Governance, Transnational
Rules, and the Resource Curse: Exploring the Effectiveness of the Extractive Industries
Transparency Initiative (EITI). World Development, 83, 179-192.

Transparency in Oil Industry 20
Corrigan, C. C. (2014). Breaking the resource curse: Transparency in the natural resource sector
and the extractive industries transparency initiative. Resources Policy, 40, 17-30.
Sovacool, B. K., & Andrews, N. (2015). Does transparency matter? Evaluating the governance
impacts of the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) in Azerbaijan and
Liberia. Resources Policy, 45, 183-192.
Papyrakis, E., Rieger, M., & Gilberthorpe, E. (2016). Corruption and the extractive industries
transparency initiative. The Journal of Development Studies, 1-15.
Stephens, M. (2013). LIBERIA EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES TRANSPARENCY INITIATIVE.
Retrieved from
http://www.leiti.org.lr/uploads/2/1/5/6/21569928/leiti_post_award_process_audit_final_report.pd
f
Strauss, T. (2015). Liberia Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative: Strategic Plan.
Retrieved from http://www.leiti.org.lr/uploads/2/1/5/6/21569928/approved_strategic_plan.pdf
LIBERIA EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES TRANSPARENCY INITIATIVE. (2009). Retrieved 13
December 2016, from http://www.leiti.org.lr/uploads/2/1/5/6/21569928/act.pdf

Transparency in Oil Industry 21