Analysis of Victorian Women Health and Wellbeing Strategy 2010

This essay provides a detailed analysis of the Victorian Women Health and Wellbeing Strategy 2010, focusing on its objectives, positive and negative impacts on women's health, and its relationship with the United Nations' acts on human rights. The essay explores the policy's necessity for human rights restrictions, preconditions for meeting these restrictions, and the efficiency of health structures in implementing the policy. Furthermore, it examines the systems of monitoring, evaluation, accountability, and redress to ensure the policy progresses toward its intended purpose and addresses adverse effects. The analysis also discusses the strategy's emphasis on family planning, reproductive health, and the prevention of violence against women, highlighting both its strengths and limitations, and its potential for promoting gender equality and women's empowerment within the Victorian context. The essay concludes by assessing the overall effectiveness of the strategy in achieving its goals and contributing to the well-being of women.

VICTORIAN WOMEN HEALTH AND WELL-BEING STRATEGY 2010
(Author’s name)
(Institutional Affiliation)
1

Table of Content
1 Introduction..............................................................................................................................3
1.1 Victorian Women Health and Well-Being Strategy 2010........................................................4
2 Purpose for Discovery of Victorian Women Health Policy and Wellbeing 2010....................6
3 Ways and Extent to Which the Policy Impact Positively and Negatively On Health..............7
4 Relationship between Impacts of Victorian Women Health Policy and the United Nations
(UN) Acts on Human Rights...........................................................................................................8
5 The Policy Necessitate Human Rights Restriction...................................................................9
6 Preconditions Meeting the Restrictions of the Rights............................................................10
7 Efficiency of Health and Other Structures and Services in Implementing the Policy...........11
8 Systems of Monitoring, Evaluation, Accountability and Redress Exit That Will Ensure the
Policy Progress towards Intended Purpose and Those Adverse Effects Can Be Acted Upon......12
9 Conclusion..........................................................................................................................13
10 Work Cited..........................................................................................................................14
2

1 Introduction
Human rights are intrinsic to all humans across the globe. Fundamental human rights are
universal, and every individual is equally entitled to their rights without discrimination. Human
rights promote the elimination of negative stereotypes, injustices, marginalization, and
discrimination that has been overburdened on other individuals due to societal prejudices. The
existence of human rights influences the relationships between citizens and the government
power exercise over its citizens (Donnelly and Whelan 2017).Nonetheless; human rights are
limited as States have an obligation of providing some rights while at the same time safeguarding
citizen’s freedom. Some of the greatest milestones that human rights have helped all
communities across the globe to achieve are women and persons with disability empowerment
politically, economically, socially and culturally. Human rights have therefore helped to
significantly reduce inequalities within the society especially in areas where patriarchy is the
norm and women rights have been ignored. Through human rights, women have gained access
to, control over and decision-making power on matters about their own life; a privilege most
women had missed for centuries (Kim and Johnson 2011). Human rights ideology is therefore
geared towards achieving sustainability which will promote economic, social, political and
cultural development across the globe without discriminating certain individuals. The future fate
of human rights seems promising as many people are aware of their rights.
1.1 The Human Rights Focus
The human rights major focus is on universal values. The universal values of human
rights focus on: equality, equity and non-discrimination, interdependence and indivisibility and
the rights and obligations of the right owners and duty bearers. State responsibility in protecting
human rights requires states to protect individuals and groups against injustices or any form of
3

