Analyzing Family Dynamics in Alice Munro's Royal Beatings Essay

This essay provides an analysis of Alice Munro's short story, "Royal Beatings," focusing on the complex family dynamics and the impact of the physical and social environments on the characters, particularly the protagonist, Rose. The essay explores themes of love, hate, poverty, and the psychological effects of a challenging upbringing during the Depression era. It examines the relationships between Rose, her father, and her stepmother, Flo, highlighting the power struggles, anxieties, and the unusual anticipatory excitement surrounding the "royal beatings." The analysis also considers how the environment, including the cramped living conditions and the bleak social setting, conditions the characters' behaviors and perspectives. The essay draws upon literary analysis and supporting sources to offer a comprehensive understanding of the story's intricate plot and its exploration of family relationships within a challenging societal context.

Surname 1
Student Name
Instructor's
The Course
Number
Submission
Date
Royal Beatings by Alice Munro
Alice Munro’s “Royal Beatings” revolves around a family and its complicated
relationships. There are intense emotions of love and hate in the story that is short but not simple.
The protagonist of the story is Rose who lives with her father, stepmother Flo and a younger
half-brother, Brian. Rose, the protagonist of the story is conditioned by his or her physical and
social environments.
The plot of the story is set against a complicated time during the Depression years and
among the poorest sections of the society. Rose lives with her family behind their grocery and
furniture repair store. Her father works in a shed as a furniture restorer, and his earnings are
barely sufficient to meet the needs of his family. Their neighborhood is too cramped to provide
any private space. The story takes place during the Depression that only adds to the harshness of
the physical environment for the family. Rose has seen only poverty and bleak conditions of life
around her as they lived in a poor part of town, where there were only factory workers and
foundry workers, bootleggers and prostitutes and unsuccessful thieves (Munro 120). The author
paints a grim description of the town with “dirt roads and boggy places, front yard dumps and
strange looking houses” thieves (Munro 121). Rose finds herself surrounded by a legendary
kind of poverty that has no place for her aspirations and dreams. Like her, the other characters of
the story too must have been conditioned by their physical environment.

Surname 2
Rose is an imaginative and sensitive little child, and the young girl knows only Flo as her
mother. It is from Flo that she knows about the stories about the town and its characters. Flo is
also responsible for the royal beatings for Rose, and Rose's father gives those punishments. The
only details Rose gets of her mother are from Flo as there are no pictures or clothes of her
mother. There are only some egg cups with a delicate pattern in red that were bought by her
mother (Munro 118). Each member of Rose’s family was pushed to the limits of their lives and
condition a psychic tension and frustrations inherent in their situation. The simmering conflicts
between Rose and her stepmother lead to anxieties and desires. Her father’s arrival in their
conflicts raises them to a deeper level. Rose and her father find themselves caught in a flux of
confusion and with the physical encounter of the royal beating causing a kind of unique kind of
anticipatory excitement within everyone. Rose’s father justifies his actions while Flo expresses
concern after the royal beating that transported Rose in an extraordinary state of calm. The
beating is like a special event in Rose’s eyes. Rose is pushed towards an internal splitting,
divided between her civilized self and her animal self-fighting for its survival (Garner and
Murray 153). Towards the end, Rose’s perspective widens considerably now that she
understands the physical and social environments that must have conditioned here mind and
Flo’s behavior.
The story carries an intricate plot shaped by convoluted times. Rose, the protagonist
remains in a state of struggle because of her physical and social environments that impact her
family dynamics. What develops is a power struggle within the family with a strange mix of
kindness and cruelty. The family dynamics are tested by the physical and social environment and
can be held responsible for the injustices to Rose.

Surname 3
Works Cited
Garner, Lee, and Jennifer Murray. "From Participant to Observer: Theatricality as Distantiation
in 'Royal Beatings' and 'Lives of Girls and Women' by Alice Munro." Journal of the
Short Story in English, vol. 51, 2011, pp. 149-159.
Munro, Alice. " Royal Beatings." Selected Stories vintage international, vol. 1, no. 1, 2015, pp.
117-1391.