Intellectual Property Law 2: Gaming Industry Worldwide Issues

This case study examines the critical role of intellectual property (IP) law in the gaming industry, focusing on trademarks, copyrights, and patents. It highlights issues faced by game developers and publishers worldwide, emphasizing the importance of licensing and protecting game assets. The analysis includes real-world examples such as the "Lord of the Rings" trilogy, EA's "Battle for Middle Earth," and "Grand Theft Auto," illustrating how companies navigate IP rights. The study also discusses the challenges of patent validity, trademark use, and the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) in the context of online gaming. It concludes by underscoring the necessity of maintaining trade secrets, securing copyright protection, and understanding the qualifications of patent lawyers to safeguard innovations and creative works in the competitive gaming market. Licensing is portrayed as a vital element that gives legal worth to creative works.

University
Gaming Industry worldwide
Issues faced by gaming industry and applications in context with Intellectual property
Student Credentials
3/26/2020

Intellectual Property Law 1
Introduction
All the Intellectual property in relation with the Gaming industry and applications all together
generally includes, Trademarks, Copyrights, patents and as such. These help in protecting
several laws and rights of individuals who have created certain games with the motive of
earning. All these intellectual properties as in the Licenses or widely known the patents,
alongside with the copyrights, trademarks as well as certain secretive trade issues or topics,
each one of these serve so as to spike pioneers to make new and stimulating games by giving
various protections to their undertakings. For instance, the patent structure stimulates
improvement by promising creators a short timeframe of particularity if they approach with
their manifestations.
Without copyright affirmation, there is insignificant catalyst for makers and authorities to
make new innovative works, since they ordinarily would be hesitant to make works that
others could copy the basic part without compensation to the skilled worker and Trademarks
help ensure that the name people have made for themselves remains theirs. Ultimately, prized
equation law energizes the people who decide to keep their advancement secret, like the
extensively puzzle formula for Coca-Cola®.
Issue
The major aspect that needs awareness here is getting everything licensed. There are
instances, where a particular game was launched in market without being licensed leading to
an ultimate blunder.

Intellectual Property Law 2
Rule
A crucial cognizance of IP grants planners or the ones preparing to launch an app or game to
even more feasibly handle the extent of approving issues developing over the value chain
with licensors in the case of relating to ensuring about middleware (programming that is
composed into the game engine to manage specific parts, for instance, delineations or
frameworks organization), capacity, or any kind of external IP licenses that are relating to, for
instance, some kind of music, or any sports or even film.
Analysis
Here, it is seen that dependence of progression costs keeps on varying based on the
capriciousness of game play, stage, masterpiece, and if there is any approval of crucial IP. It
is essential to look towards the most crucial part while running into huge dollars number in
relation to web games and console along with the colossal dollars numbers required for
blockbuster games (George, Top 5 Legal Issues Facing App Developers, 2020). There is a
good example of creation of employments of originators and distributers, and swarm
financing as seen based on the distributers activity for improving game through making sure
about financing along with the various kind of trade sponsoring and scattering structures.
However, this resulted in vesting of IP rights with distributers ordinarily conferring to planner
guarantee or distributer or endeavouring vehicle. These changes in such ownership instances
further showed the critical elementary for architects getting IP carefully (PGA, 2020).
The pace of progress inside the gaming industry itself can be a test to the degree that the laws
that are starting at now set up to safeguard and enable advancement and imaginativeness may
fall behind and may not by and large offer an adequate response for a rising or sudden
condition. These troubles are also heightened by the nonattendance of harmonization of the
laws material to the PC game industry around the world (New Media Rights, 2018).

Intellectual Property Law 3
Even in cases of the most famous games also, there are secured boundaries that need to be
followed up with, such as the case of “Lord of the rings” trilogy, where Peter Jackson wanted
to obtain the rights from Saul Zaentz Company in order to gain rights regarding the work of
Tolkien. The trilogy here was legally copyrightable and had the option to entirely be licensed
under another person’s name as the copyright tenure ended. Apart from this, another case is
of EA or the Electronic Arts, that in the year 2001, Battle for Middle Earth was launched and
license regarding the same was again discussed (George, How to Protect Your Intellectual
Property – Complete Guide, 2020). The origin from Jackson films as subsidiary work
permitted EA to deliver as game substance. In any case, in 2005 while making the
continuation of Battle for Middle Earth and different Rings match-ups, EA obtained a permit
to create a game dependent on Tolkien's distributed works (Hussain, Zainol, & Rahman,
2018). This opened up a lot of a new area for innovativeness. The industry insights mirror the
business' amazing development and developing fame. Another case that can be discussed
here is the case of “Grand Theft Auto”. Within 24 hours of its discharge in September 2013,
“Grand Theft Auto” 5 earned more than US$800 million dollars and sold in excess of 11
million duplicates around the world. Inside a record-breaking three days, deals hit US$1
billion dollars (Srinivasan, 2015). In correlation, the greatest film hit of the late spring of
2013, “Iron Man 3” acquired overall deals of US$372 million in its first end of the week.
Inside 24 hours of the arrival of Microsoft's “Xbox One” and Sony's “PlayStation 4” consoles
in November 2013, more than 1 million units of each were sold. Inside 18 days, deals for
each support hit the 2,000,000 imprint (Greenspan, Boyd, & Purewal, Video Games and IP:
A Global Perspective, 2014).
Online income for computer games including advanced conveyance and memberships
expanded to US$24 billion of every 2012. Thus, versatile gaming produced between US$8 to
12 billion in income in 2012 with game applications, overwhelming the iOS and Google Play

