Sustainability Report: Timberwell Constructions' Performance Analysis

This report provides a comprehensive sustainability analysis of Timberwell Constructions, a real estate organization facing various allegations. It assesses the company's performance against GRI standards, covering economic, environmental, and social sustainability. The report highlights financial risks related to climate change, incidents of corruption, anti-competitive behavior, and non-compliance with environmental regulations. It also examines issues such as employee turnover, discrimination, and community engagement. The analysis reveals areas of concern, including workforce dissatisfaction, environmental damage, and unethical practices, and outlines actions taken or required to address these issues. The report concludes with recommendations for corrective actions to improve Timberwell's sustainability performance and mitigate risks, emphasizing the need for ethical conduct, environmental responsibility, and social equity. The report also emphasizes the need for Timberwell to improve its practices to ensure long-term viability and positive impact on the community and environment.

1
Timberwell Constructions Sustainability Report
Particulars Page no.
Introduction 2-3
Sustainability Reporting
1. Economic Sustainability 3-4
2. Environmental Sustainability 4-5
3. Social Sustainability 5-7
Conclusion 8-9
Reference 9

2
Introduction
Timberwell Constructions is one of the reputed Real Estate organization that is engaged in
building apartments in Stanwell Council District. It is a small scale business that operates with
58 male personnel for its different construction related operations. Due to competitive
marketing environment in that region, Timberwell is facing workforce trouble as they need
more employees (at least 12 apprentices) for carrying out the business successfully and to cover
up those 17 employees who recently left for joining in rivalry firm or to start their own venture
in this field.
Scenario-The organization is facing troubles on different grounds like Workplace harassment,
misuse of market power, manipulated dealings, unfair industrial practices, corruption,
environmental damage, window dressing and many other major and minor allegations. The
company is now struggling in business and they need to recover from it.
Purpose of the report- The purpose of this report is to prepare a Sustainability Report for
Timberwell Constructions under GRI standard guidelines to cover the various aspects of the
allegation lodged and pointed at organization to find to what extend the organization has
violated standards and what should be the corrective actions for these.
GRI Standards- Global Reporting Initiative is an independent organization that provides the
guidelines and norms prescribed for economic sustainability, environmental sustainability and
social sustainability. The purpose of this organization to bring up humanity in global community
and build an environment where there is equal opportunity for everyone in matters of
economy, environment and society. GRI standards are the first common standards followed for
sustainability reporting. The standard is a modular and inter-related structure represents range
of economic, social and environmental impacts. [Kolk, A. (2003).]
Management Approach of Timberwell- From the case study, it is clear that workforce were not
happy with the treatment of management which is why almost 1/3 of workforce left
organization and huge vacancy arose. The company tried to cover it up with increase in
compensation and changing roaster plan with day off system. From the case study, it seems

3
that there were no fair management system which led the organization to follow up the
allegation with penalty or suspension. Though in media release it has been claiming to be
environmentally and socially sustainable but people have already made negative impression on
their mind.
Sustainability Assessment
Sustainability reporting is a broader assessment report of an organization which not only
includes economic performance but also environmental, social and corporate governance
performance. It is not meant for collecting data and reporting it to the concerned authority
rather it is the method to contribute in sustainability development. The following Sustainability
reporting is done for Timberwell Construction. In this report, we have taken economic, social
and environmental sustainability performance as per the data available.
Economic Sustainability
Disclosure 201-2 Financial Implications and other risks opportunity due to climate change
 Timberwell has good number of opportunity in Stanwell Council region as the organization
has got the opportunity to develop Otford Park site where there is already existence of rare
category wallum sedge frog so that proper residential complexes can be built.
 Timberwell may have to incur a rehabilitation cost of $440000 against the review of its
vegetation management program.
 Its external town planning with the support of Stanwell council may cost the organization
around $50000 for the service offered in development planning.
Overall the organization needs to incur expenses in their development planning which are
mostly capital expenditure in total (at least 440000+50000= $490000) There may be more
operational expenditure in case of bio-diversity and ecology rules in future date which can be
predicted rightly after environmental audit. The demand for the residential houses in flora and
fauna and vegetation area is decreasing day by day to balance the environment and bio
diversity. So in future, it will bring reduction in business. Even the suppliers and contractors
have withdrawn in the future development plans for Timeberwell. [O'Dwyer, B.,et.al2005]

