Developing Sports Law in India: A Challenge for the Future

This report delves into the evolving landscape of sports law in India, highlighting the transformative impact of globalization and commercialization on the sports industry. It acknowledges the unique characteristics of sports compared to other businesses, particularly the need for competitive balance and the rise of financial restrictions. The paper examines the current legal framework, the absence of comprehensive sports legislation, and the influence of international bodies like the WTO, US, UK, and EU on Indian sports law. It explores the potential for emulating successful models from these regions to address issues such as doping, gender inequality, and contractual disputes. The report further analyzes the role of WTO rules, the Bosman case, and the modes of service in fostering sports law development. It advocates for the establishment of a national sports controller and emphasizes the significance of the White Paper and Lisbon Treaty in shaping future sports law in India. The report concludes by emphasizing the need for a robust, authoritative, and material culture of national identity through promoting health interaction, gender equality, and political sanity to support sports in India.

Running head: SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 1
"Developing Sports Law in India: A Challenge Ahead"
Student’s Name
Institutional Affiliation

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 2
Introduction
The twin powers of globalization and commercialization in the world trade organizations
have transformed Indian sports into a worldwide business. However, there are a considerable
number of ways by which sports elements remain fundamentally not the same as different
business associations. The monopolistic idea of sports associations and the essential requirement
for keeping up a competitive balance between the athletic groups have brought about the rise of
numerous types of financial limitations like income sharing, spending tops, drafts, non-altering
clauses.1 Although these restrictions are ordinary in present-day Indian sports, they have
unavoidably pulled in consideration of rivalry law, which intends to shield markets from against
severe limits. Their legitimateness under Indian sport laws has frequently been addressed in
different purviews on a regular basis. India has been no particular case in such regards. It is
imperative to acknowledge that WTO rules and other Indian policies are entirely responsible for
maintaining reasonable competition in the field of sports.
This paper also incorporates the US, UN, UK and EU rules regarding their implication
son Indian laws. The US articles depict its systematic approach on sports law as it is classified it
into amateur, professionals and international levels each comprising of its law. It also entails how
the UN has recognized sports as a manner of entering health, education and national
development. It has streamlined the filed with critical law system that guides such procedures.
According to this paper, The UK and EU sports law entails the legal regulation enhancing the
creation of a cultural and social network in sports important for India.
1 Hamid Mamdouh, Adlung, and Rudolf. "How to design trade agreements in services: Top down
or bottom-up?" Journal of World Trade 48, no. 2 (2014): 191-218.

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 3
Hypothesis
Sports law in India will work if only the entire country will realize the critical aspects needed in
the field of sports. The Indian sports laws should emulate what has been in use in areas such as
the US, WTO, EU, UN, and also in the UK.
The Modern Scenario of Indian Sports "Without proper Sports Law Act."
India is a country with umpteen sports. Currently, sports like cricket have been followed
hence the need for progressive change in bringing about more games. In the modern scenario, the
ministry of youth affairs and sports has to handle both administration and financing of various
competitions.
Currently, there exists no state legislation to regulate sports in India. The administrative
activities regarding games are the responsibility of autonomous authorities such as the Indian
Olympic association making it difficult for the government to be actively involved. They are
registered under society's registration acts of 1860 and are no quite flexible. This situation
requires an immediate course of action to enact proper sports law act. The national sports policy
1984/2011 has no complete or implemented bill hence bringing about challenges like doping,
gender inequality and inappropriate contracts that demoralize sportspeople.
How might we create Sports Law from UK and EU Sports Law Acts and Rule Separately;
model Sports Law Act of UK; Article 45 TEFU
As an action of undoubted business centrality, sports bodies from the UK and EU should
guarantee their exercises don't negate Treaty arrangements to create sports law separately. As the

