This essay delves into the dynamic relationship between the church and the state, particularly focusing on the contentious issue of same-sex marriage. The paper begins by establishing the necessity of separating religious and secular spheres for the formulation of value-free laws, especially within a multicultural context like the United States. It then examines the perspectives of various scholars and biblical verses on the church-state relationship, emphasizing the separation of powers and the importance of discretion in applying religious principles to political matters. The essay analyzes the theological arguments surrounding same-sex marriage, referencing scholarly studies and papal statements to understand the evolving stance of the church. It explores biblical interpretations, contrasting arguments used to oppose same-sex relationships with verses that advocate for tolerance and acceptance. The essay concludes by reiterating the need for the church to refrain from interfering in state matters and supports the separation of the church and state. The lack of explicit biblical condemnation of same-sex marriage is highlighted, thus encouraging the church to be tolerant.