Supporting and Challenging Articles: Play in Early Childhood Education

This essay critically examines the concerning trend of the diminishing role of play in early childhood education. The introduction frames the issue, highlighting societal pressures and technological influences that are reducing children's opportunities for play. The essay then analyzes three articles that support the issue, exploring the impact of curriculum policies, standardized testing, and the shift towards direct instruction. Furthermore, it challenges the issue by examining alternative perspectives on the importance of moral and religious education, self-directed play, and the paradox of play itself. The essay identifies similarities and differences between the articles, while also providing a point of view on the issues. The conclusion reiterates the importance of play in early childhood development and suggests a need for a balanced approach that integrates play with learning. The essay emphasizes the need for a balanced approach that integrates play with learning, ensuring children's holistic development.

Running head: Supporting and challenging articles 1
Play in Early Childhood
Disappearance of play from early childhood education

Supporting and challenging articles 2
Contents
Introduction......................................................................................................................................3
Section 1..........................................................................................................................................4
Support of 3 articles.....................................................................................................................4
Section 2..........................................................................................................................................6
Challenges of 3 articles................................................................................................................6
Section 3..........................................................................................................................................8
Point of view on the issues...........................................................................................................8
Conclusion.....................................................................................................................................11
References......................................................................................................................................12

Supporting and challenging articles 3
Introduction
Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood includes cutting edge work and interdisciplinary which
can involve the subsequent areas such as post modern, poststructuralist and approach of
postcolonial and handle with issues such as language and identity, new information technologies,
pedagogy and curriculum. The journal article of “Disappearance of play from early childhood
education” is chosen to describe the issues in early childhood. The major issue of disappearance
of play is found in now days because the schools, parents and societies are only encourage and
focus on the study and ignore the playing factor for children. Apart from that television, new
technology, internet, mobile phone, laptop and many more are liable to snatch the right of play
from children and they are happy to spend their time to sit one place for many hours. Play is the
activity which can be interpreted as a concept and as including dynamic complex systems of
various activities on both micros as well as macro level (Darbyshire, 2007). The report is made
on the selected issue and 3 articles will be chosen in the context of this issue which will show the
support about this issue and reflects the challenges about the selected issue. Critical analysis will
be made in this assignment of the supporting and challenging points.
The issue said that play is being disappeared out of early childhood education in many
countries. It could be seen that children are spending their most of time in being instructed and
tested in math and literacy in the comparison of learning from play and exploration, using their
imaginations and exercising their bodies. There are number of kindergartens that use high
standard of tests that incorporates the burden of study such as number of subjects. The teachers
are strictly order to follow the scripts of study which may not be deviated by them __________.
At the same time, parents of the children pressurize them inadequate manner to study which lead

Supporting and challenging articles 4
children into adverse situation and they started overburden in early childhood. The freedom
should be available for the child so that the child can choose the sports and other activities apart
from that only considering the study. The program of learning and development is not accepted
by number of kindergartens which being the reason of overburden of study on the children.

Supporting and challenging articles 5
Section 1
Support of 3 articles
There are 3 articles will be discussed in this section in the support of “Disappearance of play
from early childhood education” issue.
The first article topic is “Searching for play in Early Childhood Care and Education Policy”,
written by Sophie Alcock. This article reflects the early childhood curriculum policy and early
childhood assessment policy and explores the invisibility of play in recent Early Childhood Care
and Education policies. This paper observed of the ignorance of play in New Zealand ECCE
policy. Play is an important activity for the student that encourages them to involve in the sports
and other activities as per their interest. Play is the activity which can be interpreted as a concept
and as including dynamic complex systems of various activities on both micros as well as macro
level. In the perspective of micro, playfulness is considered as the inter-subjective behaviour and
way of describing to play with others or together with other children or with things. The view of
playfulness is assumed as the altitudinal process resonates with the theme of flow which
describes players in the term of intensely occupied in the present in being and in the activity
(Alcock, 2013). It has been found through this article that play has disappeared from early
childhood education and teachers are forced to focus on study of the student. The notions of
simplistic learning and learners are pretend to have replaced complex process of care,
development and play in Ministry of Education which rapidly disclose a devaluation image of
young children in the form of learners (Alcock, 2013).
The second article has been chosen of Ageliki Nicolopoulou which topic is ‘The Alarming
Disappearance of Play from Early Childhood Education’. It has been found that this article

