ERP Systems in the Cloud: Comparing Cloud and Hosted Solutions

This report provides a comparative analysis of cloud and hosted ERP systems, exploring their functionalities, advantages, and disadvantages. It begins with an introduction to ERP systems, tracing their evolution and highlighting their role in integrating business operations. The discussion section delves into the specifics of cloud and hosted ERP, examining factors like cost, implementation, security, and scalability. It contrasts on-premise, hosted, and cloud ERP systems, presenting case studies of companies that have adopted these solutions. The report emphasizes the importance of carefully selecting the right ERP system based on specific business needs, considering factors such as data control, customization, and IT infrastructure. It references various research papers and case studies to support the analysis, offering insights into the strengths and weaknesses of each approach and concluding with a summary of the key findings.

1
ERP systems in the cloud

Table of Contents
Introduction........................................................................................................................3
Discussion..........................................................................................................................6
Conclusion.......................................................................................................................15
References.......................................................................................................................16
2 | P a g e

Introduction
Garner group developed Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) software in the 1960s.
ERP software is widely utilized by numerous organizations to deal with their trade
exercises. ERP software fundamentally coordinates with organization's business tasks
and exercises like economics, human resource (HR), sales, buy, stock, CRM, creation,
and so on(Dutta, 2016). ERP software encourages organizations to prepare, follow and
use all business resources to get their set objectives. Major ERP modules are –
Purchasing
Vendor assessment
Inventory administration
Material Requirement Planning (MRP)
Material scheduling
Warehouse management
Invoice authentication
To put it plainly, the ERP software framework is a gift for the IT field. It gives the chance
to deal with all business divisions' activities without a moment's delay in a computerized
approach to control work process. Organizations need to select vigilantly amongst cloud
and hosted ERP for their trade tasks. The Internet is used in order to access both
clouds and hosted ERP and they are fundamentally alike (Egorova and Zhidchenko,
3 | P a g e

2015). Cloud and hosted ERP brings benefits for its clients since it chops down
equipment cost and offers applications compliance highlights.
Hosted ERP software applications are off-site and it ordinarily has an industrialist as a
resource. Hosted ERP software application is acquired and recognized on a distant
server. Hosted ERP software is accessible all the way through a VPN and remote work
area or terminal administrations. Hosted ERP software applications have to be
introduced on a workplace and user can access through workstation connection, for
example, remote work area, and so forth (Januzaj et al. 2015). The purchaser or
workplace set up is ended on the hosted server. Hosted ERP software applications are
not normally Internet-empowered. In this manner to run this application, the network
foundation is required, for example, a terminal server.
Cloud ERP software applications are Internet-empowered and need not bother with the
customer (workstation) set up. For cloud ERP software, server establishment is required
and a gadget with web connection for the end client. No customer establishment is
required and no compelling reasons to sign into a program like remote work area
initially. A lot of advancements and work goes into taking an application depending on a
workstation to genuine web-empowered software that just needs a web browser to work
(Kashif et al. 2018). Numerous entrepreneurs are adding this process to their
advertising. By utilizing cloud ERP, an organization can take its ERP to a more
enhanced level and give a more adaptable and versatile administration arrangement.
This kind of automation licenses supervisors and proprietors to get a firm and
immediate perspective of business usefulness, including procedures and resources
from which to draw derivations. ERPs likewise streamline data stream between
4 | P a g e

divisions, bringing about an incorporated and bound together stage creating less
dissimilar data.
The current report focuses on the comparison of the different perspectives of ERP
System. Cloud and hosted ERP systems have gained popularity from the past few
years. Execution of an ERP framework isn't a simple employment (Rajan and Baral,
2015). An organization ought to dependably pick amongst cloud and hosted ERP
software very carefully as per the business necessities. Various companies have
gained benefits using these ERP systems.
5 | P a g e

Discussion
Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) structure is the business development
management systems that enable the company to help a planning of business
application to transaction with a business and computerize numerous support agency
capacity known with administrations, Human Recourses and production. Therefore, the
central Components of the ERP programming framework are Financial Accounting,
Manufacture and Distribution, Customer Relationship Management, Human Resources
with Payroll highlights, Stock and Sales figures and Manufacturing Resource Planning.
Huge names like Microsoft, Google, Adobe, Amazon, HP, and IBM are putting forth this
office. Presently, organizations expected to pick painstakingly cloud and facilitated ERP
for their business tasks. Everybody appears to have their own particular meaning of
cloud and facilitated ERP sending alternative for business programming (Stephen et al.
2018). Both cloud and facilitated ERP are gotten to through the web and they are
fundamentally the same as.
Presently, the various advantages and dangers of both Cloud and Hosted ERP are
analyzed. Companies like Amazon and Google have benefitted greatly from using cloud
ERP. Cloud ERP is the mainly economically ability Cloud advantage as one can
presently rent a goods and without any asset. It necessitates insignificant fixing up and
something but complicated to set up, as applications are normally straightforward in
readymade and utilization. Cloud ERP helps in quick sending while the items are totally
provision on demand (Tang and Liu, 2015). Therefore, the consumer does not must
strain over a government of use, because this is in sum deal among through the dealer.
6 | P a g e

