Appraising Evidence: Youth Suicide Experiences and Perceptions Report

This research article presents a qualitative systematic review of experiences and perceptions of youth suicide. The study analyzed 27 articles, focusing on factors leading to suicide attempts, elements important to recovery, community beliefs, and treatment/prevention strategies. Thematic analysis revealed four categories: triggers and risks, factors in recovery, institutional strategies, and community beliefs. The first category was further divided into behaviors, feelings/emotions, family, peer influences, and others. The second category included interpersonal, cultural, and individual influences. The third category was split into education and treatment. The review emphasizes the complexity of youth suicide, highlighting the need for procedural reform and a shift in societal attitudes for successful prevention and treatment.

RESEARCH ARTICLE
A qualitative systematic review of experiences
and perceptions of youth suicide
Jessica Grimmond1, Rachel KornhaberID
1, Denis VisentinID
2, Michelle Cleary1*
1 School of Nursing, College of Health and Medicine, University of Tasmania, Sydney, NSW, Australia,
2 School of Health Sciences, College of Health and Medicine, University of Tasmania, Sydney, NSW,
Australia
* [e-mail]
Abstract
Background
Suicide remains a global issue with over 800,000 people dying from suicide every year.
Youth suicide is especially serious due to the years of life lost when a young person takes
their own life. Social interactions, perceived support, genetic predisposition and mental ill-
nesses are factors associated with suicide ideation.
Objectives
To review and synthesize qualitative studies that explored the experiences and perceptions
of suicide in people 25 years old and younger.
Design
Qualitative systematic review.
Data sources
PubMed, PsycINFO, Scopus and CINAHL were searched alongside hand-searching refer-
ence lists up to October 2018.
Methods
Methodological quality was assessed using the qualitative Critical Appraisal Skills Pro-
gramme checklist. The 27 studies included in the review centered around youth suicide and
included interviews with young people and members of the wider community. Thematic syn-
thesis focused on factors leading to suicide attempts, elements important to recovery,
beliefs within the community, and treatment/prevention strategies.
Results
Thematic analysis of the articles revealed four categories: i) triggers and risks leading to sui-
cidality; ii) factors involved in recovery; iii) need for institutional treatment/prevention strate-
gies; and iv) beliefs about suicide at a community level. The first category was further
subdivided into: i) behaviours; ii) feelings/emotions; iii) family influences; iv) peer influences;
PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568 June 12, 2019 1 / 25
a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111
OPEN ACCESS
Citation: Grimmond J, Kornhaber R, Visentin D,
Cleary M (2019) A qualitative systematic review of
experiences and perceptions of youth suicide.
PLoS ONE 14(6): e0217568. https://doi.org/
10.1371/journal.pone.0217568
Editor: Soraya Seedat, Stellenbosch University,
SOUTH AFRICA
Received: January 7, 2019
Accepted: May 14, 2019
Published: June 12, 2019
Copyright:© 2019 Grimmond et al. This is an open
access article distributed under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License, which
permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided the original
author and source are credited.
Data Availability Statement: All relevant data are
within the manuscript and its Supporting
Information files.
Funding: This work was supported by the
University of Tasmania (AU) Summer Scholarship
Scheme to JG. The funder had no role in study
design, data collection and analysis, decision to
publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared
that no competing interests exist.

and v) other. The second category was split into: i) interpersonal; ii) cultural; and iii) individ-
ual influences, while the third category was divided into i) education; and ii) treatment.
Conclusion
Youth suicide is a complex issue with many causes and risks factors which interact with one
another. For successful treatment and prevention, procedural reform is needed, along with
a shift in societal attitudes toward emotional expression and suicide.
Introduction
Suicide impacts the lives of many people across the globe and is a concerning pub
issue [1]. Almost 800,000 people’s deaths are the result of suicide internationally e
accounting for 1.4% of all deaths [2]. The incidence of suicidal ideation universally
during adolescence [3], with suicide the second leading cause of death worldwide
29 years age group [2]. Hence the impact of suicide on the families and communit
cant. Since the proportion of suicide deaths among young people is high, youth su
be considered a serious health issue due to the broader social cost and the years o
when a young person takes their own life.