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 4
European Court of Justice's (ECJ's) ruling according to in Busman illustrated, EU law can
profoundly affect sport. Even though this concise clarification does not legitimize the mark EU
sports law, it explains why there is a connection between game and EU law. The EU's
arrangement inclusion in sport reaches out past legal guideline. Article 3 likewise communicates
the EU's craving to venture into progressively social fields. Since the 1984 Fontainebleau
Summit, the EU has endeavored to expand European joining past the monetary area by setting up
a 'people's Europe'. To create sports lawks and EU expects to utilize games to actualize a scope
of cultural, social and educational strategy goals laid out in Article 45. Be that as it may, the over
the top commercialization of game joined with legal guideline at EU level takes steps to
undermine these political goals. Without more coordinated activity in the field of play, the EU
approach towards sports dangers separated by contending strategy pressures.
The rise of a coordinated EU sports approach held together by a discrete region of sports
law is another advancement in the EU. It has its underlying foundations in the post-Bosman
political discussion about the eventual fate of EU association in sport.
The UK and EU have an administrative strategy enthusiasm for sport because of its duty
to ensure the safety of legal frameworks of the Single Market. Conversely, the EU harbors
political arrangement yearnings for sport, especially in the field of the separate individuals
Europe project. Therefore, there will be creation of a sports law in India from different UK and
US sports laws.
Bosman case
The Bosman case in 1995 was one such circumstance where the European Court of
Justice felt it essential to require the European overseeing assortment of football, UEFA, to

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 5
revise its guidelines concerning the exchanges of players between clubs. The choice has without
a doubt had the ideal impact according to empowering the free movement of players and has
been a device which has been generally utilized by some prominent sportsmen in the course of
the most recent 15 years. India should acquire the laws of the case to ensure the flexibility of its
sports system.
How WTO rules can also help develop Sports Law in India
Two groups playing against one another resemble two corporate firms delivering a single
item. The item is the game, weighted by the incomes got from its play. In one sense, the groups
contend; in another, they consolidate in a solitary firm where the achievement of each branch
requires productivity. Inconsistent dispersed playing ability can create a competitive imbalance.2
Compensation of the team players, to a great extent, relies upon the degree of rivalry between the
groups in the specific games. Sport is commonly sorted out in a sort of a 'pyramid' structure, with
a solitary overseeing body controlling generally administrative and business parts of each game.
Sports overseeing bodies, for example, BCCI, have laws and policies that frequently
endeavor to safeguard for themselves the sole capacity to direct the game and to compose
occasions. To forestall the improvement of adversary associations, they have tried to tie players
in by denying them from contending on different events. Such principles have been the subject of
problematic issues under competition law. 3
2 Rachel, Fefer. Trade in Services Agreement (TiSA) Negotiations: Overview and Issues for
Congress. Congressional Research Service, 2016.
3 Mark, James. Sports law. Macmillan International Higher Education, 2017.

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 6
The Indian Sports industry has been advanced significantly by the existing WTO rules.
Sports have expected a corporate structure with the number of business intrigues included. With
expanding market development and the requirement for clear and far-reaching legitimate
documentation, sport issues are gradually turning into a significant concentration. This because
agreements must have the option to explain gatherings' desires and responsibilities, must secure
the competitor's and the brand's substantial picture premiums. 4The nation has arrived at a phase
where India needs an enactment that manages sports law. India's disappointment in all the
universal games means that there are poor infrastructural developments and corruption which
exist inside the sports alliances. To fulfill the expanding needs of the evolving situation, it is
significant that a uniform code and rule for sports be advanced.
WTO rule thus supports the Indian sports sector by dealing with issues like inefficient or
unnecessary deploying the finances. It also ensures responsibly tackling mistakes in managing
non-accountability for sports results.
WTO rules also support India by establishing and promoting standards of ethics and spirit
of sportsmanship by enacting strict anti-doping procedures. It encourages and provides education
to sportsmen on dangers and demerits of doping. It offers consultancy services to legal issue sin
sports to ensure flexibility in the Indian decision-making bodies. This enables the ministry of
youth affairs and sports to be excellent in accounting for academic programs such as coaching
and also physical education awareness domains. It also constitutes contractual rules that guide
4 Kashid-Patil et al, "Agriculture and Rural Development: Spatial Issues, Challenges and
Approaches."

