APC311 - IFRS: A Critical Evaluation of Financial Reporting in Germany

This report provides a critical evaluation of financial reporting practices in Germany and Japan, focusing on tangible and intangible assets, as well as creative accounting techniques. It delves into the regulatory discussions and relevant International Accounting Standards (IASs) related to these areas, examining the accounting treatments of goodwill, concessions, brands, and patents. The report also analyzes the valuation of stock and fixed assets under both German GAAP and Japan GAAP, highlighting the differences in accounting for items like software and long-term investments. Furthermore, it explores the implications of different accounting treatments on the usefulness of financial statements, addressing key qualitative characteristics, true and fair presentation, and potential issues related to creative accounting. The analysis includes a comparison of amortization methods and impairment considerations for intangible assets, providing a comprehensive overview of financial reporting in these two countries. Desklib provides access to this report and other solved assignments for students.

Running Head: INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING
0
International Financial Reporting

INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING 1
Table of Contents
Introduction................................................................................................................................2
Accounting for intangible assets................................................................................................2
Definition and classification...................................................................................................3
Definitional of goodwill.........................................................................................................4
Treatment of the goodwill......................................................................................................4
Accounting for tangible assets...................................................................................................6
Tangible assets........................................................................................................................6
Creative Accounting...................................................................................................................8
Conclusion................................................................................................................................11
References................................................................................................................................12

INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING 2
Introduction
In the period 1973 to 2000, there was the introduction of the International Accounting
Standards commonly known as IASs. The IASB took the place of the IASC in 2001. From
that point forward, the IASB has corrected some IASs and has proposed to change others, has
supplanted some IASs with new International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRSs), and has
received or proposed certain new IFRSs on themes for which there was no past IAS (Nobes,
2014). Germany is an EU part state. Therefore, the organizations of Germany which are
recorded on the EU/EEA securities showcase take after IFRS since 2005. The European
Commission (EC) intermittently which gives a rundown of the utilization of alternatives of
the IAS control which are executed by the European Union part states
In Japan under the Tokyo understanding, between the bookkeeping Standards leading body of
Japan (ASBJ) and the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) marked in August
2007. The meeting between the IFRS and the Accounting Principles Accepted in Japan is
under advance. As a result, IFRS is incorporated into the Japanese accounting standards. For
IFRS appropriation in Japan, nine organizations have just begun to apply IFRS by March
2013, in light of the beginning of wilful selection of IFRS from March 2010. The quantity of
organizations that choose wilful reception of IFRS is exceptionally prone to extend in light of
expanding cross-outskirt exercises and systems involving the mid-and long haul designs of
Japanese organizations.

INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING 3
Accounting for intangible assets
The intangible assets are of greater importance for both the managers and the investors. There
is a significant increase in the intangible assets such as trademarks, goodwill, brands, and
patents. The intangible assets are basically those assets whose value cannot be touched or
calculated in a quantified manner but can only be determined in a qualitative manner. The
tangible assets are of utmost importance and its recognition at the early stages there has
always been a debate in the case of the definition of the intangible assets. Basically, the
intangible assets are measured at the cost on the date of the purchase. To measure the assets
at the fair value the relevant requires of 255(4) shall be applicable while calculating. All the
expenses related to the development of the intangible asset must be included in the cost from
the date on which the recognition criteria were met (Adeyemo, et al 2017).
Definition and classification
The practice and the methods for recording the intangible assets must be kept on the same
track within the boundaries of the objectives to cater the requirements of the financial
statements as a whole.
One of the basic objectives of making the financial statements is to give the reliable and the
suitable information to increase the process of the decision making and facilitate the users
with a better understanding (Ball, 2006).
Under Germany, the assets of intangible nature are not defined legally. In Germany, the
definition of the intangible asset is the fixed asset other than the intangible or the financial
asset.
Intangible assets Category Example
Human Capital A workforce which is trained and assembled,

INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING 4
the contracts of the employment and
agreements
Artistic Copyrights and maps
Contracts Favourable supplier contracts
Marketing Brand names, logos, and trademarks
Technological Process Patents and patents application
Location Leasehold Interest, mineral exploration rights
and water rights.
Engineering Industrial design, blueprints, engineering
drawings.
Goodwill Institutional goodwill, going concern value,
personal goodwill.
Definitional of goodwill
According to 255(4) HGB, the goodwill can be calculated as per cost of acquisition less the
liabilities.
Treatment of the goodwill
According to the HGB 225(4) goodwill originated from an asset shall be recorded in the
balance sheet. Further, the method of the amortisation is applicable if the goodwill is
capitalized. The same shall be done in the upcoming year or by at least 25 percent which is to
be distributed and are likely to benefit in the future. On the other hand of the goodwill is not
recognized it must be treated as an expense (Kim, Shi, and Zhou, 2014).
According to the HGB 309 Para 1, there are various ways for the treatment of the goodwill

INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING 5
1. Amortisation of the goodwill over the period of the four years following the first
consolidation. The first consolidation shall be done quarterly each year.
2. Amortisation over its economic life irrespective of the description of the maximum
period.
3. The balance can also be set off against the group reserves
4. Additionally along with these individual practices or the combination of both along
with the proportional set off against the reserves (Chandra, Erlina, Maksum and
Supriana, 2018).
5. In case of the impairment the German GAAP lacks in knowledge of the impairment
however, amortization is mandatory except for the permanent diminution in value.
In case of Japan the concept of intangible assets in case of the assets which are currently not
available for use or having an indefinite life. In case of any slight indication for the
impairment, the annual impairment testing is not required yet all the intangible assets are
tested along with the goodwill as well. Generally the business units are in benefit due to the
goodwill and is not required otherwise but permitted; so that it can be allocate to the different
group of assets for assessment of the impairment (PWC, 2013).
Accounting treatment of concessions, Brands Patents, and similar Intangible assets
Concessions and similar rights, patents, licenses, brands processes are not explicitly recorded
in the balance sheet according to 266(2) HGB. According to the HGB 248(2), an intangible
asset generated internally cannot be capitalized. Both the purchased software and the
internally developed and during their useful life of asset are capitalised and amortised (Bryan,
Dafferty, and Wigan, 2017).
In Germany most recently it has been decided that if the acquired-in-process research project
is continued at the risk of the entity for the development of the intangible asset the

INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING 6
recognition option in the 248(2) section sentence 1 of the HGB shall be applicable. If the
previous option is considered than the carrying amount of the research project is partially or
fully clubbed with the production cost of the new intangible asset (Vetoshkina and
Tukhvatullin, 2015).
In the case of the finite-lived non-current intangible assets, the accounting treatment of the
assets is to amortize the same over the expected entity specific useful life of an asset. In case
there is confusion regarding the specific useful life of asset than the assets are amortized over
the period of 10 years.
Further, there are certain assets which are used for the indefinite period and they are not
amortized (Heng Wang, 2016). The brand's mastheads, customer lists, the publishing titles
and other similar non-current intangible assets fall under the section 248(2) of HGB they
cannot be used indefinitely as they have a definite life and therefore they must be amortized
(Osinski, Selig, Matos and Roman, 2017). In the concept of the intangible asset with
indefinite useful life the useful life under tax law is often used under the Japan GAAP.
In association with the 266(2) of the HGB, the internally generated assets of the intangible
nature are recorded in the heading A.I.1. In addition to the disclosure of the accounting
policies, the statement of changes in the intangible asset must also reflect the notes. The
expenses related to the consumption of the goods, or the use of the services for the purpose of
the research and the development must be clubbed in the aggregate amount and shall be
disclosed only if the recognition option under the section 248(2) sentence 1 of the HGB is
activated (Bianchi, 2017). Under the Japan GAAP, all the soft wares that fall under the
particular criteria are capitalised. However, the recognition criteria are different from IFRS
(PWC, 2013).

INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING 7
Accounting for tangible assets
Tangible assets
To generate the revenue for the company the tangible assets are one of the good sources.
Tangible assets are either current or fixed in the nature. The items which are generally
followed in the list of the current assets are cash, inventory and the marketable securities.
These items are readily available for cash as these are used within a period of one year
(Contractor, Yang, and Gaur, 2016).
The tangible fixed assets are initially recorded at the historic purchase as per the section 255
subsection 1 or manufacturing costs as per the section 255 of subsection 2. The treatment is
according to the German tax law; German GAAP does not permit revaluation of fixed assets
in excess of original cost as reduced by depreciation (Accounting Standards Committee of
Germany, 2017). In case of Japan the fixed assets are recorded at the cost less market value.
The acquisition cost of machinery and equipment used solely for the purpose of a specific
research and development project which cannot be used for any other purpose is expensed as
research and development cost when acquired (PWC, 2013).
The valuation of stock is done on the basis of market value; replacement value; net realisable
value or another value permitted by tax rules whichever is lower as per section 253 (3), 254
HGB, there were certain stocks which are purchased in terms of foreign currency and are
recorded at a cost lower than the original cost and there was the corresponding write down in
the stock’s carrying value due to subsequent fall in the exchange rate, same as for UK GAAP,
under section 280 HGB. Such exceptions are not allowed by German GAAP, where the
stocks were being prohibited to be carried on such a value that exceeds the cost.
In case of the investments especially the long-term investments are recorded at a difference of
the cost and the provision for any permanent value being diminished. Fixed assets

INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING 8
investments (long-term investments) are the investments which are recorded at provision for
any permanent diminution in value minus cost under section 253 (2) HGB. Such deduction in
amount is charged to the profit and loss account, and such provisions should be no longer
required to write back under section 280 (1) HGB.
Current assets investments generally the investments which are purchased for the purpose of
short term period are recorded at market value or cost whichever is less, where its market
value is calculated on the basis of investment which is listed or publicly traded under section
253 (3) HGB) According to the German GAAP there is hardly any difference between the
fixed assets and the assets purchased for the investment purposes. Following are the rules
relating to the fixed assets (Saunders and Brynjolfsson, 2016). As per the Japan GAAP the
assets like investment and the rental property are generally recorded at the cost with the
subtraction of the depreciation. However, some of the value is also recorded at the after value
(PWC, 2013).
The valuation of the stock is done on different basis such as
 Market value
 Replacement value
 Net realizable value or any another value permitted by tax rules whichever is lower as
per section 253 (3), 254 HGB.
There were certain stocks which are purchased in terms of foreign currency and are recorded
at a cost lower than the original cost and there was the corresponding write down in the
stock’s carrying value due to subsequent fall in the exchange rate, same as for UK GAAP,
under section 280 HGB. These kinds of exceptions are limited by German GAAP, where the
stocks were being prohibited to be carried on such a value that is more than cost (Hope,
Thomas, and Vyas, 2017). To check whether the direct costs are in any kind of alignment

INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING 9
with the other prevailing standards, it is the duty of the entity to evaluate the direct costs from
all possible areas. Otherwise in the vice versa cases the costs gets capitalised if the cost is
relatable to the contract and the future performance in case of the rules as per the Japan
GAAP.
Cost includes both manufacturing cost and purchase cost. Manufacturing cost is a direct cost
which includes the cost of raw material and production costs (including special production
costs) which are directly included in the cost of production (Nastase, Calin, and Margina,
2016). As per section 255 (2) of HGB: Other costs such as an appropriate proportion of
material overheads, depreciation on fixed assets of the tangible nature, overheads relating to
the production and manufacturing of the material are also included. Such cost is recorded on
the basis of the requirement of tax purposes as they are a part of the manufacturing process
which is incurred at the time of production (Zhang and Zhang, 2017). The cost of general
administration cost is inclusive of expenditure for voluntary staff benefits, social
infrastructure and facilities and pensions after excluding the selling cost under section 255 (2)
HGB The finance used in the production of an asset received in the form of loan, such
interest on loan may be recorded during the period of production as per section 255 (3) HGB.
The method of weighted average cost and LIFO as per section 256 HGB) are commonly
accepted in the general practice and also accepted for tax purposes. FIFO method is not
generally practiced or accepted for tax purposes until shows its ties with the actual pattern of
consumption (Madhani, 2015).
Creative Accounting
Innovative bookkeeping comprises of bookkeeping and accounting practices following the
required laws and controls but usually diverts from what those standards intend to achieve.
Creative accounting emphasizes loopholes and standards of accounting exploit a superior

INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING 10
picture of the organization (Seetharaman, Helmi Bin Zaini Sooria, and Saravanan, 2012).
Albeit creative accounting practices are legalized, and the areas they dig are often reframed to
avoid such practices.
Governments can participate in "creative accounting" to hide the borrowings and sugar coat
the spending balance and recommend utilizing "the contrast between spending deficiencies
and the adjustment out in the public debt" to quantify creative accounting. Stock-stream
modifications depict the distinction amongst shortages and the adjustment of the change in
the debt (Stolowy and Jeny-Cazavan, 2013).
An essential advantage of public accounting statements is that they enable investors to
analyze the financial health of contending organizations. In any case, when firms enter into
creative accounting methods the value of the information gets distorted and the financials so
provided are not reliable in nature. Innovative bookkeeping also is known as the creative
accounting can be utilized to keep the debt securities out of the balance sheet and to keep a
track of the earnings. For instance, Pressure to complete the term expectations of the Wall
Street of the financial targets due at the end of each year can be due to the creative accounting
activities. The CFO of a company belonging to the software industry can keep a portion of
the revenue and record it as the liability on the balance sheet and recognize the same as
current period earnings to achieve a certain goal.
The CFO of a product organization may take a part of incomes that ought to be recorded as
an obligation on the asset report and remember it as earned in the present time frame to
achieve a specific income objective. A CFO of an assembling organization could defer the
account of current period costs to an ensuing period to improve current period profit look. On
the off chance that a hazy area of bookkeeping is discovered, it might be misused (German
climate Finance, 2017).

INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING 11
The government of Germany intends to guarantee €4 billion of every 2020 not exclusively by
means of the financial plan, but rather additionally by counting the low-intrigue KfW
advances. In any case, just spending stores were considered to build up the 2014 benchmark.
Consequently, the expansion is certifiably not a genuine multiplying. A legitimate use of the
promise would require the €4 billion to be raised completely by means of the financial plan in
2020 and apart from this anything would qualify for the creative accounting (Hill, 2017).
One of the major incidents that happened in Germany had two phases, first was when the
banks and the stockbrokers bought and sold shares for the investors of the foreign countries
in such a way that they went to claim a tax refund for which they were not eligible. The
second was when the banks and the investors purchased and sold the shares just before and
after the dividend was distributed BBC, (2018). This practice was outlawed in the financial
year 2012and the Panama papers were in the major highlight when the systematic tax
dodging at the offshores were revealed unintentionally. The total number of banks that were
involved in the practice of the creative accounting was around 40. Literature provides
evidence that creative accounting exists and is still practiced. Organizations search for the
best graduates and experts who know the law and bookkeeping direction by heart and still
discover approaches to influence the association to look great and alluring for speculation.
While opinions on the acceptability of accounting manipulation, control change, usually saw
as ethically unpardonable since it includes out of line exercise of intensity, injustice to clients
and also involves in the unfair practices that weaken the authority of the regulations and the
accounting theories. The below table depicts the usage of the creative accounting
methodology ad for what purposes.
Managers To reduce the cost of the capital and manage
the total available remuneration.