Report: Argumentation Analysis of E-Commerce Research Articles

This report presents an argumentation analysis of three e-commerce research articles. The first article, by Angelina, Hermawan, and Suroso (2019), examines the DeLone and McLean model to analyze e-commerce success, focusing on data quality and user fulfillment in the context of Lazada, Bukalapak, and Shopee. The second article, by Shao (2020), employs a case study methodology to compare and contrast Alibaba and Amazon in cross-border e-business, highlighting their similarities and differences in market strategies and distribution. The third article, by Yang, Wang, and Chen (2017), investigates the current research trends in e-commerce, identifying key academic settings and influential research papers. The analysis compares the findings, results, and methodologies of these three articles, providing insights into the current state of e-commerce research and its diverse approaches to understanding online business models, consumer behavior, and market dynamics. The report concludes by synthesizing the key takeaways from each article, highlighting their interconnections and contributions to the broader field of e-commerce.

Running head: ARGUMENTATION ANALYSIS
ARGUMENTATION ANALYSIS
Name of the Student:
Name of the University:
Author’s Note:

1ARGUMENTATION ANALYSIS
Article 1:-
This article aims to examine the connection between data quality, structural quality and
dealing quality to consumer use and fulfillment. Besides, the study objects to investigate the
connection between user fulfillment and use to a net profit (Angelina, Hermawan and Suroso
2019). This research also states that effective e-commerce must be balancing with a decent
information structure. This study also developed the factors which can affect the achievement,
counting McLean and DeLone. This study also develops some variables of the e-commerce
success model. The variable is system quality, use, information quality, e-commerce success,
user fulfillment, service quality, and clear advantage (Angelina, Hermawan and Suroso 2019).
This research is applying McLean and DeLone model. The research findings state that the four
hypotheses were relevant in Lazada, Bukalapak, and Shopee. At last, this article concludes that
system quality had an irrelevant effect of applying and also data quality to execute in Lazada,
Bukalapak, and Shopee.
Article 2:-
This article aims to argue the connections and variances between Alibaba and Amazon in
their cross-border e-business. The research state (Shao, 2020) Cross-border profession has been
place on the first program by industries when they arrange their long-term strategies in the
current commercial atmosphere. This article accepted the case study methodology and selected
the manufacturing giants: Alibaba and Amazon as the goals (Shao, 2020). These two
organizations have their specific business stage for worldwide clients, and the cause for Amazon
and Alibaba select their target marketplace is similar (Shao, 2020). Conversely, two
organizations have variances in their market plans, distribution techniques, and expense
structure. This paper will try to clarify the dissimilarities and similarities between two industries

2ARGUMENTATION ANALYSIS
to assists readers have a proper idea about cross-border e-business in the present business
situation.
Article 3:-
This research paper objectives to recognize the current study tendency of e-commerce
investigation and report academic settings applied in the e-commerce research papers (Yang,
Wang and Chen 2017). By examining these papers, the recent study records the tendency and
discloses the extremely inspirational research article. The researcher also exposes some models
that applied in the online business scenarios. According to this study, the reader identifies that
Electronic business is presently becoming a promising research area (Yang, Wang and Chen
2017). These is only possible for the signs of progress of ICT infrastructure, as well as the
significant penetration of mobile communication and an internet connection, and persons now
can do a variety of commerce actions through online media. The research outcomes also deliver
fundamental understandings of the current research of e-commerce. The rise in the number of e-
commerce research articles redirected the standard of electronic commerce actions, which
validates that researchers and academics progressively pay attention to e-commerce research
(Yang, Wang and Chen 2017). This Study offered instructive understandings into the knowledge
arrangement of e-commerce research, and it has some boundaries. First, the researcher contains
only articles circulated in the top tier e-commerce journals recorded in the SSCI database, which
can influence the simplification of this study.

3ARGUMENTATION ANALYSIS
References:-
Angelina, R.J., Hermawan, A. and Suroso, A.I., 2019. Analyzing E-Commerce Success using
DeLone and McLean Model. Journal of Information Systems Engineering and Business
Intelligence, 5(2), pp.156-162.
Shao, Y., 2020. Discuss The Similarities And Differences Of Amazon And Alibaba With Respect
To Cross-Border E-Commerce. [online] Sciencepublishinggroup.com. Available at:
<http://www.sciencepublishinggroup.com/journal/paperinfo?journalid=175&doi=10.11648/
j.sjbm.20190706.14> [Accessed 17 March 2020].
Yang, Y.J., Wang, C.C. and Chen, C.C., 2017. Recent Development Trend of Electronic
Commerce Research: 2000 to 2016. Contemporary Management Research, 13(2).