A number of theoretical models provide a framework for understanding the com
action between biopsychosocial influences on suicidality. While each of these mod
a different explanation and emphasises different specifics, there are similarities th
The Interpersonal Theory of suicide (IT) [4], the Integrated Motivational-Volitional M
suicidal behaviour (IMV) [5] and the Three-Step Theory (3ST) [6] each separate sui
tion from actual attempts and explore the differences between suicidal thoughts a
actions. While the IT was developed to provide a comprehensible and potentially fa
framework of suicidality [4], the IMV model was borne out of a need to predict fact
influence suicide ideation and the circumstances whereby these thoughts are acte
Similar to the IT, the 3ST is a demonstration of what Klonsky and May call an “idea
action" framework [7] based in empirical evidence [6], though it emphasises differ
Each of these models provides a detailed perspective of the cognitive, social and p
contributors to suicidal ideation and attempts.
Psychological factors and personality differences such as hopelessness, impulsiv
resilience all have a bearing on a person’s likelihood of experiencing suicidal ideat
Hence, identifying and understanding these factors is an important step in predicti
venting suicide. The first step in the 3ST centres around experiences of hopelessne
which are usually, but not exclusively, emotional. [6]. They posit that frequent exp
pain act as punishment, resulting in the individual “essentially being punished for
but that pain must also be coupled with psychological experiences of hopelessness
cal data supports this, as both pain and hopelessness were strongly related to suic
and with one another [6]. While this theory is not specific to young people, the res
consistent in the youth age bracket [6].
The IT also highlights the importance of psychological experiences. A key eleme
is the perception of burdensomeness whereby low self-esteem and feelings of expe
(among others) contribute to dimensions of self-hate and liability [4]. These dimen
bine to result in perceived burdensomeness [4]. The IT suggests that when perceiv
someness is coupled with barriers to socialisation, and these are viewed as ‘stable
Experiences and perceptions of youth suicide
PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568 June 12, 2019 2 / 25

permanent’ [4] states, suicidal ideation may occur. These barriers to socialisation a
‘thwarted belongness’ and include feelings of loneliness and a lack of reciprocal ca
this way, the IT provides a dynamic explanation of suicidal ideation as it considers
logical influences in conjunction with social ones [4].
Other theoretical frameworks also consider social factors to have a strong influe
cidality. In the second phase of the IMV model, the motivational phase, feelings of
humiliation can progress to those of entrapment when threats to self-moderators,
inability to adequately resolve social problems, exist [5]. Like the IT, the IMV mode
thwarted belongingness to be an important social factor and, here, it acts as a mot
moderator which sees feelings of entrapment develop into suicidal ideation [5]. Re
ports this model suggesting those who are more sensitive to the social judgements
more likely to feel defeat and entrapment, which are central to the motivational ph
IMV model [5].
Socialisation is also considered a factor in the 3ST. The second step in this theor
connectedness which usually describes interpersonal relationships, but can also be
include an attachment to work or hobby interests [6]. In this model, connectednes
against progression from moderate to severe ideation [6]. In this way, the 3ST diffe
IT, as it acknowledges factors which can stem progression [6], where the IT focuse
tive factors alone [4]. In the 3ST, the psychological experiences of pain and hopele
lead to suicidal ideation, but only when these feelings are combined with a disrupt
nectedness is it possible for a person to move from ideation to suicide attempt [6].
Klonsky and May [6] suggest that social influences play a vital role in suicide.
In line with these theoretical models, difficulty with socialisation and interperson
have been identified as predictors of suicidality in adolescents [1]. The death of a l
been linked to suicidality in adolescents [1, 3] and research has identified that ado
have been exposed to suicide and related behaviours were far more likely to self-r
related behaviours [8]. The causes for this link, however, are unclear. Experiencing
of a family member may offer a behavioural model for young people who are alrea
ble [1, 5] or it may simply make it more salient in a young person’s mind as a solut
problem [5].
