Critical Review: Barriers to Pain Management in Dementia Patients

This report presents a critical review of the challenges associated with pain management for individuals with dementia in Australian aged care facilities. It highlights the critical role of registered nurses and the impact of their inexperience on the quality of care. The review covers key aspects such as chronic pain management, assessment strategies, training requirements, and communication barriers. It delves into various barriers, including lack of recognition, insufficient training, misdiagnosis, and the non-use of assessment tools. Furthermore, the report explores the implications for healthcare practice, including the significance of individual patient needs, diversity considerations, and the need for improved training and resources. Finally, it offers suggestions for future research and educational improvements to enhance pain management outcomes for people with dementia.

RUNNING HEAD: CRITICAL REVIEW 1
Critical Review: Synthesizing research
evidence to inform practice on
identifying barrier for pain
management for people living with
Dementia in Aged Care Facilities
Student Details:

CRITICAL REVIEW
2
Abstract
This report is based on the Critical Review of pain administration for persons living with
Dementia in Elderly care services of Australia which basically focuses on inexperienced
registered nurses in pain management. Aged care facilities for patients who are suffering from
dementia generally provides services to the elder patients such as personal care, pain
management, nursing and clinical services, equipment and aiding and allied health services and
other services. However, it has been observed that people are not getting quality services in aged
care facilities of Australia especially in terms of pain management. Reason related to inadequate
services of pain management at aged care facilities is found to be inexperienced registered
nurses. Pain management is known to be the important factor for the quality care of patients
having Dementia. This critical review of the topic basically covered the following like
management of chronic pain, assessment and management plans, training and education
requirements, and communication barriers. Therefore, this report includes the brief discussion of
background and potential benefits, explanation of barriers (lack of recognition, insufficient
education or training, misdiagnosis, no usage of valuation equipment’s, insufficient evidence,
types of pain, social approaches), framework to understand the barriers, implications for
healthcare practice (knowing the individual, significant by diversity, teaching and preparation,
adequate implements), suggestions for research, implications for education along with work
cited.

CRITICAL REVIEW
3
Contents
Abstract............................................................................................................................................2
Introduction......................................................................................................................................4
Background and potential benefits..................................................................................................4
Explanation of barriers....................................................................................................................6
Lack of recognition......................................................................................................................6
Insufficient education or training.................................................................................................6
Misdiagnosis or late diagnosis.....................................................................................................7
Non-use of assessment equipment’s............................................................................................7
Insufficient evidence....................................................................................................................7
Probable no pain subsection of persons with dementia...............................................................7
Type of pain.................................................................................................................................8
Stoical attitudes............................................................................................................................8
Framework to understand the barrier...............................................................................................8
Implications for healthcare practice, education and future research.............................................12
Inferences for healthcare practice..............................................................................................12
Significance of person...........................................................................................................12
Significance through diversity...............................................................................................12
Teaching and training............................................................................................................12
Satisfactory tools...................................................................................................................12
Implications for research...........................................................................................................12
Implications for education.........................................................................................................13
Conclusion.....................................................................................................................................14
Bibliography..................................................................................................................................15