The softwares are normally exceptionally stable, since this is reinforcing with a Cloud
provider’s vast groundwork and IT group.
But there are various risks in using cloud ERP as well. The client using cloud ERP has
negative power above the frame preparing its data. There are denial influences on that
the clients exploit the product. Therefore, the item is utilized through a group of regulars.
A case of it would be Dropbox. There is absolutely slight or negative power over the
limit of encoding. Again, the client has a very modest control above deal, testing and
procedure (e.g. Dev, UAT, Live frameworks convenience) (Yamato, 2015). Additionally,
addition with training on other frame is also difficult or unconfirmed (single sign-on).
Companies like Google have again been greatly helped by the utilization of hosted ERP
too. Here, client has full managed on their VM and the whole thing within it. On addition
to, the clients can robotize the provision or manufacture their own VM. A client can run
anything they need inside their VM. They possess the full organize of prepare within
VM. It thereby simplifies addition with huge business groundwork (Rajan and Baral,
2015). Hosted ERP has the potential to protected Cloud advantage mostly by operating
a PUC due to more high up rule of VM. Again, it could be said that the clients primarily
can scamper and run its individual virtual framework with no overhead of charge and
carry from operation its individual exacting equipment.
Besides, all the benefits, hosted ERP shows some risks too. Hosted ERP software
applications are very costly as the clients are currently hiring a substantial quality, the
dealer could charge for both Cycle, a fragment of RAM or sphere room utilized (Januzaj
et al. 2015). Here, the customer head of the reinforcements, disparate with PaaS or
7 | P a g e

SaaS, where the customers are in charge of every part of VM Management. But there is
at rest no influence above which the physical (land) section or server of the VM.
With the increasing pressure to analyze the best suited of ERP systems for the
company, potential understanding and knowledge are required to identify the strengths
and weaknesses of each ERP system. A significant number of ERP systems is
available in the market based on the requirement of the company. In contrary, the
argument still lies on the effectiveness of ERP system and its applicability based on the
requirement of the company. As opined by (Aalmink et al. 2010), there are numbers of
options for choosing the best technologies but it is the requirement of the company
based on which ERP systems need to be integrated into the system. On the other hand,
(Al-Ghofaili and Al-Mashari, 2014) argued that it is not about just requirement of the
company, choosing the appropriate ERP system based n its weaknesses and benefits
is also significant for companies in order to attain success and growth in the competitive
market. Based on economic arguments, it has been identified that ERP systems are an
integral part of business companies to attain growth in the market, however, there exist
a significant difference between on argument ERP system, Hosted ERP systems along
with Cloud-based ERP systems.
On-premise ERP system and its effectiveness in business
As put forwarded by (Malhotra and Temponi, 2010), on premise ERP systems are the
most traditional approach where the company makes a one-time purchase for the
licenses in order to buy an ERP system and integrates it in the company. On the other
hand, the argument about its cost-effectiveness and time consumption is critical and it is
8 | P a g e

evident from the studies conducted by scholarly authors. On-premise solutions, in
general, are privately hosted and significantly needs to manage the company’s internal
IT resources. The argument stated by (Elragal and El Kommos, 2012), depicts that the
cost of maintenance and its integration is relatively high compared to other ERP
systems. For instance, the company Nestle, headquartered in Konicki Switzerland in
the late 90s planned to integrate on-premise ERP system and invested hugely for its
successful integration in the company as well as for its enhanced security infrastructure.
However, based on the policy problems as well as several organizational requirements
critically plagued the complete initiation. This, in turn, led to a significant loss for the
company. After, facing such implications of the traditional system it planned to move
into SAP that enhanced efficient communications, supply chain management and
accounting structure, (erpfocus.com, 2018).
On the other hand, from the case study of Essex, it has been analyzed that their
traditional G-cloud system did not manage the procurement process for the public
sector. There was a significant issue regarding the G-cloud system based on bandwidth
issues as well as critical implications on the payroll. In order to resolve the problem, the
company adopted cloud-based CRM system namely (KANA) Lagan, which is an on-
premise solution. This solution has assisted Essex to engage the citizens extensively.
This is one of the success stories of on-premise ERP system, (cloudpro.co.uk, 2018).
Based on the case study of Nestle and Essex, it has been analyzed that on-premise
ERP systems have both positive and negative aspect. The benefits of on-premise ERP
systems are security as the entire data is responsible for the company, (Helo et al.
2014). It also offers customization and provides huge control over data. In other
9 | P a g e

