This report analyzes an ethical dilemma faced by James, who is contracted to interview staff at a web design company. The dilemma arises when a senior VP requests information about individual performance, despite the promise of confidentiality. The report explores the ethical, professional, and legal issues involved, referencing the ACS code of ethics and Australian privacy legislation. James must navigate the conflict between maintaining confidentiality, upholding professional standards, and potentially jeopardizing his job. The report recommends a course of action based on ethical principles and provides a detailed analysis of the situation, including the application of ethical frameworks to resolve the dilemma. The report emphasizes the importance of honesty, professionalism, and the primacy of public interest in ethical decision-making.