Project Closure and Post Implementation Review: Report Analysis

This report provides a detailed analysis of project closure and post-implementation review (PIR) processes. It outlines the activities involved in project closure, including stakeholder briefings, checklist creation, asset inventory, financial settlements, and employee compensation. The report emphasizes the importance of a smooth closure to avoid uncertainty and facilitate post-project evaluations. It then delves into PIR, describing its role in assessing overall project performance, technical efficiency, and project management techniques. The PIR process helps to identify successes and failures, providing valuable data for future projects and ensuring that projects meet stakeholder expectations. The report highlights the significance of integrating PIR into project management to improve performance and create a baseline for future endeavors. The report includes a project closure checklist as an appendix and references relevant literature on project management.

Project end review 1
Project closure and post implementation review
Submitted by
Affiliation
Supervisor’s name
Date of submission

Project end review 2
PROJECT CLOSURE
Towards the end of any project managers will need to prepare for the closure. Project closure is
the last phase of a project life cycle (Heagney 2016 p.34). It represents a phase in which
activities and functions of a project come to a stop. It is all normal for projects to come to a
closure because they must begin and end this is part of its characteristic. The project closure may
take place quickly, clean or a longer process depending on the reason for closure. Project closure
take place if goal of the project has been met, it is not economical and mutual agreement of
stakeholders. Project managers need to be ready for any project closure in case it comes early or
later. The project closure becomes the first event before project stakeholders review the post
implementation.
Project closure activities
Once the management of the project decides to close the project all process leading to it must be
planned and implemented (PMI 2013 pp.56). It should be a smooth planned process that will
bring significant results. Similar to other project life cycle phase it should be planned, budgeted
and scheduled appropriately. The first step to a closure process is to have a termination manager
who will oversee the process. There are several activities, procedures and events that take place
during project closure. Project managers organize a briefing meeting with all stakeholders
(Heagney 2016 p.34). The meeting is preparing all stakeholders explaining to them events that
takes place during project closure. A plan in form of a checklist for closure is created by the
project manager. The checklist enables project team to follow them as part of steps during
closure (example of checklist is attached in appendix 1). An inventory list was created of all
resources and assets that are available and used in the project. The inventory list of assets was
useful in providing a methodology in which assets was disposed of. For example others were
transferred to parent projects and others were sold for residual value.
The project closure is not an individual activity every stakeholder needs to be informed and
participate in the entire process. During closure all project team members, investors, suppliers
and customers were summoned to a brief meeting were agreements were done mutually on
matters that affected them directly or indirectly. Before accounts were closed the contractors,
creditors and suppliers owing the business were paid for full statements of their accounts. All

Project end review 3
debts that the business owes are collected and banked. The human resource department was
engaged in coming up with suitable plan of compensating the employees. For example some of
the employees who had completed their contract were given gratuity as form of compensation.
The termination managers who in most cases are the project manager will ensure that documents
and records are closed, filled and stored well. Those documents with critical information are
stored well in locked cabinets, while others are disposed of. The closure of works should be
done smoothly to avoid conflicts and breakdown of operations. For example it can be done in
stages or phases to allow organization and scheduling of resources and employees involved. A
budget review was done to establish variances of the planned and actual performance. The
review was done by having a project audit that covered finance and asset management. Later a
ceremony of project closure was done involving the project stakeholders.
Potential issues arising from none closure of projects
The project closure was performed to ensure a smooth end to the project seek approval of project
client or sponsor. The can be two potential issues that can arise if a project is not closed
completely include: The first issue is that it can bring uncertainty among stakeholders if the
processes and functions of the project continue. The second issue is that management cannot be
able to evaluate how they performed by carrying out a post evaluation. The first issue can be
solved by having a stakeholder closure briefing meeting, while the second issue is by having a
post evaluation audit to establish if the goals have been met. The project closure phase is
important in project because it signifies the end of process and acceptance of the project
(Heagney 2016 pp.45). Project managers need to have a clear budget and schedule for project
closure.
POST IMPLEMENTATION REVIEW
Post implementation review comes after project closure has taken place. It is an assessments
carried out after completion of a project which defines time and life cycle of the project (PMI
2013, pp.45). But is normal practice to allow time for project changes before PIR is done. The
assessments are done based on three elements of aims, scope and objectives. PIR should clearly
indicate what went wrong or right, indicating persons who contributed to success. Not forgetting
activities and functions that brought value to the project. In project management it is important

Project end review 4
for project managers to review experiences in order to learn approaches for new experiences.
PIR activity can be done by project team through audit or evaluation process with final report
being made. A suitable PIR should cover the following subjects: project overall performance,
technical/operative performance, techniques of project management, and organization structure.
A review of overall performance was carried out to make comparison of had been achieved on
the basis on what was planned. The findings from PIR process did provide proper justifications
of the failures and triumphs that occurred. A review of technical and administration performance
were useful in explaining if certain practice or procedure were efficient or effective. The PIR did
provide findings of structure and schedule reviews of the project of which some aided or
impeded the project (Crawford & Nahmias 2010, pp.34). The project team’s review helped in
describing performance of each team member towards project. The findings did provide
appraisal data was used to make decisions of retaining some of the skilled and competent
employees. Lastly the PIR did provide data that was used to assess the effectiveness of the
project tools, techniques and methodologies employed in executing project activities.
Role of PIR in projects
The fundamental purpose of PIR process is to improve and provide baseline data future projects.
Many projects carry out PIR in order to establish if the project is meeting the required
deliverables. The data collected can be useful in providing baseline information for future
projects. They will be used by project managers as part of evidence of good practices that will be
adopted. It is useful information when making estimates and budgets for similar projects in
future. The projects can use PIR as a post evaluation activity that management can use to provide
reports to relevant stakeholders. The team can review performance to establish whether the
project did meet the goals and expectations of the stakeholders. In addition it can be useful in
providing learning experiences. The data from PIR can provide weaknesses, failures and
successes in which can be used to correct future projects. Project managers will need to integrate
PIR in their projects in order to assess performance after they have been completed.

Project end review 5
Reference lists
Crawford, L., & A. H. Nahmias, 2010, ‘Competencies for Managing Change’, International Journal of
Project Management, 28 (4), pp.405-412.
Heagney, J., 2016, the project manager leader: in fundamentals of project Management. New
York: Adventure works press.
PMI, 2013, A guide to project management body of knowledge . Newtown Square: PA: PMI.

Project end review 6
Appendix I Example of project closure checklist
Item
No.
Requires action
Yes No
Date of
action
Person
assigned
Remarks
1 Conduct a closure meeting
2 Prepare a performance
evaluation
3 Financial documents closure
4 Payment of contracts
5 Closure of project works
6 Termination of resources
usage
7 Compensation of employees
8 Filing and record keeping
9 Disposal of fixed assets
10 Final technical reporting
11 Final review meeting
12 Handing over the project