A Critical Analysis of Plato's Allegory of the Cave and its Relevance

This essay delves into Plato's Allegory of the Cave, a philosophical concept presented in Book VII of The Republic. The allegory uses the metaphor of prisoners in a cave mistaking shadows for reality to illustrate the human condition and the difficulty of attaining true knowledge. The essay explores the symbolism of the cave, the prisoners, and the escaped individual's attempt to enlighten others, highlighting the resistance to new truths and the challenges of education. It also discusses the allegory's continued relevance in contemporary society, where individuals can be seen as prisoners of desires, technologies, and belief systems, emphasizing the need to break free from these chains to achieve genuine freedom and understanding. The essay references Plato's original text and interpretations from various sources to support its analysis.

urname 1
Student Name
Instructor's
the Course
Number
Submission
Date
Plato's allegory of the cave
The Allegory of the Cave was given 2400 years ago by one of the most famous Greek
philosopher and thinkers in history, Plato (YouTube, 2015). Plato’s philosophy in book VII of
Republic gives Plato’s cave (YouTube, 2011) and it forces one to think about life and its
meaning. Plato, who looked at life like being chained in a cave and looking shadows flitting
across the walls of the cave.
Plato’s focus is not just on the ironical situation of the human being but also his own
political situation. The prisoners represent the natural condition of human beings within their
ordinary world that can be likened to the cave (Zamosc 258). As long as they live within the
limited realms of the cave, they will never know what lies beyond and the world outside. For
Plato, the world is like a dark cave, and the humans are trapped like prisoners, even if they think
they are making continual progress and living in freedom. This is because they do not see the
invisible chains of desires that bind them to the dark cave. Their heads are forever facing the
wall, and they are unable to turn and look towards the light at the entrance of the cave. When one
of them eventually escapes the cave and finds the real truth outside. He realizes that what they
have been looking at inside the cave were just shadows and not the real images. He is eager to
return and share his knowledge with others. He tells that that within the cave, they are just mere
puppeteers. However, the other prisoners think he has gone mad and do not believe him. As
humans are never able to leave the cave, they live in a world of darkness like trapped prisoners.

urname 2
And this is how they spend their whole life, believing that they are free, but the reality is that
they are chained within the cave and live without real freedom.
Humanity can be compared to those prisoners within the cave who think that their
reflections on the walls of the cave are real. Plato draws attention to the dividing line of
distinction between what we can understand and what we can see (YouTube, 2011). The
prisoners within the cave take those illusions to be the reality as they cannot turn their heads and
cannot see the entrance of the cave. They believe that the echoes are the real sounds created by
the shadows. The Allegory of the Cave suggests that people are not willing to change and are
comfortable with that ignorance. They feel comfortable with what they know and do not like the
idea of adjusting with some new truth as the whole process seems frightening to them as it takes
them away from their old ways of living. However, once they know the truth and adjust to it,
they would never go back to their ignorant ways of living (MIT Edu. 1). Plato tries to explain his
views on how difficult it is to educate the masses as they turn hostile towards those who say
anything against their belief system (YouTube, 2015).
Plato’s’ philosophy holds true even today as, despite the progress made on the planet,
each one of us still feels like a prisoner, bound by the chains of desires. The cave is like an
extended metaphor for the world and its corrupt cultures and society. (Zamosc 261). Each one of
us is living within a cave, and those caves have only become deeper and darker. The invisible
chains of desire have become stronger and increased in numbers. There are so many caves in our
world today, and it is our belief systems and self-centered attitudes that kept us bound to our
chains. Today, human beings are a slave to many new chains such as new technologies and
selfish desires. Thus, we are chained much intensely within our cave. It is ironical that we think
that we are free, progressive and liberated, but we are not. We are still living in Plato’s Allegory

urname 3
of the Cave, and unless we break those chains and turn your heads, we will never be able to get
out of the cave and escape to freedom. Unless and until people realize the truth about the cave,
the chains, and shadows, it will not be easy for them to understand the reality and move towards
the entrance of the tunnel and escape from the cave. However, there are very few who have the
courage to break their chains and turn their heads towards light and freedom. Even if they do, it
is difficult for them to change the belief systems of others and motivate them to move towards
real light and freedom.

urname 4
Works Cited
MIT Edu. " Plato Book VII of The Republic." classics.mit.edu, vol. 1, no. 1, 2018, pp. 1-4.
YouTube. “Plato’s Allegory of the Cave- Alex Gendler” YouTube, 17 May. 2015,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1RWOpQXTltA. Accessed 13 Feb. 2019
YouTube. “Plato's cave analysis.” YouTube, 27 Oct. 2011,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=axARKd24eHo Accessed 13 Feb. 2019
\Zamosc, Gabriel. “The Political Significance of Plato’s Allegory of the Cave”. vol. 66, no. 165,
2017, pp. 237-265.