abuse. It is the responsibility of the state to take, formulate and implement affirmative action that
will endorse the gratification of human rights (Nonet 2017). International human rights treaties
ratification has prompted governments to establish domestic measures and legislation that
matches their legislative obligations and duties which are guaranteed under international human
rights laws (Nonet 2017).
Human rights focus allows individuals opportunity to express their dissatisfaction at
regional and international levels. Global rights focus on women and persons with disability and
the societal stereotypes that have disadvantaged women. Human rights focus dealing with
women rights has uplifted women from private sphere participation to public domain
participation thus granting women right to education and health. For instance, the right to
education has created awareness among women thus leading to economic, social and political
empowerment (Deere and De Leal 2014). Right to health has prompted women access to
information on contraception, protected women from environmental hazards and allowed them
general access to health services. One of the most re-known policies that have promoted human
rights while at the same time promoting health is the Victorian women health policy and well-
being strategy that aims at safeguarding women health
2 Victorian Women Health and Well-Being Strategy 2010
Victorian women and health policy 2010 is an Australian government policy that is
aimed at preserving the health rights of Victoria state women. The strategy is a four-year term
plan developed by the health department and designed to improve women health and wellbeing
(Blank and Burau 2013). The strategy was established for all women in Victoria State with the
intent of identifying health concerns and outcome of women unable to afford healthcare due to
inadequate income. The Victorian women health policy gives priority to women sexual and
4

reproductive health issues. Other functions of the strategy are to collaborate with other social
bodies in preventing all forms of violence against women by prioritizing work at the health
sector through rehabilitating, creating awareness and providing shade of domestic violence
victims. The essence of Victoria Women health policy is, therefore, more geared towards
tackling avoidable illnesses and deaths that affect Victorian women (Blank and Burau 2013). The
development of Victoria Women Health Policy and Wellbeing strategy was facilitated and
spearheaded by a committee of professionals who consults widely on the state and basic needs of
women about their health and well-being.
Besides focusing on women who cannot afford medical access, the strategy also focuses
on women who have been mainstreamed in accessing health services by identifying better health
services for women and linking the health services together to improve the outcome of women
(Whv.org.au.2017). The Victorian women health policy and well-being have helped improve the
livelihood and well-being of women by creating awareness on disease prevention, providing free
medical services and enhancing greater employment opportunities for women. The major
strength of the strategy is its highlight and determination to support women from a younger age
as twelve years old. The organization slogan is based on the belief that positive development of
women health is not only a plan but rather a contemporary plan that is geared towards
developing a better future for women by encouraging positive health values adaption and
resilience (Hub for health service and Business 2017). The organization supports health
resilience by identifying the different issues that women undergo in the quest for accessing
health facilities and by focusing on the poor health outcomes among women. Secondly, the
organization also addresses women major health concerns and their wellbeing throughout their
lifespan.
5

3 Purpose for Discovery of Victorian Women Health Policy and Wellbeing 2010
The principal reason for discovering the strategy was to advocate for family planning among
Victorian women by protecting women sexual and reproductive health. The policy slogan is
based on care, education, and advocacy for women with lower health outcomes (Browne et al.
2016). Other three major areas that the strategy was created to defend when it comes to women
health was chronic illness and injury, violence against women and their mental health (Grych et
al. 2015). The family planning departments of the central strategy target are women from the
ages of twelve as these are sexually active individuals. The family planning department allows
women the right to exercise reproductive health over their life by enabling them to make
decisions on the appropriate time they want to get children and the number of children they want
to have (Sonfield et al. 2014).
The strategy has also linked sexual and reproductive health to mental illness, chronic
diseases, violence, and injury. This is because; most women are more prone to sexual injustices
which exposes them to violence, injury and mental illness regarding depression and post-trauma
after sexual, violent acts (Motz 2016). The aim of the strategy is, therefore, to join the four
policies together in diversifying women through creating reproductive health awareness and
providing health services responsive to Victoria's marginalized and disadvantaged women.
Finally, the policy was discovered for health social determinant purpose where the Family
Planning Victoria entrusted the government with the work of analyzing and determining the state
of women health.
6

