HC2121 Business Ethics: Analysis of Unethical Data Breach Incident

This essay analyzes the unethical data breach incident in a Victoria State government organization, focusing on the breach of data security affecting government employees. The essay discusses the key ethical issues, including the government's failure to secure employee data and the unethical actions of cyber hackers. It explores ethical solutions and decision-making processes, emphasizing the importance of honesty, loyalty, and the common good. The analysis aligns with virtue ethics, advocating for the government to prioritize employee data protection. The essay concludes that the government's inadequate response constitutes unethical behavior, highlighting the critical role of ethics in data security.

Running head: UNETHICAL BEHAVIOUR
UNETHICAL BEHAVIOUR
Name of the student:
Name of the university:
Author Note:

1UNETHICAL BEHAVIOUR
Table of Contents
Introduction:....................................................................................................................................2
Summary of the article:...................................................................................................................2
Key ethical issues:...........................................................................................................................3
Ethical solution:...............................................................................................................................4
Ethical decision-making process:....................................................................................................5
Conclusion:......................................................................................................................................6
References:......................................................................................................................................7

2UNETHICAL BEHAVIOUR
Introduction:
The aim of this essay is to analyse the unethical incident of data breach in Victoria State
government organization. In this case, the unethical actions of the cyber hacker in the Victoria
State government organization has two different ethical aspects one is associated with the
government’s incapability to work effectively and secure the accounts of the employees and
another is the disloyalty of any employee for helping tin this data breach in the organisation. This
essay will discuss the incident of 22 December, 2018 detailed in the ABC News, published in 1st
December, 2019 (ABC News, 2019). It will also discuss the key ethical issues, initiative of the
organization based on the ethics and morality and resolve this issue and best fitted moral
philosophies for this unethical behaviour.
Summary of the article:
The ABC News of Australia has published the incident of the breach of data security in
the Victoria government employees. This news covers the issues of unethical behaviour of a
third-party agency which has allegedly stolen the details of the government employees in the
Victorian region. This list had the work email, work phone numbers and job titles of the
employees. This incident may lead to have an intense and dangerous future effect. Due to this
data breaching process, the issues like increasing phishing, social engineering attempts and spam
via the work email address as well as telephonic numbers. This type of risks is associated with
the financial threats as the personal details of the employees can be accessed though the available
data.
This news published in the first January, 2019 details the incident of 22 December 2018
when the third party accessed the list after compromising the employees’ account. According to
the researcher named Suelette Dreyfus in this context has opined that this ind of data theft is not

3UNETHICAL BEHAVIOUR
acceptable in the state government level (ABC News, 2019). This kind of data breaching often
appears less harmful but causes more dangerous problems. This type of theft regarding highly
personal and sensitive information relates to the account security of the employees. This dataset
entirely can be useful for more targeted attack. In such cases, the researcher states, even a small
snippet of information can help the cyber attackers to aggregate them and form bigger a dataset.
This will eventually help the attackers to get a clear image of all types of data of the State
Government entirely. This is due to the fact that the cyber criminals to get the information about
all different people, their induvial positions along with phone numbers (ABC News, 2019). This
enables the hackers to figure out the exact power centre in the state government of Victoria
which they can use for affecting the government by targeting to hack emails of any employee.
Key ethical issues:
In this case, there are two main ethical issues associated with data breaching of the 30000
state government employees in December. These two ethical issues are the unethical having
process of the cyber criminals who have attacked the employee information and stolen data from
the list the second ethical issue is associated with the government of Victoria. First it has failed
to provide complete security to the employee information and secondly, it has not addressed the
issues or risk on the part of the employees.
Ethics are the moral principles which effectively govern the behaviour and attitude of the
people. This relates to one of the most critical parts of any cyber security defence strategy. In
case there is no clear ethical standards or rules, the cyber security professionals will be
indistinguishable from unethical cyber criminals against whom the business seek to defend
systems or data. In this case of unethical data breach in the state of Victoria, the ethical issues of
leadership have been seen (Mishna, Bogo & Sawyer, 2015). The government has not taken

4UNETHICAL BEHAVIOUR
effective measures to secure the data of the employees. This can lead to the direct harm to the
state government as well as the personal security of more than 30000 employees of the state.
In this respect another perception of unethical data breaching can be pointed out where
the cyber criminals have stolen data from the list of the state. The data security system of these
employees is the responsibility of some of the employees who can by any means be associated
with this breaching process. The news does not refer to the fact that whether there are any
measures of investigation in this incident or if there are any issues with the personal details given
in the individual bank account of the employees.
The key ethical issues mandates to analyse the reasons why the cyber criminals actually
indulge in breaching information of the employees of the state government, Victoria. The An
unethical hacking process is an actions of data theft where the target of hack is not aware of it.
This is done for breaking into the network systems and steal information and money. This can
also damage the entire system of control by the authority of a business organisation or the
government of a state or country. Unethical hacking of secured data has always been against the
law and those who engage in such act are the cyber criminals. In this case, the unethical actions
of the cyber hacker in the Victoria State government organization need to have proper
investigation and punitive measures to restore data security for the employees.
Ethical solution:
In this particular case, the organization is expected to address the issue of unethical
behaviour of cyberattack regarding the data theft of more than 30000 state public service
employees of the state. It is a case of data breach when a partial copy of the directory of
Victorian Government employee has been unethically downloaded by unauthorised third party.
This is respecting the government had to take responsibilities so that the employees do not face

