Health Practices Report: Smoking and Harm Reduction in Australia

This report examines smoking and harm reduction strategies in Australia, particularly focusing on Indigenous populations. It begins with an introduction highlighting the high prevalence of smoking among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, citing factors like stress and historical context. The report then explores databases and keywords used in the research, along with inclusion/exclusion criteria. It synthesizes findings from several articles, including studies on perceived stress, barriers to cessation, and the impact of interventions. The critical appraisal section evaluates the reliability of the articles, discussing the strengths and limitations of the research methods. Finally, the report offers recommendations based on the evidence reviewed, emphasizing the need for culturally sensitive interventions and further research to address the complex issue of smoking in Indigenous communities. The report is a valuable resource for students studying public health, global health, and related fields, providing a detailed overview of the challenges and potential solutions in reducing tobacco use and improving health outcomes.

Health Practices September 23
2017

Table of Contents
Introduction:..........................................................................................................................................3
Smoking and Harm Reduction:..............................................................................................................4
Databases used......................................................................................................................................4
Keywords...............................................................................................................................................4
Articles:..................................................................................................................................................5
Critical Appraisal:...................................................................................................................................7
Recommendations:................................................................................................................................9
References...........................................................................................................................................10
Appendix:............................................................................................................................................11

Introduction:
In Australia, the consumption of smoking is high among various sub-populations in
comparison to the basic wide-ranging population. Such sub-populations includes Torres
Strait and the Aboriginal Islander citizens, these are the individuals with ethnically and
linguistically miscellaneous backgrounds, also consists of the characteristics with
psychological and material disorder.
Survey conducted in Australia among the the Aboriginal individuals 1994, about 54% of the
Indigineous and the Aboriginal individuals were men, about 46% of Indigineous and the
Aboriginal females were active smokers, with extremely amall number of the Aboriginal
individuals being the ex-smokers (Thompson, Robertson & Clough, 2010). The study has
suggested that in a few communities the pervasiveness of tobacco consumption is very high
which may also go up to around 83% amongst the men and around 73% among the females.
By assessment, in the year 1998, about 25% of the male people of Australia plus 20% of the
female members of Australia were active smokers (Thompson, Robertson & Clough, 2010).
The probable cause for such unreasonably high occurrence rate is high level of professed
stress. Strain linked to the significance of a persons awareness of unpleasant ecological
circumstances, where the difficulty of the surroundings is professed to surpass the
individual's aptitude to administer that anxiety. It has also been at times suggested that an
elevated level of professed pressure may originate from the social and monetary ‘pressures’
that are frequently connected with the underprivileged group, where the habit of smoking is
considered as a passive means of coping (Tsourtos et al., 2014). Elevated professed levels of
pressure are often noticed as a barrier to smoking self-restraint, both as fence to quit and
promote the consumption.
The procedure of colonisation of the country of Australia doomed that many of the Torres
Strait and the Aboriginal Islander citizens dropped into the line with tobacco during miner’s
missionaries, anthropologists, fishermen and cattle station personnel. Tobacco also extremely
appreciated by the Torres Strait and the Aboriginal Islander citizens and the Europeans also
frequently used it to manipulate them. Torres Strait and the Aboriginal Islander citizens are
less probable than additional Australians to have attained superior levels of learning; as with
additional Australians, a lesser level of learning appears to be connected to the use of
tobacco. The occurrence of other threat factors, like death, childhood underfeeding, and

livelihood in sandy rural or distant environment, may additionally enhance the physical
condition risk of tobacco.
Smoking and Harm Reduction:
The process to tackle with the supporting mechanism and multifaceted enabling of smoking
among the indigineous persons is demanding for the number of reasons. First of all, there has
been a comparative dearth of movement in this vicinity (albeit to the exemption of a few
comparatively and the endeavours which have been undertaken have approached for the most
part from a customary abstinence/cessation standpoint.
The National Torres Strait and the Aboriginal Islander Tobacco organize development was
conducted by the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation
(NACCHO) stuck between November 2000 and the middle month of the year i.e. June 2002.
The development aimed to decide the key issue for tobacco organize in the Torres Strait and
the Aboriginal Islander community and make a recommendation for prospect acts based on
complete discussion with the Aboriginal & the Torres Strait Islander society member and
health professional all across Australia.
Databases used
The record used was Google academic. This file provides full-text and complete peer-
reviewed periodical article. The folder is up to date, and the frequent article can be
established on a scrupulous subject (Ritchie & Reading, 2004). The EBSCO congregation
folder was also used.
Keywords
The keywords take part in a significant role in the hunting policy. The use of an appropriate
keywords makes the hunting process to be easy and precise. Keywordsused are the smoking,
tobacco, interventions, Australian Aboriginal Health and Physical activity.
Inclusion criteria
The article linking to the selected topic was measured.The article having published a year
after 2005 was measured.

