Finance & Procurement Failures: A Case Study of the BBC's DMI Project

This case study examines the BBC's Digital Media Initiative (DMI), a technological transition program aimed at improving multimedia content management. Launched in 2008, the DMI project was dissolved in 2013 after significant investment and failure to meet objectives. The National Audit Office (NAO) highlighted issues such as delays, unmet user expectations, and a lack of clear organizational goals. Key factors contributing to the collapse included ineffective project management, insufficient technical oversight, and HR-related problems. The case study also explores sourcing methods, the importance of integrative management, and a SWOT analysis of the DMI project. Ultimately, the DMI's failure underscores the critical role of sound financial planning, procurement strategies, and risk management in large-scale projects. Desklib provides access to similar case studies and solved assignments for students.

Finance and
procurement
management

Contents
Contents...........................................................................................................................................2
INTRODUCTION...........................................................................................................................1
TASK 1............................................................................................................................................1
DMI..............................................................................................................................................1
An Overview................................................................................................................................1
TASK 2............................................................................................................................................2
The NAO has issued a statement and evaluation of the same in a detailed manner....................2
TASK 3............................................................................................................................................3
Purchasing Conceptual Structures...............................................................................................3
TASK 4............................................................................................................................................4
The Collapse of DMI and the reason behind it............................................................................4
Sourcing Methods........................................................................................................................5
Management that works together.................................................................................................5
SWOT Evaluation........................................................................................................................6
Purchasing Techniques to Accelerate Currency and Non-Monetary Supplier Chains
Development................................................................................................................................7
Commitment to Purchasing.........................................................................................................7
TASK 5............................................................................................................................................7
Recommendations........................................................................................................................7
Conclusion...................................................................................................................................8
References........................................................................................................................................9

INTRODUCTION
The BBC's Digital Multimedia Initiatives was a full of technological transition program
which enabled team members and customers to generate, build, share, and manage multimedia
content on their PCs (Akan and Tevfik, 2020). It required the development of an all-in-one
robotic manufacturing and sorting system. Consolidating methods for producing factual and
recent affairs shows along some of the BBC's principal divisions required a considerable societal
change.
TASK 1
DMI
DMI is a British distributor, was aired by the BBC in 2008. The goal would have been to
revive the firm's aesthetic and archival strategy, and also to make audiovisual and online
creativity options available to administration. After five years of expansion, throughout which
£98 million was poured from 2010 and 2012, the company was eventually dissolved in May
2013. As a consequence, this paper will review the existing state of the DMI and voice
displeasure. This would also go into the purchasing function for activities like DMI, and how
effective those organisations should be if company apply the right sourcing strategy (Anderson,
Chandy and Zia, 2018).
An Overview
DMI is a fast-paced transformational change effort aimed at improving the BBC's video
generation workflow for its viewers. DMI, which would be a core component of the formation,
folks, and creativeness which underpins both the BBC's experimental solution and its one of
the greatest foundation for unifying the formation, stockpiling, and utilisation of broadcast
programming on TV, broadcast, and the Web, is also bolstered by the BBC's unique direction
and its exceptional method for unifying the manufacturing, allocation, and application of mobile
content on broadcast TV, microphone, and the Online databases. The key of DMI programming
was also a clever technique which allowed BBC employees and its colleagues to generate, edit,
exchange, and organize information, and also arrange sound and visual, on individual monitors.
As the Foundation outlined the reasoning for DMI in June 2010, the BBC and the Foundation
decided that now the advances would not be accessible for the BBC to comprehend its
perspectives (Buettner, Overesch and Wamser, 2018).