In a similar way, the presence of ‘cluster effects’ and the concept of peer contag
lights the important role of socialisation, especially in adolescents [9]. However, sin
causes of these phenomena are poorly understood, misconceptions about the soci
sion of suicide exist within society. The belief that incidents of suicide become high
ideation and related behaviours are discussed is common and has informed public
These beliefs, however, are not based in empirical evidence [10]. Nonetheless, the
effects’ do exist, and adolescence seems to be the peak time for peer contagion an
ence [9].
One explanation for these cluster effects is that people are more attracted to tho
perceive as being similar to themselves [11]. The group will likely experience simil
and events [1] and an adolescent’s experience of depression can be well predicted
their friends [9]. Therefore, rather than a ‘copycat’ explanation of suicide, it is reas
assume that some of the factors contributing to suicidal ideation in one person wil
affecting that person’s peers [9]. In fact, experiencing a peer’s suicide, itself, may
of hopelessness and thwarted belongingness which are linked with suicidal ideatio
cussed theoretical models [4, 6].
The acceptance of suicide as an appropriate response to negative life events ma
become normalised as a shared belief between members of social groups or certai
[12, 13]. In this way, attitudes and understanding become shaped by the experien
Experiences and perceptions of youth suicide
PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568 June 12, 2019 3 / 25

beliefs of others [12]. It is also important to consider, however, that those with pre
nerabilities may be drawn to likeminded people or subcultures (eg. Goth or EMO) f
outset, which will bias the sample and overemphasise the social influences on suic
13].
When considering the social impact that a family member’s suicide may have, it
ble to separate the possible predisposition to psychiatric disorders associated with
[1]. Autopsies indicate a prevalence of psychiatric disorders of over 90% in those w
died by suicide, though these are not always diagnosed while the person is alive [3
history of mental health problems or suicide can also be a predictor of suicidality [
though the genetic influence is unclear.
These biological influences are also well explained in the current theoretical mod
explains that for a person to progress from ideation to attempt, they must acquire
ity for suicide [4]. This capability can be acquired cognitively, through a reduced fe
or physically through increased pain tolerance [4]. Similarly, the 3ST acknowledge
pain sensitivity can provide a dispositional capacity for suicide, while it can also be
through repeated exposure socially or through practical access to means [6]. It is c
these models that physiology has a part to play in suicidality, but that both suicida
and suicide attempts involve a complex combination of biopsychosocial factors.
Since there are so many influences on suicidality, identifying them and exploring
tionships to one another is an important step in prevention and treatment approac
also important to consider that, while the current models of suicide provide a stron
work of the issue, they are not age specific. Since the experiences of adolescents w
greatly from those further into adulthood, research that centres on young people i
[3]. While information gathered from quantitative studies is important in assessing
aspects of youth suicide, detailed thematic analysis of qualitative data [14] can pro
and specific insights into the thoughts and feelings of those directly affected, as w
wider community.
The need to explore societal perceptions of suicide has been identified [3] and t
compare these views with the lived experience of suicidal young people, for examp
vide a deeper understanding of the issue. Hawton, Saunders and O’Connor [1] hav
gested that future research should explore the factors that assist in moving away f
suicidality. While various studies focus on specific aspects of suicide such as preve
gies [15, 16], psychiatric factors [17], and treatment strategies, there is a need for
which takes a more macro approach. Therefore, this review focuses on the suicida
of young people and explores not just the experiences of suicidal people, but inclu
ions of health professionals, parents and members of the wider community in orde
the true complexity of the issue.
Objective of the review
To review and synthesize qualitative studies that explored experiences and percep
cide in people 25 years old and younger.
Methods
This qualitative systematic review was guided by the thematic synthesis methodol
Thomas and Harden [14] with reporting meeting the Enhancing Transparency in Re
the Synthesis of Qualitative research statement (ENTREQ) consisting of 21 reporte
Table) [18].
