CSCM37: Flow Visualization Report

Verified

Added on  2019/09/18

|3
|816
|183
Report
AI Summary
This report analyzes two image space approaches for vector field visualization: Image Space Advection (ISA) and Image Based Flow Visualization for Curved Surfaces (IBFVS). It details their application in texture-based, unsteady flow visualization on surfaces, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses. The report compares the algorithms, implementation details, and results of both methods, concluding that the choice between ISA and IBFVS depends on model complexity; IBFVS is suitable for surface visualization, while ISA is better for large meshes. The report also notes that neither method relies on proprietary hardware. The analysis is based on Robert S. Laramee's work on reading visualization research papers, emphasizing the extraction of essential information from scientific publications.
tabler-icon-diamond-filled.svg

Contribute Materials

Your contribution can guide someone’s learning journey. Share your documents today.
Document Page
R. S. Laramee, CSCM37, Data Visualization
Assignment Three–Flow Visualization
“Extracting the Essentials”
Robert S Laramee
December 9, 2016
3.1 Summary of Concept
The paper presents a detailed study on the
texture-based, unsteady flow visualization
on surfaces using two recent image space
approaches for vector field visualization.
These are Image Space Advection (ISA) and
Image Based Flow Visualization for Curved
Surfaces (IBFVS), which are used for
generating dense representations of time-
dependent vector fields with high spatio-
temporal correlation.
Author has achieved fast frame properties by
exploiting frame-to-frame coherency and
graphics hardware. The goal of the paper is
to present a side-by-side comparison of the
two approaches for texture synthesis of
unsteady flow on boundary surfaces. The
paper also presents their strengths and
weaknesses along with recommendations on
their vast applications.
3.2 Contributions
The paper explicitly discusses the dense,
texture-based, unsteady flow visualization
on surfaces that has remained an intangible
problem since the introduction of texture-
based flow visualization algorithms
themselves. This has been done by
projecting the surface geometry with their
associated vector field to image space and
then apply texturing. Additionally, the paper
has explicitly provided the characteristics of
the approaches.
A framework where the two selected
approaches have been unified and compared
at the same time has been used contributing
to the novelty of the paper.
Figure 1: Algorithm of ISA and IBFVS
3.3 Related Work Summary
This paper has been constructed on the basis
of How to Read a Visualization Research
Paper: Extracting the Essentials by Robert S
Laramee (R.S. Laramee, 2011). The paper is
based on instructing the PhD researchers on
how to read a visualization research paper.
The paper provides a detailed study on how
to extract most important and critical
information from the previously published
scientific conference or any other journal
tabler-icon-diamond-filled.svg

Secure Best Marks with AI Grader

Need help grading? Try our AI Grader for instant feedback on your assignments.
Document Page
R. S. Laramee, CSCM37, Data Visualization
paper. It provides insight on the
summarizing important information with
proves to be an aid for researchers interested
in data visualization. This paper is highly
recommend for educational use and for
students reading research papers for the first
time.
3.4 Summary of Implementation
The ISA approach has been implemented in
the commercial software framework and is
being tested on various data sets with
varying velocity magnitudes. The
disadvantage with this implementation was
that it required read-back of the depth
buffering. Whereas, the original IBFVS
implemented was seen to provide an option
of translating the textures in image space as
per the mouse pointer and its motion
allowing improvement in perceived
imagery. Both were implemented in the
same software application for a side-by-side
implementation.
3.5 Summary of results
The paper identified that both the methods
namely ISA and IBFVS are seen to project
the surface mesh and associated vector data
for image space and can be applied to a
series of textures. However, the difference
arises as ISA is seen to utilize the image-
based mesh for advecting the texture where
in the case of IBFVS the texture advection is
driven by original 3D mesh. This prime
difference leads to differences in various
parts of the algorithm which is seen to use
the image space vs. object space.
Accordingly various strengths and weakness
for ISA: Image Space Vector Field
Projection and IBFVS: Object Space Mesh
Projection have been presented. Similarly,
ISA is seen to present Image Mesh Texture
Advection whereas IBFVS presents
Polygonal Mesh Texture Advection and in
the case of edge detection and blending,
Image Space Edge Detection and Blending
is depicted by ISA and Object Space Edge
Detection and Blending by IBFVS.
Further, it was analysed that both ISA and
IBFVS support exploration and visualization
in the case of large and unstructured
polygonal meshes along with on time-
dependent meshes with dynamic topology
ad geometry.
3.6 Analysis and Discussion
The choice of application of ISA and IBFVS
solely depends on the complexity of the
model. For example, in the case of surface
visualization, it is better to choose IBFVS,
but in the case of visualization of flow on
large meshes, ISA must be utilized. IBFVS
can be used in software development.
Finally, both of the approaches are seen not
to rely on the proprietary programmable
graphics hardware and therefore are not
bound to any specific graphics card.
3.6 References
R.S. Laramee. How to Read a Visualization
Research Paper: Extracting the Essentials.
IEEE Computer Graphics & Applications
(IEEE CG&A), 31(3):78–82, May/June
2011. (available online).
3.7 Improvements
There were few grammatical errors in the
paper. Additionally, the resources are cited
in a cumbersome manner.
Document Page
R. S. Laramee, CSCM37, Data Visualization
chevron_up_icon
1 out of 3
circle_padding
hide_on_mobile
zoom_out_icon
[object Object]

Your All-in-One AI-Powered Toolkit for Academic Success.

Available 24*7 on WhatsApp / Email

[object Object]