Supporting and challenging articles 6
supports the issue of early childhood play. This research has focused on the degree to which the
kindergarten is significant in laying the fundamentals for later development as well as learning.
There are some considerable evidence that the type of resources and support which is liable to
ready young children for formal education. For instance, through encouraging the early
acquisition of developing literacy skills is generally available to middle class in comparison of
many low incomes. It has been analyzed that the sense of urgency is resistance through extensive
misimpression that research on early brain development gives permission for increasing the
direct instruction in preschool. Furthermore, the mission for accountability embodied in No
Child Left behind Act has escorted to amplify reliance on upper stakes standardized tests, forcing
teachers to train flourishing test takers at younger ages. In such scenario, the priority of playing
seems at lower or considering as the time wasting distraction at worst (Early, Maxwell,
Burchinal, Alva, Bender, Bryant, Zill, 2007). It has been discussed in the support of the
mentioned issue that social competence is essential elements for the readiness of school because
it promotes the cognitive attainment of children.
‘The Playing Learning Child: Towards a Pedagogy of Early Childhood’ is the article written by
Ingrid Pramling Samuelsson & Maj Asplund Carlsson. It shows in the favour of the issue that
play and learning practices are not separate rather learning of early childhood can be developed
with the help of playing activities. It is necessary as per this article that the teacher of the
preschool should be aware about the perspective of children as well. The learning process should
be there in which involvement of teacher as well as children is necessary. Activities are
disappeared from the education and it has been analyzed that the children are not motivated to
involve in the sports activity (Moss, 2011). It defines the organizing activities with children
which are considered as an approach that involve the communication between children and

Supporting and challenging articles 7
teachers. It reflects that interaction, attitude and environment are tangled into a totality. Early
childhood education must be controlled to allow the most possible amount of interaction and
communication between children and teachers on regular basis (Samuelsson & Carlsson, 2008).
Three aspects has been discussed in this article these are the experience of children as a point of
departure, discernment, simultaneity and variation as key‐factors and meta‐cognition, meta‐
cognitive dialogues and meta‐communication as crucial issues. As per first aspect, it defines that
the activities of children come from own perspective. Play is not same as learning; it is entirely
different activity that brings enthusiasm of children and motivates them to interact with others
(Husa & Kinos, 2005). The second aspect reflects that flexibility is more important in
comparison of accuracy because without flexibility neither playing nor learning is possible. The
third aspect reflects that the attention of children in more important for learning and without
playing it cannot be done in an adequate manner.
Section 2
Challenges of 3 articles
Three articles are described in this section that is opposing, challenging or alternative to the
issue. The similarity and the difference between the articles will be elaborated in this section.
First article
The key idea of the first article “Searching for play in Early Childhood Care and Education
Policy”, also reflects the definition of play as paradox which involve the tension that raise the
description of play as including love, playing, work, development and learning; play can be

Supporting and challenging articles 8
described in the oppose of ‘child’s work’. It is also stated in this article that if play could have
opposed, ‘no play’ would be closer to it than work (Rogers, 2010). It has been discussed in this
article that oppose the raised issue it is the presence of learning can also be reflected as work
rather than play with phrases such as “learning through play”, it has been found from this article
that the play, love, development, work, learning and care are crucial to play as a process of
relational.
Second article
‘The Alarming Disappearance of Play from Early Childhood Education’ is showing the
alternative point in against to mentioned issue. The children need to self directed to play by
involving the physical play. There is an enhancing concern that an elite organization of
instruction and testing leaves number of kindergarten under-exercised and overstressed to
become overweight. There should be key dimension encompassing attention, emotion and self-
regulation; and social knowledge. There are various kinds of social forms that are liable to
promote the socio-emotional skills of the children at the time of children’s early years.
Third article
The third article reflects the opposing point as well in against of chosen issue. The article ‘The
Playing Learning Child: Towards a Pedagogy of Early Childhood’ it defines that in term to
activities of children, there is another area which shows that how the child is apparent in relation
to adults. Moral and religion is necessary for the early childhood in comparison of focusing on
play (Samuelsson & Carlsson, 2008). The discussion has been made in this article that the long
term goals are not driven by children as adults but it is necessary for the parents and the societies
to learn their children about values, morale and how to respect their elders. These things are