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 7
terms of games hence boosting the morale of sportspeople. 5The WTO is critical in creating a
robust, authoritative, and material culture of national identity through promoting health
interaction, gender equality, and political sanity to support sports in India.
How can four modes of Service in WTO rule also help in developing Sports rule in India?
The four modes of supply coveted by the General Agreement on trade in service under
WTO are cross border supply, consumption abroad, commercial presence, and presence of a
natural person. These help in delivering sports services like training, offering products like
jerseys and shoes. They are essential in ensuring that service delivery is done on a personal basis
hence creating a strong relationship between countries across the globe that interact with India in
enhancing sports activities. Some of the principles of such mode of services include liberations,
commitment, and completion, which enhances perceptions regarding the commercialization of
the worldwide sport.
Other than empowering national approaches and projects, the development of the game to
the simultaneous rundown will empower the formation of a free and wide-running national
games controller, along the lines of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi). This body
could supervise, in the open intrigue, the exercises of national games leagues as well as state
alliances, similarly significant entertainers in a unified administration model. Sebi is entrusted
with ensuring the open financial specialist through the implementation of guidelines and posting
measures while regarding the independence of public organizations to maintain their
organizations. This is the kind of job a free games controller must play, given that the general
5 Singh Chandel Yadav and Mani, "Sports Law in India-An Evolving Discourse or a Need for
Paradigm Shift." NUALS LJ 12 (2018): 21.

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 8
population is the essential financial specialist in sport. It follows that anybody looking to
administer sport must be responsible for this financial specialist.6 The national games controller
could likewise be entrusted with supervising races to these bodies and setting up a lasting games
court that is situated to hear and resolve sports-related questions proficiently, rapidly and
successfully.7 Around the world, this is an administration model that has gotten acknowledgment
and acknowledgment, and it is the ideal opportunity for Indian games administration to step up
and convey administration to the general population.
The modes of service are important in incorporating issues like public entitlement and
privatization of sports teams. This will help Indian private investors in investing in sports like
owning clubs and teams hence supporting the upcoming young athletes.8
One noteworthy issue in Indian games today identifies with dispute resolution goals and
explicitly disputes goals inside National Sports Federation (NSFs). The kinds of disputes alluded
are disciplinary issues against the competitors, bans forced because of age fraudulent activities,
sexual orientation disparity, doping, upkeep and accommodation of restorative records, and
issues concerning monetary help. Therefore, the WTO rules and actions create a dynamic state of
balance in ensuring that people cooperate and there exist no disputes in the sports system.
6 Scott, Sinclair. "The WTO and its GATS." In The Handbook of Globalisation, Third Edition.
Edward Elgar Publishing, 2019.
7 Vijay Kumar, Singh. "Issues in Emerging Area of Sports Law: Lex Sportiva." May 22 (2017):
114-147.
8 Dr. Yadav, "Commercialization of Sports and Competition Law." Commercialization of Sports
and Competition Law (December 24, 2016) (2016).

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 9
How to use White Paper Rule and Lisbon Treaty of Sport rule for development in Indian
Sports law Act for future.
India can use both the Treaty of sport and the white paper in various ways. First of all, the
two rules work on improving the status of games within a country. Therefore, India has to
emulate aspects such as coming up with strategic concepts that will analyze the future of sports
in the country. The gathering of evidence necessary for the development of games is one of the
critical objectives of the two rules. Through this analogy, then it means that India has to foster
positive development that will aid in handling sports-related activities. Besides, White Paper rule
and the Lisbon Treat advocate for the improvement of health through the use of physical
activities. Therefore, India has to copy this objective, thus coming up with a new curriculum that
incorporates the importance of physical activities. Through this analogy, it will be easy for the
country to initiate new sporting ideas hence improving the field of sports.
On the other hand, the Lisbon Treaty came up with overall goals on how to change to the field of
sports by 2022. The vision was inducing sporting activities, thus helping nations to create
employment opportunities as well as promoting aspects of social inclusion. India has to emulate
this vision by investing more resources that will help in expanding the industry of sports.
How can India sports develop from US law also?
US sports are definite on matters related to games. The federal government has drafted
different sports laws that control spotting activities. Some of the requirements in the US include
amateur sports law, labor sports laws, and the academic aspects of sports law. The amateur sports
law governs the ethical conduct in sports, issues of gender equality in sports, and also
inexperienced legibility concepts. India has to borrow all these concepts contained in the amateur