4
Disclosure 205-3- Confirmed incidents of corruption and actions taken
 One of the employee named Dennis complained against Timberwell to State Corruption
Commission that the organization is involved in corruption activities. As per his complaint
lodged, 5 Timberwell employees and 2 business partners were engaged in this corruption
act.
 The corruption took place these 5 culprits were trying to give bribe to the Stanwell Council
members to pass the development plans quickly without much verification.
Action taken- The State Corruption investigated the matter and found 6 of them guilty of the
corruption i.e. all employees and one strategic partner. Timberwell suspended all the
employees who were doing such act and also broke the partnership with those two consultants.
Disclosure- 206-1- Legal actions for anti-competitive behavior, anti-trust, and monopoly
practices
 The organization has been filed with a number of complaints against this disclosure. The
same employee (Dennis) registered it with various Govt. departments. It is the Australian
Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) took the charge to investigate the matter
and sue in Federal court for its anti-competitive behavior like misusing market strength and
manipulation in client dealing.
 The executives were found to be guilty for forcing the suppliers and contractors not to form
any competitive firm to reduce the business of Timberwell using either coercive power or
expert power. [Gray, R.,et.al2002]
 The organization was also brought under notice for deceiving new players to come into
market to lessen the competition. They were able to do it with the support from Stanwell
council.
 Action- The case is still pending in Federal Court and no such actions taken by the
organization to justify their authenticity to this complaint.
Environmental Sustainability
Disclosure-302-1- Energy consumption within organization

5
The organization in its 2nd media release claimed that it is an energy efficient organization. The
claim made so on grounds of the prescribed limit of energy consumption from renewable and
non-renewable energy resources and electricity consumption given by Australian Department
of Industry and Science. The company has disclosed the use of energy in the reporting period.
Action- In another media release, they have claimed to achieve at least 50% of total energy
consumption from the Renewable energy within the span of 3 years. At present, it is around
33% of total Fuel consumption.
Disclosure 304-2- Significant impacts of activities, products, and services on biodiversity
 Dennis complained to Dept. of Environment and Energy that the current projects of
Timberwell is putting ecological balancing in coast grasslands in trouble which is why it had
to pay fine for it to clear the area.
 The new development plan of the organization proposed for medium density population in
that area where rare category frogs are living and with the constructions, they may go
extinct. Only after rehabilitation to Wallum Sedge frogs, the project progress is possible.
 Action-The Stanwell council and Timberwell is working towards amending Bushfire zones
rules and regulations amendments, so that the organization can give Bushfire safety to the
residential people to avoid hazard.
Disclosure 307-1-Non-compliance with environmental laws and regulations
 The Department of Environment and Energy filed a case against Timberwell for clearing the
ecological community in coastland around 0.45 hectares area. The organization had to pay
$200000 for compensating this environmental violation.
 The organization had to incur an expense around $440000 for rehabilitation plan as per the
review of vegetation management under State Planning Scheme. This much amount is
charged for balancing flora and fauna in that location.
 Action-1-The organization with support of Stanwell Council is working towards the
rehabilitation of wallum sedge frog which were found in the new development plan site of
Timberwell.

6
 Action-2-The organization is also working on amending Local Environmental Plan (LEP)
especially for the areas which are prone to bushfire. This new regulation will cost around $4
million along with other service charges up to $50000. The new regulation will come into
action around 6 weeks. [Perrini, F et.al2006]
Social Sustainability
Disclosure 401-1-New employee hires and employee turnover
 The current workforce is 58 and entire workforce is male only. There is no place for women
employees within the organization.
 Due to internal management problem and competitiveness, 17 employees were reported to
leave organization and 12 enrolled on apprentice basis.
 The age group of employees in Timberwell is between 30-50 years. Only one employee is
above 50 years of age and he is Dennis who brought all the allegations under scanner.
The circumstances is saying that Timberwell doesn’t have a balanced workforce system and
there is a high level of dissatisfaction and uncertainty in working environment. It may be due to
the rough attitude of the executives on employees or the compensation issues which is
affecting the workforce balance. The company is having deep trouble as the rate of leaving is
more than rate of joining. No reporting was done for the age group of employees left or joined
but as they have only 30-50 years employees, so we can assume it under that slab.
Action- At present the company is looking for new trainees to join the organization and also
trying to keep the key personnel with monetary incentives. Any dissatisfied employees are
given compensation as per court summon.
Disclosure 406-1 Incidents of discrimination and corrective actions taken
 The senior most employee of Timberwell Dennis complained about the remuneration
system of the company which is not fair to employees. [Guthrie, J.,et.al2008]
 The discrimination regarding workforce, commission, recognition etc. are taking place
more often. Younger employees are treated well while the elders are not treated fair.

7
 Comments were made to Dennis on his age and seniority by his colleagues and no such
actions were taken by the executives to deal with this unfair treatment.
 There were no anti-discrimination policies and training to the employees here thus Fair
work Commission has passed an order to start these two programs in the organization
soon.
 Moreover the organization is also obliged to pay $4400 to Dennis against the
discrimination faced on his work.
 Action- Apart from the above, Timberwell has taken steps towards increasing the pay rate
and to give a day off monthly apart from other leaves to reduce the work burden.
Disclosure 413-1-Operations with local community engagement, impact assessments and
development programs
Timberwell has been claiming to be a good corporate citizen from the media releases it did.
These media releases took place on seeing people have been perceiving the image in a
negative manner.
 In the first media release, it claimed to be a partner in development for Otford Park where
the rare species of frog are found in large number. It is working with Stanwell Council and
other eco-friendly groups to provide habitat for Wallum Sedge Frogs prior to start
developing medium density residential complex.
 In its third media release, it has mentioned about engaging local community and will assess
impact and will conduct social development program for all the proposed residential
complex. To prove engagement with local community, it is going conduct meeting with the
community people to know the need of them regarding housing. The organization will also
participate in local community development program. [Dumay, J et.al2010]
 Action- Timberwell has also promised to conduct environmental assessment and impact
assessment from the residential complexes it is building. For ex- They have calculated the
use of renewable fuel consumption will be 50% within 3 years and they have taken steps to
conserve the rare species of frogs which are the example of their assessment plan.