 Manufacturing plants as tools for changing work roles
 The BBC ended the DMI in 2013 for around £100 million to compensate the shortfall.
 As a component of DMI, a logbook with connection data and a register with indexing
entries recording all occurrences and prescriptions should be shared.
 A visual package including all of the BBC's most recent content.
 Agencies of the Partnership Deal which support the aforementioned
Whenever the BBC looked at DMI's performance in 2011, they acknowledged it was a
"major investment" and that DMI's real execution will define a significant portion of the BBC's
existence (Caselli and Roitman, 2019). The BBC has shown that it will employ DMI for a
number of services and it intends to complete this assignment as quick as practicable in 2011. In
just about any case, we'd been conned. The BBC utilized DMI to debut a fresh show lately. At
the moment, the BBC really cannot handle the DMI program without stopping it or heeding clear
signals that this was in peril.
TASK 2
The NAO has issued a statement and evaluation of the same in a detailed manner
National Audit Office in the Great Britain examines government spending. In a
memorandum broadcast on the BBC's DMI show, many key findings were documented. Initially
and importantly, the reality that the program was still 18 months behind schedule when the in-
house group began operating on it provided a considerable challenge. Secondly, the technical
team released upgrades which came up below of end-user expectations throughout the program,
weakening confidence in the venture (Chaston, 2017). Moreover, the BBC focused more on
technological developments than on establishing organisational goals operational enhancements
which might increase adoption. Furthermore, the NAO discovered that the DMI does not have a
set of policies which is suitable for the program's scale, risk, and complexity. The BBC planned
to create an entirely participatory technological creation and archive system which might enable
workers to generate, create, transport, and preserve multimedia content and programs right from
personal computers. The BBC stopped broadcasting in May 2013 following deciding that this
had forfeited the most of the £125.9 million it had allocated. The NAO report, which was
released recently, says that the inability of the foundation to operate has resulted in a growing
gap among program development and consumer requirements. The executive group appeared to
exhibit a comprehensive knowledge of the project and did not even know the depth of the

problems till it was too late. The notion was not submitted to an independent scientific
examination, according to the NAO (Clews, 2016).
The below are some of the study's findings:
 The BBC could not adequately address points highlighted by outside opponents during
the course of the broadcast. For instance, it was aware that the DMI's marketplace criteria
also weren't adequately defined.
 According to the BBC, the DMI costs £125.9 million. To repay the £27.5 million
expenditure on the DMI, the BBC utilized currency, revenue, and agreement allowances
as elements of their commercial agreement with Siemens.
 Since taking over ownership for developing the DMI system from Siemens in July 2009,
the BBC has run out of time to meet critical organizational milestones (Danilova, 2019).
 To determine if the DMI was operationally viable, the BBC was unable to develop clear
standards or acquire a full external examination of its technical design.
 The BBC was unable to appoint a top accountability ownership to act as a single point of
accountability and guarantee that all components of the DMI were in sync. The allows for
the application proved ineffective.
 The total cost was £98.4 million. The BBC discontinued the DMI despite taking into
account its technical feasibility or cost.
TASK 3
Purchasing Conceptual Structures
Acquisition is a time frame which comprises all actions refers to the safety and
management of the group's in-kind gifts. The following are the purchasing assumptions:
Philosophy of Vendor Administration
The supplier of administrators has indeed been added to the just-in-time purchasing
management science (Fan and Chatterjee, 2018). The activities are at the authority of the single
traders, not the purchasing or administration divisions. The features of a desktop can be used by
vendors to arrange the products which have been acquired. This approach tries to make the most
of salesperson's experience and client feedback.
The Concept of Fordism