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 10
law of games. Besides, the academic aspects of sports law in the US show how various
institutions are educating learners on the importance of sports. There are schools such as the
University of Florida that incorporates games as one of the main subjects. Through this analogy,
India has to emulate this behavior and then introduce sports in all schools. Therefore, India
should emphasize on these laws.
How can UN General Assembly rules, can develop sports law in India.
Various ways can be used by the UN General Assembly to initiate the idea of sports law
in India. The first aspect of the body is to consider the importance of sports in India. Researchers
believe that physical education is key to the development of sporting activities. Through this
analogy, it means that the UN General Assembly has to focus on how to educate India as a
country on fundamental aspects contributed by sports law9.
On the other hand, the chamber has to acknowledge and take note of the issue of sports in
India. The idea is that the UN offers financial assistance to its members, thus helping nations to
induce projects necessary. In the case of India, the UN has to provide all the resources needed
when drafting sports laws. Besides, through the principle of the UN, the chamber has to ensure
physical education in India includes the idea of sports law10.
Consequently, the UN General Assembly has to monitor sporting activities in India. The
idea is that the UN demands its members to give reports annually on what is happening in the
industry of sports. The 2005 meeting held by the UN revealed how nations should work hard to
9 C-519/04 P, Meca-Medina & Majcen v. Commission, Judgment of 18 July 2006
10 Epstein, Adam. "Utah and Sports Law." Marq. Sports L. Rev. 28 (2017): 107.

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 11
control most of the scandals coming from games11. Through this analogy, the UN encourages
governments such as the Indian government to pay much attention to sporting matters. Through
this process, it becomes easy for the nation to come up with regulations and laws that govern all
activities in fields.
Why India needs a separate Sports law too
Various elements support why India needs sports laws. Most of the authors in the field of
sports have indicated that games are one of the activities that enhance the aspect of entertainment
and recreation. Through this analogy, it means that there must be appropriate rules and
regulations that control games all the time. The idea is that games have metamorphosed into a
big industry that needs strict rules. In every country, we tend to have selected organizations that
have been formulated to supervise all games. Just like in India, there must be a stable legal
system that governs and controls what is happening in the field of sports12. Therefore, some of
the reasons that show why India should advocates for laws in games are;
First of all, sporting not only in India but also in the whole world has been plagued by
numerous scandals. Most of the issues and cases in-laws concerning sports in India are a result of
a deficiency of a clear legal framework in the nation. For example, scandals such as those
witnessed in IPL scam and also the issue of sexual harassment by the Hockey team rocked the
11 K. Murugan v Fencing Association of India, Jabalpur and Ors (1991) 2 SC 412
12 M.P. Triathlon Association through its Secretary and Anr v Indian Triathlon Federation and Ors 1996
(8) SCALE 693

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 12
entire country. The whole aspect experienced by the nation about the scandal faced by the
hockey team of women shows that India is yet to recognize the element of law in sports13.
On the other hand, the maladministration experienced in the field in sporting activities
shows that there is a need to come up with common law to administer sporting activities. We
have sporting activities in India that have halted due to the lack of legislation to control them.
Currently, the cricket games for men in India have marred due to the deficiency of laws to
regulates these games. For the last five years, cricket games in India experienced aspects of
match-fixing. According to researchers in the field of sports, match-fixing in India is a crucial
issue that needs to be controlled with an immediate effect. The solution to match-fixing cannot
be managed if no laws14.
Besides, India needs sporting laws to control labor issues as well as aspects of drug abuse
in sports. Labor issues in sporting activities in India are some of the elements that need an
appropriate legislative framework. There must be laws and policies that show how club owners
and players should negotiate issues such as payments, working hours as well as working
conditions in the country. Besides, the agents ought to work just as per agreement between the
appropriate parties. These goals on labor issues can only be achieved in India if the country
formulates prevailing laws regulating sporting activities15.
13 National Basketball Association (NBA) v Motorola and STATS (New York) Second Circuit Court of
Appeals, USA 480 US 941 (1987)
14 The Industrial Disputes Act 1947
15 The Sherman Anti-Trust Act 1980