CRITICAL REVIEW
4
Introduction
Sufficiently reacting to discomfort practiced by persons alive with dementia in elderly
care services is a precaution imperious. Discomfort is mainly produced by age connected
musculoskeletal situations and is projected to be current in at around 50% of persons breathing
with dementia in long term location. The general occurrence of discomfort in these backgrounds
is mutable across global data which varieties from 60% to 80%. Pain valuation for persons with
dementia develops stimulating particularly in the advanced phases of the illness procedure as
reasoning and language services reduce. With cumulative reasoning damage the aptitude to self-
report pain is bargained and persons often have social changes related with pain. Valuation is
then founded on interactive observational apparatuses. Though, social changes are frequently
credited to mental or psychiatric glitches somewhat than discomfort, which results in
underassessment and misdiagnosis (C Neville, 2014). The results of improper treatment of pain
comprises of fall of physical functions, depression, anxiety, social and mental indications of
dementia like anxiety and violence and general reduction of life quality. In the background of
evidence practice, numerous studies are implemented for the improvement of these programs
like best knowledge practices of staff recommendations, implementation of pain management
protocols for the enhancement of engagement of staff for pain management and assessment
practices. Important tests to best repetition organization of discomfort in older individuals with
dementia comprise incomplete use of discomfort valuation tools by scientific staff and absence
of competence and sureness amongst old care operate to understand discomfort signals and to
initiate action. Although some investigation proposes that at least certain of these subjects can
be spoke through directed teaching, wider universal subjects donates to deprived obedience with
best repetition and require more complete methods in its place of teaching. The cumulative
development of old and dementia aged care facilities in Australian public needs additional
registered nurses, organization and management of variety of care facilities for this health
populace (SMG Zwakhalen, Systematic pain assessment using an observational scale in nursing
home residents with dementia: exploring feasibility and applied interventions, 2012). This report
basically highlights the critical review of barriers like inexperienced registered nurses in
discomfort organization of persons living with Dementia in elderly care amenities of Australia.
Background and potential benefits
Study by Achterberg in 2014 stated that physical variations in the arrangement of the
Australian aged care staff, like the growth of the role of individual care helpers along with a
subdivision wide reduction in the statistics of clinical nursing operate (enrolled nurses and
registered nurses) current tests for indication founded performs in nursing. Moreover, a lack of
clinical management by nursing operate for the provision of appointment in pain organization
events and ineffective announcement and provision nets to assist in operationalizing the extended
roles of repetition in pain organization. Norberg and Hallberg (1993) established in a skillful

CRITICAL REVIEW
5
provisional of 12 months experimental management through 38 Swedish registered nurses
employed in severe dementia regions that this interference meaningfully and definitely changes
nurse’s insights in the direction of a extra optimistic opinion of their part, feeling other in
regulator and sensation worth by their directors (BS Husebo, 2011). This optimistic knowledge
was significant in determining to continue working in dementia maintenance wards. Hyrkas in
2005 also described an optimistic holding consequence from a one year package of regular peer
medical management meeting for 34 first streak Canadian registered foster administrators. In
complexity conversation with bosses through and subsequent the package exposed apparent
better situational switch and handling services, with better dangerous rational and wider
viewpoints that industrialized more future absorbed capability. This new found intelligence of
apparent capability was an important issue in meaning to continue working in nurturing
organization (JL Phillips, 2013).
Heller in 2004 researched that the “University of Maryland” staffing and holding package
for scholar and advanced nursing scholars prospered in retentive new alumnae in related health
amenities. The act knowledge for management services progression delivers student nurse voting
and continuance teaching for center treatment staff. The answers suggest that new alumnae halt
in a system which ropes run-through fineness and capitalizes in their upcoming (DM Fick, 2013).
Helpful organization also contained contrast of example of Australian and Canadian nurses.
Details for remaining and sendoff the field were inspected. Intended for nurse managers the
greatest significant issues in nurse holding were exterior standards, principles around nursing,
counting specialized side feelings and communal representation of nursing vocations (K Herr,
2011). Survey reply shows that bosses profoundly touches what substances most to nurses and
that nurses who are most probable to stay feel reinforced by their bosses in a number of habits,
such as supple work schedules and staff education chances. Following a review of registered
nurses by the “New South Wales Nurses Association, Australia”, a sequence of federal focus
groups with treatment combination legislatures and a chance selection of 40 current and 47 left
nurses, identified the position of income to nurses. Although a significant holding factor for aged
upkeep, there was a powerfully heal view that broader, universal organization disappointment
attendant with the change to cost control was the chief issue in the meaning to permission.
Conversely, organization provisions in addressing effort connected anxieties were reported to
upsurge the intrinsic rewards of nursing and meaning to stay (DR Kuhn, 2012). In the aged care
sector, contributing nurses optional a significant salary increase similar to their public health
service peer would designate developments in the occupations quality, status and credit, factors
related with retention. Whilst lower pay for capable nurses is an issue for the dementia and aged
care subdivision, it is more the mode this imitates their lower position associated with their
severe and public nurse complements which worries these nurses.
Also, understanding the being behind the dementia was an important result of a study
Kitwood in 1997 which highlights the rank of significant about a being life history in order to
allow the individuality of a person to be upheld. Likewise in 2001, Brown coped that for person