Exclusion criteria
The article not connecting the selected topic was not taken into considered. The article having
published a year before 2005 were not taken into considered.
Articles:
(Tsourtos et al., 2014) The occurrence rate of smoking residue is high for the people of
Australia and the Indigenous citizens in spite of the waning charge in Australian individuals.
Given a lot of Aboriginal Australians carry on to understand a variety of societal and
monetary structural troubles, pressure as an important causative factor to prevent smoking
moderation. The reason why some original citizens have remain flexible to demanding
unpleasant circumstances, and not depending or relying on the habit of smoking to handle as
an end result, provides significant insight and teaching for health encouragement policy and
perform. In-depth interview was engaged to gather oral histories from 31 original adults who
reside in the urban Adelaide. Participants were appointed as per the habit of smoking status
(all of the non-smokers were evaluated with present smokers to put on a superior depth of
consideration of how some participants have got themselves abstained from the smoking).
The Perceived level of pressure was connected with heartening smoking behaviour. A lot of
the participant’s report of having dissimilar stresses compares with the non-Indigenous
Australians, with a number of participant coverage having supplementary stressors like
constantly experiencing the racism. Liability over and over again occurs when a participant
reported illustration upon interior psychological property like being aggravated to give up and
where outer social shore up existed. These conclusions are discussed in comparison to the
latest urbanized psycho-social interactive model of flexibility, and how this flexibility model
can be enhanced on the topic of the chronological and educational context of aboriginal
Australians' knowledge of smoking.
(Thompson, Robertson & Clough, 2010) In the article, 14 studies were done to meet the
insertion criterion. On the whole, the literature suggests that IHWs’ smoking position is a
blockade. Though, the poor excellence of most study weakens the confirmation for this
termination. The matter of IHWs smoking position as a blockade is marginal to each and
every one but two of the study. Writing cited and the review were over and over again, not
comprehensive and relied on simply a few previous empirical studies. Most studies were

uncertain about if the IHWs’ view were reported as different from the view of health
personnel in universal. The current COAG speculation to Tackling Smoking is a significant
input to the Closing the breach in the health of the aboriginal Australians. Though, there
linger potential barrier faced by IHWs which may chip away at hard work to lessen
Indigenous smoking. Overcome these barrier and supplementary IHWs to give up smoking
may offer an occasion to speak to a high charge of smoking in original community.
(Ritchie & Reading, 2004)
To decide what factor is connected with the smoking position in the middle of some of the
audience and participant of the North American Indigenous Games which took place in the
year 2002. A survey inquisitive about tobacco make use of and way of life behaviours was
implement at the North American original Games at the state of Winnipeg in Canada.
This review, at liberty the 2002 original Youth way of life Survey, incorporated Aboriginal
youth stuck between the ages of 12 to 22 years. There was total about 570 review participants
(53.5% female) which met the addition criterion. It was gritty that smoking beginning began
previous than what is reported in the writing and did not take place away from age 18. The
logistic deterioration psychiatry exposed that the variables period, self-rated health, peer
smokings and the participation position at the NAIG, were connected with a smoking position
(Ann MRoche, Coralie Ober) carried out the study to address such principles that reduce the
potential contribution of the smoking towards the poor health of the indigenous individuals.
The article discussed the different surveys done by The National Drug Strategy while
interviewing the Aboriginal individuals, discussed smoking characteristics which include the
adaptive and the addictive nature of the functional roles. Author outlined the perspective of
the Aboriginal on the health and their importance to the smoking. The usage of the drugs and
the elements that are useful in reducing the harm of the smoking among the individuals with
the reduction strategic related to the smoking is applied among the Aboriginal Individuals.
The survey related to the smoking and the harm reduction processes and drugs are
recommended to such group of the Aboriginal individuals.
(Chamberlain et al., 2017) searched the health database from 2000 till Jan 2016 for evaluating
and examining the effects of the smoking and the interventions related to the control of
smoking among the individuals. An independent review aims in synthesising the evidence
that is related to the reduction in the consumption of the tobacco among the Aboriginal