4 Ways and Extent to Which the Policy Impact Positively and Negatively On Health
The policy impacts positively on women as it advocates for the sexual and reproductive health of
women by linking the challenges women undergo as a result of poor reproductive health
outcome. The Strategy is embedded on the belief that that violating women sexual right exposes
them to chronic illnesses such as Sexually Transmitted infections and cancers. Secondly, women
who lack reproductive rights don't have control and decision-making power family planning; the
strategy educates, advocate and create awareness to women from the age of twelve on family
planning. Thirdly, the strategy understands that women who lack childbirth decision-making
power and women who undergo sexual abuse are more prone to suffer mental disturbances due
to depression and trauma (Kleppe 2016). The strategy aims at rehabilitating women in such
scenarios. Personally, I believe that the strategy is an empowerment action that is likely to
promote women dignity and give them the right to freely express their sexual desires,
frustrations, and interests thus allowing them an opportunity to participate in other matters of
concerns within the society.
Nonetheless, the strategy has focused so much on women and ignored the interests. The
approach fails to understand that quality reproductive health is one which focuses on the needs of
both men and women and goes beyond the absence of disease and emotional illness to rational
and emotional dimensions. Separating men and females health policies promotes marginalization
and stigmatization due to population assumption. In most instances, Men are always the assumed
population. Assuming men sexual reproductive health and focusing on women may not be
effective as when all genders are involved (Alexander et al. 2016). It is important to note that the
positive and adverse effects of reproductive health occur differently in all populations and
impacts the same way severely on the entire population. The Victorian state should, therefore,
7

advocate for equity among women and men in promoting their sexual and reproductive health
rights.
5 Relationship between Impacts of Victorian Women Health Policy and the United
Nations (UN) Acts on Human Rights
The UN acts of human rights in 2012, declared contraception a universal fundamental
human right, an implication that the rights should benefit everyone (Roosevelt, 2001). Even so,
the Victorian women health policy has proven discriminative in two ways; first, it only helps
women. Secondly, it is limited to women within the Victorian of Australia. All the same, the
policy well targets; it is over-inclusive as it targets women as young as twelve years old. Besides
it allows women opportunity to participate in matters affecting their lives by combining more
and less restrictive, coercive and punitive policies. Restricted and coercive policies are used in
instances where a situation poses harm to an individual wellbeing. Less restrictive and coercive
policies are used as alternative humane policies in cases where the programs aim at reaching a
particular objective. For instance, the Victoria women health and well-being use advocacy,
education and care policy strategies as an alternative policy to enhancing the program
effectiveness (Michau et al. 2015).
Alternative humane policies emphasize on the main vision of a program agenda thus making
it readily achievable. The policy has proven to be under inclusive as it focuses sexually related
illness and ignoring other diseases those impacts on human the same way. Policies can be both
inclusive and under inclusive depending on the matter of concern. For instance, The Victorian
state has implemented a policy where commercial sex workers are penalized with intent of
reducing STI'S, yet their agent is not penalized (Hextell 2017). This policy is under-inclusive
because it targets a vulnerable population yet sexual behaviors occur with the participation of
8

other members such as commercial sex agents and clients. The policy is over inclusive as it
considers the fact that not all sex workers are infected, it, therefore, advocate for safe sex
practice and clients access to information on potential risks associated with commercial sex.
6 The Policy Necessitate Human Rights Restriction
The policy is essential as it protects women from all sexual violence, makes provisions
for treatments against post-sexual violence outcomes, creates awareness on reproductive health
and provides marginalized and disadvantaged women with appropriate medical facilities. On the
contrary, the policy itself is a restriction on human rights especially the women rights as it
imposes certain policies on women on the grounds of protecting human rights. For instance, the
policy fosters compulsory admission and detention of women who undergo serious violence
issues as they administer treatment and investigate on certain criminal activities that may be
associated with the sexual violation. The rights restrict individual freedom to the movement as
people movements may be limited within a hospital premise due to illness or at a rehabilitation
center for necessary medication and due to the impacts of mental diseases that arise due to post
sexual violence trauma (Humanrights.gov.au.2017). The policy necessitates human rights
restriction as it protects victim's information from third-party access. Nevertheless, hiding
information from close family members or relatives may be risky, the program may, therefore,
be considered restrictive in such scenarios. The World Health organization treaty argues that
reproductive health rights should be enjoyable and equitable granted to every individual (World
Health Organization 2014). The policy only advocates for women reproductive assuming that of
men, it 's hard to achieve reproductive health sustainability when one group is excluded from
reproductive health awareness creation.
9

