NSB202 Essay: Cultural Safety Addressing Racism in Indigenous Health

This essay critically examines cultural safety in the context of Australian healthcare, particularly concerning Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples. It begins by defining and contrasting personal versus systemic racism, discussing the power dynamics of 'whiteness,' and comparing cultural safety with cultural competency. The essay reflects on the impact of institutional racism on Indigenous access to healthcare, education, and employment, linking these issues to white privilege. Furthermore, it explores how culturally safe nursing practices address personal and institutional racism, emphasizing the importance of bi-culturalism, knowledge sharing, and fair representation. The author reflects on their evolving understanding of the nurse's role in promoting culturally safe healthcare, highlighting the necessity of empathy, historical awareness, and educational initiatives to combat racism and improve health outcomes for Indigenous Australians. This essay is available on Desklib, a platform offering a wide range of study resources, including past papers and solved assignments.

Assessment title - Cultural Safety Essay
Name
Student number
Tutor name
Total word count – 1787 words
0
Name
Student Number
Unit Code

TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. STEP 1
2. STEP 2
3. STEP 3
4. STEP 4
5. STEP 5
6. REFERENCES
1
Name
Student Number
Unit Code

STEPS 1-5
1. Demonstrate your understanding of the following key concepts.
a) Compare and contrast personal racism and systemic/institutional racism.
b) Briefly discuss the power dynamics associated with the concept of whiteness and describe how
it may relate to contemporary nursing practice in Australia.
c) Compare and contrast the concepts cultural safety and cultural competency.
a) Racism refers to the discriminative behaviour met out to a person in the society based
merely on the colour of their skin. It may lead to debarring the person from basic
societal benefits like education, employment and healthcare. When a person of colour
is subjected to an individual level of discrimination, it is referred to as personal
racism. It is firmly guided by prejudices, which when endorsed by one group results in
reinforcement of the other group as inferior (Jones, 1997). Institutional/ systemic
racism refers to the discrimination in administrative policies and practices being met
out to various groups within an institution. A relevant example of this may be found in
schools where punitive measures are more stringent for students of colour or within
the employment sector where hiring practices are biased towards certain races. The
urge for social dominance in this hierarchy has led to both intentional and
unintentional expressions of bias (Brigham, 1993) (156 words).
b) The concept of whiteness is referred to as the selective availability of benefits like
quality healthcare, wages and education for the whites over people of colour. In
purview of the contemporary nursing practice in Australia, whiteness has resulted in a
massive health gap between the health of the Aboriginal Australians and the white
Australian population. Racial discrimination has been a hindrance in provision of
adequate healthcare access to the aboriginal population. Delivering culturally
appropriate healthcare facilities to this population remains a challenge mainly due to
2
Name
Student Number
Unit Code

miniscule representation of their population within the medical community. According
to a 2011 report, the Australian nursing community had a mere 0.8% representation
from the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders (Stuart & Nielsen, 2011). Even this
minuscule representation suffers from white dominance in the contemporary nursing
field and their indigenous practices are ignored, even when treating their own
population (Nielsen et al., 2014). This means less knowledge-flow from their
community and consequent widening of the health gap. (163 words)
c) The term cultural safety is said to have been originated within the Maori mid-wifery
students- community while being trained in an Anglo educational setup. It was
devised to describe their fear of safety of the colonial training measures. Today, it has
become a framework for navigating the risks and challenges concerning the health of
indigenous people. It amalgamates the concepts of sociocultural and historical
backgrounds to devise effective health service based on cultural identity of the
recipient (Johnstone & Kanitsaki, 2007). While it enables the patient to draw
maximum benefits from the healthcare provider, it also results in endorsement of
regimes yielding positive results.Cultural competence, on the other hand, focuses on
the skill of the healthcare provider to deliver a positive experience for the patient by
integration of cultural parameters with clinical concepts. It involves assessment of
community-based values and transforming the derived knowledge resource to provide
bespoke healthcare for meeting the cultural, linguistic and social needs of the patient
(Durie, 2001). Both cultural safety and cultural competence seem to be contrasting
with one another with the former being a robust branding for inequality and
discrimination of medical policies and practices for indigenous people; nonetheless,
3
Name
Student Number
Unit Code