Supporting and challenging articles 9
more than play as per this article which shows the opposition in the context of taken issue
(Bennet, 2010).
Similarity between the articles
The similarity has been found between the articles such as these articles are in favour of the
chosen issue. The main concern of this assignment is disappearance of play from early childhood
education. These articles are similar because as it has been discussed that play is considered as
the activity that interprets in the form of concept. These articles are focused on the awareness of
play in the life of children along with the learning. Learning activities can be done by adapting
various techniques that make amuse them while developing (Nicolopoulou, 2010). Sports
activities should be considered by kindergarten while educating them because flexibility is
necessary for learning as well as per these articles. It shows that these articles are similar and
support the issue of this task. The recommendation has been given in the articles to give
importance of playing along with the learning.
Difference between the articles
It is hard to have the similar opinion of different authors on one topic. However, the main focus
of all articles on developing other activities for student in the education but there are various
difference between articles. The first article shows the opposition of the issue as well and play
has considered as paradox for children that distract them from working. On the other hand the
second articles are in favour of the issue and provide the alternative such as children need to self
directed to play. The third article describes the importance of moral and learning of child in
comparison of play (Samuelsson & Carlsson, 2008). This argument reflects that there are major
differences of these articles. It is necessary for the preschool to attain the attention of children

Supporting and challenging articles 10
towards study and it can be done via various ways such as by showing different activities or
involving those learning activities with the help of play (Zevenbergen, 2007. Communication
and interaction are necessary for developing the skills of the children and the way of thinking is
different of all authors.
There are three articles has been discussed about the mentioned issue in this assignment, it has
been evaluated that all articles has different point of view regarding the concern but the motto of
all articles are same. These described the importance of play in the early childhood.

Supporting and challenging articles 11
Section 3
Point of view on the issues
As per my point of view, integrating free play time into the early childhood education
programming is advantageous not only for the development of children but for enhancing the
performance in academic activities as well. It has been analyzed that importance of early
childhood playing is undervalued due to over burden of education and competition. Parents want
good position of their child in the class that is why they do not allow them to spend their time for
playing (Farquhar & White, 2014). It is necessary to build play into the curriculum as it is
considered as the important part for the childhood development. The role of play has the large
impact on development in so many areas involving cognitive skills, languages skills and social
skills (Samuelsson & Carlsson, 2008). It is considered as the critical part for building strong
social skills at early stage and it can be done only by playing with other children. It would be
helpful for them to learn with live others and share. The languages skills can be increased of
early childhood because dramatic play is deemed as the effective technique to foster the language
skill of children. Play is the process that encourage student to learn, solve issues and imagine
instead of stimulating the only development of brain. As per my point of view there are
numerous advantages of play in early childhood education.
Improved social skills: Involvement of play in early childhood education improves the social
skills as it facilitates to engage better with other children and adults (Hellman and Heikkila,
2014). It would be helpful for the children to express their own ideas, share, cooperate and make
friends.

Supporting and challenging articles 12
Improve the performance and increase the flexibility: the involvement of play helps kids to
understand the various aspects and they develop their skills and start take decision as per their
understanding (Essa, 2012). Play is an integral process which make flexible and it is necessary to
be fit for better study. Therefore, the importance of play in early childhood education is essential
as the growth of mind and physical of children are done in early years.
Motivate for lifelong learning: the involvement of play in early childhood education motivates
the children to get confident and curious to know things (McNamee & Bailey, 2010). They
become responsible to tackle the challenges and create resilience at the time of difficulty.
Enhanced attention spans: without attention or concentration study could not be done in proper
manner, play is the process which make healthy mind of children as they prepare to involve in
the learning process with enthusiasm.
There can be various theories on play such as classical theories and contemporary theories.
Classical theories are comprised surplus energy theory, relaxation theory, pre-exercise and
recapitulation. On the other hand contemporary theories are encompassed psychoanalytical,
Arousal Modulation, Meta communicative and cognitive. Classical theory focuses on the
biological and native aspects of play by utilizing the evolutionary descriptions instead of
observing the variations of children’s activities (Milteer, Ginsburg & Mulligan, 2012).
Contemporary theories of play provide importance to the psychological value and the cognitive,
social and emotional development. It can be said that it is liable to keep importance of higher
level of thinking and thoughts. It shows that the importance of play in early childhood education
is crucial (Samuelsson & Kaga, 2008). For instance, only study without other activities may get
bored to the kids and theoretical knowledge is not sufficient for the children because it is