Experiences and perceptions of youth suicide
PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568 June 12, 2019 4 / 25

Inclusion and exclusion criteria
Included studies met the following criteria: i) original qualitative studies published
reviewed journals in the English language with no date restriction; ii) participants w
adolescents or young adults (25 years of age or younger) who had attempted suici
family members of those who had attempted suicide or experienced suicidal ideati
sionals working with young people or members of the wider community; iii) qualita
views primarily discussing youth suicide and suicidal ideation in young people. Exc
studies were abstracts, editorials, conference proceedings, theses, and secondary
sources (e.g. reviews). Studies which were quantitative were excluded.
Search strategy
A comprehensive literature search was conducted up until October 2018 without ti
(by RK, MC) using four electronic databases: PubMed, Scopus, Cumulative Index of
and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL), and PsycINFO. Boolean connectors AND and
were used to combine the following MeSH and search terms: adolescen�
, teenager�
, suicidal
ideation, suicide, attempted suicide, trigger�
, risk factors, perception�and qualitative research.
As each database uses different indexed terms, the search strategy was adapted f
in syntax and indexed/MeSH terms for each database (S2 Table).
Title and abstract screening of all papers identified by the search strategy was in
performed by authors MC, RK and JG with reference to the published inclusion/excl
criteria.
Search outcome
A total of 617 studies were identified. Following removal of 160 duplicates, 457 titl
abstracts were then screened of which 406 did not meet the inclusion criteria. Fifty
text articles were therefore retrieved and screened for eligibility and 31 were exclu
of the reference lists of the remaining studies identified 7 further studies meeting
criteria. In total, 27 qualitative studies met the inclusion criteria for this systematic
study selection process is detailed in the PRISMA Flow Diagram [19] (Fig 1).
Quality appraisal
Quality appraisal of studies meeting the inclusion criteria was conducted by three
the research team (MC, RK and JG) using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme fo
tive Studies Checklist [20]. All 27 qualitative studies identified were included (Tabl
Characteristics of studies
The studies included in this review ranged in size from a case study of one individu
134 participants [22] with an average of approximately 38 participants, though no
disclosed exact numbers. At least five studies involved Caucasian participants [21,
included Native American populations [27–30] while four involved Hispanic and Lat
ticipants [23, 31–33]. At least one study each focused on participants from Nicarag
Korea [22], Iran [35], Italy [36] and Cambodia [37], while other studies referenced
participants from a variety of ethnic backgrounds [38, 39]. In all studies which prov
gender of participants, there were more female participants, except one which had
sentation of gender [36]. Five included studies reported only female participants [2
Participants who attempted suicide ranged in age from 11 to 28 years and had exp
cidal ideation or attempted suicide at 25 years of age or younger. Studies which in
Experiences and perceptions of youth suicide
PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568 June 12, 2019 5 / 25

Fig 1.PRISMA flow chart search strategy.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568.g001
Experiences and perceptions of youth suicide
PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568 June 12, 2019 6 / 25

Table 1.CASP ratings.
Authors and year of
publication
Bergmans,
Langley, Links,
and Lavery
(2009)
Bostik and
Everall (2007)
Coggan,
Patterson, and
Fill (1997)
Everall, Bostik,
and Paulson
(2005)
Everall, Bostik,
and Paulson
(2006)
Fullagar,
Gilchrist, and
Sullivan (2007)
Gulbas,
Hausmann-
Stabile, De Luca,
Tyler, and Zayas
(2015)
CASP Question Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No
Are the aims stated clearly?● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Is the qualitative
methodology appropriate
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Is the research design
appropriate to address aims
of the research
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Recruitment strategy
appropriate to aims?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Does the data collection
method addressed research
issue?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Has relationship between
researcher and participants
been considered?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Have ethical issues taken
into consideration?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Was the data analysis
sufficiently rigorous?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Is there clear statement of
findings?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
How valuable is the
research?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568.t001
Table 2.CASP ratings.