practically both complement each other for maintenance of high standards of
healthcare (Williamson & Harrison, 2010). (212 words)
2. In accordance with the 5Rs of Reflection Framework, report on one of the prescribed
readings (from Week’s 1-5) that grabbed your attention, and then describe your
response to this prescribed reading.
NSB202 has etched the prime areas of concern for healthcare for Aboriginal and
Torres Strait Islanders. Out of the various contexts, I was maximally intrigued by the
concern about the mental healthcare of these people (Pg.22). I was disturbed by the
fact that despite the strong positive values embedded in their community, their mental
health suffers because of personal and systemic racism. The enhancement in suicide
rates and instances of substance abuse, specifically within their youth population is
disheartening. It highlights the need to practice cultural safety and competence in
healthcare and also educate the mainstream population to denounce whiteness.
(100 words)
3. Discuss how institutional racism has been enacted and perpetuated throughout Australia’s
history, particularly in regards to Indigenous peoples’ access to adequate health care, education
and employment. Describe how these actions relate to the concept of white privilege.
Institutional racism is deeply rooted within the Australian societies and even today
ethnic disparity continues to be a constant with regards to the Aboriginals. The long
history of colonial rule and constant oppression of the Aboriginals has taken a heavy
toll on their healthcare, education and employment. There is ample evidence stating
the ill state of these three consequential markers of racism within the Australian
4
Name
Student Number
Unit Code

Aboriginals. The life expectancy of an indigenous male is 21 years less and that of a
female is 19 years less as compared to non-aboriginal males and females. They exhibit
a high susceptibility to diabetes, cardiovascular and respiratory disorders and triple the
rate of infant mortality as compared to mainstream population8. Despite the adverse
health conditions, procurement of healthcare services remains an issue because of
poverty. Poor health also became a limitation for attainment of education and
employment.
The clash of culture between the whites and aboriginals is the prime reason fuelling
this institutional racism. The discriminative practices met out to the aboriginals due to
lack of sensitivity to their culture, language and social values has created a strong
prejudice among the white population.
Institutional racism is also evident in the early healthcare policies of the country. For
example, the allotment of low-cost nursing care for Aboriginal and Torres Strait
Islander people born in 1940s while allotment of higher amount for the white
population of the same age group. Even the primary health care benefits per capita
were 11 times less than that allotted to mainstream Australian population (Henry et al.,
2004). Further low representation of the aboriginals within the medical community
due to bias in education and employment opportunities has resulted in linguistic
barriers between the patient and practitioner. Despite the government efforts for
restoration of adverse health conditions of the aboriginals, the extent of impact of
racism has been uncurbed. Ad per, the Closing the Gap target report of Australian
Institute of Health and Welfare, 47% of the existing health gap may be endowed upon
institutional and personal racism. The indigenous population is given least priority for
5
Name
Student Number
Unit Code

clinical care even in acute health conditions like cancer or coronary heart disease
(Bourke et al., 2018).
(361 words)
4. Discuss how culturally safe nursing practice does address personal and institutional
racism that impact on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples’ access to health
care.
Ensuring cultural safety within the health, educational and employment setup is a
major step not only towards better healthcare provision for Aboriginal and Torres
Strait Islander peoples but also for addressing personal and institutional racism faced
by them. Colonial history of the country has deeply embedded it with the prejudices
and stereotypes associated with the aboriginal population and this can only be
eradicated by openness of the non-aboriginal population towards bi-culturism.
Inclusion of the knowledge resource from the aboriginal communities within the
healthcare training modules creates an interface for cross-cultural exchange and helps
in eradicating the current indifference and ignorance in the mainstream population
(Merritt et al., 2018). It also helps in building an efficient treatment module for the
aboriginal patients for enhancing the healthcare standards provided to them. Ensuring
better representation of aboriginal population in the nursing workforce would help
dissolve linguistic barrier which is currently the major cause for miscommunication
and consequent sub-standard healthcare delivery to aboriginals (Brascoupé & Waters,
2009) Its inclusion within the organisational framework makes it obligatory for the
provider to tailor the treatment regime as per the cultural needs of the recipient. It
ensures the participation of the care recipient in his treatment regimen and thus has a
6
Name
Student Number
Unit Code

critical impact on the practitioner-recipent relationship. It also calls for administrative
policies within the institutions to discourage the co-workers from resorting to racist
attitude and empower the nurses in the workplace to challenge and address racist
behaviour (Vukic et al., 2012). These policies would also ensure the fairness of the
system to promote cultural integrity and social justice. However, cultural safety needs
to be accompanied with inculcation of compassion and acceptance within the white
Australian population to address the address the negative impacts of racism on
aboriginal heath, social and economic status.
(296 words)
5. In accordance with the 5Rs of Reflection Framework, reflect on the transformation of your
understanding regarding the role of nurses in addressing the health needs of Aboriginal and
Torres Strait Islander peoples in a culturally safe way. Consider how your knowledge and
understanding has developed through your engagement with the learning material and activities
(i.e. the required and recommended readings, videos, lectures and tutorial material and
activities).
My earlier understanding of the impact of racism on the healthcare needs of the
Australian aboriginal population was statistic-based and superficial. Having engaged
with the reading material, I have been able to explore and assess the critical role of
cultural safety in nursing for the provision of healthcare for Aboriginal and Torres
Strait Islander peoples in Australia. Given the history of the country and its impact on
the economic, health and social status of the aboriginals, I feel that cultural safety
targeted these concerns while also being a robust measure against racism.
7
Name
Student Number
Unit Code

