NRSG367: Critique of Position Statement on Reflective Practice

This essay presents a critique of a position statement concerning the implementation of reflective practice within the nursing profession. The critique assesses the structure of the position statement, noting its clear introduction, well-defined conclusion, and overall organization. It evaluates the statement's alignment with established nursing standards, particularly those emphasizing patient-centered care, and examines the credibility and currency of the references used to support its claims. The critique highlights the importance of reflective practice in promoting professional and personal development among nurses, facilitating critical review of actions, and integrating contemporary procedures and policies in clinical settings. It further explores the potential benefits of reflective practice for patient care, such as improved patient-nurse relationships and enhanced health outcomes. The critique concludes by affirming the value of the position statement and emphasizing the significance of reflective practice in nursing, provided it is implemented effectively and ethically, while also acknowledging the importance of continuous self-evaluation and adherence to ethical values and principles within the nursing profession. Desklib offers a wealth of resources, including solved assignments and past papers, to support students in their academic endeavors.

Running head: POSITION STATEMENT CRITIQUE 1
Position Statement Critique
Student’s Name
Institutional Affiliation

POSITION STATEMENT CRITIQUE 2
Position Statement Critique
The position statement on reflective practice is well argued and presented. Furthermore,
its structure is well organized. The position statement has a clear introduction which tries to
explore some of the advantages of applying reflective practice in clinical practice. It states that
reflective practice is essential to registered nurses because it aids them in advancing both
personally and professionally. Furthermore, the practice creates an opportunity to critically
review their actions and incorporate contemporary procedures and policies in clinical settings.
The conclusion of the position statement explicitly explains its position. It sums up that
reflective practice is imperative to both patients and nurses (Thompson Pascal, 2012). On the
contrary, this depends on its successful implementation. The conclusion of the position statement
further notes that the advantages of reflective practice outweigh the disadvantages. According to
contemporary research, the summary of the article is true.
The position statement is in line with the topic. It reviews that the effective application of
reflective practice could help improve the care delivered by medical practitioners. In instances
where reflective practice is properly implemented, patient health has been enhanced
significantly. When healthcare providers critically examine their deeds after providing care, it
strengthens their relationship with patients (Kinsella, 2010). Notably, ailing or sick people have
confidence that their health threats are prioritized by the nurses. Therefore, they develop the urge
to reveal additional information which could be helpful in improving their health.
Every aspect of the practice of registered nurses is guided by specified nursing standards.
The position statement justifies that reflective practice is directly influenced and directed by the
standards. As nurses conduct and implement the reflective practice, they are compelled to act in
line with the provisions of the standards (Bulman and Schutz, 2013). For instance, the nursing

POSITION STATEMENT CRITIQUE 3
principles require that registered nurses provide personalized and patient-centered care (Bulman
and Schutz, 2013). Therefore, nurses have to ensure that any evaluation and analysis they
conduct in regards to their practice must be directed towards availing the best possible care. All
nursing standards interconnect to ensure that as registered nurses apply reflective practice, they
must adhere to the provided guidelines. In addition, the standards guide nurses to uphold their
ability to avail the finest medical service.
In the same vein, the references utilized in this position statement are credible, verifiable
and contemporary. The evidence outlined in them reveals that reflective practice is the capability
to conduct self-evaluation by registered nurses in the medical field. Additionally, this self-
reflection advances the nurses’ skills towards the provision of excellent care (Johns, 2017). In the
same token, registered nurses must observe the stated standards hence strive to maintain ethical
values and principles. The author extensively examined all fundamental details regarding
reflective practice in regards to health care. Moreover, the author explicitly states that the
effective implementation of reflective practice will be beneficial to both registered nurses and
patients. In the same token, the position statement has a clear introduction which tries to explore
some of the advantages of applying reflective practice in clinical practice.

POSITION STATEMENT CRITIQUE 4
References
Bulman, C., & Schutz, S. (Eds.). (2013). Reflective practice in nursing. John Wiley & Sons.
Johns, C. (2017). Becoming a reflective practitioner. John Wiley & Sons.
Kinsella, E. A. (2010). Professional knowledge and the epistemology of reflective
practice. Nursing philosophy, 11(1), 3-14.
Thompson, N., & Pascal, J. (2012). Developing critically reflective practice. Reflective
practice, 13(2), 311-325.