By providing a uniform guidance and structure which regulated the use of certain
techniques, Henry Ford transformed manufacturing. As a result of his development, Fordism was
born, culminating in a worldwide perspective and manufacturing system. The procurement
company's capabilities that are rooted in Fordism, place a premium on the provider's clout. To
support large scale production, procurement managers strive to collaborate with providers and
manufacturers, like polymers and alloys (Gabor and Brooks, 2017).
TASK 4
The Collapse of DMI and the reason behind it
DMI is a inter-disciplinary company which concentrates in all aspects of BBC
broadcasting's electronic technologies (Henry and Prince, 2018). The institution's main goal was
to create an electronic information stream which can have been accessed via a databases as well
as a software application. The project ended in failure after the BBC teamed up with Siemens to
achieve at least this goal. Alternatively, it may be linked to a lack of enthusiasm for the
company. The key elements which led to DMI's demise were synergistically management, a
shortage of technical closeness, and Personnel issues.
Errors in Hr Department in the Business
As said before, hr department has been incapable to effectively identify the corporation's
magnitude. In actuality, it was a cross between two big internet networks. In any case, the
personnel relations department engaged on this work solely for the purpose of diversion. It's
probable that the BBC had operations in both its division and its areas and divisions. There have
been various other issues as well, such as efficient strategies (Li and Yang, 2016).
Insufficient Personal Connectivity
It's a viable marketing, but a strategic planning might jeopardise it. Individuals who
prepared the financial and technological study, and also those who assessed and approved it,
were all responsible for the incident. Nobody from the BBC were assigned to Siemens' remote
headquarters or administration facilities in Deutschland, in which this investigation was
conducted. They were only interested in Siemens' findings. The firm's demise was primarily due
to a lack of supervision (Ljungqvist, Richardson and Wolfenzon, 2020).

Sourcing Methods
The BBC brought charges against Siemens after a major acquisition in 2004, when the
organisation signed a ten-and-a-half-year managerial memorandum of understanding with
Siemens as its key information tables supplier. The BBC did not even have to compete for DMI
because it was qualified to compete on a broadcasting program for Siemens as a consequence of
a clear and quick competition. If there is conjecture, the BBC might establish that now the
contract management is arguably the largest inducement for assets to demonstrate whether it
does not necessarily conform to purchase behaviour for questionable goals (Lohk and Siimann,
2016).
 An application for concepts and evaluations should be sent out.
 Whether or not a resource provider is trustworthy is judged and evaluated.
 Agreement negotiations
 Collecting and validating commodities from merchants, as well as taking note of pending
contracts (service suppliers).
 Competition tendering is frequently utilised to acquire resources, goods, and technology,
and for support, misadministration, and expansion (Maaldu, 2019).
 The power requirement is used when the area of activity is explicitly established. This
method is being used to give credits to the very first responder or to pre-qualify target
participants for a harsh response.
 Interim arrangements are tolerated since they are not considered significant
commitments.
Management that works together
With the help of integrative management, emerging individuals and organizations can achieve
overall impact goals. The correct method ahead is to keep in touch with personnel on all education
programmes on a frequent basis so that they can develop confidence in them and the company
(Ziegler, and et, 2021). DMI's management wanted to know everything regarding the company
straight soon because he didn't come from a technology experience, especially in real-time and testing.
As a result, he was hesitant to communicate the results and objectives of these efforts with
neighbourhood and Siemens authorities. He was also averse to expressing a feeling of obligation and
avoided making an unfavourable impact on his colleagues or Siemens authorities. Most significantly,
there were no preparatory workshops prior to or even during the work (Njeru, 2016).

SWOT Evaluation
Strength
The goal of the Electronic Multimedia Project was to improve system performance by
enabling BBC employees to create, develop, disseminate, and consume visual and sound
material from personal computers. It was shut down in May 2013, and the remaining £98.4
million in DMI payments being payed off at a disadvantage to the BBC (Zhang and Zheng,
2020). Almost all of the BBC's key broadcast producing divisions would be enabled to use the
DMI technology to interchange and organise audiovisual content for factual and timely events
broadcast shows, and also undertake basic movie processing and preserve substantially final
project (Parvaneh and El-Sayegh, 2016).
Weakness
The BBC terminated its Digital Media Initiative in May 2013, after deciding that it had
forfeited the most of the £125.9 million it had committed. Despite the fact that there are indeed
significant issues to address, such as insufficient planning, BBC-commissioned process
improvement specialists stated that the DMI elements offered by the BBC were well welcomed.
Customers lacked faith in the DMI's capacity to develop a reliable network which met their
requirements as the program have become more complex and delayed (Phillips and Stalter,
2020).
Opportunities
The BBC's Digital Multimedia Initiatives was a significant technological conversion
effort which enabled employees and customers to generate, develop, distribute, and administer
multimedia content and programmes on their computers (Yao and Whalley, 2016). It required
the creation of an all-in-one computerized manufacturing and preservation system. Mandating
protocols for information production across a few BBC's main divisions responsible for
producing documentary and information programming necessitated a significant culture change
(Post and Altman, 2017).
Threats
The BBC seemed completely unconcerned about the massive investment of bringing
operations in-house. Nobody was in responsible for putting the DMI in place and receiving the
incentives and no one took accountability for any issues that arose. he BBC's right to withdraw
the Digital Multimedia Investment , which cost about £100 million and yielded hardly anything,