Authors and year of publicationGulbas and Zayas
(2015)
Herrera,
Dahlblom,
Dahlgren, and
Kullgren (2006)
Holliday and
Vandermause
(2015)
Jegannathan,
Kullgren, and
Dahlblom (2016)
Jo, An, and Sohn
(2011)
Keyvanara and
Haghshenas
(2011)
CASP Question Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No
Are the aims stated clearly? ● ● ● ● ● ●
Is the qualitative methodology
appropriate
● ● ● ● ● ●
Is the research design appropriate to
address aims of the research
● ● ● ● ● ●
Recruitment strategy appropriate to aims?● ● ● ● ● ●
Does the data collection method
addressed research issue?
● ● ● ● ● ●
Has relationship between researcher and
participants been considered?
● ● ● ● ● ●
Have ethical issues taken into
consideration?
● ● ● ● ● ●
Was the data analysis sufficiently
rigorous?
● ● ● ● ● ●
Is there clear statement of findings?● ● ● ● ● ●
How valuable is the research? ● ● ● ● ● ●
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568.t002
Experiences and perceptions of youth suicide
PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568 June 12, 2019 7 / 25

from other members of the community included participants aged up to 64 years o
studies involved data from young people who had experienced suicidal ideation an
additionally provided their parent/caregiver’s testimony [32, 40, 41]. Some studies
data from members of the wider community and their thoughts about youth suicid
28, 30, 37, 39, 42] or those who worked with [43] or knew [44] a young person wh
attempted suicide. At least three of the included studies took place in schools [37,
while others included interviews in treatment facilities [36, 40, 43] and post-discha
Table 5 presents a summary of included studies.
Data extraction and synthesis
Researcher JG in collaboration with other team members (MC, RK) led the data ext
and synthesis of these studies. Key themes were compiled for each article and the
were then grouped based on common traits. In line with Thomas and Harden’s [14
for thematic synthesis, the ‘Results’ section of each article was analysed using line
ing. Each category was designated a colour and the sub-categories within each the
resented by a number. Text that was relevant was highlighted in the theme’s corre
colour and the number of the subtheme written adjacent. Coloured tabs were used
page to ensure each piece of relevant text could be quickly and appropriately acce
ther analysis. Upon completion of the line-by-line coding, each subtheme was re-ex
and each piece of text compared to others in that category for similarities and diffe
findings were then reviewed by all team members and synthesised.
Table 3.CASP ratings.
Authors and year of
publication
Matel-Anderson
and Bekhet
(2016)
Montreuil,
Butler, Stachura,
and Gros (2015)
Orri et al. (2014)Roen, Scourfield,
and McDermott
(2008)
Schwartz, Pyle,
Dowd, and
Sheehan (2010)
Shilubane,
Ruiter, Bos,
Reddy, and Van
Den Borne
(2014)
Shilubane et al.
(2012)
CASP Question Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No
Are the aims stated clearly?● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Is the qualitative
methodology appropriate
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Is the research design
appropriate to address aims
of the research
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Recruitment strategy
appropriate to aims?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Does the data collection
method addressed research
issue?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Has relationship between
researcher and participants
been considered?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Have ethical issues taken
into consideration?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Was the data analysis
sufficiently rigorous?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Is there clear statement of
findings?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
How valuable is the
research?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568.t003
Experiences and perceptions of youth suicide
PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568 June 12, 2019 8 / 25

Results of the review
Thematic analysis of the articles revealed four categories: i) triggers and risks lead
ality; ii) factors involved in recovery; iii) need for institutional treatment/prevention
iv) beliefs about suicide at a community level (Table 6). The first category, triggers
leading to suicidality was further subdivided into: i) behaviours; ii) feelings/emotion
ily influences; iv) peer influences; and v) other. The second category, factors involv
ery was further divided into: i) interpersonal; ii) cultural; and iii) individual influenc
the need for institutional treatment/prevention strategies category is split into i) ed
and ii) treatment subcategories.
