Comparative Business Ethics & Social Responsibility Essay

Desklib provides solved assignments and past papers to help students succeed.

Comparative Business Ethics & Social
Responsibility
1

Table of Contents
Topic................................................................................................................................................3
“Cheap, exploitative: Woolworths, coles cop backlash for plastic collectables”............................3
Reference.........................................................................................................................................8
2

Topic
“Cheap, exploitative: Woolworths, coles cop backlash for plastic collectables”
The given article it explains the information which is cheap and exploitative cops towards plastic
collectibles of Woolworths. The article describes the information regarding Woolworth’s
company products which directly affect to the environment. It is noticed that cheap quality
plastic toys affect to the ecosystems. Toys are not destroyed and use by many customers. In this
essay, it explains the depth information of ethical issue, summary, decision-making process
regarding the ethical issue and provides information regarding ethical moral philosophies and
actions.
Outline of the article
In the given article it shows that Woolworths promote cheap and collectible plastic toys which
create problems for ecosystems. It is analysis that it is wasteful and directly affect to the
environment. It is also called an environmental issue. These toys are wasteful and manipulate
and its targeted customers are children’s (Y, 2019).
The company promotes various types of products and services but its plastic toys create
problems for the environment. It is investigated that these plastic toys are unfriendly and harm to
the environment. The toys varieties are; lion king ooshies which is design through wastages of
material and shows side effects of the products (Knudsen, et. al., 2015).
This case dictates the unethical marketing and promotes it. It is noticed that ethics in marketing
have adopted the norms which include; many marketers face challenges in adopting that which
ethics are useful and which ethical information are not relevant according to the business.
Woolworths face issues regarding promoting the plastic toys which are made up of wasteful and
manipulative waste material and harmful for the ecosystem (Grabara, et. al., 2016). It not only
affects the environment but also affects the company revenue, marketing plans, reputation, and
whole business structure.
It is investigated that the toys are replaced by after sometimes but impacts of the toys affect the
environment, harmful for the kids, children’s and their life. It is investigated that supermarkets
should completely ban these types of products and not permits to the company to manufactures
these types of products.
3

In the given article it explained that these products target the children’s and influence them to
purchase it. It is an analysis that many companies realized the values of manage and maintain
ethical activities and practices. The company makes efforts, practices towards marketing of the
products, and become aware through the advertising the products, promote it. It is an analysis
that many companies use ethical laws, rules and promote the goods and services. Findings of the
article investigate that it is unethical and give negative impacts on the environment (Al Ariss and
Sidani, 2016).
Decision-making process regarding ethical issues:
The companies need to stop manufacturing the products such as; plastic toys because it not only
harms to the children’s but also affects the environment. So the decision which is adopted by the
companies is as follows:
The first step regarding the ethical issue is companies should adopt it i.e. collect all the facts,
figures and information regarding the issue. Defining the ethical issues in-depth, find out the
affected parties and identify the outcomes. The other step is addressing all the relevant standards
and principles and considers the features. The next step for decision making is thinking unique
towards the potential and analysis of the outcomes, actions. It is important to check and analyze
the actions, consequences and finds out the ways to improving the issues.
It is an analysis that companies should conduct the campaigns for completely banned these
plastic toys and make plans for adopting the ethical rules and regulations. It is also essential for
the decision-making process towards the ethical issue is decided for the proper and suitable
ethical function to prepare the deal and prevent the environment. In this article the companies
need to make plans; strategies for reducing the risk of wasteful toys and completely banned these
types of products to preventing the ecosystems.
Individual ethical judgments are made and how they may vary.
The ethical judgments are the main element which is helpful to analyze the effective ethical
environment and their importance in the company to maintain the professionalism in the
effective way. The significant components of ethical sponsoring involve responsibility, decency
and a high level of respectability in all business circulation. So, it is analyzed that the act of
4