words, the benefits of on-premise ERP systems are limited compared to its
weaknesses.
In addition to (Hajjat et al. 2010) disputed that the benefit of on-premise ERP systems is
its risks. As on-premise ERP system offers high security, it is highly costly to maintain
each security layers. This is a significant weakness of on-premise ERP systems. The
upgrade system of on-premise is highly time-consuming and requires a huge budget
to attain benefit in business. The implementation process is very time-consuming as it
requires personnel to integrate the system into the company which significantly raises
the budget for hardware and IT maintenance.
Hence, after attaining complete research on on-premise ERP system it is evident that
this system has a number of weaknesses than its strength. This, in turn, can damage
the reputation of the company, increase its financial budget as well as is highly time-
consuming. In contrary (Smets-Solanes et al. 2011), argued that on-premise ERP
systems can benefit small sized business companies as their resources are limited
and the infrastructure is small and limited. However, for large companies, this system
would degrade the operational activities of the company.
Hosted ERP system and its effectiveness in business
In hosted ERP system or also known as IaaS system, a cloud provider hosts the
complete architecture elements traditionally that are available on on-premises data
center incorporating networking hardware, servers, and storage as well as hypervisor
layer. In general (Elragal and El Kommos, 2012) stated, every cloud computing needs
the integration of a service provider which is a 3rd party organization that sells IaaS. In
10 | P a g e

contrary, the argument that lies in this context is a business can also opt to integrate
private cloud in order to become its own provider of IaaS. For instance, Amazon Web
Services is the independent IaaS provider that integrated the platform IAM or Identity
and Access Management which tracks down information regarding authentication and
specifically designed for tracking system users. The company is benefitted through its
two-factor authentication that assists the company to maintain its financial budget as
well as time effective standard, (searchaws.techtarget.com. 2018).
As well as, (Brynjolfsson et al. 2010) showed that compared to other ERP system the
users of IaaS are responsible for managing their own middleware, applications, data,
and runtime. For instance, Microsoft Azure is successful to integrate IaaS
infrastructure into its system by integrating it into its traditional on-premise system. The
use of IaaS infrastructure offered the company to release their workloads and gain
market share extensively. Being one of the largest multinational companies around the
world, the integration of IaaS assisted the company to gain a competitive edge as well
as lowered its temporary workloads.
After analyzing the case studies and making significant research about IaaS
infrastructure, it is evident that this platform has huge benefits as it is cost-efficient,
easier and faster in order to reduce workload without concerning about the underlying
infrastructure. It can be either rented or taken on lease from a business company
offering IaaS services, (Lamba and Singh, 2011). Though the financial aspect of IaaS
is flexible and effective, billing could be the critical aspect for few businesses that is a
significant risk of this ERP system. In case the company does not monitor the working
system of IaaS then they might be charged for unauthorized services as well. Lack of
11 | P a g e

transparency is critical in this system as the infrastructure performance and
configuration of IaaS providers are rarely transparent to the users, (Xu, 2012). In case
the IaaS provider experience external or internal downtime, then the whole system
would disrupt affecting workload’s performance as well as availability.
Hence compared to on-premise ERP system, Hosted or IaaS system can benefit
business companies to manage their workloads and increase organizational
performance, (Saeed et al. 2012). Microsoft and Amazon are the significant examples of
the effectiveness of IaaS infrastructure. Though it has few weaknesses its strengths are
significant to strike off its weaknesses.
Cloud ERP system and its effectiveness in business
The argument stated by economists that the most essential decision for business
companies is to select the most appropriate ERP system. As stated by (Lenart, 2011),
cloud-based solutions are effective for business organizations however, its
implementation cost is significant to consider in order to attain financial value. Cloud-
based ERP systems are hosted on 3rd party vendor’s servers and can be accessed via
Web browser. The cost of ERP system is relatively high and well as its maintenance.
(Sharma et al. 2010) argued that cloud-based ERP systems also require huge
investment similar to other ERP systems. However, the price is paid under an annual or
monthly subscription basis.
For instance, the company Motorola integrated Xactly SaaS in order to enhance sales
representative’s compensation scheme. After the company analyzed that the sales
team requires a new system for effective team management, it spent a year to identify
12 | P a g e