Triggers and risks leading to suicidality
Behaviours.The most commonly displayed behaviour was difficulty with commun
tion, specifically with communicating personal feelings [25, 38]. This was in part a
participant age with many younger people lacking the “vocabulary to talk about fe
instead relying on cliche´s and metaphors which inadequately expressed their true emot
[25, 29]. For others, communication issues stemmed from emotional barriers due t
tionships [32, 34] including mistrust of those around them [30]. When communicat
attempted, disclosure to friends and family can be difficult for the suicidal person,
receives little sympathy or tough love [32, 34, 36, 39, 42]. In addition, their confida
Table 4.CASP ratings.
Authors and year of
publication
Strickland and
Cooper (2011)
Strickland,
Walsh, and
Cooper (2006)
Sukhawaha,
Arunpongpaisal
&
Rungreangkulkij
(2016)
Tingey et al.
(2014)
Walls, Hautala,
and Hurley
(2014)
White and
Morris (2010)
Zayas, Gulbas,
Fedoravicius, and
Cabassa (2010)
CASP Question Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No Yes Can’t
tell
No
Are the aims stated clearly?● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Is the qualitative
methodology appropriate
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Is the research design
appropriate to address aims
of the research
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Recruitment strategy
appropriate to aims?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Does the data collection
method addressed research
issue?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Has relationship between
researcher and participants
been considered?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Have ethical issues taken
into consideration?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Was the data analysis
sufficiently rigorous?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Is there clear statement of
findings?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
How valuable is the
research?
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568.t004
Experiences and perceptions of youth suicide
PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568 June 12, 2019 9 / 25

Table 5.Summary of included studies (n = 27).
Author/s, year &
country
Aims Sample & study population Methods Findings
Bergmans, et al.
[47], 2009, Canada
To understand the transition to safer
behaviours and to provide clinical
suggestions to those who provide care
to this population.
Sixteen people aged 18–25 years
with a history of two or more
suicide attempts.
Qualitative, grounded
theory study
A pathway from high to lower risk was
established. Young people at the
highest risk of attempting suicide
spoke about “Living to Die” and
progressed through “Ambivalence and
Turning Points” to “Pockets of
Recovery” as they move aware away
from suicidality.
Bostik and Everall
[24], 2007, Canada
To develop an understanding of
adolescent’s perceptions of the role of
attachment relationships in the
process of overcoming suicidality.
Fifty adolescents who were
previously suicidal between the
ages of 13 and 19 years old.
Qualitative interviews,
grounded theory study
Parents, peers and extra-familiar
adults each had important attachment
relationships with young people
recovering from suicidal ideation as
did a spiritual connection. Finding
acceptance, having a permanent
relationship, receiving encouragement
and experiencing intimacy and
closeness were all common
experiences of attachment. These
attachment relationships and
experiences helped young people
change their self-perceptions.
Coggan, et al. [42],
1997, New Zealand
To enhance knowledge of ways to
address youth suicide.
School age students Focus groups and analysisStudents spoke about what they
believed the warning signs of a suicidal
friend, their perceptions of available
services and resources for young
people at risk and potential prevention
strategies.
Everall, et al. [21],
2005, Canada
To illustrate the role developmental
processes, cognitive development,
identity formation and autonomy
seeking played in one teenager’s
experience of becoming and
overcoming being suicidal.
One 20-year-old female Case study The participant spoke about factors
which contributed to her becoming
suicidal and those that were important
in overcoming suicidality.
Everall, et al. [25],
2006 Canada
To explore how adolescents and
emerging adults conceive their
emotional experiences associated with
being suicidal.
Forty-one females, nine males
previously suicidal between the
ages of 14–24
Qualitative interviews,
grounded theory approach
Participants spoke of the
overwhelming despair, shame and self-
loathing, and alienation and isolation
they experienced. They also spoke of
how they responded to these emotions
and how they moved beyond
suicidality.
Fullagar, et al.
