Management Accounting Report: VCX Property Valuation and Retail Impact

This report focuses on the property valuation of VCX, a leading retail asset management company. It examines the company's valuation process, which includes internal and external valuations conducted biannually, adhering to AASB and IFRS standards. The report explores the flexibility management has in determining investment property valuations based on factors like future returns, competition, and development potential. It then analyzes the impact of changes in the Australian retail industry, including the rise of online shopping and shifting consumer preferences, on VCX's financial statements, specifically addressing changes in revenue, key metrics like gearing and EBITDA, and the economic impacts of these shifts. The report also references the positive accounting theory and the impact of foreign exchange rates as per AASB 121, providing a comprehensive overview of the financial and economic considerations for VCX within the evolving retail landscape.

Running head: MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
Management accounting
Subject name and number
Name of the student and number
Name of the university
Student ID
Author note

1MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
Executive summary
The main objective of the report is to identify the property valuation of VCX. The report will
further identify and explain the flexibility of management in order to determining valuation
of investment property. It will also explain the expected impacts owing to the changes in
retail industry and its impact on the financial statements. Finally, the report will state the
economic impact of changes in the retail industry.

2MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
Answer (a)
Vicinity is the world leader in the retail sector for management of the assets that
brings together 2 most established companies in the retail property management of Australia
that is Novion property group and Federation Centres. The main objective of the company is
to enrich the community experience and the company is re-imagining the destinations for the
future to create places where the people will love to connect (Vicinity.com.au 2018).
Looking into the annual report of the company it is identified that the company
prepares its financial statements as per the requirement of general purpose financial report.
Further, the report is prepared in accordance with Corporation Act 2001 and the AASBs
(Australian accounting standards). That is issued by the Australian accounting standards
board. It further ensures the compliance with the IFRS (International Financial Reporting
Standards) that is issued by IASB (International accounting standards board).
Vicinity takes into consideration various criteria for evaluating the investment
potential of assets. This offers framework with which the company can benchmark the
portfolio composition in every six months and it also refers when reviews the potential
opportunities for acquisition (Malone, Tarca and Wee 2016). The investment properties of the
group represents leasehold and freehold interests on building and land that is held for
deriving rental income. Initially the investments are measured at cost including the associated
transaction cost. Eventually, these are carried at the fair values at each of the reporting period
on the basis of the market value that is determined by the internal valuations or external
valuers. These valuations are inclusive of the cost of capital and work in progress on the
development projects (Setyaningrum and Siregar 2015). The process of portfolio valuation is
as follows –
Each investment property of the company is valued internally or independently in December
and June of each year as part of biannual process of valuation. This process required –
 Each property shall be valued independently at least once in the year.
 Internal valuation must be carried out if the property is not due for the purpose of
independent valuation
 Internal valuation shall be reviewed by the director of independent valuation firm for
assessing the adopted assumptions and the reasonableness of outcomes.

3MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
 If the internal valuations reveals that the variance is more than 10% as compared to
the previous independent valuation then a new independent valuation shall be taken
place (Hodgson and Russell 2014)
Methodology of portfolio valuation
For determining the fair values –
 Independent valuations shall be adopted commonly at the midpoint of capitalization
of the net income and the methods of discounted cash flows.
 Internal valuations utilizes the latest available information related to property
valuation
 Properties with sales agreements in the place at the closing of the year are valued at
agreed amount of sale
 Both internal as well as independent valuation employs the method of residual value
while valuing the properties for development (Miah 2017)
Further, the company classifies the measurement of fair value into the following
hierarchy as per the requirement of AASB 13 on Fair Value measurement –
 Level 1 – unadjusted quoted price in the active market for similar type of liabilities or
assets.
 Level 2 – inputs except for the quoted price that is included within level 1 that can be
observable for assets and liabilities, directly or indirectly.
 Level 3 – inputs for liabilities or assets that are not recognized on market data base.
Answer (b)
The management can make the investment valuation as follows –
 Based on forecasted future returns – if the company feels that the future returns will
be more than expected based on the expected returns then the valuation of the
inventories can be altered accordingly.
 Competition – if there exists a competition then the market price may be reduced and
the investment price shall be adjusted accordingly.
 Resilience on long-term basis – if there is flexibility in long term basis that the
investment can be altered or reinvested then the value can be changed accordingly.

4MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
 Potential of development – if the company has reinvestment opportunity then it can
increase the valuation of the investment
 Growth and sales productivity – if the company has good opportunity of productivity
and sales then the company can increase the value of the investment accordingly.
Answer (c)
Retail industry of Australia has been reshaped by interplay among the economic,
technology and social circumstances that is changing the customer’s expectations and
emergence of new business channels and models. For assisting the customers and the
community to navigate the change in the future retail publication it will bring together wide
range of case studies in the Australian retail business that will embrace the trends and re-
imagine the future of the retail business (Cristina-Aurora 2013). The company believes that
its success is deeply associated with the success of its retailers. The asset management
approaches of the company offers high level of service to the retailers for assuring that they
will be well supported in the operations. The leasing, data, insights and marketing team’s
works together for engaging with the retailers on the ongoing basis for understanding their
requirements, solving any issues and supporting them in various ways. However, the changes
in the Australian retail industry will have the following impact on the financial statement of
VCX. –
 Investment extending capacity – with new entrance in the industry, it will face tough
choice. The new entrants like Aldi from German will give tough competition which
in turn will reduce the sales of the company. it can be identified from the annual
report of the company that the revenues of the company has been reduced from $
1259.5 million to $ 1235.8 million over the years from 2016 to 2017 (Hu, Percy and
Yao 2015).
 Key metric changes due to changes in lease accounting – the new accounting
treatment will have immediate impact on wide range of key metrics those are
monitored by the shareholders and it includes –
 Gearing and net debt – it will increased as the reported debt will increase, however the
ROU assets will not be included in this (Danielsen et al. 2014).
 EBITDA – it will go up as no operating lease expenses will be included
 EBIT – it will be increased as part of lease cost will be included under interest
expenses that are not included in EBIT.

5MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
 PBT – while the PBT for overall lease will be neutral, the profit will be lower in
initial stages of the lease owing to higher rate of interest in respect of the upfront
payment.
Answer (d)
The retail sector of Australia is underperforming continuously as compared to the
other economy. This is leading to the various convergences of events that include –
 Structural changes with regard to the industry that is driven by the shift to the online
shopping
 Changes in the consumer preference that will include greater emphasis on the
experience
 Fierce competition that will lead to the compression of margin (Riccardi 2016)
 Every slow rate of wage growth and higher rate of inflation for the essentials that will
limit the ability of the consumers for spending.
However, as per the positive accounting theory the accounting work is completely
based on reasoning. The generally accepted accounting cannot be completely changed as they
are universally accepted. Further, the changes in the economic condition will have an impact
on the foreign exchange of the company as per the AASB 121 on the effects of changes in
foreign exchange rates.

6MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
Reference
Cristina-Aurora, B.B., 2013. Valuation Techniques Used In Fair Value
Measurement. Management Strategies Journal, 22(Special), pp.97-104.
Danielsen, B., Harrison, D., Van Ness, R. and Warr, R., 2014. Liquidity, Accounting
Transparency, and teh Cost of Capital: Evidence from Real Estate Invetment Trusts. Journal
of Real Estate Research, 36(2), pp.221-251.
Hodgson, A. and Russell, M., 2014. Comprehending comprehensive income. Australian
Accounting Review, 24(2), pp.100-110.
Hu, F., Percy, M. and Yao, D., 2015. Asset revaluations and earnings management: Evidence
from Australian companies. Corporate Ownership and Control, 13(1), pp.930-939.
Malone, L., Tarca, A. and Wee, M., 2016. IFRS non‐GAAP earnings disclosures and fair
value measurement. Accounting & Finance, 56(1), pp.59-97.
Miah, M.S., 2017. Accounting standards complexity, audit fees and financial analyst
forecasts in Australia: a thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of
Doctor of Philosophy in Accounting at Massey University, Albany, New Zealand (Doctoral
dissertation, Massey University).
Riccardi, L., 2016. Accounting Standards for Business Enterprises No. 3—Investment Real
Estates. In China Accounting Standards (pp. 25-29). Springer, Singapore.
Setyaningrum, D. and Siregar, S.V., 2015. The Value Relevance of Foreign Translation
Adjustment: Case of Indonesia. Academy of Accounting and Financial Studies
Journal, 19(2), p.251.
Vicinity.com.au., 2018. Vicinity Centres, Home Page. [online] Available at:
http://www.vicinity.com.au/ [Accessed 2 May 2018].