Toxicological Analysis: CO and HCN Poisoning in Fire Incidents

This report delves into the toxicological implications and clinical patterns associated with carbon monoxide (CO) and hydrogen cyanide (HCN) poisoning, particularly in the context of fire incidents. The analysis focuses on the fractional effective doses (FEDs) of CO and HCN, referencing ISO 13571:2012 to assess the potential risks to occupants. The report examines the mechanisms of CO and HCN toxicity, including the formation of carboxyhemoglobin and the disruption of cellular oxygen utilization by cyanide ions. It highlights the acute toxicity of these gases, emphasizing the importance of time-exposure data and sensory effects, such as lung irritation. The study recommends preventative measures, such as smoke sensors and ventilation, to mitigate the dangers of CO and HCN exposure, underscoring the need for prompt escape paradigms and effective emergency response systems. The report also provides reference to several relevant research papers.

Topic
Institution Affiliation
Name of Student
Unit Title
Submission Date
1

Toxicological implications and clinical pattern of Carbon monoxide and
Hydrogen cyanide poisoning
From the data analysis on time of incapacitation of an occupant who was present in the closed
bedroom opposite the lounge where a fire broke out, and considering the concentration profile of
carbon monoxide and hydrogen cyanide gases produced as a result of a fire in the lounge. The
assessment of the fractional effective doses and value additives, this section presents detailed
toxicological implications on the occupant as a result of inhaling CO and HCN (Bertol et al .,
2015). Fractional effective dose FED was used to characterize the possible accumulated hazards
and risks exposure by occupant present in the opposite room at the time of the fire. As measure
by the international organization for standards ISO, the FEDs related to asphyxiant gases that are
toxic to human inhalation and outline the probability of escape paradigm from fire scenes. The
main objective of the assessment and dosage calculation was to establish the asphyxiant toxicity
of CO and HCN based on the ISO 13571:2012.
The release of the CO and HCN gases as a result of combustion and inhalation of them by
humans expose individuals to danger of breathing complications. As illustrated in the
spreadsheet calculation, it takes considerably less time for one to succumb to these toxic gases.
As per the data, there is conformity with the ratios of the ISO 13571 on the variability of human
response to toxicological effects of inhaling smokes as the standards stipulate that the rate of
population susceptibility is almost 1:1. With half likely to experience tenable conditions and
another half to experience compromised tenability. In the case of lounge fire, there is only one
occupant, and the result variation was by 4% deviation from the ISO values. CO presents acute
toxicity to the blood circulation system as it combines with oxygen in the blood to form
carboxyhemoglobin, preventing blood supply to vital organs of the body (Newhouse. and Chiu.,
2

2017). Some of the effects of prolonged inhalation of CO are anemic hypoxia; this is rampant
since the hemoglobin has a higher affinity to carbon compared to oxygen. The rate of
carboxyhemoglobin can be determined in a clinical laboratory and is expressed in percentage
saturation. Through the application of Stewart-Peterson's expression, the saturation exposure of
the occupant was empirically determined (Hartzell., 2019). The outcome of the
carboxyhemoglobin saturation was proportional to time; hence the longer time of exposure to
CO would cause instant fatal conditions.
Hydrogen cyanide is approximately 25 fold toxic than carbon monoxide due to the presence of
cyanide ions that fasten the hydrolysis in blood. Its toxicity is attributed to the fact that cyanide
ions are transported along with the blood to body cells and tissues where it reacts with
cytochrome oxidase enzyme, hence affecting the oxygen utilization in nearly all body cells and
tissues. Unlike CO, the effects of HCN are more linear with respect to its concentration, and its
impact on humans is an exponential function (Grabowska et al., 2018). The less exposure to
higher HCN concentrations is more dangerous than more prolonged time exposure.
Generally, the effects of these two toxic gases to the occupants are stipulated to be on the
dependent sensory effects such as in eye and upper-respiratory tracts, effects on the vagal nerve
receptors, alteration on the neural reflex response such as pain in the nose, eye or throat,
lachrymation, and breathing problems (Bertol et al ., 2015). Exposure to CO and HCN
compromises the ability to perform conditional escape paradigm as they cause lung irritation and
effect to neural reflex nerve systems that would initiate self-escape measures (Hartzell et al.,
2018). Therefore, it is recommended to have smoke sensors with high sensitivity to trigger
alarms in case of fire in the adjacent rooms or buildings. Another preventive measure is to ensure
that rooms are well ventilated to allow efficient inflow of fresh air into the room and, if possible,
3

fit automatic sprinklers in case there is a fire break out. From the data presented on the
spreadsheet and graphical representations of the time-exposure (Pauluhn., 2016), the effect
shows that there are high chances of poisoning to the occupant since the concentration of HCN
and CO are lethal to human and affects blood circulation systems
4

Reference
Bertol, E., Mari, F., Orzalesi, G. and Volpato, I., 2015. Combustion products from various kinds
of fibers: toxicological hazards from smoke exposure. Forensic science international, 22(2-3),
pp.111-116.
Grabowska, T., Skowronek, R., Nowicka, J. and Sybirska, H., 2018. Prevalence of hydrogen
cyanide and carboxyhaemoglobin in victims of smoke inhalation during enclosed-space fires: a
combined toxicological risk. Clinical toxicology, 50(8), pp.759-763.
Hartzell, G.E., Grand, A.F. and Switzer, W.G., 2018. Modeling of toxicological effects of fire
gases: VII. Studies on evaluation of animal models in combustion toxicology. Journal of fire
sciences, 6(6), pp.411-431.
Hartzell, Gordon E. 2019. Overview of combustion toxicology." Toxicology 115, no. 1-3: 7-23.
ISO 13571, 2012 . Life‐threatening Components of Fire—Guidelines for the Estimation of Time
to Compromised Tenability in Fires. Geneva: International Organization for Standardization.
Newhouse, K. and Chiu, N., 2017. Toxicological review of hydrogen cyanide and cyanide
salts. Washington (DC): US Environmental Protection Agency.
Pauluhn, J., 2016. Risk assessment in combustion toxicology: Should carbon dioxide be
recognized as a modifier of toxicity or a separate toxicological entity?. Toxicology letters, 262,
pp.142-152.
5