[26], 2007,
Australia
To explore how everyday
understandings of the issues
surrounding suicide risk and
prevention were constructed within
community contexts and were
mediate by a range of social
institutions.
Eighty-one young people (aged
15–24 years), service providers
(teachers, school counselors,
sports coaches and youth and
health workers) and adults
(parents and community leaders)
Structured interviews
including 10 open ended
questions
Constructions of suicide through
statistics and stories were common, as
was discussion about stigma and
distancing of suicide. Young people
and adults also differed on their
perspectives of youth suicide.
Gulbas, et al. [31],
2015, USA
To describe and compare the
conditions and experiences that
precede the decisions to self-harm in
order to contribute to an
understanding of the contexts
surrounding self-harmful behaviours
within in Latina adolescent behaviour.
Thirty-seven Latinas between the
ages 11–19 who attempted suicide
through self-harm.
Qualitative interviews and
analysis
Attempters spoke about feeling
powerless, as well as unloved and
unsupported in their interpersonal
relationships. A history of self-harm
was also common.
Gulbas and Zayas
[32], 2015, USA
To link the attempters experience to
the broader socio-cultural forces that
the attempters both encounters and
surrenders to.
Ten Latina teen suicide attempters
and their parents
Qualitative interviews and
comparative analysis
Participants reported subjective
distress, interpersonal discord and
emotional isolation.
(Continued )
Experiences and perceptions of youth suicide
PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568 June 12, 2019 10 / 25

Table 5.(Continued)
Author/s, year &
country
Aims Sample & study population Methods Findings
Herrera, et al.
[34], 2006,
Nicaragua
To explore perceived causes and
discover triggers and processes
leading to suicidal behaviour among
adolescent girls in Leon, Nicaragua.
Eight Nicaraguan girls aged
between 12–19 admitted to
hospital after attempting suicide
In-depth interviews,
grounded theory and
content analysis
Perceived causes were material
conditions, family structure and
norms and values. When combined
with triggering events and emotions
these conditions elicit action from the
participants. These actions were
explained as problem solving, escape
or suicide attempt.
Holliday and
Vandermause
[38], 2015, USA
To describe and interpret the
phenomenon of attempted suicide in a
sample of teens who visit an
emergency department for a suicide
attempt
Six young people aged 15–19 who
visited an emergency department
for a suicide attempt
Heideggerian hermeneutic
methodological approach
Common patterns and themes were
identified. The pattern of attempting
as a way of communication was
evident through themes of Ambiguity
and cries of pain. The second pattern,
attempting as transforming is
described through being unconnected,
spiraling down and being alone with
suffering. Conversely, connecting was
seen as a way to climb upwards.
Jegannathan, et al.
[37], 2016,
Cambodia
To explore the views of the focus
group on the societal attitudes towards
suicide, contemporary media norms,
Buddhism and their influence on
suicidal behaviour
Forty-eight students from 2
schools in Cambodia
Focus groups and thematic
analysis
The social stigma of suicide was a
common theme throughout, as was the
double-edged nature of the media as
both educative and suicide-
provocative. Suicide-ambiguity in
Buddhism was also prevalent.
Jo, et al. [22],
2011, Korea
To understand the suicidal ideation of
the qualitative content analysis in
South Korean college students
One hundred and thirty-four
South Korean college students
Non-structured open
questions, qualitative
content analysis
Physical, physiological and social
concerns were discussed as being
facilitators of suicidal ideation, while
religious, individual and relational
beliefs were seen as inhibitors.
Keyvanara and
Haghshenas [35],
2011, Iran
To illuminate the socio-cultural
context of attempted suicide among
Iranian youth.
Twenty-five young people aged
14–17 who attempted suicide and
were admitted to hospital in
Isfahan
Qualitative interviews,
thematic analysis
Participants frequently reported
despair, failure in love, family issues
involving conflicts between children
and their parents and/or siblings, the
pressure of high expectations from
family and peers, and poverty as
important factors in their suicide
attempt.