individual with the use of the comprehensive framework that comprises of the (NATSIHP)
National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Plan and (NTS) National Tobacco. The
evidence related to the interventions developed an inclusive approach’ incorporate National
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Plan and National Tobacco Strategy priorities
and Principles of engagement and partnership with this the logic programmes and
approachable assessment plans might recover intervention adequacy, implementation,
effectiveness and alleviate risks of adapting evidence of smoking for Indigenous Australians.
(Ivers, 2003): conducted the review of interventions that help in reducing the harm of
smoking among the Indigenous Australians and the probable effect of the variety of tobacco
intervention among the population. The systematic evaluation of remedial literature and an
inspection from the 32 government and non-government organisations and Indigenous health
organisations were processed in the study.
The evidence-based drug is careful, judicious and explicit the utilization of the present most
excellent evidence in building decisions related to the care of the individual patients. In the
article, an approach based on the evidence is used for planning the programmes related to the
Indigenous people health area. There was lack of evaluation and evaluation of tobacco
intervention for Indigenous Australians.
Critical Appraisal:
The critical analysis of the articles is used to adjudge the articles reliability. The analysis of
the articles is very significant in the study and the tool related to the critical appraisal is used
in fulfilling the purpose of the task.
The author of the first study learns support health encouragement from side to side by
mentoring and counselling practices by giving social hold that helps alleviate apparent levels
of pressure, for native community. Also, in harmony by the Ward's psycho-social interactive
replica of malleability, we suggest that interior property like the self-confidence and the self-
determination is urbanized and confident at the same time with admiration to smoking self-
denial. However, this replica of pliability lacks the capability to think the historical
background regarding educational issues that is probable to be significant for native
populations (Tsourtos et al., 2014). It is optional with the intention of the psycho-social
interactive replica of pliability should be redesigned to look at factors beyond the life route of

as a person, and to comprise as a chronological viewpoint in relation to an improved
considerate of the longer expression cultural and communal backdrop of populations.
The second study includes the data that is collected from different reports of the government
and is researched by the examiners. The research established a need for sensible quit hold up
to help IHWs who desire to give up. Additional study is required to recognize the barrier and
way to overcome them which shall enable IHWs to offer tobacco information/give up support
to the group of people, ii) examine ways to help IHWs to talk to their own smoking position,
iii) recognize what IHWs require in order to experience contented to give tobacco in
sequence and/or quit hold up to the society, iv) appraisal the present training for IHWs plus
expand it past brief interference to comprise education about habit, motivational interview
plus the utilize of pharmacotherapy’s to hold up customers to quit. furthermore, preparation
in case organization may also help out to augment IHWs information in sustaining
community member wanting to alter their smoking nature A key in thing or deliverable is to
make sure follow up and prop up is provided with program suitable to Aboriginal
communities’ precise requirements, particularly recognising the variety of educational and
verbal communication groups (Tsourtos et al., 2014). It is significant to make a note of the
fact that evidence-based follow up in this momentous region may be unnatural require of
unevaluated interference programs.
There is a limitation in the third study as cannot be deduced from the studies that are cross
sectional and the measurement of the exposures and the outcomes are collected in the similar
time. The contextual scope of the study is another limitation for it. The limitation of the study
is introduced in terms of the sampling population. The sample also limits the finding
applications only to the youth population of the Australian Aboriginals. The research was an
exploratory study which is used in creating the strong interventions and to prevent smoking
among the youth and providing the protection with promotions of the smoke free
environment.
Fourth study Harm lessening approach may provide better scope for improvement in fitness
problems connected amid smoking than conventional cessation approach. A damage
reduction comes up to avoid the disciplinary and anti-pleasure aspect of a self-denial loom.
Such approach may also build it easier for indigenous Health personnel who are smokers to
lift the query of smoking inside their community. At last, there is a question that arises
concerning whether damage minimisation refers smoking (as an alternative of self-denial) is

