Organisational Analysis Assignment 1: Critical Analysis of Papers

This assignment comprises a critical analysis of four research papers related to organisational analysis. The first paper, by Tata and Prasad (2015), examines the influence of national cultural values on sustainability beliefs and organizational initiatives. The second paper, by Powel and Osborne (2015), explores the role of marketing in achieving sustainability for social enterprises. The third paper, by Cho, Laine, Roberts, and Rodrigue (2019), investigates organized hypocrisy, organizational facades, and sustainability reporting. The fourth paper, by Atkins, Thomson, and Maroun (2015), discusses utopian sustainable accounting. Each analysis addresses the authors' arguments, methods, and the paradigms from lecture 1, providing a detailed evaluation of the research presented in each paper and their implications for organizational theory and practice. The student matches the analysis to the rationale given in Lecture 1 for Organisational Analysis.

Organisational Analysis Assignment 1
Student Name:
Student ID:

Organisational Analysis Assignment 1
Given Paper 1: Tata and Prasad (2015) National cultural values, sustainability beliefs,
and organizational initiative
1 In your lectures, four rationales for organizational analysis are described.
1 Critically discuss the argument presented by the author(s).
The author stated that a company can implement the sustainability program in
several nations with a diverse social-culture environment. In contrast to this, the
literature on the sustainability does not provide clear picture regarding how
national culture can impact the interpretations of the meaning of sustainability as
well as, how these transformations in interpretation can outcome in different
sustainability practices. The author also discussed the ways of identifying the
mechanism related to sustainability beliefs as well as perception, which can
mediate the association among organizational sustainability program and
national cultural value. This paper discusses that cultures low in power distance
as well as high in collectivism, long-term orientation and femininity are a
prospect to keep stronger belief regarding the significance of sustainability.
Moreover, these cultures are high in the individualism; uncertainty avoidance
and short-term orientation are possibly maintaining stronger opinion regarding
the inconvenience of sustainability.
2 What is the method - how does the author(s) convince their readers?
The author stated that the literature on sustainable as well as cultural practices is
used by the author for convincing their readers. Furthermore, the conceptual
model is used that illustrates how cultural value impacts the sustainability
program of the company.
A different proposition is determined that a particular association between the
constructs and instructions are offered for testing the model in the potential
investigation. Qualitative data is used in this research. Data is collected through
secondary sources such as journal articles, books, websites, and journal articles.
Data is analyzed by using the content analysis method to comprehend the
qualitative information and obtains reliable outcomes.
The model demonstrates that natural culture impacts the sustainability belief as
well as the perception that may impact on quantity with the scope of
sustainability initiatives. It also illustrates the relationship between
organizational sustainability programs and sustainability beliefs are moderated
through organizational capacity and orientation of sustainability.
3 Drawing on your answers from analyzing Q (1) and (2), critically analyze and
match your analysis to the rationale given in Lecture 1 for Organisational
Analysis
Functionalism paradigm is used in this research, in which, system development
may proceed by using the formal concept, intervention with the rationalistic
methods and tools. It may also enhance the systematic knowledge where people,
software, hardware and rules as physical or formal and considers objective
entities. Structure analysis is used in this research for providing the
methodological understanding regarding national cultural values.
Along with this, Functionalism paradigm can support the investigator and
practitioners to effectively comprehend the meaning related to sustainability in
international business. This paradigm helps to address the system that can
illustrate the relation between sustainability and culture. It can support the

Organisational Analysis Assignment 1
investigator for creating the hypotheses for potential investigation. This is
beneficial for instructing the global companies making efforts to drive the
initiatives in the context of sustainability. This paradigm is used in the
implementation of sustainability in subsidiaries as well as agencies related to the
international level and making efforts for implementing the initiative regarding a
partnership with the local non-governmental companies.
Given Paper 2: Powel and Osborne (2015) Can Marketing Contribute to Sustainable
Social Enterprise
Questio
n
In your lectures, four rationales for organizational analysis are described.
1 Critically discuss the argument presented by the author(s).
This paper mainly concentrates on exploring the role of marketing in the
sustainability of social enterprises by offering public services. It also evaluates
the relationship between social, economic, and enterprise marketing. It could be
conducted by offering the role of marketing for sustainable social enterprises.
It is also stated that there is a different impact on marketing in the public and
private sector organization. It is also stated that social care services could
directly influence marketing activities. It also found that the unconscious
application of the marketing method could affect social enterprises.
2 What is the method - how does the author(s) convince their readers?
This research paper is used in the case study method in which four causes are
considered. In this, the semi-structured interview method was considered as it is
conducted on chief executives of social enterprises. The specified cases were
classified by their age. The data collection method is effective for getting the
conceptual and statistical information about the research issue. The conclusion
of this paper demonstrates the overall study in the concise form. It can also be
concluded that the paper is supportive of exploring the nature of marketing acts
by SMEs. It is also stated that marketing gives a higher contribution to the non-
profit and public sector organization. It is also stated that the marketing method
could lead to the firm for promoting business and selling their goods and
services among a huge number of consumers. It could also be effective to
sustain social enterprise. There are certain factors that are evaluated by the
social enterprise like business-to-business and business-to-customer as it would
lead to an increase in the possibilities of sustainability of the social enterprise for
the long term. It is also examined that marketing potentials could directly offer
organizational resilience for social enterprises. It is also addressed there is a
strong relationship between social enterprises and marketing. Thus, it can be
evaluated that the organization could mainly concentrate on marketing due to
getting higher competitive benefits.
3 Drawing on your answers from analyzing Q (1) and (2), critically analyze
and match your analysis to the rationale given in Lecture 1 for
Organisational Analysis
It is evaluated that the organization should critically evaluate the marketing
factors that might affect the business process and sustainability. The implication
of marketing in public services could positively affect the overall outcome of the