Matel-Anderson
and Bekhet [43],
2016, USA
To explore components of resilience
in adolescents who survived a suicide
attempt from the perspective of nine
psychiatric nurses.
Nine psychiatric nurses. Focus group and analysisRisk factors were split into six
categories: Unstable households and
traumatized childhood history, having
a means to drugs and firearms,
bullying, cognitive distortions and lack
of vision for the future, absence of
parental bonding and lack of positive
role model, and poor self-esteem and
issues with identity.
(Continued )
Experiences and perceptions of youth suicide
PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568 June 12, 2019 11 / 25

Table 5.(Continued)
Author/s, year &
country
Aims Sample & study population Methods Findings
Montreuil, et al.
[40], 2015, Canada
To find what the perceptions of
children with suicide associated risk
factors and their parents are regarding
helpful nursing care in pediatric
mental health settings?
Children with at least one suicide
risk factor and their psychiatric
problem, and their parents
Semi-structured
interviews, participant
observation and inductive
analysis
Caring for the child as a special person
was considered important in recovery.
Ways of doing this included getting to
know the child, personalizing care,
being available, and communicating
calmly. Caring for parents was
achieved through being available to
parents and reassuring parents
through talking. Managing the child’s
illness involved including parents in
the care team, linking the body to the
thinking and teaching coping
behaviours. It was also important to
create a therapeutic environment by
managing the physical and social
environments.
Orri, et al. [36],
2014, Italy
To explore the perspective of
adolescents directly involved in
suicidal acts
Sixteen adolescents with either
single or multiple suicidal acts in
their past or with a history of.
Qualitative interviews and
interpretive
phenomenological analysis
Common themes were divided into
individual and relational dimensions
of the suicide attempt. Individual
dimensions included negative
emotions toward the self and the need
to have control over their lives.
Relational dimensions involved a
perceived impasse in interpersonal
relationships, communication issues,
and suicide as revenge.
Roen, et al. [39],
2008, UK
To consider how some young people
become positioned as suicidal subjects
while others do not and how some
young people find suicidal behaviour
imaginable while others do not
Sixty-nine people aged 16–24
years
Interviews and focus
groups, discourse analysis
Common themes for discussion
involved the ‘othering’ of suicide,
suicidal subjecthood as being readily
accessible and attempts to rationalize
why people attempt suicide.
Schwartz, et al.
[23], 2010, USA
To understand the attitudes, beliefs
and perceptions of adolescents and
parents of adolescents from a variety
of backgrounds regarding adolescent
suicide
Ninety-six children of 13–18 years
of age and parents/guardians of
children aged 13–18 years
Semi-structured focus
groups, analysis
Participants spoke about the risk
factors, predictability, preventability
and environmental factors of suicide
in young people,
Shilubane, et al.
[46], 2012, South
Africa
To identify psycho-social target points
for future educational interventions
Fourteen adolescents who
recently attempted suicide
One-on-one in-depth
interviews, analysis
Psychosocial factors identified in this
study were disturbed family
relationships and perceived
accusations of negative behaviour.
Problems with social support systems,
such as family and peer problems, and
experiences of negative emotions and
depression were also prevalent.
Participants discussed negative life
events, often a family history of
suicide, peer suicide or the individual’s
previous suicide attempts, as well as
the impact of living circumstances and
a lack of knowledge of available
counsellors.
Shilubane, et al.
[44], 2012, South
Africa
To describe the impact on high school
students of a suicide or suicide
attempt by a peer to assess students’
knowledge about suicide, perceived
risk factors, signs of poor mental
health, and to assess their awareness of
available mental health care and
resources and opinions on prevention
Fifty-six high school student who
had a peer commit or attempt
suicide
Focus groups, inductive
analysis
Peer reactions were discussed, as were
the signs of poor mental health, the
perceived cause of the peer’s suicide
attempt/suicide, perceived availability
of resources and opinions on
prevention.
(Continued )
Experiences and perceptions of youth suicide
PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217568 June 12, 2019 12 / 25