tolerable to all community. This might not be the intimate matter. Nevertheless, the point in
time is well past due for an energetic debate of these problems and for the complete array of
the option to be made obtainable from which indigenous community and indigenous Health
personnel can decide to concentrate on smoking.
The fifth study is related to the systematic review, where it is concluded by the different
viewers that certainly limited evidence are which supports the priorities and principles
related to the interventions for reducing the smoking among the Aboriginal individuals.
The sixth research is related to qualitative evaluations of the research that is held among the
different focus groups of the Australian individuals. In the research the different kinds of
literature were reviews and the data is collected from them. The research on a great way lacks
in the evaluation of the interventions on tobacco for Aboriginal individuals.
Recommendations:
The above discussed articles develop a great understanding about the interventions reacted to
the smoking and promoting the health among the Aboriginal individuals. The perspectives of
the health and the relevance to the smoking are outlined in the articles. The articles developed
a great understanding regarding the interventions and how such interventions with the drugs
can control the harm of the smoking among the Aboriginal individuals. Hence it is
recommended to develop such a cultural and social environment which helps the Aboriginal
to quit smoking and lives a health life.

References
Brady, M. (2012). The National Drug Strategy and Indigenous Australians: Missed
opportunities and future challenges. Drug And Alcohol Review, 31(6), 747-753.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1465-3362.2012.00457.x
Chamberlain, C., Perlen, S., Brennan, S., Rychetnik, L., Thomas, D., & Maddox, R. et al.
(2017). Evidence for a comprehensive approach to Aboriginal tobacco control to
maintain the decline in smoking: an overview of reviews among Indigenous
peoples. Systematic Reviews, 6(1). http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13643-017-0520-9
Ivers, R. (2003). A review of tobacco interventions for Indigenous Australians. Australian And
New Zealand Journal Of Public Health, 27(3), 294-299.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-842x.2003.tb00398.x
Ritchie, A., & Reading, J. (2004). Tobacco smoking status among Aboriginal
youth. International Journal Of Circumpolar Health, 63(sup2), 405-409.
http://dx.doi.org/10.3402/ijch.v63i0.17945
Thompson, M., Robertson, J., & Clough, A. (2010). A review of the barriers preventing
Indigenous Health Workers delivering tobacco interventions to their
communities. Australian And New Zealand Journal Of Public Health, 35(1), 47-53.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1753-6405.2010.00632.x
Tsourtos, G., Ward, P., Lawn, S., Winefield, A., Hersh, D., & Coveney, J. (2014). Is resilience
relevant to smoking abstinence for Indigenous Australians?. Health Promotion
International, 30(1), 64-76. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/heapro/dau087

Appendix:
Fraser, D., Gartner, C., & Hall, W. (2014). Patterns of tobacco smoking among illicit drug users
in Australia 2001-2010. Drug And Alcohol Review, 33(5), 534-539.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/dar.12187
Hill, D., White, V., & Segan, C. (2010). Prevalence of cigarette smoking among Australian
secondary school students in 1993. Australian Journal Of Public Health, 19(5), 445-449.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1753-6405.1995.tb00408.x
INDIG, D., & HAYSOM, L. (2012). Smoking behaviours among young people in custody in
New South Wales, Australia. Drug And Alcohol Review, 31(5), 631-637.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1465-3362.2012.00426.x
Mohsin, M., & Bauman, A. (2005). Socio-demographic factors associated with smoking and
smoking cessation among 426,344 pregnant women in New South Wales,
Australia. BMC Public Health, 5(1). http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1471-2458-5-138
Poland, B. (2000). Heterogeneity among smokers and non-smokers in attitudes and behaviour
regarding smoking and smoking restrictions. Tobacco Control, 9(4), 364-371.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/tc.9.4.364
Rao, S., Aslam, S., Zaheer, S., & Shafique, K. (2014). Anti-smoking initiatives and current
smoking among 19,643 adolescents in South Asia: findings from the Global Youth
Tobacco Survey. Harm Reduction Journal, 11(1), 8. http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1477-
7517-11-8
Tessier, J., Freour, P., Nejjari, C., Belougne, D., & Crofton, J. (1993). Smoking behaviour and
attitudes towards smoking of medical students in Australia, Japan, USA, Russia, and
Estonia. Tobacco Control, 2(1), 24-29. http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/tc.2.1.24