CRITICAL REVIEW
6
centered care to become a realism, it is significant to distinguish the being and in this
background Baldwin in 2009 planned that the upkeep of personhood as the emotion of a being
focused care idea (N Wang, Quality of nursing documentation and approaches to its evaluation: a
mixed‐method systematic review, 2011). Also, in the description Nolan in 2006 deliberated a
intellect of steadiness as being significant in attainment of the association focused care, this
includes credit and worth of a being profile and use of historical to contextualize the current
(Savvas, 2014). Phinney in 2009 studied that investigation vigorously seeks the personal
knowledge of persons with dementia has arose steadily throughout the past 15 years. Though, the
degree to which this reproduces the knowledge of all collections of persons with dementia is
disputed with a stress to day on investigation connecting people in the initial level of dementia (T
Hadjistavropoulos, 2014).
Explanation of barriers
Fisher-Morris and Gellatly in 1997 explained that fences to pain assessment happen for
all elder grownups with dementia, a populace for whom the acknowledgment of discomfort can
demonstrate fairly stimulating. Separately from glitches connected to sensual damage and
statement problems, the valuation of discomfort in grown-up with dementia is additional
complex by a greatness of other issues, counting indication that the knowledge of discomfort is
irregular for few certain persons with dementia. Problems in the uncovering of discomfort delay
positive valuation, which is vital for the application and assessment of suitable interferences. Fox
in 1999 originate that the occurrence of discomfort is comparable for those older persons who
are powerless to interconnect orally. Healthcare clinicians have a moral and qualified
accountability to measure and then treat pain in persons who are particularly susceptible since of
their reasoning damage or other glitches which reduce their aptitude to interconnect their
discomfort orally (N Kupeli, 2018). In instruction for constant pain to be abridged in persons
with dementia, nurses essential to be conscious of the greatest actual plans for measuring their
hurt.
Fences to positive pain valuation in footings of operate deliberations are mentioned below:
Lack of recognition
Majdar and Higgins in 1996 create that there is a tall occurrence of long-lasting pain in
nursing household inhabitants, certain which is unrecognized by supervise, and that long-lasting
discomfort is infrequently registered whichever as a medicinal or treatment analysis or thorough
in nursing tactics. Long-lasting pain is particularly unrecognized in individual’s inhabitants in
the initial phases of dementia who are really able to designate the spirits (SMG Zwakhalen,
Systematic pain assessment using an observational scale in nursing home residents with
dementia: exploring feasibility and applied interventions, 2012).

CRITICAL REVIEW
7
Insufficient education or training
Creedon and Cohen in 2002 pragmatic that numerous nurses are inhibited by their
preparation and by individual characteristic habits of abstracting the condition, like trusting that a
interactive problematic was the consequence of mental suffering and consequently needs precise
interferences, somewhat than observing for possibly dissimilar reasons of the performance.
Allock in 2002 delivered teaching to capable nurses about the valuation and association of the
uneasiness in individuals with dementia, with equal fewer on disorder that this for maintenance
helpers. In an examination of nursing staff evidence and government regarding pain in older
populations with dementia, Zwakhalen in 2007 originate material shortages with admiration to
pain estimate; nevertheless defendant’s satisfaction around the technique pain was restrained on
their regions.
Misdiagnosis or late diagnosis
Indications related with discomfort in dementia are frequently misunderstood, subsequent
in mis-diagnosis or late analysis. As declared earlier, nurses frequently quality an alteration in
conduct to mental or psychiatric problematic somewhat than observing for additional cause.
Kovach in 2000 originated that painkillers were habitually only managed after management with
psychotropic medications has been ineffective. Registered nurses were found to emphasis
excessively on the identifies specified on a being’s chart as a clarification for conduct, rather
than observing for additional possible details (H Brorson, 2014).
Non-use of assessment equipment’s
Non-use of passable and suitable valuation apparatuses for the dimension of discomfort
has been recognized as impairment to precise pain calculation in persons with dementia. Allock
in 2002 observed that 75% of the treatment families in their education did use a consistent pain
valuation apparatus, with at smallest 84% trusting on self report comment by nursing. However,
Higgins and Majdar originated that no methodical or complete tools were used to measure or
manuscript pain.
Fences concerning persons with dementia deliberations are listed below:
Insufficient evidence
Creedon and Cohen perceived an absence of adequate indication as a barricade to the
discovery of discomfort in grownup people with dementia. They originate that performances
desirable to be recurrent numerous eras and perceived in the attendance of similar nurse formerly
they were accompanying to pain.
Probable no pain subsection of persons with dementia
“Gellatly and Fisher-Morris” recommended that there might be a subsection of persons
with dementia who have what would usually be recognized as throbbing circumstances, but who
do not knowledge pain. Result of the study highpoints the variety of likely separate replies to
what are usually considered as throbbing circumstances, as well as the fact that conceivable

