This report critically reviews an article focused on police oversight in New South Wales, specifically evaluating the recommendations made in the Tink Report. The analysis centers on two key suggestions: the integration of the Police Integrity System (PIC) and the Police Division of the Ombudsman’s Office (PDOO) into a single regulatory body, and the recognition of the NSW Police Force as the sole competent agency for investigating critical incidents. The report examines the implications of these recommendations, considering various jurisdictional models from other Australian states and the Commonwealth. It highlights potential shortcomings, such as the dilution of accountability and the creation of overlapping powers, which could undermine effective oversight. The report concludes that while the Tink Report considers important factors, the recommendations contain gaps that could lead to unregulated scenarios, necessitating a well-defined and comprehensive approach to reform.