Despite the positive agenda associated with cultural safety, I am forced to think about
how willing is the mainstream population to adapt to bi-culturism and step down from
the superior pedestal in their heads to believing in equality. The shift of power
dynamics from the provider to recipient may be enforced during delivering service but
does it account for the interpersonal behaviour being met out to the patient or the
aboriginal co-workers?
The current coursework also made me delve into the readings of Australia culture and
history. After going through this, I concluded that nursing education and cultural
education need to be imparted in cohesion, especially in context of countries like
Australia and New Zealand. The cultural considerations for the aboriginals can only be
realised by the white population by learning about the social, political and economic
reforms that have landed the community in the dismal state. Inculcation of empathy for
the cultural values of aboriginals among non-aboriginals is possible only via taking
them through this historical discourse.
The efficacy of cultural safety in healthcare can be majorly attributed to educational
initiatives in various healthcare domains including nursing. This has helped in
eradication of culturally unsafe clinical principles for treatment of indigenous people. It
has encouraged the engagement of patient and nurse and led to enhancement in trust
and willingness among aboriginals to opt for professional healthcare. Crampton et al.,
(2003) suggested a cultural immersion education program for healthcare trainees and
highlighted its effect in combatting racism and acceptance of nurses towards culturally
safe practices. Conforming and acceptance would also pave way for fair employment
and organisational policies and better representation of aboriginals in the nursing
workforce. Trained and certified aboriginal nurses are essential for dealing with
8
Name
Student Number
Unit Code

linguistic barrier which leads to miscommunication between the nurse and patient,
especially in busy clinical environment (Kelly et al., 2018).
It was interesting to note the fine line between cultural safety and cultural competence
that are complementary in practice despite being contrasting in definition. With respect
to nursing, the two parameters create a balance in the power relationships of the care
provider and recipient. I have imbibed that as a registered nurse, cultural safety is not
just guided by understanding of the indigenous culture but also being aware of one’s
own culture. It is instrumental to developing a higher cultural intelligence to read,
interpret and respond to different nursing scenarios when dealing with a patient from a
different cultural identity.
(499 words)
9
Name
Student Number
Unit Code

REFERENCES
1. Bourke, C. J., Marrie, H., & Marrie, A. (2018). Transforming institutional racism at an
Australian hospital. Australian Health Review
2. Brascoupé, S., & Waters, C. (2009). Cultural safety exploring the applicability of the
concept of cultural safety to aboriginal health and community wellness. International
Journal of Indigenous Health, 5(2), 6-41.
3. Brigham, J. C. (1993). College students’ racial attitudes. Journal of Applied Social
Psychology, 23, 1933-1967.
4. Crampton, P., Dowell, A., Parkin, C., & Thompson, C. (2003). Combating effects of racism
through a cultural immersion medical education program. Academic Medicine, 78(6),
595-598.
5. Durie, M. (2001, November). Cultural competence and medical practice in New Zealand.
In Australian and New Zealand Boards and Council Conference (Vol. 22).
6. Henry, B. R., Houston, S., & Mooney, G. H. (2004). Institutional racism in Australian
healthcare: a plea for decency. Medical Journal of Australia, 180(10), 517.
7. Johnstone, M. J., & Kanitsaki, O. (2007). Health care provider and consumer
understandings of cultural safety and cultural competency in health care: An
Australian study (Doctoral dissertation, RMIT University).
8. Jones, J. M. (1997). Prejudice and racism. McGraw-Hill Humanities, Social Sciences &
World Languages.
10
Name
Student Number
Unit Code

9. Kelly, J., Dowling, A., McBride, K., Keech, W., & Brown, A. (2018). ‘We get so task
orientated at times that we forget the people’: staff communication experiences when
caring for Aboriginal cardiac patients. Australian Health Review.
10. Merritt, F., Savard, J., Craig, P., & Smith, A. (2018). The" enhancing tertiary tutor's
cultural safety" study: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultural training for tutors
of medical students. Focus on Health Professional Education (2204-7662), 19(3).
11. Nielsen, A. M., Alice Stuart, L., & Gorman, D. (2014). Confronting the cultural challenge
of the whiteness of nursing: Aboriginal registered nurses’ perspectives. Contemporary
nurse, 48(2), 190-196.
12. Stuart, L., & Nielsen, A. M. (2011). Two Aboriginal registered nurses show us why black
nurses caring for black patients is good medicine. Contemporary Nurse, 37(1), 96-
101.
13. Vukic, A., Jesty, C., Mathews, S. V., & Etowa, J. (2012). Understanding race and racism
in nursing: insights from aboriginal nurses. ISRN nursing, 2012.
14. Williamson, M., & Harrison, L. (2010). Providing culturally appropriate care: a literature
review. International journal of nursing studies, 47(6), 761-769.
11
Name
Student Number
Unit Code