Informative Essay: E-books or Hard Copy Books? A Comparative Analysis

This informative essay delves into the ongoing debate between e-books and hard copy books, presenting a comparative analysis of their respective merits and demerits. The essay begins with a summary that highlights the core argument: while e-books offer increased reading flexibility, the satisfaction derived from paperback books remains unparalleled. It then elaborates on the tangible benefits of physical books, such as their role in sparking conversations and the sentimental value associated with owning and sharing them. The essay contrasts these advantages with the potential drawbacks of e-books, including device limitations and the lack of physical interaction with the text. The author's perspective strongly favors hard copy books, emphasizing the importance of the reading experience, the development of attachment, and the memories that physical books evoke. The essay concludes by reiterating the superior qualities of hard copy books and their irreplaceable contribution to the reading experience.

INFORMATIVE ESSAY

TABLE OF CONTENTS
MAIN BODY..................................................................................................................................3
Summary......................................................................................................................................3
Essay: E- books or hard copy books............................................................................................3
REFERENCES................................................................................................................................5

MAIN BODY
Summary
The text illustrates the argument between evaluation of the argument where online book
reading is compared to the offline book reading i.e. paperback books. It has been evidently
argued that despite the increased reading flexibility that e- books provide, it is a widely accepted
notion that the satisfaction which paperback books give cannot be paralleled or beaten.
The text further states that just by reading the title of the book which any person is reading,
a lot of facts about the taste and personality of that person can be identified and it also acts as a
great conversation starter. Such is definitely not the case in case of electronic books where the
readers are simply reading from the screens and hence cannot be easily judged. It is further
summarised that in case with the electronic books even if the book is shared, it is again done by
electronic means where the different readers read it individually and separately and hence do not
develop any connectivity or bonding over the same book. The text concludes that possessing
books is just like fine wine where the books ages along with the wine and becomes exquisite
retaining their own unique smell and memories which cannot be possible in case of e- books.
Essay: E- books or hard copy books
I completely agree with the sentiment of the essay that states that hardcover and paperback
are always much more satisfactory as compared to electronic books. According to me there are
several extra disadvantages as well that can be associated with the electronic reading such as the
devices can easily shut down due to lower batteries and this can make the reader devoid of their
books (Loh and Sun, 2019). Additionally, the fact that the devices can easily get damaged, lost or
broken is another added drawback that contributes towards the positive aspects of the hardcopy
books. Apart from all of this, it cannot be denied that when one reads from an actual physical
book, throughout the journey of reading, an attachment is developed with the book where the
reader can highlight some meaningful or beautiful lines, can mark down some words or phrases
etc. Sometimes a book gets shared between friends, couples or families and that often acts as a
major source of bonding as well between such readers (Sheu, Downey and Klingler, 2018). All
these create a memory and when that same book is opened again year’s later, it often brings back
a myriad of memories which can be relished only through the hard copy books.
3

I also think that the harmful aspects that reading from these electronic devices are
prominent as these affects the eyes negatively and hence the feeling or experience of reading an
extremely interesting book for an entire night cannot be experienced by the electronic readers
(Baron, 2017).
Therefore I am of the opinion that the reading is a pleasure for the majority of the avid
readers where they enjoy reading and knowing stories of different people and different lands.
The prominence and contribution of the hard copy books in this is limitless. Online and
electronic books simply curb or limit the entire experience that an individual can have by reading
from the paperback and hence, I am of the favourable opinion that the hard copies are a much
better option over the electronic books with immaculately more satisfaction and benefits.
4

REFERENCES
Books and Journals
Loh, C.E. and Sun, B., 2019. “I'd still prefer to read the hard copy”: Adolescents’ print and
digital reading habits. Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy. 62(6). pp.663-672.
Sheu, F.R., Downey, K. and Klingler, T., 2018. CAN HARD-COPY TEXTBOOKS ON
LIBRARY RESERVE HELP ADDRESS THE TEXTBOOK DILEMMA?. Textbooks in
Academic Libraries: Selection, Circulation, and Assessment (An ALCTS Monograph),
p.97.
Baron, N.S., 2017. Reading in a digital age. Phi Delta Kappan. 99(2). pp.15-20.
5

6