CRITICAL REVIEW
8
incapability to touch and define discomfort can be a fence to the operative care of persons with
medicinal disorder which needs management (M Vaismoradi, 2013).
Type of pain
Creedon and Cohen investigate complicated plotting and questioning of nurses regarding
deliberation influences in the calculation of discomfort in grownup individuals with dementia.
Emphasis groups shaped an extended list of ache pointers and an amount of these connected to
physical changes, counting “skin discoloration, changes in vital indication, and change in skin
tone”. Adams found that fosters trusts on physical vicissitudes like variations in vital signs,
protecting and paleness to aware them that a being with dementia was feeling pain, and these
indications were establish to be revealing of severe, but not long-lasting pain.
Stoical attitudes
Firm approaches detained by grown-up adults feeling pain may also help as problems to
precise discomfort valuation. In an education of elder persons in nursing families. Higgins and
Majdar establish that greatest inhabitants articulated social approaches and known their pain as
portion of the growing old procedure. Mutual subjects recognized were a terror of medication
compulsion, recording pain understood as irritable, and misgivings that actual pain respite was
really conceivable. These prospects and arrogances are fences to pain calculation, as they
preclude nursing household inhabitants from recording their ache.
Framework to understand the barrier
Investigation evidence proposes that fences to applying dementia absorbed interferences
in aged care amenities interference happen through administrative, team and separate
backgrounds and comprise absence of management assurance, lack of collaboration and lack of
period and possessions to contrivance interferences. Consequently, to certify that all educations
had satisfactory organizational consistency, valuation of excellence of the educations is
accompanied by means of the “Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool” which assesses the
organizational superiority of investigation educations for the determination of methodical
appraisals. This contained of four standards for each practice kind (“qualitative, quantitative
randomized controlled, quantitative nonrandomized and quantitative descriptive”), concentrating
on staffing of members, assortment of suitable approaches, deliberation of investigator
inspiration and answer charges. At the separate stage, mapper potentials and their aptitude to
efficiently principal dementia care charting application were elevated within an amount of
educations. There is an agreement amongst the educations deliberating this part that assortment
of persons who need the services to tool and principal DCM is vital to positive application.
Services such as decent statement, understanding and the aptitude to involve, work efficiently
with and deliver control to operate crews were seen as vital. Thoroughly related to mapper
assortment were the mapper insights of preparation for their character subsequent conclusion of
DCM exercise. Otherwise and more programmatically, the fitness and communal care staff is

CRITICAL REVIEW
9
varied and consequently, any approaches and their related exercise delivery required to
explanation for diverse preceding information, information and ability stages (Claire A Surr,
2018).
Prisma Flow Chart
Records recognized through
database examining
Extra records recognized through other
causes
Records after duplicate removal
Records examined
Full-text article measured for
suitability
Studies comprised in data
combination
Identification
Screening
Eligibility
Included
Records accepted: Not DCM
related used as practice
development tool, secondary
research, editorial review,
description of tools, and
application of DCM in non-
dementia setting/population
Full Text articles omitted: not
primary research/DCM not
used as practice development
tool or psychometrics,
adaption of method, paper