may serve as a warning to other governmental and commercial business organisations about the
perils of large-scale Technology projects (Saksonova and Savina, 2016).
Purchasing Techniques to Accelerate Currency and Non-Monetary Supplier Chains
Development
Big enterprises benefit financially and non-financially from the advent of digital and
internet technologies. The following are procurement strategies which enhance strategic source
information economic and non-economic (Yano and Shiraishi, 2016). Adjusting a firm's
thinking is not unusual, but somehow it reveals a lot about a desire to change an organization's
leaders' perspectives. Accountancy is reliant on thinking and effort if the entire company is built
and conducted as per the same international currencies. The purpose of considering non-
monetary assets is not to dismiss them, but to mix them with other images of how basic
arbitration improves an organisation directly and indirectly (Santis, Grossi and Bisogno, 2018).
Commitment to Purchasing
Conventional possession stats and statistical production processes ensure that nothing
indefinable is left out, even if the benefits aren't financial. This aggravates the problem.
Purchases should tend to explain how they connect to the industry's key focuses (Shi, Sun and
Zhang, 2018). This involves attempting to convert non-monetary benefits into financial ones. It
also attempts to stoke a fierce discussion about monetary benefit by coming to the storey and
offering a different perspective on the realities that makes it feasible. This requires the bravery to
advertise oneself while including a communication and self-expression program as if they were
the competence necessary to interact with others (Shapiro and Hanouna, 2019).
TASK 5
Recommendations
Considering the DMI's sad history and the clear and present danger of domestic purchases,
the BBC was far too careless. After the BBC seized command of Siemens domestically, DMI
was delayed by one and a half seasons. The BBC received no clearance of the Structure
Proposals from certified experts, and there is no assurance whether the technology would be
correctly suited to the prospective customer. As problems occurred in both cases, the impotent
administration ensured that these fundamental flaws were not challenged. Considering the BBC's
weaknesses in domestic competence, it's hard to believe the BBC would ever consider anything

Siemens couldn't achieve. The scope, significance, and residual risk of the essential sectors must
be reflected in the BBC's administration and authorisation plans. No one has a responsibility or
obligation to hand out, utilize, or transfer on DMI in most cases.
Conclusion
DMI was thus a BBC endeavour, with Siemens' assistance, that was meant to be a
productive but ultimately failed undertaking. Its demise was caused by a number of factors,
along with a miscommunication, inexperienced management, and so forth. In addition, the
importance of recruiting in the organisation effectiveness was emphasised in this paper.