7 Preconditions Meeting the Restrictions of the Rights
Human rights maybe are limited and restricted to safeguard the life of an individual
without their consent. For instance, victims of sexual violence might be coerced into a certain
form of medication without their approval or knowledge of the medication. People are prescribed
medication without their knowledge in instances where the condition is a threat to their survival.
Secondly, the freedom of movement may be restricted whereby an individual is at risk or under
legal command where the law necessities a solitary confinement within an area during a case
investigation (Upshur 2002). Thirdly, freedom of movement is restricted by medical conditions
where an individual is under a medical condition that may cause harm to other people or may to
the person on medication. For example, patients with chronic illness may be limited to
movement at an advanced stage due to the critical medical conditions that require close
supervision and attention.
On the other hand, patients with mental illness such as post-traumatic trauma and
depression may be restricted within a rehabilitation center as their actions or response to stress
management may expose them to actions that can harm other people. For example, individuals
under stress may engage in disturbing activities such as drug abuse, may attempt suicide or
inflict pain on other people as a way of relieving themselves from stress. Lastly, certain
individual’s rights may be restricted by prioritizing other people’s rights than others despite the
laws. For example, Women rights have often been given more priority than that of men in most
societies; this is because women have been constrained by societal norms from accessing certain
rights. However, the globalization and women empowerment agenda has given women more
priorities than men with the intent of helping women attain equality and rise from societal
10

drawbacks. Women rights can therefore not be similar to men rights as they are not
homogeneous beings (Dudgeon and Inhorn 2004).
8 Efficiency of Health and Other Structures and Services in Implementing the Policy
Health programs are effective in implementing the Victoria women policy, and well-
being as health programs such as reproductive health programs share the same vision of
education, care, and advocacy in family planning. Health programs provide women with
necessary contraceptives and educate them on them of such contraceptives. Likewise, structures
such as the Australian bill of rights provide a provision for women access to contraceptives and
decision-making on family planning patterns about their lives (Shahnaz 2017). Even so, high
pricing on contraceptive and medication may prevent the Victoria women health and well-being
policy from being effective as most women are not able to afford to afford contraceptive cost
despite the program strategy in caring for their contraceptive needs. Alternatively, the Victoria
health program, the bill of rights, the health and government structures may provide all necessary
provisions for better contraception but still fail to achieve its reproductive health agenda due to
individual attitudes, cultural and religious belief against a particular form of contraception. All in
all, the factors and strategies for health and policy implementation is not the same across all
cultures, populations, and ages. Thus the policy implementation process may differ depending on
an individual conviction on what is best for them (Kass and Beyrer 2007).
11

9 Systems of Monitoring, Evaluation, Accountability and Redress Exit That Will Ensure
the Policy Progress towards Intended Purpose and Those Adverse Effects Can Be
Acted Upon
Rights systems on health programs can be monitored through establishing a framework of
supervision, research and data collection which will enable stakeholders to analyze the progress
of the health program implementation. For instance, the effectiveness of the policy application
and success can be determined by supervising on how providers educate, supply and guide
people in implementing the program. The policy can also be monitored through gathering data
on how individuals are responding to the program by researching on the impact of the program
on beneficiaries. The collected research and analysis should be evaluated by different
professional neutral parties to attain genuine and none biased research. All stakeholders and
external stakeholders should be held responsible for the outcomes of the program
implementation process. The information shall be shared with interested parties and disseminate
to members y their departmental leaders; this is aimed at promoting easy access to policy
implementation report and for accountability purposes on awareness creation. Challenges that
arise from the policy implementation process will be redressed by conducting an evaluation
analysis of the policy expectations, where the team shall analyze and determine its effectiveness
in fulfilling the program vision. Stakeholders shall then brainstorm and conduct further research
on better ways to enhance the program effectiveness.
12

10 Conclusion
Human rights health policies are essential as it promotes an individual well-being while
at the same time protecting the health status of individuals. Human rights are universal but not
homogeneous to all persons due to race, gender, religion, and culture. All the same, certain rights
are similar among groups of individuals or populations. For instance, the reproductive health
policy has similar provisions for all women across the world. Over the years, women have fall
victims of violation, discrimination, and marginalization. Fortunately, the rise of globalization
has promoted women empowerment and allowed women privileges that never existed before.
Victoria women health and well-being is an example of one of the rights that women enjoy as a
result of globalization. However, women empowerment strategy should not diminish men; it
should be based on an equity approach where both men and women enjoy globalization benefits
at a fairly.
13