ethics in promoting among many business promoters ends up worrying in bright of the fact that
to be ethical it is an abstract judgment of figuring out what is correct or wrong.
To examine ethical issues in showcasing expensively the weekly utilizes two related
investigations of Woolworths and Coles organizations in Australia that are looked by issues of
untruthful advertising. On the other hand, issues of ethicalpromotion have been in the important
discussion (Leonard,2018). This has been significantly owing to the financial downturns which
here and there challenge the benefits of the organizations. To have the option to get by in the
market in the times of financial dropping a few organizations take part in corrupt strategic
approaches.
The examination findings have established a portion of the organizations which take part in
unequal showcasing practices they do it unaware which need to be implemented in the company
to analyse the ethical environment. They don't have the unclear idea what it involves ethical and
misleading showcasing practices. For an example, the 43% of the advertisers needed
ethicaldecency. So, it means the ethical integrity is the main element which need to implement in
the company to accomplish the ethical need and professionalism in the working place.
Outline of relevant ethical moral philosophies and discussion
There is no law management misleading show casing, most of the organizations lean to getting
equal to the method for expanding their higher hand both in the market and in their industry. So,
there are a few items to be sold they need a load of engaging and elaboration between the clients
with the goal that they favour them when settling on a purchasing choice.
On the other hand, the organizations acting ethically in their advertisement practices advance a
component of trust between their customers in the effective way to promote the products with the
transparency. For an example, if the management means the outlooks referenced in its
publicizing the product in the proper way, it constructs trust among the consumers that the
organization sincerely contributed on the worth and nature of the item (Feigin, 2016). This is
main element to sale their product with the effective way which maintain the popularity in the
effective way.
5

Apart from this, the ethical sponsoring practices will boost the organization out of the business.
Besides, for the organizations that expects to improve their brand name in the market just as
build up a long-term association with their customers will rise toward approval an ethical
attitude.
The organization may choose to also take part in ethical or untrustworthy sponsoring work on
trusting upon the objectives of the organization. The organization which imagines building
acceptability and trust among its partners both in the short run and long run will endeavour to
hold ethical advertising practice (Schleper, et. al., 2017). Then again, the business which plans to
keep up high benefits, just as higher indicator in the market, will improvise the receiving unequal
promoting. For additional clarification and understanding of the ethical issues in advertising this
clarification operates the two background analyses of the Woolworth and Coles organizations in
Australia. The parts of untruthful practices among the Australian business are basic both at full
scale and small-scale levels.
Apart from this, the pollution covers without taking part in the satisfactory social duty as the
method for rewarding the general public for the social damage produced. On the other hand,
offering the nation's raw materials to the outside Managements without the authorization from
important government offices. So, the Woolworths need to maintain the ethical environment in
the company to make the professionalism in the proper way. These are a portion of the
untrustworthy issues that are main between the Australian organizations to survive the company
in the competitive edge.
It is concluded that this article shows the depth information about plastic toys which is made by
Woolworths and coles and affect to the environment. It explained that it is harmful to the
ecosystems and also affect the children’s life. This essay presents the environmental issue and its
causes and impacts on the atmosphere. It also explained the information regarding the decision-
making process to ethical issue and shows various types of ways regarding ethical-moral. This
essay described the information regarding ethical moral philosophies to understanding the topic.
These philosophies will apply to take the appropriate actions and help to provide the information
to take the actions as well as consequences. The essay also explained two aspects which are
6

positive and negative. Negative aspects directly affect to the environment and positive aspects
affect the company productivity.
7