Organisational Analysis Assignment 1
study. The organization should also use different strategies and make a plan for
improving the marketing process and sustain the business effectively. This paper
is used social relativism paradigm in which the user discuss the concern to the
system.
Given Paper 3: Cho, C., Laine, M., Roberts, R. and Rodrigue, M. (2019). Organized
hypocrisy, organizational façades, and sustainability reporting.
Questio
n
In your lectures, four rationales for organisational analysis are described.
1 Critically discuss the argument presented by the author(s).
The main purpose of this report is to evaluate the organized hypocrisy,
organizational facades, and sustainability. There are two theirs that affected to
the corporate reporting named signalling thirty and legitimacy theory. It is also
found that corporate social responsibility reporting could lead to sustain the
business. In the current era, the private organization has needed to use
sustainability reporting as it could directly impact on organizational
performance.
2 What is the method - how does the author(s) convince their readers?
In this study, the theoretical data analysis method will be practiced as it
facilitates to collect the data from different sources and make a reliable decision
in the context of research matter. There are certain sources that are considered
by research like articles, books, online and offline sources, which could be
effective in getting a reliable outcome. In addition, it is examined that the
theoretical analysis method could be effective in the attainment of the research
task.
3 Drawing on your answers from analyzing Q (1) and (2), critically analyze and
match your analysis to the rationale given in Lecture 1 for Organisational
Analysis
In the study, Radical Structuralism is practiced by the research as it facilitates to
make a reliable decision in the context of the research matter. This paradigm in
which the radical structuralism reflecting the status critique quo with the
purpose of offering rational in radical change. This study is effective for
gaining the understanding of the current research issue that could facilitate to
conduct reliable research in the upcoming period. Moreover, it is evaluated that
the researcher will be capable to comprehend different research tools that will be
effective in conducting the study and reach the reliable conclusion. The
researcher also is capable to meet the aim and objectives of the research matter.
Given Paper 4: Atkins Thomson and Maroun (2015) Good News from nowhere
imagining utopian sustainable accounting
Questio
n
In your lectures, four rationales for organizational analysis are described.
1 Critically discuss the argument presented by the author(s).
The author stated the information regarding the ray of hope with respect to
Morris-style utopian dream in the context of modern culture. This author argued

Organisational Analysis Assignment 1
that in the traditional way, the development of accounting is illustrated as the
enhancement that demonstrates the technological transformations and resultant
in the development of economic.
In addition to this, efficiency, organizational economy and effectiveness could
be enhanced through a more refined system of accounting. But, their essence
cannot be transformed through accounting. Under positivist epistemological
way, accounting serves as a rational technical intention only, offering the
financial data to make competent the efficient distribution related to capital.
This author also stated that accounting is a natural system to gather and
disseminate financial data. This functional view regarding accounting focuses
on how accounting itself may navigate in dynamic transformation and
reformation. There is fluent as well as emerging craft that both demonstrate an
impact on development in organizational governance as well as management.
This author also demonstrated the views related to social with institutional
context.
2 What is the method - how does the author(s) convince their readers?
The method is used by the author is four-fold, contextual dialogues between
lobbyists as well as accounting scholars and also integrating the auto-
ethnographic approach. A Morris-inspired utopian metaphor, as well as
stakeholder accountability practices in the context of oral disclosures, can be
written as a song cycle. In addition to this, existing attempts related to integrated
reporting is unlikely to transformation about how large firms perform their
business to identify the uncertainty of climate transformation in short-term.
When UN reports regarding making a correction in climate transformation then
the authors need to take prompt action. The method is implemented in this paper
is for fold where initially author use a type of auto ethnographic approach by
using story telling. It also addresses the different limitations in integrating and
maintaining the projects of sustainability reporting.
3 Drawing on your answers from analyzing Q (1) and (2), critically analyze and
match your analysis to the rationale given in Lecture 1 for Organisational
Analysis
Neo-humanism paradigm is used in this research. There are certain critical social
elements that are used in this paradigm such as software, organizational
procedure, hardware, rules and formal objective entities with respect to TKI. It
is also beneficial for increasing the knowledge interest, subjectivity of meaning
as well as subjectivity of language use. It helps to enhance human
comprehension as well as rationality regarding human action through the
liberation of suppressed interests along with, liberation through unwarranted
social and natural restraints. Critical social theory is used in this paper for
gaining the understanding regarding research concerns.
The utopian image cannot demonstrate the practical as well as a realistic
solution for the existing issue. However, it represents the starting point in the
context of optimizing. It also facilitates the motivation for policy maker in order
to create effective form related to sustainability reporting as well as more
appropriate to accelerating rates regarding climatic transformation. This also
aids in attempting to create the Morris’s News From Nowhere by developing a
new structure of accountability as well as accounting.