11 Work Cited
Alexander, L.L., LaRosa, J.H., Alexander, W. and Bader, H., 2016. New dimensions in women's
health. Jones & Bartlett Publishers.
Blank, R.H., and Burau, V., 2013. Comparative health policy. Palgrave Macmillan.
Browne, Varcoe, Lavoie and Smye, V et al., 2016. Enhancing health care equity with
Indigenous populations: evidence-based strategies from an ethnographic study. BMC health
services research, 16(1), p.544.
Deere, C.D., and De Leal, M.L., 2014. Empowering women: Land and property rights in Latin
America. The university of Pittsburgh Pre.
Donnelly, J. and Whelan, D.J., 2017. International human rights. Westview Press.
Dudgeon, M.R. and Inhorn, M.C., 2004. Men's influences on women's reproductive health:
medical anthropological perspectives. Social science & medicine, 59(7), pp.1379-1395
Grych, J., Hamby, S. and Banyard, V., 2015. The resilience portfolio model: Understanding
healthy adaptation in victims of violence. Psychology of Violence, 5(4), p.343.
Hextell, W. (2017). Sex Work. [online] Hivlegal.ashm.org.au. Available at:
http://hivlegal.ashm.org.au/index.php/guide-to-australian-hiv-laws-and-policies-for-healthcare-
professionals/sex-work [Accessed 2 Oct. 2017].
Hub for health service and Bussiness, V. (2017). Victorian public health and wellbeing plan
2015-19. [online] Www2.health.vic.gov.au. Available at:
https://www2.health.vic.gov.au/about/health-strategies/public-health-wellbeing-plan [Accessed 2
Oct. 2017].
14

Humanrights.gov.au. (2017). Freedom of movement | Australian Human Rights Commission.
[online] Available at: https://www.humanrights.gov.au/freedom-movement [Accessed 2 Oct.
2017].
Kass, N. and Beyrer, C., 2007. Human Rights and Public Health Ethics. Public Health and
Human Rights: Evidence-Based Approaches, p.362.
Kim, A.S. and Johnston, S.C., 2011. Global variation in the relative burden of stroke and
ischemic heart disease. Circulation, pp.CIRCULATIONAHA-111.
Kleppe, A.E., 2016. Tactics of Sexual Control and Negative Health Outcomes (Doctoral
dissertation, University of South Florida).
Michau, L., Horn, J., Bank, A., Dutt, M. and Zimmerman, C., 2015. Prevention of violence
against women and girls: lessons from practice. The Lancet, 385(9978), pp.1672-1684.
Motz, A., 2016. The psychology of female violence: Crimes against the body. Routledge.
Nonet, P., 2017. Law and society in transition: Toward responsive law. Routledge.
Roosevelt, E., 2001. Universal declaration of human rights. Applewood Books.
Shahnaz Kohan, S. (2017). Association between women's autonomy and family planning
outcome in couples residing in Isfahan. [online] PubMed Central (PMC). Available at:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4223960/ [Accessed 2 Oct. 2017].
Sonfield, A., Hasstedt, K. and Gold, R.B., 2014. Moving forward: Family planning in the era of
health reform.
Upshur, R.E., 2002. Principles for the justification of public health intervention. Canadian
Journal of Public Health/Revue Canadienne de Sante'e Publique, pp.101-103.
Whv.org.au. (2017). Victorian women's health and wellbeing strategy 2010-2014 - Women's
Health Victoria. [online] Available at: http://whv.org.au/publications-resources/publications-
15

resources-by-topic/post/victorian-women-s-health-and-wellbeing-strategy-2010-2014/ [Accessed
2 Oct. 2017].
World Health Organization, 2014. Ensuring human rights in the provision of contraceptive
information and services: guidance and recommendations. World Health Organization
16