Intellectual Property Law 4
application stores. A typical misguided judgment is that a patent awards the option to make a
development, however this isn't valid. Like copyright, licenses award a negative right, which
means they award a correct that keeps others from accomplishing something (United States
Courts, 2013). As it were, a patent presents the option to keep others from making, utilizing,
selling, or bringing in a development. The patent proprietor is under no commitment to ever
really develop the protected creation, yet can keep others from rehearsing the innovation.
There are two conditions when patent weakness is especially significant in the game industry.
The primary case is the point at which a game organization is attempting to get a patent given
through the USPTO (Chisum, 2020). The subsequent example is the point at which a game
organization is being sued by a patent holder for encroachment. In the principal example, the
organization will need to show that its patent application speaks to a substantial creation. In
the subsequent occurrence, the organization will attempt to demonstrate that the patent
holder's patent doesn't speak to a substantial development. This region of patent law is
massively intricate and the thoughts contained in the areas underneath ought to be considered
as insignificant rundowns (Chang & Dannenberg, 2020).
Utilizing a trademark in business without any enrolment that awards custom-based law
insurance for the trademark right now, is utilizing offers extra insurances past a documenting
of plan to utilize. Trademark law offers a few securities here including securities against the
encroachment called 'going off' (Lekka & Sakellariou, 2014).
There are two manners by which one can publicize on the web: one is to put promotions
concerning the game; the other path is to have others' commercials on the website to create
income. There is a potential trademark inconvenience with ads; ensure that people are not
utilizing another's image name (that is the name of the computer game) so as to free ride on
their prosperity. Making sure to painstakingly peruse the Terms of Service of the
advertisement administration is what people in general opt with. The DMCA gives a shield

Intellectual Property Law 5
from obligation to online specialist co-ops (OSPs), which cover an expansive assortment of
administrations from the web get to supplier to application stores like the Android Market
and IPhone application store that have computer games (Greenspan, Intellectual Property in
the Videogame Industry, 2013).
Conclusion
It might be amazing to discover that most lawyers rehearsing patent law have extra
capabilities and specific examination that they need to follow through. In the United
Kingdom, turning into a patent lawyer is a totally different lawful instructive process from
different lawyers. In the US, graduate school is the equivalent for all lawyers and all
rehearsing lawyers are required to take a state bar to specialize in legal matters, yet just patent
law has an extra assessment important to be an 'enrolled patent lawyer.' This test covers
patent law and especially the principles managing patent applications. The test is managed by
the USPTO and might be taken by either lawyers or non-lawyers. One prerequisite for this
test is a school level logical or specialized training. The test is troublesome and in certain
years just around 50% of individuals pass, while, a lawyer that finishes this test is viewed as a
'patent lawyer.' A non -attorney that breezes through the test is a 'patent specialist.' Patent
operators can help recorded as a hard copy patent applications and different issues before the
USPTO, however their capacities are more restricted than enlisted patent lawyers.
Typically, trademarks are not intended to cover a title that will be utilized for just a single
property as it were. Review that trademarks are an indication of the source of an item.
Movies, books, and other innovative items as a rule need some sort of item expansion, for
example, marketing or a spin-off. Be that as it may, regardless of the typical decide that
applies to most different products and ventures in the US, there is an exceptional special case

