Strategic Report: Finadale Station Renovation Plan - Northern Rail

This report presents a comprehensive plan for the renovation of Finadale Station by Northern Rail, addressing the key considerations and decisions involved in the project. It begins by identifying critical information for successful completion, including geographical location, demography, economic conditions, and tourist attractions in Northern England. The report emphasizes the relevance and importance of management levels in decision-making, highlighting the need for appropriate decisions and proper execution. It then explores the application of a rational decision-making model for Finadale Station, followed by contingency planning to address potential risks related to time, budget, and resources. The report provides an elementary budget and a graph to illustrate contingency measures. Finally, it critically evaluates methods to investigate and monitor decision-making, ensuring project success. Desklib offers a variety of solved assignments and resources for students.

Running head: RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
Renovation of a Railway Station
Name of the Student:
Name of the University:
Author

1RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
Table of Contents
Introduction:...........................................................................................................................2
Identification of the key information for successful completion of the project:....................2
Geographical location:...........................................................................................................2
Demography of Northern England:........................................................................................3
Economic conditions:.............................................................................................................4
Tourist Attractions:................................................................................................................4
Relevance and importance of management levels involved in decision-making:.....................5
Making appropriate decisions:...............................................................................................5
Proper execution:...................................................................................................................5
Choosing and applying an appropriate decision making model for Finadale Station:..............6
Planning of contingencies:.........................................................................................................7
Time:......................................................................................................................................7
Budget:...................................................................................................................................9
Resources:..............................................................................................................................9
Critical evaluation of methods to investigate and monitor decision-making:..........................10
Conclusion:..............................................................................................................................11
References:...............................................................................................................................12

2RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
Introduction:
The paper studies the process of decision making at various levels in organisations.
The assignment is set against the backdrop of a railway operating company called Northern
Train which is set renovate a station. The station is unstaffed and does not contain level
crossing. This means that the company has to reconstruct the station and have level crossings
construction. The company Northern Train operates railway services in Northern England
and researcher has considered Northern England the backdrop of the construction work. The
paper opens with a study of the key factors which is considered by the Northern Trains. It
consists of the developments that the Northern trains ensure. The report ensures the fact that
the project is completely successful. This section has details about the geography, population
and economic conditions of Northern England. The next section studies the various levels of
management where the decision-making takes place. The section delves into the importance
of the different levels of management to ensure execution of projects. This is followed by
application of an appropriate decision making model which Northern Train can use to make
decisions regarding the construction of the station. The fourth section deals with the
contingency plans which the company needs to make while renovating the station. This
section has an elementary budget and a graph to explain the contingency measures. The final
section studies ways, which the apex management can use to monitor its decisions.
Identification of the key information for successful completion of the project:
As the service manager at the Northern Train, I have identified the following
management areas, to renovate Finadale Station:
Geographical location:
The first important criterion, which has to be considered to renovate railways, is the
geography of their locations. I can assume that the Finadale Station is located in Northern

3RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
England since the company Northern Train operates the station. An analysis of the geography
of the location shows that the most of Northern England is occupied by the majestic Pennines
Ranges. The Altantic Ocean washes the shores of the Northern England. A study of the relief
features of the region reveals that a considerable portion of it comes under have parklands
and national parks. This information about physical feature is important because the railway
company building the railway network would require it to time their construction work and
operation. For example, the presence of steep slopes of Pennines Range would require the
company to use methods like rack railway technology or funicular railways to prevent the
trains from sliding down the track (Wojtas-Harań 2016). The presence of rivers and hills
would require construction of bridges and cause ways to ensure movement of the trains.
Similarly, the company constructing the station should build shaded railway platforms and
over the lines to keep out snow and rain since, Northern England receive very heavy snow
and rainfall, which are hazardous to railway transport (Wojtas-Harań, 2016). This analysis
shows that the railway company in renovating the station should form station and track
construction plan considering the geographical conditions.
Demography of Northern England:
The next important criterion, which Northern Train as per my reflection should
consider to renovate the station in Finadale, is demography. The railway company should
consider the population of the place. This is important to form strategies regarding the
construction of the platform. For example, if the population of the place is high, the size of
the waiting area should be big to accommodate a large number of waiting passengers.
Moreover, the demography of the region should be considered while construction of the
shops (Steel et al. 2014). For example, an analysis of the population of Northern England
shows that, various groups like, people who are British by birth, Europeans, Asians, Africana
and Americans, inhabit it. The majority of the people are Christians while considerable ratio

4RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
of the population consists of Hindus, Muslims and Buddhists. Thus, the shops should sell
items to satisfy the needs of these diverse populations and earn high profits. This analysis
shows that Northern Train should consider the population of North England while updating
the structure of the station.
Economic conditions:
I can reflect that the economic conditions of places play very role in the construction
of infrastructure like railway stations. This is because the upper class people prefer travelling
by flight or by private cars. The lower and the middle class people prefer to travel by public
transportation modes like trains. For example, Northern England has considerable population
of middle and lower middle class people. This means the station would receive a huge
number of people. This consideration is very important in order to estimate the profit the
company can generate after investing £ 20 million towards construction of the railway station
(Pike et al. 2015). This because a large number of middle class and lower middle commuters
would mean high sale of tickets which would generate huge profits to the operating
companies like Northern Train.
Tourist Attractions:
Tourist attractions are a very criterion in my opinion, which Northern Train must
consider while renovating the station. This is because; tourist attractions are capable of
attracting tourists from the other parts of England and foreign countries. An analysis of
Northern England shows that the region has several World Heritage sites like the Durham
Castle and the Fountain Abbey (Clayton et al. 2014). This shows that these tourist attractions
would attract foreign tourists in large numbers and earn huge revenue from them. This shows
that renovation of Finadale station in Northern England would be profitable. This would
enable the company to earn high revenue from selling tickets at high rates and providing

5RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
services to these large tourist populations. It would also encourage development of other
infrastructure like roads in the Finadale area (Rajesh 2013).
Relevance and importance of management levels involved in decision-making:
The management levels in organisations play very important role in decision-making.
The consideration of criteria Northern Train needs to consider reconstructing the railway
station in Finadale clearly points out to the importance of the management levels in making
decisions. The management level in organisations consists of four levels, the board of
directors, the top managers, the middle level managers and the employees who execute the
orders (Armstrong and Taylor 2014). The following section would identify the relevance of
these management levels in decision making in Northern Train.
Making appropriate decisions:
The four management levels play significant role in making decisions. The lower
level management consisting of the executive and junior employees collect market
information in Northern England like population, the elevation of the land and economic
conditions of the people. They communicate this information to the middle level managers
who in turn pass the information to the upper level. The upper level management as a result is
able to acquire a great deal of information and use it to make appropriate decisions. This
ensures that the decisions are based on a large number of sample data, which lends them
accuracy (Goetsch and Davis 2014). Thus, management levels play significant roles in
ensuring that the apex management takes appropriate decisions.
Proper execution:
The multiple levels of decision-making ensure effective execution of the decision-
making. The strategies and decisions made by the apex management are communicated down
the hierarchy. The middle level managers segregate these decisions among the lower level

6RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
managers who in turn allocate them among the lower level employees. This multilevel system
ensures efficient allocation of job responsibilities among the employees as per their
experiences, capabilities and educational qualifications (Graham, Harvey and Puri 2015).
This analysis shows that multiple levels involved in decision making ensure timely execution
of strategies.
Choosing and applying an appropriate decision making model for Finadale Station:
The study would consider rational or economic man model to be applied to the
decision making of Northern Train. The economic man model as shown in the figure,
identifies the various alternatives the managers can consider while decision making. This
facilitates tracking the movement of the resources and helps the managers to locate faults,
which they can rectify. The rational model allows the managers to take rational decisions
towards execution of the strategies made by the apex management (Child and Hsieh 2014).
The evaluation of the case study shows that the company Northern Train is
constructing a new station. The apex management of the company requires obtaining
information regarding the environment of Northern England like population and economic
conditions. The mangers require allocating the task of command execution among the
employees (Smith 2014). They require identifying the various alternatives, which they can
consider while restructuring the railway station. This analysis shows that the management of
Northern Train should consider rational model.

7RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
Figure 1. Economic decision making model
(Source: Child and Hsieh 2014)
Planning of contingencies:
The company in order to deal with construction related risks need to prepare
contingency plans. The case study shows that Northern Train is planning to rebuild the
railway station. This exposes the project to several contingencies stemming due to lack of
resources, time, lack of expertise and change in customer preferences. Moreover, the region
of Northern England has hostile physical and climatic conditions, which pose threat to the
restructuring of the railway station (Cummings and Worley 2014). The main risks to the
project of railway station renovation are time, budget and resources.
Time:
The biggest threat challenging a project is time because it results in increase of
expenditure due to non-completion of project within time. As stated in the case study, the
project of revamping the railways station has been allocated a fund of £ 20 million. The

8RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
figure shows that amount allocated towards the project has been divided among three cost
centres namely, human resources, machinery and miscellaneous expenses like survey,
electricity and maintenance of portions of the project completed. The graph below shows that
if it is assumed that the project would be extended for 1 year where the actual target time is 5
years and all the expenses are assumed by rise by 1 percent, the expenditure would supersede
the amount of 20 million allocated to the project by 1 percent (Moody and Galletta 2015).
Thus, from the budget and the graph it is clear that time a very contingency factor for
projects. Failure of the companies to complete projects within the target time leads to
manifold increase in the expenditure.
Budget of the railway project
Sources of funds £ Expenditure £
Allocated funds 20,000,000.00 Human resources 1,000,000.00
Machinery 10,000,000.00
Miscellaneous expenditure 9,000,000.00
20,000,000.00 20,000,000.00
Figure 2. An elementary budget
(Source: Author)
Term>5 years Expenditure Rise of
expenditure
-
5,000,000
10,000,000
15,000,000
20,000,000
25,000,000
Series1
Series2
Series3

9RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
Figure 3. Graph showing increasing expenditure due to time extension
(Source: Author)
The company should form a contingency plan to deal with time constraint. It can
allocate more amounts of funds to the project so that it can mobilise more resources to
complete the project within the time. Northern Train can also outsource the different parts of
the project to subcontractors to ensure that the construction steps are completed with the
target period (Qiao, Wu and Zhou 2014).
Budget:
The budget and the graph show that extension of projects leads to increase in the
expenditures. The construction of railway stations requires huge expenditure in technology,
machinery and human resources. Northern Train requires spending amount resources to
source metal tracks and other construction materials. Moreover, it has to employ engineering
and other skilled experts to manage the project. This analysis shows that the construction of
the station places a huge bearing on the budget (Poola et al. 2014).
Northern Train should form contingency plan to deal with the budget constraint. The
company should allocate the total amount of resources judiciously. The company can also
collaborate with other firms and diversify the risks.
Resources:
The next contingency category pertains to the resources like materials and machinery,
which Northern Train can allocate to the project. The project companies normally mobilise
their resources as materials and work force towards projects for a predetermined time period
say 5 years. Now if the project tenure were extended, it would cause the construction
companies to restrict their resources for that project. This prevents the companies to using its

10RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
resources in subsequent projects and lead to loss of projects (Haslum and Geffner 2014).
Thus, the company should allocate its resources towards multiple projects to avoid loss of
projects.
Critical evaluation of methods to investigate and monitor decision-making:
Northern Train must investigate and monitor its decision making process to ensure
accurate execution and avoiding expenditures due to extension of projects. The apex
management must define the area in which the decision-making has to take place like
marketing and finance. They should analyse the problems which they may confront and make
appropriate contingency plans to deal with them. The next step is critically evaluating the
decision making to locate flaws and take steps to rectify them. The next step is to identify the
alternative ways, which the managers take to deal with the problems and choose the best
possible way (Tsang 2014). The managers should implement the decision and monitor the
outcomes of their decisions. The apex management should take steps if the decision does not
achieve the desired outcome.
The case study states Northern Train is renovating the railway platform at Finadale.
The study also shows that the region in Northern England is subjected to harsh weather
conditions like snow and rain. This is likely to cause extension of the project, which would
put immense pressure on the resources. The apex management of the company should form
the strategies of constructing the station and managing the project. They should form
alternative ways to manage the contingency situations like harsh weather conditions. The
middle level managers should evaluate the resources on regular basis and report any future
shortages. Thus, it can be evaluated that the apex management should form the decisions and
monitor them against the desired results (McCombie and Thirlwall 2016). They should

11RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
compare between the actual result and the result they sought to achieve. They should take
steps to rectify the differences between the two results.
Conclusion:
I, upon reflecting on the project of renovating the station at Finadale assumed to be in
Northern England, can point out to several facts from the discussions. The station of Finadale
is in Northern England which has steep terrains and harsh climatic conditions. This would
require Northern Train to allocate huge amount of resources to build the station. Since, the
place is sloping, the project of reconstructing of the station and lines would require
employment of advanced technology, human resources and materials. The harsh weather of
the place is likely to cause the project tenure to extend would in turn increase the expenditure
of the company manifold. The company must form an appropriate contingency plan t deal
with these probable challenges. The apex management should make accurate decisions and
monitor these decisions regular to be able to incorporate any probable changes.

12RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
References:
Armstrong, M. and Taylor, S., 2014. Armstrong's handbook of human resource management
practice. Kogan Page Publishers.
Child, J. and Hsieh, L.H., 2014. Decision mode, information and network attachment in the
internationalization of SMEs: A configurational and contingency analysis. Journal of world
Business, 49(4), pp.598-610.
Clayton, W., Ben-Elia, E., Parkhurst, G. and Ricci, M., 2014. Where to park? A behavioural
comparison of bus Park and Ride and city centre car park usage in Bath, UK. Journal of
Transport Geography, 36, pp.124-133.
Cummings, T.G. and Worley, C.G., 2014. Organization development and change. Cengage
learning.
Decision mode, information and network attachment in the internationalization of SMEs: A
configurational and contingency analysis. Journal of world Business, 49(4), pp.598-610.
Goetsch, D.L. and Davis, S.B., 2014. Quality management for organizational excellence.
Upper Saddle River, NJ: pearson.
Graham, J.R., Harvey, C.R. and Puri, M., 2015. Capital allocation and delegation of decision-
making authority within firms. Journal of Financial Economics, 115(3), pp.449-470.
Haslum, P. and Geffner, H., 2014, May. Heuristic planning with time and resources. In Sixth
European Conference on Planning.
McCombie, J. and Thirlwall, A.P., 2016. Economic growth and the balance-of-payments
constraint. Springer.

13RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
Moody, G.D. and Galletta, D.F., 2015. Lost in cyberspace: The impact of information scent
and time constraints on stress, performance, and attitudes online. Journal of Management
Information Systems, 32(1), pp.192-224.
Pike, A., Marlow, D., McCarthy, A., O’Brien, P. and Tomaney, J., 2015. Local institutions
and local economic development: the Local Enterprise Partnerships in England,
2010–. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 8(2), pp.185-204.
Poola, D., Garg, S.K., Buyya, R., Yang, Y. and Ramamohanarao, K., 2014, May. Robust
scheduling of scientific workflows with deadline and budget constraints in clouds.
In Advanced Information Networking and Applications (AINA), 2014 IEEE 28th
International Conference on (pp. 858-865). IEEE.
Qiao, Y., Wu, N. and Zhou, M.C., 2014. Scheduling of dual-arm cluster tools with wafer
revisiting and residency time constraints. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics, 10(1),
pp.286-300.
Rajesh, R., 2013. Impact of tourist perceptions, destination image and tourist satisfaction on
destination loyalty: A conceptual model. PASOS. Revista de Turismo y Patrimonio
Cultural, 11(3).
Sharma, R., Mithas, S. and Kankanhalli, A., 2014. Transforming decision-making processes:
a research agenda for understanding the impact of business analytics on
organisations. European Journal of Information Systems, 23(4), pp.433-441.
Smith, W.K., 2014. Dynamic decision making: A model of senior leaders managing strategic
paradoxes. Academy of Management Journal, 57(6), pp.1592-1623.
Steel, N., Hardcastle, A.C., Bachmann, M.O., Richards, S.H., Mounce, L.T.A., Clark, A.,
Lang, I., Melzer, D. and Campbell, J., 2014. Economic inequalities in burden of illness,

14RENOVATION OF A RAILWAY STATION
diagnosis and treatment of five long-term conditions in England: panel study. BMJ
open, 4(10), p.e005530.
Tsang, E., 2014. Foundations of constraint satisfaction: the classic text. BoD–Books on
Demand.
Wojtas-Harań, A., 2016. On the roof of Europe–the frolics of architects. Czasopismo
Techniczne.
Wojtas-Harań, A., 2016. On the roof of Europe–the frolics of architects. Czasopismo
Techniczne.