References
Books and journals
Akan, M. and Tevfik, A.T., 2020. Fundamentals of finance. In Fundamentals of Finance. De
Gruyter.
Anderson, S.J., Chandy, R. and Zia, B., 2018. Pathways to profits: The impact of marketing vs.
finance skills on business performance. Management Science. 64(12). pp.5559-5583.
Buettner, T., Overesch, M. and Wamser, G., 2018. Anti profit-shifting rules and foreign direct
investment. International Tax and Public Finance, 25(3), pp.553-580.
Caselli, F. G. and Roitman, A., 2019. Nonlinear exchange‐rate pass‐through in emerging
markets. International Finance. 22(3). pp.279-306.
Chaston, I., 2017. Managing Process. In Technological Entrepreneurship (pp. 169-190).
Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.
Clews, R., 2016. Project finance for the international petroleum industry. Academic Press.
Danilova, O.V., 2019. Sustainability as a Strategic Goal of Managing Growth and Development
of Modern Socio-economic Systems. In “Conflict-Free” Socio-Economic Systems.
Emerald Publishing Limited.
Fan, L. and Chatterjee, S., 2018. Application of situational stimuli for examining the
effectiveness of financial education: A behavioral finance perspective. Journal of
Behavioral and Experimental Finance. 17. pp.68-75.
Gabor, D. and Brooks, S., 2017. The digital revolution in financial inclusion: international
development in the fintech era. New Political Economy. 22(4). pp.423-436.
Henry, M. and Prince, R., 2018. Agriculturalizing finance? Data assemblages and derivatives
markets in small-town New Zealand. Environment and Planning A: Economy and
Space. 50(5). pp.989-1007.
Li, X. and Yang, H.I., 2016. Mandatory financial reporting and voluntary disclosure: The effect
of mandatory IFRS adoption on management forecasts. The Accounting Review, 91(3),
pp.933-953.
Ljungqvist, A., Richardson, M. and Wolfenzon, D., 2020. The investment behavior of buyout
funds: Theory and evidence. Financial Management, 49(1), pp.3-32.
Lohk, P. and Siimann, P., 2016, December. Predicting the risk of encountering financial
difficulties by the example of Estonian municipalities. In 5th International Conference
on Accounting, Auditing, and Taxation (ICAAT 2016) (pp. 297-306). Atlantis Press.
Maaldu, E.B., 2019. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT PRACTICES AND FINANCIAL
SUSTAINABILITY OF LOCAL NON-GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS (Doctoral
dissertation).
Njeru, M.D., 2016. Effect of Liquidity Management on financial performance of Deposit Taking
Saving and credit co-operative society in Kenya (Doctoral dissertation, Business
Administration (Finance), JKUAT).
Parvaneh, F. and El-Sayegh, S.M., 2016. Project selection using the combined approach of AHP
and LP. Journal of Financial Management of Property and Construction.
Phillips, J.M. and Stalter, A.M., 2020. Systems Thinking for Managing COVID-19 in Health
Care Systems: Seven Key Messages. The Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing,
51(9), pp.402-411.
Post, J.E. and Altman, B.W., 2017. Managing the Environmental Change Process: Barriers and
Opportunities 1 (pp. 84-101). Routledge.

Saksonova, S. and Savina, S., 2016. Financial Management as a Tool for Achieving Stable Firm
Growth. Economics & Business, 29(1).
Santis, S., Grossi, G. and Bisogno, M., 2018. Public sector consolidated financial statements: a
structured literature review. Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial
Management.
Shapiro, A.C. and Hanouna, P., 2019. Multinational financial management.John Wiley & Sons.
Shi, G., Sun, J. and Zhang, L., 2018. Product market competition and earnings management: A
firm‐level analysis. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting. 45(5-6). pp.604-624.
Yano, G. and Shiraishi, M., 2016. Two forms of trade credit finance in China. Comparative
Economic Studies, 58(1), pp.60-92.
Yao, D. and Whalley, J., 2016. The China (Shanghai) pilot free trade zone: Background,
developments and preliminary assessment of initial impacts. The World Economy,
39(1), pp.2-15.
Zhang, D. and Zheng, W., 2020. Does financial constraint impede the innovative investment?
Micro evidence from China. Emerging Markets Finance and Trade, 56(7), pp.1423-
1446.
Ziegler, T., and et. al., 2021. The 4th European Alternative Finance Benchmarking
Report. Available at SSRN 3772260.