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 13
On the other hand, there must be laws governing aspect of doping. There are numerous
cases of drug abuse in sporting activities in India. It is evident that FIFA has banned doping, and
this means that India has to come up with drafted policies controlling doping in India.
Moreover, there must be laws in India to advocate for the aspect of accountability.
Through this, it will be easy to achieve the vision of sports in the nation. The idea is that most
projects related to games in India have backslidden due to the issue of corruption. The
government has to ensure those agencies managing games ought to follow the law of games16.
Consequently, the sporting laws should work on promoting aspects of sportsmanship as well as
rules of ethics in sports. The vision of sports in India can only be achieved if laws are advocating
for standards of ethics in competitions. Through this analogy, it will be easy to promote the
morale of players. It will also gear the growth and development of sports in all parts of the
country.
About the future of Sports Law and Sports Law Act in India, how will it look like.
India now appreciates the importance of sports. The idea is that for now, the country can
testify on the progress it has made on matters related to games. Therefore, the future of the sports
law in India will work If only the country is ready to learn from what other nations have done
sporting activities. Most of sports laws that have been drafted by different countries and agencies
keenly aim at building sports just like any other industry. India has to learn from the strategies
and visions outlined by UK sports law. Through this process, India will have a rigid future for
sports law. Also, the sports law in the future will create a conducive environment whereby the
rights of players and also contract agreements will be protected.
Conclusion.
16 Indian Constitution Art 252

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 14
To sum up, India has to come up with numerous aspects that will govern the industry of
sports. Various elements show how sports law is a fundamental aspect of India. The country has
failed to handle some of the scandals faced by players and other related stakeholders in the field
of sports. The UN policies, as well as the models of WTO, are on the frontline advocating for
sports laws in India. The country has to emulate what other European nations have done to
support sports law. Therefore, for the state to have massive progress in sporting activities, then
there must be legal policies that work to eradicate issues in sports. Only sports laws will help
India to achieve a positive vision when it comes to sporting issues.
Bibliography
Primary Resources
Case Laws
C-519/04 P, Meca-Medina & Majcen v. Commission, Judgment of 18 July 2006
Epstein, Adam. "Utah and Sports Law." Marq. Sports L. Rev. 28 (2017): 107.
K. Murugan v Fencing Association of India, Jabalpur and Ors (1991) 2 SC 412
M.P. Triathlon Association through its Secretary and Anr v Indian Triathlon Federation and Ors
1996 (8) SCALE 693

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 15
National Basketball Association (NBA) v Motorola and STATS (New York) Second Circuit
Court of Appeals, USA 480 US 941 (1987)
Legislation
The Industrial Disputes Act 1947
The Sherman Anti-Trust Act 1980
Indian Constitution Art 252
Secondary Sources
Articles in Peer Reviewed Journals
Adlung, Rudolf, and Hamid Mamdouh. "How to design trade agreements in services: Top down
or bottom-up?." Journal of World Trade 48, no. 2 (2014): 191-218.
Fefer, Rachel F. Trade in Services Agreement (TiSA) Negotiations: Overview and Issues for
Congress. Congressional Research Service, 2016.
James, Mark. Sports law. Macmillan International Higher Education, 2017.
Shanediwan, Principal Dr RK, D. L. Kashid-Patil, and Mrs ND Kashid-Patil. "Agriculture and
Rural Development: Spatial Issues, Challenges and Approaches."
Sinclair, Scott. "The WTO and its GATS." In The Handbook of Globalisation, Third Edition.
Edward Elgar Publishing, 2019.
Singh, Vijay Kumar. "Issues in Emerging Area of Sports Law: Lex Sportiva." May 22 (2017):
114-147.

SPORTS LAW IN INDIA 16
Yadav, Dr. "Commercialization of Sports and Competition Law." Commercialization of Sports
and Competition Law (December 24, 2016) (2016).
Yadav, Mani, and Abhinav Singh Chandel. "Sports Law in India-An Evolving Discourse or a
Need for Paradigm Shift." NUALS LJ 12 (2018): 21.