CRITICAL REVIEW
10
Additionally, “Joanna Briggs Institute PACES and GRIP programme” are the greatest
regularly used connected instrument to behavior reviews and enable repetition alteration.
Moreover, the many philosophies and outlines obtainable to notify and improve application
study highpoint the energetic environment of this procedure, which is typically considered in
numerous phases. Affording to the EPIS theoretical model, there are four stages of application:
Examination, Application, Planning and Sustainment. Investigators establish that exercise and
teaching of specialists, expansion of investor interrelationships and the usage of “evaluative and
iterative” policies are regularly engaged to present and endorse alteration in preparation. Though,
though significant and possible, these plans merely partially report what is recurrently
emphasized in the evidence improper: that structural influence is stated as the chief fence to
operation of information within dementia upkeep. Health facilities investigation in other parts of
care proposes that application policies to endorse indication founded preparation and recover
quality of care are conquered by instructive methods to educate specialists mostly over
instructive conferences and the delivery of instructive resources, prompt schemes to enable
clinician conclusion construction, and evaluative plans such as review and opinion (Ilianna
Lourida, 2017).
Additionally, the mainstream of comprised educations cover fences and organizers to
employment reported some influence lying at the administrative stage. This discovery occurred
through locations and was predominantly prominent amongst nurses. Recurrent reports
emphasizing the character of executive provision and inadequate period to thorough heavy
assignment are reliable with indication on administrative philosophy issues that act
correspondingly as organizers of and fences to application of best preparation from dissimilar
corrections (A Corbett, 2012).

CRITICAL REVIEW
11
Flow Chart of study selection process
Articles identified from electronic searches
Duplicates, citations excluded
by initial screening
Possibly applicable articles for full text examining
Articles accepted after full writing appraisal with
reasons, improper population, incorrect prevention,
incorrect intervention, incorrect outcome, no primary or
insufficient data, duplicates, text not retrievable
Full text articles reviewed and meeting inclusion criteria
Articles meeting inclusion criteria from
forward citation searching
Articles recognized over other governments
Final articles for presence in scoping review
Dissemination
and
implementation
Barriers and
facilitators

CRITICAL REVIEW
12
Implications for healthcare practice, education and future research
Inferences for healthcare practice
Suggestions for recurrence subsequent from the responses of this report are accessible
below, composed with the heights of suggestion allocated.
Significance of person
Complete information of the existence is a main subject in the detection of discomfort
and formation and exact discomfort assessment in elder persons with dementia. Pain indications
are distinctly well distinct; nurses must use authenticated apparatuses, but adapt the technique
taken to appraisal. Care distribution schemes must be prearranged in a method that licenses
nurses to endure with same clients for a protracted past of time. Delicate alterations in the
behavior of persons with dementia who are in uneasiness are only understandable by
memberships of nurses who dependably effort through similar being (K Barnett, 2012).
Significance through diversity
The material collected as an importance of varied scientific information with individuals
through dementia in uneasiness can be castoff for the improved discovery and valuation of
uneasiness in these inhabitants (D Tolson, 2011).
Teaching and training
Additional schooling and implementation must be on condition that in together the
estimate sequence and knowledge of the communal marks and symptoms of pain in the existence
through dementia (A Kitson, 2013).
Satisfactory tools
Ache estimate tools are highly valued if they remain modified to a character’s ability.
Pain valuations should be absorbed using an instrument that is understated to the variations
among severe and long-lasting anxiety. As particular valuation tool preparations are improved to
others, thought must be assumed to the prearrangement of the discomfort implement and its
aptness for pain estimate in persons through dementia. Foremost standard assessment is
significant for discriminating vicissitudes. Estimates must be run by the similar existence when
imaginable (N Wang, Quality of nursing documentation and approaches to its evaluation: a
mixed‐method systematic review, 2011).
Implications for research
Further investigation requires to be focused in the direction of increasing information
about current fences and examining the efficiency of the plans defined above. Predominantly,
investigation is obligatory to inspect in aspect the possibility of emerging an acceptable pain
valuation instrument for usage with persons with dementia. Precisely the subsequent must be
examined (A Robinson, 2014):