8
 The company has also assess the impact of climate change and bushfire on the residential
complex under its new development plan. It has requested LEP to amend its acts and
declare the area as “bushfire prone zone.”
 Actions to be taken- The new area which is declared as bushfire prone zone needs high
degree of safety and security which the organization will take into consideration. These are-
distance between two buildings and boundaries and use of fire retardant materials to make
complex.
Department of Environment and Energy has taken action against Timberwell for deviating the
bio-diversity rule for the residential projects on which actions were taken and proceedings for
penalty done. Even further audit trial will start to find clearer picture about the vegetation
planning done by this organization.
Limitation of study- The above sustainability report doesn’t take all the disclosures as
mentioned in GRI standard due to unavailability of information. The reporting has been done as
per the information provided and media releases. The authenticity of information can be
proved only by undertaking independent examination of the report materials mentioned
above.
Conclusion
GRI Sustainability Reporting of Timberwell has done through three important grounds which
are economic, environmental and social. The reporting guidelines are followed as per the GRI
standard prescribed as per 2016 standard reporting. From the information available, this
sustainability reporting has been done which draws out the following facts about the Real-
estate organization-
Economic point of view- The organization has been facing the financial obligations from
different parties due to violation of basic principles. Moreover as the competition in Stanwell
district for real estate market is increasing the organization is facing business risk more and
more. To avoid the risk and reduce the intensity of competition, the company followed

9
unethical practice like corruption which caused penalty and negative image of organization. The
company also used market power to keep the new players out as a sign of anti-competitive
nature. In this criteria, the organization scores low. [Brown, H. S.,et.al2009]
Environmental point of view- In matter of energy consumption, the organization is working
towards use of more renewable resources. It is hoping to reach 505 mark in next 3 years in
renewable fuel consumption which is a positive point for them. 2/3 instances the organization
has given importance to environment which are conservation of Wallum Sedge Frogs and
bushfire prone zone but in case of green coastland, it was found to violate ecology for which it
had to pay fine. Thus in this ground, it can be put under moderate result. [Higgins, C.,et.al2018]
Social point of view- The organization despite having small workforce it is facing a lot of trouble
in employee’s retention. The organization is having high attrition than enrollment. There is
several complaint against compensation, employee treatment and other discrimination. Even
the company doesn’t have a single female employee which is showing an orthodox workforce
management of Timberwell. The company had to pay fine for the bad treatment to one of its
senior employees. On the other hand, towards local community and society development, is
working with various new development plans. It is working with other independent bodies to
amend the polices, society housing development and improved building material to give better
residential experience to local community. In this case also it scores low as it is their own press
release which authenticity has to be proved.
Overall Performance- The purpose of this report was to determine whether Timberwell is
contributing towards sustainability development or not. From the above three analysis we
came to know that in 2 out 3 barometer it scored low and in case of economic point of view it
scored moderate. It means the organization has not contributed well to sustainable
development. In none of criteria, it stood positive which is why it has created a negative image
in public.
Suggestions- The organization should start fulfilling the requirements of disclosure as soon as
possible. It should not follow corruption practice, exploitation to workforce and environment,

10
coercive power for business etc. so that again it will get the earlier position as it started few
years ago.
References
Kolk, A. (2003). Trends in sustainability reporting by the Fortune Global 250. Business strategy and the
environment, 12(5), 279-291.
Perrini, F., & Tencati, A. (2006). Sustainability and stakeholder management: the need for new corporate
performance evaluation and reporting systems. Business Strategy and the Environment, 15(5), 296-308.
Guthrie, J., & Farneti, F. (2008). GRI sustainability reporting by Australian public sector
organizations. Public Money and management, 28(6), 361-366.
Dumay, J., Guthrie, J., & Farneti, F. (2010). GRI sustainability reporting guidelines for public and third
sector organizations: A critical review. Public Management Review, 12(4), 531-548.
Brown, H. S., de Jong, M., & Levy, D. L. (2009). Building institutions based on information disclosure:
lessons from GRI's sustainability reporting. Journal of cleaner production, 17(6), 571-580.
Higgins, C., Stubbs, W., & Milne, M. (2018). Is sustainability reporting becoming institutionalised? The
role of an issues-based field. Journal of Business Ethics, 147(2), 309-326.
Gray, R., & Milne, M. (2002). Sustainability reporting: who's kidding whom?. Chartered Accountants
Journal of New Zealand, 81(6), 66-70.
O'Dwyer, B., & Owen, D. L. (2005). Assurance statement practice in environmental, social and
sustainability reporting: a critical evaluation. The British Accounting Review, 37(2), 205-229.