Level 4 CRI1007 Essay: The Science of Crime and Criminals Analysis

This essay examines the science of crime and criminal behavior, specifically addressing a philosophical problem related to a case study involving a surgeon and organ transplants. The essay explores the ethical and legal implications when a surgeon is faced with a scenario where five patients need organ transplants but a young man refuses to donate his organs. The author argues that the surgeon has a moral and legal duty to save lives, but cannot proceed without the individual's consent, as it would be a violation of their rights and ethical codes. The essay emphasizes the importance of ethical norms and consent in medical practice, concluding that a surgeon cannot perform any procedure without the patient's permission, aligning with moral and legal standards. The essay is supported by references to relevant literature on the subject, providing a comprehensive overview of the ethical considerations in the context of crime and criminal behavior.