Reference
1. Knudsen, J.S., Moon, J. and Slager, R., 2015. Government policies for corporate social
responsibility in Europe: A comparative analysis of institutionalisation. Policy &
Politics, 43(1), pp.81-99.
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Jette_Steen_Knudsen/publication/
272403354_Govrnment_policies_for_corporate_social_responsibility_in_Europe_A_com
parative_analysi of_institutionalisation/links/56b08f2408ae8e37214fca6d/Government-
policies-for-corporate-social-responsibility-in-Europe-A-comparative-analysis-of-
institutionalisation.pdf
2. Grabara, J., Dura, C. and Driga, I., 2016. Corporate social responsibility awareness in
Romania and Poland: A comparative analysis. Economics & Sociology, 9(4), p.344.
https://www.economics-sociology.eu/files/E&S_9_4_Grabara_Dura_Driga.pdf
3. Al Ariss, A. and Sidani, Y., 2016. Comparative international human resource
management: Future research directions. Human Resource Management Review, 26(4),
pp.352-358. https://fardapaper.ir/mohavaha/uploads/2017/10/Comparative-international-
human-resource-management.pdf
4. Ehnert, I., Parsa, S., Roper, I., Wagner, M. and Muller-Camen, M., 2016. Reporting on
sustainability and HRM: A comparative study of sustainability reporting practices by the
world's largest companies. The International Journal of Human Resource
Management, 27(1), pp.88-108.
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09585192.2015.1024157?af=R
5. Cowton, C.J. and Downs, Y., 2015. Use of focus groups in business ethics research:
potential, problems and paths to progress. Business Ethics: A European Review, 24,
pp.S54-S66.
http://eprints.hud.ac.uk/id/eprint/24583/1/Focus_group_paper_27_Jan_2015.pdf
6. Scherer, A.G., Rasche, A., Palazzo, G. and Spicer, A., 2016. Managing for political
corporate social responsibility: New challenges and directions for PCSR 2.0. Journal of
Management Studies, 53(3), pp.273-298.
http://openaccess.city.ac.uk/id/eprint/15596/1/JMS_PCSR_SI_Intro_v14.pdf
8

7. Ekuma, K. and Akobo, L., 2015. Human resource management ethics and professionals’
dilemmas: A review and research agenda. Human Resource Management Review, 5(3),
pp.47-57.https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Kelechi_Ekuma/publication/
289497356_Human_resource_management_ethics_and_professionals'_dilemma_A_revie
w_and_research_agenda/links/576a5c4408aea502083c8869.pdf
8. AboBakr, A. and Azer, M.A., 2017, December. IoT ethics challenges and legal issues.
In 2017 12th International Conference on Computer Engineering and Systems (ICCES)
(pp. 233-237).
IEEE.https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Ahmed_Abo_Bakr2/publication/
322875867_IoT_ethics_challenges_and_legal_issues/links/
5c5bb70d45851582c3d3e536/IoT-ethics-challenges-and-legal-issues.pdf
9. Leonard, P., 2018. Emerging Concerns for Responsible Data Analytics: Trust, Fairness,
Transparency and Discrimination. Fairness, Transparency and Discrimination (April 2,
2018).https://www.commsalliance.com.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0018/58104/Peter-
Leonard-Emerging-Concerns-for-Responsible-Data-Analytics_-Trust-Fairness-
Transparency-and-Discrimination-Paper-for-the-NSW-Data-Analytics-Centre-Showcase-
12-Jul.pdf
10. Feigin, L.M., 2016. The effects of protests and boycotts on a brand and its reputation: a
case study on Woolworths and boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) (Doctoral
dissertation, The IIE).http://iiespace.iie.ac.za/bitstream/handle/11622/89/Lior%20Feign
%20%282%29%20%281%29.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
11. Schleper, M.C., Blome, C. and Wuttke, D.A., 2017. The dark side of buyer power:
Supplier exploitation and the role of ethical climates. Journal of Business Ethics, 140(1),
pp.97-114.https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10551-015-2681-6
12. Y, Jessica., 2019. [Online] Yahoo finance, “Cheap, exploitative: Woolworths, coles cop
backlash for plastic collectables”, Available at:
https://au.finance.yahoo.com/news/woolworths-coles-backlash-plastic-toy-collectibles-
future-landfill-070043724.html Access on: [27th August 2019].
9