5UNETHICAL BEHAVIOUR
any type of problems due to this data breach (Schmidt, 2016). However, from the part of the state
government of Victoria, any type of, measures have not been taken. The authority did not share
any news with the affected employees who can be vulnerable for their personal data theft. The
employees are not officially announced about this issue rather the government has only stated
that the employees do not have any insecurity about their financial state (Crozier and Crozier,
2019). This does not make the employees quite satisfied with their situation. The government
however does not take any investigative measure on this data theft case and there is no initiative
to take punitive measures against the criminals (Dörr & Hollnbuchner, 2017).
Ethical decision-making process:
Among all the seven moral philosophies available in the ethical decision-making process
are dignity of human life, autonomy, honesty, loyalty, fairness, humaneness and the common
good. In this case of decisions main for the security of data of the state public service employees,
honesty, loyalty and the common good are important (Pearson, 2017). All of these moral
philosophies are associated with the virtue ethics based on which the government of the state of
Victoria need to indulge in the decision making (Goodpaster, 2015). The virtue ethics can be the
most fitted and apt moral philosophy for the Victoria State organisation. This has been a part of
normative ethics that is related to the individuals as well as organizations connected with the
virtues and moralities. The virtue ethics accentuates the ethical duties and the consequences of
actions. According to this theory, the virtue ethics support the facts that the loyalty to the
organisation for which one is working is necessary. It is the duty of the individuals to work
ethically in the organization and protect the interests of themselves as well as of the others in a
helping people in need would be charitable or benevolent (Crane & Matten, 2016). According to
these specific ethical considerations, persons need to work ethically by being better persons for

6UNETHICAL BEHAVIOUR
supporting the others. Virtue ethics therefore discusses the ethics of the people, eagerness as well
as characters which are to be examined (Schmidt 2016). The people associated with the data
breaching issue in their work place, are the most vulnerable due to this reason. Therefore, the
government must do their duty to protect the information of their employees perfectly. This will
lead to have a positive impact on the work environment as well as the work culture where the
employees operate (Trevino & Nelson, 2016).
Conclusion:
Therefore, it can be concluded that the ethical issues have a major role to play in the
incident of data breaching in the third-party agency which has allegedly stolen the details of the
government employees in the Victorian region. This is a case of unethical hacking which has
made more than 30000 employees of the state government vulnerable. In this case of Victoria
State government organization, the government has not addressed the issue properly and did not
take any initiative to mitigate the situation. Therefore, these can be termed as the unethical
actions in the part of the authority.

7UNETHICAL BEHAVIOUR
References:
ABC News (2019). Victorian Government employees' details stolen in data breach. [online]
ABC News. Available at: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-01-01/victorian-
government-employee-directory-data-breach/10676932 [Accessed 25 Jan. 2019].
Crane, A., & Matten, D. (2016). Business ethics: Managing corporate citizenship and
sustainability in the age of globalization. Oxford University Press.
Crozier, R. and Crozier, R. (2019). Vic Govt employee directory accessed by unauthorised party.
[online] iTnews. Available at: https://www.itnews.com.au/news/vic-govt-employee-
directory-accessed-by-unauthorised-party-517421 [Accessed 25 Jan. 2019].
Dörr, K. N., & Hollnbuchner, K. (2017). Ethical challenges of algorithmic journalism. Digital
Journalism, 5(4), 404-419.
Goodpaster, K. E. (2015). Business ethics. Wiley Encyclopedia of Management, 1-6.
Mishna, F., Bogo, M., & Sawyer, J. L. (2015). Cyber counseling: Illuminating benefits and
challenges. Clinical Social Work Journal, 43(2), 169-178.
Pearson, R. (2017). Business ethics as communication ethics: Public relations practice and the
idea of dialogue. In Public relations theory (pp. 111-131). Routledge.
Schmidt, J. (2016). Melancholy and the care of the soul: Religion, moral philosophy and
madness in early modern England. Routledge.
Trevino, L.K., & Nelson, K.A. (2016). Managing business ethics: Straight talk about how to do it
right. John Wiley & Sons.