Intellectual Property Law 6
for computer games in the United States Trademark Office expressing that game titles may
look for trademark protection.
The best guidance for a gaming organization setting out on any new task is to keep up some
arranged mystery at each stage. Attempt to keep key in-game estimations, client records,
network data, and key business contacts a mystery. For whatever length of time that
appropriate non-revelation measures are tracked with the way, it is conceivable to store up all
in all a bit of prized formula information that ought to keep your game thoughts from being
taken or on the other hand replicated. The significant explanation that game organizations
lose exchange privileged insights is the expense what's more, trust issues related with keeping
up such privileged insights. Regularly, a little game organization might be begun with a
gathering of companions who feel that such measures would be superfluous due to a
significant level of trust between the organizers. In spite of the fact that this might be the
situation, it is in every case better to guarantee the assurance of significant assets with the
best possible measures before there are any issues.
Apart from all the above discussed, Copyright is the aspect that needs to be talked about as
well. Copyright is apparently the most significant IP security for most game organizations.
As a rule, copyright secures the fixed articulation of thoughts, and no problem at all qualifies
as the best instrument for securing game property in light of its convenience, force, and
adaptability. Protected innovation (IP) is the most significant part of law for videogame
engineers and distributers to comprehend. IP is a fundamental component of videogame
improvement contracts, work understandings, dissemination, publicizing and each permit in
the game business. As houses are produced using wood and stone, videogames are made
solely from IP. Licensed innovation laws are tied in with securing engineers and their
imaginative work. These laws shield the engineer from privateers and contenders that need to
take a game work and use it with no remuneration.

Intellectual Property Law 7
All of these discussed Intellectual properties state the necessities concerning each and their
importance make them so unique. Licensing is a very essential aspect that relates any kind of
creativity to obtain its legal worth. If something is created and instead of being registered or
getting it licensed, it is directly launched, the revenue will not charge up, neither will the
goodwill. This is the main reason behind any kind of creativity being so actively licensed or
registered.

Intellectual Property Law 8
Bibliography
Chang, S., & Dannenberg, R. (2020). Hey, That s MY Game! Intellectual Property Protection
for Video Games. Retrieved March 27, 2020, from
https://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/3546/hey_thats_my_game_intellectual_.php
?print=1
Chisum, D. S. (2020). US Supreme Court Patent Law Decsions - Cases, Briefs, & Oral
Arguments. Retrieved March 27, 2020, from https://www.ipmall.info/content/us-
supreme-court-patent-law-decsions-cases-briefs-oral-arguments
George, A. (2020). How to Protect Your Intellectual Property – Complete Guide. Retrieved
March 27, 2020, from Law Kick: http://blog.lawkick.com/protect-your-intellectual-
property/
George, A. (2020). Top 5 Legal Issues Facing App Developers. Retrieved March 27, 2020,
from App Empire: https://appempire.com/top-5-legal-issues-facing-app-developers/
Greenspan, D. (2013). Intellectual Property in the Videogame Industry. In Mastering the
game Business and Legal Issues forVideo Game Developers. WIPO.
Greenspan, D., Boyd, S. G., & Purewal, J. (2014). Video Games and IP: A Global
Perspective. Retrieved March 26, 2020, from WIPO:
https://www.wipo.int/wipo_magazine/en/2014/02/article_0002.html
Hussain, W. M., Zainol, Z. A., & Rahman, M. N. (2018). AUGMENTED REALITY
GAMES (ARG): ETHICAL AND LEGAL ISSUE PLAYING POKÉMON GO IN

Intellectual Property Law 9
MALAYSIA. International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology (IJCIET),
1008–1016.
Lekka, A., & Sakellariou, M. (2014). Computer games and ethical issues. 342-343.
New Media Rights. (2018, November 19). Video Games and the law: Copyright, Trademark
and Intellectual Property. Retrieved March 27, 2020, from New Media Rights:
https://www.newmediarights.org/guide/legal/Video_Games_law_Copyright_Tradema
rk_Intellectual_Property#What%20do%20I%20do%20if%20I%20receive%20a
%20notice%20that%20I%20am%20in%20violation%20of%20the%20Digital
%20Millenium%20Copyright%20Act%20%28DMCA%29%2017%2
PGA. (2020). Video Games and the law: Copyright, Trademark, and Intellectual Property
questions. Retrieved March 27, 2020, from PGA:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1hJ-OZhZhC_hF-
MESN4yrbeSPEUvK0a4GD3OrXnee9aU/edit?hl=en
Srinivasan, D. (2015). Videogames Revenue Worldwide. Retrieved March 27, 2020, from
Statista Inc: https://www.mondaq.com/india/Intellectual-Property/434828/Game-
Over--Videogames-Intellectual-Property
United States Courts. (2013). Just the Facts: Intellectual Property Cases—Patent, Copyright,
and Trademark. Retrieved March 27, 2020, from United States Courts:
https://www.uscourts.gov/news/2020/02/13/just-facts-intellectual-property-cases-
patent-copyright-and-trademark